ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – dispute concerned interpretation of clause 41.1 of the Independent Distillers Employment Agreement 2011 which deals with cashing out of personal/carer’s leave – employees contended custom and practice regarding the application of clause 41.1 had been since the inception of the clause for an employee to cash out any hours over and above an accrual of 15 days – employer submitted that the clause merely facilitates the ability for an employee to cash out personal/carer’s leave – further submitted clause does not entitle employees to cash out personal cash/carer’s leave by right and that cashing out can only occur by agreement, contending that Asahi could decline a request to cash out personal/carer’s leave at its discretion – Golden Cockerel applied – Commission found clause requires employees to agree in writing to the cashing out of personal/carer’s leave, i.e. the cashing out of personal carer’s leave is not automatic at the request of an employee as employer has the discretion to agree or not to agree to any such request. Employee Representative Committee of Asahi Premium Beverages v Asahi Premium Beverages P/L
April 26, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – termination at initiative of employer – constructive dismissal – ss.386, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant employed as primary school teacher – respondent raised jurisdictional objection that applicant resigned – applicant alleged constructive dismissal – applicant submitted she was subjected to harassment and intimidation by parents – further submitted little support offered by respondent – respondent commenced investigation into complaint – Commission held investigation inaccurate as it made findings as to ‘unlawfulness’ – found respondent did not engage in course of conduct designed to force resignation – respondent provided appropriate level of support to applicant – applicant resigned employment voluntarily following legal advice – no dismissal at initiative of respondent – objection upheld – application dismissed. Reynolds v Highfields Preparatory and Kindergarten School Ltd t/a Highfields
April 26, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – genuine redundancy – ss.389, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – employer objected on basis employee made redundant – respondent conceded applicant dismissed – whether role no longer required to be performed by anyone – respondent’s submitted ‘Inventory Manger’ role no longer required accepted – no requirement to consult – whether ‘Materials Coordinator’ position a new job or position to which applicant could have been reasonably re-deployed into in all circumstances – whether timing of commencement of new position deliberately chosen to deprive applicant of redeployment – Commission not satisfied position changed so substantially after termination of applicant’s employment such that new job or position created – not uncommon after job abolished that duties once performance by one person are shared amongst remaining staff – slight change in duties and new job title far from establishing new job created in which applicant could have been reasonably redeployed – would have necessitated another employee’s termination to redeploy applicant – found not reasonable to redeploy applicant – found dismissal a case of genuine redundancy – application dismissed. Quinn v David Moss Corporation Limited t/a Damos
April 26, 2016
RIGHT OF ENTRY – dispute over right of entry – ss.484, 505 Fair Work Act 2009 – application to deal with right of entry dispute – dispute re whether persons on tug boat Mallina were employees such that AIMPE permitted to utilise entry rights – Rivtow asserted no employees on boat – this decision specifically relates to production of documents sought by AIMPE – Order for Production of Documents granted 1 April 2016 – Rivtow objected and asserted ‘fishing expedition’ – AIMPE asserted documents necessary to determine whether employees – consideration of revocation of Order involves same approach as whether Order should be made in first place – not satisfied evidence provided as yet by AIMPE establishes prima facie case that persons are employees or that they wish to participate in discussions – link between documents sought and issue to be determined not established with sufficient particularity – on material at present time, not persuaded Order for Production of Documents should stand – Order revoked. Australian Institute of Marine and Power Engineers, The-West Australia Branch v Rivtow Marine P/L
April 26, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – genuine redundancy – ss.389, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – applicant submitted he was dismissed to prevent accrual of long service leave entitlement – respondent submitted applicant’s termination was a genuine redundancy stemming from cash-flow problems – Commission satisfied applicant’s position made redundant – no ulterior motive – not satisfied respondent complied with consultation requirements arising from relevant modern award – therefore applicant’s dismissal not a genuine redundancy as defined by FW Act – application must be heard on its merits – applicant not dismissed for reason arising out of capacity or conduct – Commission held decision to bring about the dismissal of applicant because of an operational reason – found dismissal sound, reasonable and defensible – not persuaded termination was harsh, unjust or unreasonable – application dismissed. Fletcher v Commodore Wreckers (Gold Coast) P/L t/a Commodore Wreckers
April 26, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – application to dismiss by employer – frustration – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant dismissed following conviction for serious criminal offences – applicant lodged unfair dismissal application – conciliation unsuccessful – indefinite adjournment granted in April 2013 – respondent heard nothing from the Commission or applicant for the next two years and assumed matter had been discontinued – respondent requested that application be dismissed as applicant had not articulated a case of any substance – applicant advised he was unable to access any resources whilst incarcerated and requested matter be adjourned until he was released from prison – applicant’s argument did not have reasonable prospects of success – adjournment request would cause significant and indefinite delay and cause additional costs and expenses – Commission considered it appropriate to exercise discretion to dismiss application – application dismissed. Maddison v Commonwealth of Australia (acting through and represented by the Department of Defence)
April 26, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – applicant dismissed for alleged safety breach – applicant submitted that respondent had not properly identified how he had breached safety processes – submitted his conduct was consistent with established work procedures – respondent submitted policy and procedures clear – applicant had received earlier warning regarding safety procedures – respondent asserted it had undertaken a thorough investigation of the incident – Commission satisfied on evidence that applicant breached safety procedures – Weir Minerals Australia Ltd considered – Commission satisfied valid reason for dismissal – Commission considered other relevant factors – applicant employed by the respondent for 35 years – applicant defended his actions but demonstrated a willingness to comply in the future – applicant did not attempt to cover up what had happened – due to the application of other relevant factors Commission satisfied dismissal was harsh – satisfied dismissal unfair – reinstatement inappropriate given applicant’s personal circumstances – compensation reduced as applicant had not taken steps to mitigate loss and due to valid reason for dismissal – compensation of $30,000 ordered. Ptolemy v Nestle Australia Limited
April 26, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – high income threshold – minimum employment period – ss.383, 384, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – respondent objected to application and submitted applicant had not served the minimum employment period and earned more than the high income threshold – applicant employed as General Manager – worked for prior company (Struga) which was sold to respondent – prior to applicant commencing employment with respondent, no evidence that applicant advised in writing that his prior service would not be recognised – no dispute that Struga transferred to respondent and that applicant was transferring employee – Commission satisfied applicant served the minimum employment period – applicant stated he earned $145,000 inclusive of superannuation, and respondent stated applicant earned $145,000 plus superannuation – respondent did not provide applicant with payslips during his employment – parties provided email and text evidence of pay discussions – Commission did not accept that the text messages represented agreement between the parties – clear from applicant’s email that his package was $145,000 plus superannuation – Commission satisfied applicant’s salary exceeded high income threshold – whether applicant covered by Cleaning Services Award 2010 – Commission not satisfied that award covered applicant’s employment – earnings exceeded high income threshold – not covered by award – not protected from unfair dismissal – application dismissed. Sulejman v Cleaning Facility Cleaning Management P/L t/a PPM Corporate