NEWS HR

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant was a Senior Land Officer dismissed summarily for misconduct – applicant submitted dismissal was reprisal for lodging a complaint resulting in Queensland Crime and Corruption Commission investigation (QCCC investigation) – respondent submitted dismissal due to conduct breaching respondent’s directions requiring absolute confidentiality in respect of the QCCC investigation and not to communicate about the investigation or make disparaging comments about colleagues via general email and breaching respondent’s code of conduct (code) – Commission satisfied that directions given to applicant not to communicate except to named persons, and not to use the general email for contentious communication, were lawful and reasonable – directions clearly communicated to applicant and he either knew and understood them, and consequences of breach, or ought to have – Commission satisfied applicant’s conduct was deliberate in breaching directions and code – found valid reason for dismissal – summary dismissal proportionate to conduct as conduct deliberate, unacceptable and had potential to cause considerable disruption in workplace – held dismissal not unfair – application dismissed. Ellen v Gladstone Area Water Board

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – genuine redundancy – ss.389, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – respondent objected on basis dismissal was case of genuine redundancy – applicant argued dismissal not genuine redundancy as it would have been reasonable to be redeployed within the respondent’s business – respondent contended that due to decline in business redeployment not possible – Commission found that respondent’s decision to make applicants position redundant was genuine – satisfied that the position made redundant was created in failed restructure of the company by the then Managing Director, who later resigned – found decision to make position redundant was because of changes in the operational requirements of the company – dismissal case of genuine redundancy and not unfair – application dismissed. Johnston v Andy’s Earthmovers (Asia Pacific) P/L t/a Andy’s Earthmovers

CASE PROCEDURES – appeals – extension of time – ss.394, 400, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – Full Bench – application for extension of time to lodge appeal – application lodged 124 days out of statutory time limit – application for unfair dismissal remedy dismissed at first instance – Full Bench found no satisfactory explanation for delay of lodgment – appellant provided no evidence of his claim of mental illness – while appellant was outside the country at time decision at first instance issued did not prevent him using technology to pursue his rights given his education and skills – no arguable case for appealable error – no case put of apprehended or actual bias – Full Bench found no public interest in appeal – application for appeal out of time – is not competent – permission to appeal refused. Appeal by Mohapatra against decision of Roe C of 2 September 2015 [[2015] FWC 5976] Re: Acciona Energy Australia Global P/L t/a Acciona Energy

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – dispute under TAD Industrial Pty Ltd (Victoria) OneSteel Reinforcing Supplementary Labour Agreement 2013-2016 concerned whether agreement terms provided for retrospective application of rates of pay – AWU submitted agreement terms dealing with wage increases have plain and unambiguous meaning that required retrospective application – respondent contended there was no express term within agreement that provided for calculation of back pay retrospectively – respondent further submitted that consistent with Golden Cockerel words to be given plain, ordinary meaning – AWU argued respondent’s submission that dates specified within agreement preceded operative date was contrary to ss.52, 54 and 182 of FW Act unsustainable – Commission of view agreement has plain and clear meaning in respect of date on which rates of pay prescribed will have effect – Commission found agreement provided entitlement to rates of pay for particular dates to employees who were employed at time agreement commenced operation. Australian Workers’ Union, The v TAD P/L t/a Tad Industrial

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – genuine redundancy – ss.394, 400, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – appeal against decision to dismiss application for unfair dismissal remedy – appellant employed as non-ongoing casual employee under contract of employment – appellant’s employment status relevant to determination of what obligations employer had to consult re redundancy – existence of dispute resolution procedure in modern award/agreement not sufficient to negate an obligation to consult about redundancy – interpretation of consultation obligations requires consideration of employment status – appellant’s employment status far from clear – proper application of s.387(1)(b) of FW Act raises public interest considerations – permission to appeal on broader grounds of employment status – can then determine application of particular consultation obligations in light of employment status – permission to appeal granted – substantive appeal to be heard. Appeal by McCaffrey against decision of Booth C of 21 January 2016 [[2016] FWC 80] Re: Indigenous Land Corporation

CASE PROCEDURES – appeals – extension of time – ss.394, 400, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – Full Bench – application seeking permission to appeal decision at first instance lodged 34 days out of time – at first instance Commission refused extension of time for filing unfair dismissal application – principles for exercising discretion in extending time summarised in Jobs Australia – respondent made no submissions opposing extension – Commission did not conduct hearing or conference in relation to dismissal matter – may have been contested facts – possible findings made without proper consideration of facts in conflict – extension of time for application for permission to appeal granted – unable to determine whether permission to appeal can be granted or whether appeal should be upheld – dismissal application referred back to Deputy President Gooley to conduct hearing or conference on contested matters before Full Bench considers permission to appeal. Appeal by Fletcher against decision and order of Johns C of 13 October 2015 and 10 November 2015 [[2015] FWC 7556] Re: Little Darlings Early Development Center

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant previously granted extension of time to lodge application – respondent not a small business employer – applicant allegedly terminated for serious misconduct – applicant had accident at work on 17 September 2015 – respondent initially discouraged the applicant from lodging worker’s compensation claim – parties subsequently agreed to lodge workers’ compensation claim for applicant – applicant met with site manager and General Manager of respondent on 12 October 2015 – respondent alleged that applicant threatened General Manager at meeting with physical violence and thus, the applicant, was terminated for gross misconduct – applicant alleged he was terminated for lodging worker’s compensation claim – Commission held the applicant was dismissed for gross misconduct – held applicant was not dismissed for lodging worker’s compensation claim – held lack of procedural fairness afforded to applicant was not enough to make applicant’s dismissal harsh, unjust or unreasonable – application dismissed. Morphett v Pearcedale Egg Farm

ENTERPRISE BARGAINING – protected action ballot – s.437 Fair Work Act 2009 – Full Bench – application for a protected action ballot order (PABO) – application heard by Commissioner Williams on 23 December 2015 – Maersk applied for matter to be referred to a Full Bench pursuant to s.615A FW Act – proper construction of ss.437(1) and (2A) and meaning of ‘notification time’ – Full Bench to determine various legal issues and then remit PABO application to Commissioner Williams for determination – Maersk contends that, properly construed, s.437(2A) read with s.437(1) mean that an application for PABO cannot be made before ‘notification time’ for proposed enterprise agreement – task of statutory construction must begin with consideration of the text itself [Alcan] – Full Bench not persuaded s.437(2A) requires that there has been a notification time in respect of enterprise agreement proposed by PABO applicant – legislative purpose in enactment of s.437(2A) in Fair Work Amendment Act 2015 was to ensure protected industrial action cannot be taken until after bargaining has commenced – a consequence of construction proposed by Maersk is that by not agreeing on scope of proposed enterprise agreement, an employer would be able to prevent employees from engaging in protected industrial action unless they have first obtained majority support determination, scope order or low paid authorisation – such a consequence is inimical to scheme of FW Act – Maersk’s construction of ss.437(1) and (2A) could produce outcomes which are plainly contrary to scheme of FW Act and purpose of s.437(2A) – an employer could deny its employees right to engage in protected industrial action simply by failing to give a valid NERR, even though employer had agreed to bargain or had initiated bargaining for enterprise agreement with those employees – subsection 437(2A) enacted for limited purpose, to overcome effect of decision in J.J Richards and ensure protected industrial action cannot be taken until after bargaining has commenced – Full Bench rejected Maersk contention that because ‘notification time’ in s.173(2) triggers requirement for employer to give the NERR in respect of proposed enterprise agreement, Commission cannot make PABO unless employer has given a valid NERR for proposed enterprise agreement – application for PABO remitted to Commissioner Williams for determination. Maritime Union of Australia, The v Maersk Crewing Australia P/L