NEWS HR

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – dispute under Appendix C and clause 25.5 of Part B of the Siemens Building Technologies/”US” Utility Services and ET Enterprise Agreement 2010-2014 – employees covered by agreement are provided with use of a motor vehicle by respondent known as tool of trade (TOT) vehicle – issue in dispute was whether respondent was precluded by reason of agreement from implementing provision of e-TAGs and reimbursement for toll incurred by TOT vehicles – clause 25.5 of Part B of agreement deals with fair, travel and toll allowances – applicant argued words ‘fair and reasonable use’ contemplates respondent taking financial responsibility for operational cost of the vehicles – respondent submitted they may be required to meet petrol costs associated with ‘fair and reasonable use’ – principles of interpretation applied from Golden Cockerel – Commission did not consider there was anything in Appendix C which would prevent respondent from implementing e-TAG procedure – Commission found phrase ‘fair and reasonable use’ does not include a requirement that respondent be responsible for toll expenditure incurred while using TOT vehicle – dispute is resolved accordingly and no order is necessary. Communications, Electrical, Electronic, Energy, Information, Postal, Plumbing and Allied Services Union of Australia v Siemens Ltd.

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – varying agreement – apprehension of bias – ss.577, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – appeal – Full Bench – appeal of decision to dismiss recusal application alleging reasonable apprehension of bias – permission to appeal granted as it raised important issues concerning practice and procedure of Commission regarding communication with parties – application involved unilateral communication between a Member and one party – applied Ebner – Commission must firstly identify what factors might lead judge to decide question before him other than on merits – then, having identified factors, establish a logical connection between those factors and the fear the judge might not apply proper judicial merit – unilateral communication by party with a judge’s chambers could give rise to a reasonable apprehension of bias [John Holland Rail] – however, Full Bench not satisfied a fair minded observer might perceive logical connection between the communication in this case and a possibility that the Member would not bring an impartial mind – no error in Member’s decision not to recuse himself – appeal dismissed. Appeal by Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union against decision of Richards SDP of 4 January 2016 [[2016] FWC 37] Re: LCR Group P/L.

ANTI-BULLYING – bullied at work – ss.604, 789FC Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – application for an order to stop bullying – decision at first instance found major issues raised by appellant did not constitute unreasonable behaviour – requirements of s.789D of FW Act and considerations in Ms SB not met and order unable to be made – appellant submitted Commissioner erred in findings and was misled by facts – further submitted Commissioner applied incorrect principles in reaching decision – Full Bench found appellant unable to point to findings affected by sufficient error to require permission to appeal to be granted – weight and credit placed on evidence presented by appellant reasonably open to Commissioner – not satisfied Commissioner applied incorrect principles – Full Bench satisfied decision made by Commissioner was reasonably open to him – no basis to grant permission to appeal – permission to appeal refused. Appeal by Hammon against decision of Roe C of 14 August 2015 [[2015] FWC 5565] Re: Metricon Homes P/L t/a Metricon Homes and Ors.

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – application to deal with dispute arising under an agreement – applicant did not identify specific agreement in application – respondent acknowledged Group Resources P/L Project Delivery and Asset Services Workplace Agreement 2009 applied to applicant during employment with respondent – applicant asserted entitled to full weeks’ pay as wrongly given notice of termination concurrently with R&R leave – respondent raised jurisdictional objection that applicant not employee since 2013 and subject matter of application not raised with respondent until 15 February 2016 – Commission does not have jurisdiction to deal with dispute in relation to people who are no longer covered by relevant agreement [King] – applicant had no right under Agreement to bring dispute to Commission under dispute resolution procedure – Commission also noted relief through ‘Order to Pay’ involves enforcement of Agreement which is beyond power of Commission – only Federal Court or Federal Circuit Court empowered to make such order – application dismissed. Krajancic v UGL Limited.

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – valid reason – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant terminated shortly after making complaints against respondent to Fair Work Ombudsman and Department of Local Government and Communities – at no stage did respondent answer to applicant’s unfair dismissal application or comply with Directions issued by Commission – pursuant to s.600 of FW Act, Commission may determine a matter before it, in the absence of a person who has been required to attend before it – Commission satisfied applicant was protected from unfair dismissal and dismissal was harsh, unjust and unreasonable – reinstatement deemed inappropriate – compensation of $7,909.50 ordered. Diaz Gubern v Mimi Family Daycare Service P/L.

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – applicant employed as Manager of IT&T – summarily dismissed for misconduct related to incident at respondent’s premises at Parramatta – applicant is an internationally renowned competitive target shooter – arranged lunchtime meeting with another target shooter to discuss rifle accessories – other target shooter unable to find car park so applicant gave her access to secure parking at resident’s premises – other target shooter removed rifle from car to show applicant accessory – actions witnessed by member of public who called police – police attended site to speak to applicant and other target shooter – applicant not charged – applicant approached by his immediate supervisor for questioning – applicant refused to speak saying he had been instructed by the Police not to discuss the incident – applicant suspended on full pay during internal investigation – respondent determined that conduct breached various company policies and failed to meet expectations regarding safety and security of people and company assets – applicant dismissed after disciplinary meeting – Commission found valid reason for dismissal however applicant’s actions did not justify summary dismissal – compensation of $8,616.00 ordered. Waters v Goodyear Australia P/L.

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – costs – ss.394, 604, 611 Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – at first instance Commission dismissed application for remedy from unfair dismissal – decision was appealed and Commission granted permission to appeal [ex tempore decision issued 25 August 2015] – Full Bench received written submissions and upheld appeal, quashed first instance decision, re-determined employees application and dismissed application [[2015] FWCFB 5264] – employer then made application to Full Bench for the applicant to pay its costs for the hearing at first instance and on appeal – employer submitted that both limbs of s.611(2) of FW Act were applicable to both proceedings and that the discretion to order costs should be exercised – submitted employee fabricated version of events to support application that was designed to harass employer and that application was vexatious – argued that employees argument that summary dismissal provisions of Small Business Fair Dismissal Code (the Code) was without merit – argued employer was put to significant inconvenience, stress and expense by proceedings – Full Bench considered the interpretation and application of s.611(2)(a) [Church & Eastern Health] and s.611(2)(b) [Salva Resources] – Full Bench not prepared to accept, having not heard the evidence that employee deliberately fabricated his evidence – Full Bench found employee was ultimately successful on appeal that the summary dismissal provisions of the Code did not apply to his dismissal – found that whilst application was ultimately unsuccessful, it could not be said that his case was unarguable on the merits – Full Bench held that employee did not institute or maintain proceedings vexatiously and employee did not institute proceedings without reasonable cause or without reasonable prospect of success – application for costs dismissed. Appeal by Ryman against decision of Cambridge C of 12 June 2015 [[2015] FWC 3942] Re: Thrash P/L t/a Wisharts Automotive Services.

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – extension of time – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – application lodged seven days out of time – applicant submitted delay was result of representative error – applicant lodged application as soon as she became aware that her application had not been filed by union – Commission found applicant provided clear instructions to union representative to lodge claim and the representative had failed to do so – Commission found applicant’s case was not without merit or lacking in substance – extension of time granted. Turner v CFC Consolidated P/L atf CFC Employment Trust.