NEWS HR

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – amendment of application – ss.394, 586 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – respondent raised jurisdiction objection that application filed before dismissal took effect – applicant then filed further application out of time – submitted that original or subsequent application should be treated as valid and if required Commission may allow a correction to application under s.586 of FW Act – respondent conceded that Commission has discretionary power under s.586 to waive irregularity but contended that discretion should not be exercised because application without merit; no remedy available to applicant; and would be no injustice to applicant if application dismissed – Commission considered Mihajlovic regarding premature applications and determining date of dismissal – found application lodged before dismissal effective – Commission accepted that merits of applicant’s substantive application relevant in considering exercise of discretion under s.586 – in absence of detailed evidence on merits, applicant had arguable case on the face as to merits and remedy – applicant would suffer significant injustice if no opportunity to have substantive application heard – respondent on notice since application filed – satisfied discretion should be exercised by waiving irregularity of filing before date of dismissal and allowing application to proceed. Gee v Tasmanian Ports Corporation P/L t/a Tasports

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – minimum employment period – ss.382, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – respondent objected on basis that it was a small business and that relevant minimum employment period not met – applicant alleged respondent not a small business at the time of dismissal – Commission found only 14 employees employed at the time of dismissal – respondent a small business within the meaning of s.23 of FW Act – minimum employment period not met – application dismissed. Jaschke v Johnsen Quality Bakeries P/L t/a Australind Bakery

INDUSTRIAL ACTION – payments relating to periods of industrial action – s.472 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for an order relating to certain partial work bans – decision issued on substantive matter [[2016] FWC 892] – further hearing conducted – whether proposed reductions reasonable and consistent with the statutory scheme – whether sufficient account taken of other work being performed during partial work bans – refusal to attend meetings or undertake curriculum extension activities – refusal to undertake relief teaching – nature of bans and context of enterprise agreement considered – impact of approach to the assessment of the period of the bans and the normal working day taken into account – proposed reductions unfair in relation to relief teaching – order issued modifying certain reductions – reduction will be five per cent – undertaking noted in relation to notices issued to non-teachers – application granted in part. Independent Education Union (South Australia) Incorporated v Catholic Schools Endowment Society Incorporated (Catholic Education Office)

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – genuinely agree – ss.185, 186 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for approval of a single enterprise agreement by McDermott Australia P/L – statutory declarations were lodged by the AWU and AMWU – both unions indicated they opposed the approval of the agreement – two grounds of objection were that the application was not accompanied by a properly signed copy of the agreement and that the Commission cannot be satisfied that the employees genuinely agreed to the agreement – Swinburne considered – clear evidence that the request to employees to approve the agreement by voting for it was made to employees who were not ’employed at the time’ – Commission not satisfied that the agreement was genuinely agreed to pursuant to s.186(2)(a) of FW Act – cannot approve agreement – application dismissed. McDermott Australia P/L Ichthys Project Offshore Construction Agreement 2016

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – alleged dispute involving Forgacs Engineering P/L Enterprise Agreement 2013 – enquiry as to whether prior casual service of a permanent employee should count towards the calculation of ‘continuous service’ for notice and redundancy pay – AMWU argued that relevant clauses of no effect by virtue of inconsistency with the NES – AMWU argued that the definition of ‘continuous service’ in the FW Act encompasses both casual and permanent employment – distinction drawn between notice and redundancy and accruing rights such as annual or long service leave – service of casuals who are later made permanent compared to apprentices employed at the conclusion of an apprenticeship – contended this interpretation is consistent with the entire scheme and objects of the FW Act – Australian Industry Group (AiG) argued that casuals employed by Forgacs receive a 25% casual loading – in addition to specific exclusions in the agreement, AiG argued that this casual loading is used to compensate for a loss of benefits including notice and redundancy pay – Metals Casual Case considered – Commission did not accept the argument that casuals transferring to permanent employment can be reconciled with apprentices being employed as tradespersons – legal principle against ‘double dipping’ in regards to casual employees later made permanent considered a logical and universally accepted industrial practice – Commission accepted that while ‘continuous service’ is not definitively defined within the FW Act, the wording of the agreement is without ambiguity and the FW Act identifies no impediment to the operation of the agreement – found that prior casual service of permanent employees does not count towards the calculation of period of service for notice and redundancy pay – application dismissed. ‘Automotive, Food, Metals, Engineering, Printing and Kindred Industries Union’ known as the Australian Manufacturing Workers’ Union (AMWU) v Forgacs Engineering P/L t/a Forgacs

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant terminated for breach of the respondent’s drug and alcohol policy after returning a positive drug test result – applicant contended test results were unreliable – applicant had accepted a work assignment with random drug and alcohol testing – the respondent arranged for a secondary drug test – secondary sample returned a negative result – secondary report noted low creatine level which indicated a diluted sample – report recommended another test, but this was not carried out – the applicant subsequently dismissed as a result of the positive test – expert witness at hearing gave evidence as to which drug testing kit was to be relied on – Commission satisfied of test and analysis reliability – considered whether dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable – considered valid reason set out in Selvachandran – on the balance of probabilities, Commission found that presence of amphetamines, methamphetamine and cannabinoids in the applicant’s system was a breach of the terms and conditions of employment and valid reason for termination – application dismissed. Hafer v Ensign Australia P/L t/a Ensign International Energy Services

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – pre-approval requirements – ss.186, 585, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – appeal – Full Bench – appeal by MUA against decision to approve the SLOA Enterprise Agreement 2015 – MUA submitted application missing information about union or employee bargaining representatives involved in agreement making process – MUA submitted application redacted in part and did not comply with procedural rules – no indication omissions/ redactions remedied prior to approval of agreement – Full Bench held additional ground properly identify appealable error – agreement should not have been approved – permission to appeal granted – appeal upheld – decision quashed – application for approval dismissed. Appeal by the Maritime Union of Australia against decision of Hamilton DP of 17 December 2015 [[2015] FWCA 8698] Re: SMIT Lamnalco (Australia) P/L

REGISTERED ORGANISATIONS – alteration of eligibility rules – s.158(1) Fair Work (Registered Organisations) Act 2009 – Full Bench – application to amend eligibility rules to extend capacity to enrol as members persons employed by ResMed Limited (ResMed) – previous decision determined Commission would consent to AMWU’s rule amendments in part [[2016] FWCFB 22] – ResMed made application to Federal Court arguing AMWU’s eligibility rule amendment not made according to its rules and jurisdictional perquisite to grant consent had not been met – Commission not satisfied ResMed would suffer any significant prejudice prior to determination of its Federal Court application – application dismissed. Australian Manufacturing Workers’ Union (AMWU)