NEWS HR

GENERAL PROTECTIONS – extension of time – ss.365, 366, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – at first instance appellant’s general protections application dismissed – application was lodged 49 days out of the time limit allowed – grounds of appeal advanced by appellant included that the Commission failed to take into account the efforts the appellant made to electronically commence an unfair dismissal application arising from the dismissal and that the Commission did not have the entire file – at the hearing of the application for appeal the appellant put forward further grounds for appeal including that his case had been hampered because of the Commission’s defective administration and that he had received misleading advice from the Commission – having considered all of the matters raised by the appellant the Full Bench found that the appeal was without foundation – permission to appeal refused. Appeal by Russell against decision of Lawrence DP of 8 February 2016 [[2016] FWC 832] Re: Gippsland Group Training Ltd t/a Apprenticeship Group Australia

ENTERPRISE BARGAINING – bargaining order – s.229 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for a bargaining order – AMWU alleged that Wedderburn had breached its good faith bargaining obligations – alleged that the disciplinary action and termination of Mr Caspersz’s employment was capricious and unfair conduct which undermined freedom of association or collective bargaining – Wedderburn denied the allegations and said that both the disciplinary action taken against Mr Caspersz and the dismissal of Mr Caspersz were legitimate and bore no relationship to bargaining or his role as a shop steward or his role in bargaining – AMWU sought reinstatement of Mr Caspersz – Mr Caspersz was a member of the AMWU, a shop steward and a part of the bargaining team – in September 2015, AMWU members employed by Wedderburn took protected industrial action – Wedderburn made allegations of misconduct against Mr Caspersz arising from his conduct on the picket line – Mr Caspersz was issued with a formal warning and advised that if there were any further instance of him failing to comply with directions his employment would be terminated – in February 2016 there was a ban on performing overtime – Mr Caspersz did not finish a job at a site in Emerald because of the overtime bans – Mr Caspersz’s employment was terminated on 17 March 2016 because he had failed to perform the allotted work during the available normal working hours – AMWU submitted that the decision to terminate Mr Casperz’s employment was capricious – Commission satisfied there was an arguable case that the decision to terminate Mr Caspersz’s employment was unfair or capricious – arguable case that his conduct was protected and the decision to terminate someone’s employment, because they took protected industrial action, is not only unfair it is a contravention of the general protections provisions of the FW Act – arguable case that in making the decision to terminate Mr Caspersz, Wedderburn was motivated by its belief that Mr Caspersz was responsible for the industrial action being taken by the employees – satisfied that terminating a shop steward who has been part of the bargaining team since bargaining commenced and who plays an important role in ensuring the views of the employees are conveyed to the union will undermine collective bargaining – satisfied that there is an arguable case that such conduct would undermine freedom of association – balance of convenience weighs in favour of reinstating Mr Caspersz – order made that Mr Caspersz be reinstated to the position he occupied prior to the termination of his employment, or if that position is not available, to another position on terms and conditions no less favourable. ‘Automotive, Food, Metals, Engineering, Printing and Kindred Industries Union’ known as the Australian Manufacturing Workers’ Union (AMWU) v W.W. Wedderburn P/L t/a Wedderburn

ANTI-BULLYING – costs – ss.604, 611 Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – original decision concerned application for order to stop bullying – applicants made allegations of bullying in relation to disagreement over management of Collie Chamber – applicants withdraw from proceedings due to apparent change in composition in Collie Chamber management – appellants filed costs application – Commission determined application not made without reasonable cause or filed vexatiously – appellants asserted costs decision in error on substantial number of grounds – permission to appeal generally granted where Full Bench concludes sufficient doubt so as to warrant reconsideration of matter or where injustice may result if permission not granted – jurisdictional error generally gives rise to grant of permission – where decision of discretionary nature appealable error must be established [House v King] – Full Bench found Commission referred to number of authorities to power to award costs which clearly established preconditions about which Commission must be satisfied before exercising discretion to award costs – Commission decision also informed by reference to established authorities in determining applicants had strong belief that applications were genuine and not made vexatiously – Full Bench not satisfied original decision attended by jurisdictional error or that it involved error in exercise of jurisdiction available to it – permission to appeal refused. Appeal by Churches and Ors against decision of Bull DP of 25 November 2015 [[2015] FWC 6620] Re: Jackson and Anor

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – minimum employment period – ss.383, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – respondent objected on basis applicant did not satisfy minimum employment period – small business employer – applicant employed from 9 February 2015 and dismissed at 7.30am on 8 February 2016 – applicant’s commencement time for work was 8.00am but he submitted that he usually arrived for work half an hour early and commenced work on arrival – respondent submitted applicant was dismissed before he commenced work on 8 February 2016 and thus he only completed work up until 7 February 2016 – Commission held the time and date which employment ends is the date when the employee is given notice of termination – held applicant given notice on 8 February 2016 thus applicant employed for 12 months – minimum employment period satisfied – jurisdictional objection dismissed. Hamilton v Image Car Wash t/a IMO Carwash

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – application to deal with dispute in accordance with dispute settlement procedure in Essential Energy Enterprise Agreement 2011 – issue whether the respondent was acting in conformity with clause 3.6(a) of the enterprise agreement when it made 29 Vegetation Officers redeployees – Commission found that respondent identified positions occupied by the 29 employees as no longer required – ‘old’ positions have been identified as no longer required by respondent – employees who have chosen not to become voluntarily redundant had therefore been declared ‘redeployees’ and given the opportunity to apply for one of the ‘new’ positions – those employees who successfully obtained one of these positions would then cease to be a redeployee – found concept of a ‘spill and fill’ is well recognised and accepted method of dealing with a situation where a restructure involves a reduction in the number of similar positions in a part of an organisation – held this was consistent with the obligations imposed on Essential Energy by the enterprise agreement. Communications, Electrical, Electronic, Energy, Information, Postal, Plumbing and Allied Services Union of Australia v Essential Energy

INDUSTRIAL ACTION – order against industrial action – s.418 Fair Work Act 2009 – Lend Lease made application alleging industrial action by CFMEU that resulted in the stoppage of work by six employees covered by the Lend Lease Project Management & Construction (Australia) P/L/CFMEU Joint Development Agreement Mark 8 2012-16 – further allegation of unlawful stoppage of work by 88 employees of various contractors – alleged industrial action commenced on 11 April 2016 at or around 6.30am, with a return to site at approximately 8.10am – direction made to remove three CFMEU flags hung from cranes on site – at manager’s meeting it was explained the workforce would be ‘out until the flags are reinstated’ – Lend Lease manager informed that site remained open and workforce were expected to remain at work – Commission held industrial action that is not, or would not, be protected industrial action occurred at the site during operational hours on 11 April 2016 – while at time of hearing industrial action not ‘happening’ as required by s.418(1)(a) of FW Act, such action was ‘threatened, impending or probable’ – CFMEU contended it was more probable than not that employees would return to work on 12 April 2016 – this contention not accepted and the issue of Lend Lease allowing or not allowing the flags considered an unresolved issue – authority did not support broad propositions made by CFMEU regarding freedom of association arguments – no evidence that written notice of an intention to hold a meeting at commencement of work issued – as employers did not grant authorisation to attend and required employees to perform their duties, the employee’s attendance would constitute unprotected industrial action – Commission not satisfied CFMEU was ‘organising’ industrial action in circumstances required for an order to be made against them under s.418(1)(c) were met – Lend Lease consequently sought orders against their employees and subcontractor employees – as Commission satisfied industrial action that would not be protected was threatened, impending or probable, order made and issued on 11 April 2016 [PR578979] – order in place until 29 April 2016, with period of nearly three weeks considered suitable for parties to advance discussions and attempt to resolve any dispute. Lend Lease Building P/L v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union

Termination of employment – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant dismissed for having inappropriate conversation with colleague about personal situation in open work area – held to be valid reason – other matters considered – applicant’s disciplinary history – warnings for interactions with colleagues that were inappropriate, disrespectful and derogatory – period of service of five years not lengthy but not insignificant – proportionality of response – had conduct been isolated incident dismissal would have been disproportionate – conduct was not sufficient for summary dismissal – employer made payment in lieu of notice – personal improvement plan fell short of best practice – on balance given earlier warnings found unlikely would have prevented applicant’s inappropriate behaviour – dismissal not harsh, unjust or unreasonable – application dismissed. McGinnis v BHP Billiton Iron One P/L

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – termination at initiative of employer – abandonment – ss.386, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – in January 2015 applicant requested two periods of annual leave – first period in early March 2015 and second period over Easter 2015 – respondent approved first period but declined second period – applicant pressed the second period of leave again in March 2015 but respondent advised that position remained unchanged – applicant proceeded to take second period of leave – respondent attempted to contact applicant during absence however no response was provided – applicant returned to work in mid April 2015 – respondent advised applicant he was no longer employed because he repudiated employment contract by taking unauthorised leave – applicant argued that respondent never made it clear that absence from employment would amount to resigning – respondent submitted that applicant was advised on multiple occasions that second period of leave would not be approved – Commission to determine whether applicant had abandoned employment or whether it was at initiative of employer – requirement that there to be some action on the part of the employer which is either intended to bring the employment to an end or has the probable result of bringing the employment relationship to an end [Searle] – Commission found that no evidence of action on part of employer to terminate employment relationship – found applicant had abandoned employment in accordance with Graphic Arts, Printing and Publishing Award 2010 – jurisdictional objection upheld – application dismissed. Mor Hiam v Jodack P/L t/a Snap Caufield South