NEWS HR

Transfer of business – enterprise agreement – s.319 Fair Work Act 2009 – application by new employer seeking orders that non-transferring employees who perform transferring work be covered IPCA (Vic) Enterprise Agreement 2012 – Commission sought additional information about how non-transferring employees would not be disadvantaged under the Agreement – concerns regarding the exclusion of penalty payments for weekends and at night which could result in employees working high proportion of weekends or at night being disadvantaged compared to the Award – employer contended the Agreement met Better Off Overall Test – BOOT based on number of rosters provided by employers to be covered by the Agreement – submitted based on representative rosters provided employees would not be disadvantaged under the Agreement – Commission noted test under s.319(3)(b) of FW Act different from BOOT – Commission found employees could be disadvantaged by making order – satisfied concerns could be overcome by combination of two methods proposed by employer – signed undertaking and incorporation of undertaking into new contract of employment for existing and future employees – employer directed to deliver documents by 13 January 2016 – if documents not provided by due date application dismissed. Sub Regional Investments P/L atf the Sub Regional Investment Trust.

Enterprise agreements – dispute about matter arising under agreement – ss.590, 604, 739 Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – appeal against orders for production of documents – appellants contended permission to appeal should be granted, the appeal upheld and the orders quashed for two reasons – Commissioner had no jurisdiction to make orders because the proceedings in which they were made improperly commenced and a nullity – none of the documents sought in orders had apparent relevance to the issues in the proceedings – Full Bench considered Re Adams and Tax Agents’ Board – found Commissioner had authority to hear and determine appellant’s objections to the competency of the dispute application to ensure Commission’s jurisdiction not exceeded – in the exercise of that authority, the use of the Commission’s procedural powers, including to order production of documents under s.590(2)(c) of FW Act, remained available – Full Bench did not consider it appropriate to allow an appeal from interlocutory procedural decision to be used as a vehicle to resolve the jurisdictional question properly before Commissioner – Full Bench rejected second ground of appeal as identified the apparent relevance of the documents to be produced for the jurisdictional objections to be determined – no proper basis demonstrated either in the public interest or otherwise for permission to appeal to be granted – permission to appeal refused. Appeal by Reddam House Limited and Anor against orders of McKenna C at Sydney of 4 December 2015 and 8 December 2015 and reasons for decision of 14 December 2015 [[2015] FWC 8541] Re: Independent Education Union of Australia.

An air of normalcy returns to the portals of the industrial referees. Nineteen applicants will parade today seeking a boost to their bank balances. The work refugees include: Bowral Co-op (Gardner), Sheike & Co Pty Ltd (Suleiman), Lynford motors (Shearer), Electricity Networks Corporation (Boyle), Ingleburn Veterinary Hospital (Pontinen), Blamey Community Group (Adams), Aussie Candle Supplies (Herbert), Johnsen Quality Bakeries Pty Ltd (Jaschke), Barrier Group Pty Ltd (Brain), Boroondara Aged Services Society (Everett), Liebherr-Australia Pty Ltd (Rees), Transdev Melbourne Pty Ltd (Skopljak), Monivae College (Bishop), Let’s talk hair (Oberholster), Springfree Trampoline Aust Pty Ltd (Barlow), The Trustee for Lillywhite Hotels Trust (Hoban), Emirates Leisure Retail (Dean), Crown Equipment Pty Ltd (O’Connor), JSC Montessori Pre-Schools (Verduyn).

CASE PROCEDURES – appeals – extension of time – s.604 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for permission to appeal decision of Commission to refuse extension of time to lodge unfair dismissal application – notice of appeal under s.604 of FW Act must be filed within 21 calendar days of decision to be appealed – notice of appeal filed 775 days late – extension of time must be granted fro appeal to be competent – considerations include whether there is a satisfactory reason for delay, length of delay, nature of grounds of appeal and any prejudice to respondent [Jobs Australia v Eland] – applicant submitted he was in Pakistan at time of decision and did not return to Australia until January 2015, at which time he saw decision for first time – Full Bench not satisfied this was a reasonable explanation for the delay, and did not explain why notice of appeal not filed until December 2015 – delay can only be characterised as lengthy – unlikely that any grounds of appeal being pursued by applicant would be upheld – respondent likely to suffer prejudice if time extended, as employment with respondent ended almost three years ago – notice of appeal incompetent and dismissed. Appeal by Ali against decision of Cloghan C of 10 October 2013 [[2013] FWC 7899] Re: Chandler Macleod Group Limited

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant employed as security officer at Brisbane airport – dismissed due to security breaches for which respondent claimed she was properly trained – zero tolerance policy towards such breaches – applicant admitted the breach but submitted her dismissal was a disproportionate response – evidence there was no written or oral communication of the zero tolerance policy – zero tolerance policy, carrying with it the very real prospect of dismissal for a single breach, requires unequivocal communication to employees – Commission found no evidence this was done – dismissal harsh and unreasonable – reinstatement appropriate in the circumstances – no order for payment of remuneration lost between dismissal and reinstatement as the conduct was a significant breach of safety requirements – reinstatement to former position, or to another position on terms and conditions no less favourable and restoration of continuity ordered. O’Brian v MSS Security P/L

Only four unfair dismissal claims are listed for hearing by the Fair Work Commission today. The full list is: CFC Electrical Pty Ltd (Paap), P&O Concrete Pumping Pty Ltd (MacDonald), Bupa Care Services Pty Limited (Cox) and Next Residential Pty Ltd (Gardiner).

The Fair Work Commission is enjoying a ‘no hearings’ mid-month respite day in most regional capitals, and only a handful of complaints are listed for hearing today. The list(s) today include: Compass Group Australia Pty Ltd (Newman) and Churches & Smargiassi (Jackson/Woods).

CONDITIONS OF EMPLOYMENT – redundancy – s.120 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant sought to reduce redundancy pay from 14 weeks to four weeks – respondent employed for five years as part-time sales assistant – respondent made redundant due to store closure – applicant submits it made respondent offer of ‘acceptable employment at another store location – respondent refused redeployment offer due to extra travel time and associated costs – respondent also submitted extra travel time would limit study time required for university studies – whether applicant obtained ‘other acceptable employment’ for respondent – Commission considered additional travel time did not necessarily make redeployment offer unacceptable [Spotless[ – however travel time to new store would double what it was previously – increased travel time represents substantial additional inconvenience – redundancy entitlement reduced to four weeks – order issued. Man to Man P/L t/a Man to Man v Sleiman