TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – valid reason – ss.394, 400, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – appeal – Full Bench – at first instance Commission found that applicant’s dismissal was unfair due to no valid reason and ordered reinstatement – Full Bench granted permission to appeal [[2015] FWCFB 7475] – Full Bench considered whether termination was harsh, unjust or unreasonable – Full Bench considered s.387(a) of FW Act in relation to whether there was a valid reason relating to applicant’s capacity or conduct – reason can be either relatively unimportant or of much greater importance – valid reason should be ‘sound, just or well founded’ [Selvachandran] – Full Bench found that Commission required to make findings about each matter in s.387 and must also give those factors weight in making assessment as to whether termination harsh, unjust or unreasonable – meaning of ‘must have regard to’ means failure to make a finding with regard to relevant matter can result in appealable error [Chubb Security v Thomas] – Full Bench found that if Commission makes assessment that a valid reason does not warrant dismissal, or that valid reason did not exist because of extenuating factors such as length of service or other matters, difficult to see how Commission has given weight to the other factors in s.387 – Full Bench found that other factors must also be given proper weight in overall assessment – found Commission made finding that there was valid reason for termination based on extenuating reasons which were relevant to whether dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable overall, but not relevant to whether or not there was valid reason for termination – Full Bench found this constituted error of law which raised issues of public interest – also found there was a valid reason for dismissal as applicant breached safety policies of respondent – in applying s.387 the Commission must give consideration to safety standards to ensure safe work practices are applied – found error of type in House v King as Commission applied erroneous principle, misapplied provisions of FW Act and allowed irrelevant considerations to influence decision – appeal allowed – decision at first instance quashed – matter to be heard and determined by Commissioner Johns. Appeal by Parmalat Foods P/L against decision of Lawrence DP of 27 August 2015 [[2015] FWC 5535] Re: Tran
April 27, 2016
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – termination of agreement – s.225 Fair Work Act 2009 – application to terminate Allen & O’Brien P/L t/a O’Brien Electrical Services Enterprise Agreement 2010 – 2014 by Allen & O’Brien P/L t/a O’Brien Electrical Services – nominal expiry date 31 October 2014 – agreement still in operation – consideration of whether termination of enterprise agreement that has passed nominal expiry date not contrary to public interest involves something district from interests of persons and bodies covered by agreement [Aurizon] – applicant contended not contrary to public interest to terminate agreement, having regard to financial viability, capacity to compete and continue to employ – submitted public interest to maintain business which employs people – witness evidence produced by applicant showed operating at loss due to diminution in trading income of applicant – Commission not satisfied evidence established existence of agreement cause of, or significant contributing factor to diminishing profit results – agreement also operational during financial year ending 30 June 2014 at which time applicant profitable – evidence not supported by any credible evidence by way of market analysis which would underpin assertion made – witness conceded no knowledge of competitors or industrial arrangements that apply to competitors – Commission found applicant’s attempt to frame case to coalesce with circumstances in Aurizon failed because of absence of any evidence of market conditions or competitive pressures – applicant also contended not contrary to public interest to terminate agreement as the applicant had been unsuccessful in achieving new agreement despite attempts to do so – Commission rejected failure to reach agreement caused by continued operation of current agreement – Commission not satisfied that it was not contrary to the public interest to terminate agreement – application to terminate agreement dismissed. Allen & O’Brien P/L t/a O’Brien Electrical Services Enterprise Agreement 2010 – 2014
April 27, 2016
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – application to deal with a dispute under Fluor Rail Services P/L, Pilbara Region, Maintenance (AWU) Enterprise Agreement 2013 – proposed new work cycle – 14 days work, 7 days off roster (14:7 roster) changed to a 7 days work, 7 days off roster (7:7 roster) – as a consequence respondent reduced the annual salaries in the agreement by 25% – dispute about what the appropriate annual salary is for the 7:7 roster – meaning and context of the words ‘annual’ and ‘annualisation’ considered – Commission satisfied that the approach adopted by the respondent, with respect to the salaries on the introduction of the 7:7 roster, was appropriate. Australian Workers’ Union v Fluor Rail Services P/L
April 27, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – genuine redundancy – ss.389, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – eight applications for relief from unfair dismissal – objection by respondent that dismissals were cases of genuine redundancy – submitted it had restructured operations – overall number of jobs or positions or roles within the organisation had decreased – employees given the opportunity to apply for new positions – Commission satisfied respondent no longer required the jobs of the applicants to be performed by anyone – consultation obligations met – redeployment not reasonable – found the applications involved circumstances of genuine redundancy – jurisdictional objections upheld – applications dismissed. McCarthy and Ors v Patrick Stevedores Holdings P/L
April 27, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant was dismissed after investigation into number of allegations made against him – letter of termination advised that three allegations of misconduct had been substantiated – prior history of complaints made by applicant against other employees that had not been investigated – Commission found that there was not sufficient evidence to support first allegation made against applicant on balance of probabilities as only evidence available was hearsay evidence – Commission relied on the evidence of third party in relation to second allegation and also found that there was no evidence to support this allegation – Commission found that third allegation was substantiated – respondent’s decision to dismiss applicant based on their conclusions that all three allegations had been proven – also real inconsistency in which respondent dealt with the complaints made against applicant compared to those made by him – Commission found decision to dismiss applicant was wrong on the evidence – reasonable to assume that perhaps different outcome would have occurred had respondent concluded that only third allegation proven – satisfied that reinstatement was inappropriate – compensation ordered. Sanzana v Activ Foundation Incorporated t/a Activ Foundation
April 27, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – demotion – ss.386, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – respondent objected to application on basis that applicant had not been dismissed – applicant engaged as Operations Supervisor – Applicant also performed duties of Revenue Protection Officer on ad hoc basis – respondent received complaints about conduct of applicant – applicant stood down pending investigation – applicant demoted to Revenue Protection Officer role full time – applicant took demotion to mean termination despite continued possession of uniform and access to learning management system and employee portal – Commission found that employment not terminated – Commission considered Terence Lollback – Commission found that changing remuneration and duties authorised by employment contract – Commission found applicant not dismissed – respondent’s jurisdictional objection upheld – application dismissed. Singh v MSS Security P/L
April 27, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – multiple actions – ss.394, 725 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant made both unfair dismissal claim and application to Human Rights Commission (HRC) – Commission wrote letter to applicant requesting advice on which application he intended to pursue – letter returned to sender – unable to contact applicant by phone, and voice messages not returned – in absence of evidence that applicant does not wish to pursue HRC claim, Commission found application is the kind referred to in ss.729 and 732 of FW Act – in absence of confirmation applicant does not intend to pursue HRC complaint, application not made in accordance with FW Act – application dismissed under s.587 – order will issue. Mirwais v Integrated Facility Solutions (IFS) P/L t/a IFS
April 27, 2016
CONDITIONS OF EMPLOYMENT – take-home pay order – Sch. 5, Item 13B Fair Work (Transitional Provisions and Consequential Amendments) Act 2009 – five applications for take-home pay orders to remedy an alleged reduction in pay suffered as a result of the operation of transitional provisions in the Security Services Industry Award 2010 – applicants employed as security guards under award – applicants entitled to Space Tracking Station Allowance until 31 December 2014 by virtue of award’s transitional provisions – applicants’ employer ceased payment of the allowance – applicants submitted their take-home pay had been reduced as a result of payment of the allowance ceasing – employer submitted that applicants’ hourly rate increased as a result of the operation of the award, and that their take-home pay had actually increased as a result of the creation of the award – Commission not satisfied applicants suffered a reduction in take-home pay – Commission satisfied it cannot make orders sought pursuant to clause 2.4 of the award, as this clause is intended to protect new employees from reductions in take-home pay resulting from the operation of transitional provisions, and the commencement of the applicants’ employment predates the award modernisation process – application dismissed. Owens and Ors