NEWS HR

ENTERPRISE BARGAINING – single interest employer authorisation – ss.248, 249 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant and 26 other employers applied for single interest employer authorisation in relation to a proposed enterprise agreement, the Oporto Enterprise Agreement 2016 – application specified the employers and employees to be covered by the proposed agreement and the Employee Relations Consultant for Oporto was the person nominated by the employers to make applications under the FW Act if the authorisation was made – a statutory declaration in support stated that the employers agreed to bargain together and that no person was coerced, or threatened to coerce, any of the employers to agree to bargain together – each employer provided written declarations and authorisations in support – Commission satisfied employers agreed to bargain together, had not been subject to any coercion and were franchisees of the same franchisor – application granted. Oporto (Franchising) P/L t/a Oporto and Ors

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – application to deal with a dispute in McMah P/L Enterprise Agreement 2014 – 2018 – applicant was employed as a Contract Security Officer at the premises of the University of the Sunshine Coast – Commission to determine three issues: whether employees had to remain on campus during their meal breaks, whether classification matching in agreement was correct and if employees are entitled to first aid allowance – employees were required under agreement to undertake broad spectrum of Standard Operating Procedures – no provisions in the Agreement dealing with first aid allowance or meal breaks, terms are found in Security Services Industry Award 2010 – Agreement does not provide for its own classifications or wage rates, but incorporates them from other industrial instruments – Agreement incorporates the Security Award and the Higher Education General Staff Award 2010 – applicant argued she and other contracted Security Officers were classified under either Level 3 or Level 4 of Schedule C of the Security Award – respondent maintained Security Officers are classified at Level 2 – Commission found that the Higher Education Award was the applicable correlated Award for the Security Officers at the University – Higher Education Award has only one level of classification for Security Patrol Officers at Level 2 where rates of pay are equivalent for respondent’s labour hire Security Officers at the University – Commission found in both modern award’s First Aid entitlements that there was no reference in the Standard Operating Procedures for a Security Officer being requested or nominated as a First Aider – Commission of the view that if a meal break is unpaid there should be no requirement that employees remain on campus or be available in emergencies, unless there is agreed arrangement between the employer and the employee. Malic v McMah P/L t/a Men at Work Labour Hire

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – extension of time – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant lodged unfair dismissal application more than 21 days after dismissal took effect – Commission can extend time for the lodging if satisfied there are exceptional circumstances – applicant registered for e-filing, attempted to upload an unfair dismissal application and paid the filing fee within 21 days – on the same day he received an email advising that his application was not taken to have been filed as it would need to be reviewed – email advised he would be advised by email if there were any further issues – on that same day a telephone message was left for the applicant to contact Commission as there had been no application form attached to lodgement – no record that the applicant was ever sent an email advising his application had not been accepted – applicant acted promptly when advised that his application had not been received – combination of factors including the Commission’s failure to advise by email that application had not been received constituted reasonable explanation for the delay – extension of time granted. Poolperm-Johnson v Hobart Police & Community Youth Club Inc

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – extension of time – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal lodged 41 days outside the statutory time limit – reasons for delay in lodgment were ignorance of the law, language difficulties and representational error – applicant’s first, and almost only, language is Oromo – this is a rare language in Australia – not one of the languages for which there is a translation on the Commission’s website – only one qualified interpreter available in Brisbane – Commission found it was more difficult for applicant to obtain information about his employment rights than it is for employees who speak English or languages for which there are translations available, both more generally, and on the website – held that a number of volunteer organisations and individuals sought to assist the applicant however all of them failed to provide the most important piece of advice i.e. to lodge in time – satisfied there were exceptional circumstances which would warrant granting an exception to the statutory time limit – extension of time granted. Muhammad v Labour Solutions Australia P/L

The hoons, louts and misfits will crowd the portals of the Fair Work Commission again today protesting over grievances, swearing they are victims, asserting innocence and vilifying employers. And the commissioners will have to separate the facts from the flannel. The full list includes: The Bank Cafe (Hammond), Croft Developments Pty Ltd (Tomlinson), Aurizon Operations Limited (Neven), Neville and Julie Robertson (Archibald), GO Traffic Pty Ltd (Page), Barrier Reef Community Child Care Inc (Townsend), TJ Diner (Tusiupu), Atwood Australian Waters Drilling Pty Ltd (Ashby), St John Ambulance Pty Ltd (Gilbert), Council on the Ageing WA Inc (Millar), National Lifestyle Villages (Campbell), Metwest Steel Pty Ltd (Guo), The Trustee for Ashton Avenue Trust (Ashton Avenue Pty Ltd) (Tomlin), Nabiac and District presco (De Tracy), Tasmanian Water and Sewerage Corporation Pty Ltd (Wright), Sydney Night Patrol & Inquiry Co Pty Ltd (Palm), Ramsay Health Care Australia Pty Ltd (Fitzgerald), Motorcycle Holdings TCO Pty Ltd ATF The Motorcycle Holdings Group Unit Trust (Dore), BHP Coal Pty Limited (McDermott), Little Darlings Early Development Center (Fletcher), Tinamba Turf Co Pty Ltd (Cooper), Feros Care Limited (Heath), Steelcon Pty Limited (Dwyer), Retep Nominees Pty Ltd (Ikking), Indigenous Land Corporation (McCaffrey), Queensland University of Technology (QUT) (Rowe), GEMSA (Hill), Bedford Group Incorporated (Willshire).

There is a big crowd in today. The full list at the Fair Work Commission chasing money, vindication or reinstatement includes: Arrium Pty Ltd (Johnston), Karidis Corporation Ltd (Weller), Coles Group Supply Chain Pty Ltd (Clayton), Ajilon Pty Ltd (Niknazar), Bailey Civil Contractors Pty Ltd (Logan), ALSCO Pty Limited (Podesta), Savvy Business Solutions and Sales Reps (Trigg), Clermont Coal Pty Ltd (Richardson), Secure Parking Pty Ltd (Syed), East Coast Car Rentals (Van Dort), Helensburgh Coal Pty Ltd (Cheetham), Wipro Technologies (Prasad), Ensign Australia Pty Ltd (Foulds), CatholicCare Diocese of Broken Bay (Duncan), Council on the Ageing WA Inc (Millar), H+Co Menswear (Ampuero), Smarter Insurance Brokers Pty Ltd (Croft), Nexus (Aust) Pty Ltd (Bonser), Worsley Alumina Pty Ltd (Bream), Fuji Xerox Australia Pty Ltd (Gordon), Allsteel Processing Pty Ltd (Menzies), Rio Tinto Aluminium Limited (Mosby), Complete Education and Touring Australia P/L (Connard), Gosnells Golf Club (Rughoobin), H & M Australia Pty Ltd (Zammit), South Oakleigh Club Incorporated (Fernando), OneSteel Trading Pty Ltd (Marshall), BananaCoast Community Credit Union Ltd (Packer), A.P.S. Group (Garcia), City of Greater Geelong (Stratton), Ray White Tweed Heads (Smith), Stockland Corporation Limited (Pate), Department of Education & Communities NSW (Astridge), Smart Plumbing Solutions (Fletcher), Qantas Airways Limited (Kay & Kibby), Chilmix Pty Ltd (Cooper), ESS Thalanyji Pty Ltd (Hellyer), Illiad Pty Ltd (Hope), David Hartree Design Associates Pty Ltd (Blythe), Electricity Networks Corporation (Boyle), SBG Administration Services Pty Ltd (Sublet), BHP Billiton Minerals Pty Ltd (Coleman), Emirate (Cozaris), Tao Cafe (Cho), Nortec Employment & Training (Bigg), Virgin Australia (Ingall), Woolworths Limited (Ruhland/Wemmerslager).

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – performance – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – applicant terminated due to poor financial performance within SA Branch – following applicant’s subsequent unauthorised removal of information confidential to respondent and personal employee information, respondent purported to summarily dismiss applicant – Commission found applicant failed to manage SA Branch in a manner that returned sustainable financial contribution – valid reason for dismissal – Commission noted that while removal of personal and confidential information would ordinarily constitute a valid reason for dismissal, as conduct occurred post termination respondent was not able to rely on it to support its earlier decision to dismiss -found while applicant was on notice that SA Branch performance unacceptable, never warned employment at risk – Commission held respondent’s failure to warn applicant denied him an opportunity to improve or respond to allegation – rendered dismissal harsh, unjust or unreasonable – applicant unfairly dismissed – reinstatement not appropriate – Sprigg principles applied – 60% discount made due to post dismissal conduct – compensation of $4602 awarded. Welsby v Artis Group P/L.

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – costs – ss.394, 611 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant’s unfair dismissal application dismissed because she had not served the minimum employment period – respondent applied for costs – submitted it should have been reasonably apparent to applicant that application had no reasonable prospects of success – further submitted application was lodged out of time and applicant not employed for minimum employment period – applicant submitted that respondent could have saved costs if they had responded to claim promptly and that her term of employment was six months – Commonwealth of Australia v Wilson considered – Commission not satisfied application had no reasonable prospects of success given the respondent sent the email dismissing the applicant at 11.41pm on 28 October 2015 when to have been employed for six months she needed to have still been employed at midnight on that day – Commission found it was not reasonably apparent to applicant that lodging application out of time meant that it had no prospects of success – also found not reasonably apparent to applicant that respondent was small business until respondent filed evidence proving such – Commission power to award costs discretionary – Commission considered this an occasion where costs should not be ordered – applicant unrepresented and inconsistent information put forward by respondent – application for costs dismissed. Whitton v Trustee for Rahul Family Trust t/a United Partners Transport and Logistics P/L.