NEWS HR

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – dispute in relation to Offshore Marine Services P/L Integrated Ratings, Cooks, Caterers and Seafarers (Offshore Oil and Gas) Enterprise Agreement 2010 relating to two-crew duty system requiring payment of dead day as duty day – the day on which crew depart a vessel and are replaced by second crew was a swing-off day – this day usually treated as dead day which is day on which employee did not accrue leave – subclause 14.8 provided that where two crew duty system did not operate or where crew member had no relief, swing-off day would be treated as duty day and employees would accrue a day’s pay and a day’s leave – Commission determined whether operation of sub-clause 14.8 required payment on the day when employees left vessel in Singapore in early September 2015 as a dead day or a duty day – ‘if the language of agreement is ambiguous or susceptible to more than one meaning then evidence of surrounding circumstances will be admissible’ [Golden Cockerel] – MUA submitted that plain meaning in sub-clause 14.8 was clear having regard to purpose and context – submitted that two-crew duty system did not operate and/or where crew member had no relief, then swing-off day would be treated as duty day and the off-going crew entitled to be paid a duty day – MUA further submitted that purpose of sub-clause was to compensate where no successive crews changing with another, there would only be one crew available to perform work on the swing off day and that accordingly the off-going crew should accrue both a day’s pay and a day’s leave – employer disputed MUA’s construction of sub-clause 14.8 – submitted that only applied if employee left vessel to which two crews had not been appointed – submitted that employees left vessel where two crews had been appointed and there was no need for any relief – submitted MUA’s interpretation erroneously construed two-crew duty system as ceasing to operate at end of a labour-hire arrangement – Commission compared sub-clause 14.8 to award – Commission found that purpose was clear – agreement provided that when two-crew system not in operation, or relief did not arrive, parties intended that this would be recognised as a duty day rather than a dead day – Commission found that two crew system referred to two full alternative crews – Commission found that short term nature of FDS assignment meant only one crew appointed – found that crew had employees who would work day or night shift and did not amount to two crews – found that words in sub-clause expressed two alternatives – first was satisfied as two-crew system did not operate and was mutual intention of parties that swing-off day would be paid as duty day – Commission found employer obliged to pay each employee’s swing-off day as a duty day. Maritime Union of Australia, The v Skills Offshore (Australia) P/L.

CASE PROCEDURES – review of external decision – s.604 Fair Work Act 2009 – cl.81 Offshore Petroleum and Greenhouse Gas Storage Act 2006 – r.53 Fair Work Commission Rules 2013 – appeal – Full Bench – at first instance Commission determined that a historical assessment was the appropriate method of determining the application from the appellant to seek revocation of NOPSEMA’s decision to issue an improvement notice – Commission adopted the questions for determination that had been proposed by NOPSEMA – appellant sought permission to appeal against the decision at first instance on the basis that it asserted that the decision applied an incorrect approach to the matter – appellant advised that it sought to challenge the improvement notice so as to protect its reputation with particular regard to future tendering arrangements – meaning of ‘de novo’ hearing – Rutjens and Shi considered – the nature of an improvement notice under the OPGGS Act and the nature of the appeal contemplated by that Act establish that this capacity to affirm, vary or revoke an improvement notice must be applied with regard to the fundamental purpose of that notice – at first instance the parties requested that Commission decide between an historical or current approach – Full Bench held that such a simple election misrepresents the nature of Commission’s task under the OPGGS Act – whilst the primary issue to be determined by Commission is whether the improvement notice should have been issued at that time, it may also, in appropriate circumstances, be necessary for Commission to determine whether an improvement notice should apply at the time it makes a decision – whilst Full Bench agreed that Commission correctly identified the major issue to be determined in the appeal, his decision did not fully take into account the extent to which a contemporary assessment of the matter may lead to a decision to review the improvement notice as part of its ultimate disposition – Full Bench unable to agree with the entirety of his conclusion – important that the approach to an appeal of this nature is founded on temporal considerations consistent with the relevant legislation and this raises matters of public interest – permission to appeal granted – the conclusion in the decision at first instance precluded the Commission from reaching a contemporary view about an improvement notice, having assessed its historical appropriateness – Full Bench held that this reflected error – appeal upheld – application referred back to the Commission to determine in accordance with this decision. Appeal by Sedco Forex International Inc against decision of Cloghan C of 26 October 2015 [[2015] FWC 7239] Re: National Offshore Petroleum Safety and Environmental Management Authority t/a NOPSEMA.

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – casual – genuine redundancy – ss.384, 389, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – respondent raised jurisdiction objections – respondent argued that applicant was not a person who was protected from unfair dismissal because he was a casual employee who worked on an irregular basis – in the alternative the dismissal was a genuine redundancy – casual – Commission satisfied applicant employed on a regular and systematic basis and had an expectation of continuing employment of that nature – approach in Shortland adopted – Commission concluded that applicant worked for a minimum of 44 weeks over a 56 week period, and most likely 48 weeks – at time of dismissal evidence suggested respondent had more than 15 employees therefore applicable minimum employment period was six months – Commission satisfied applicant achieved minimum employment period and was therefore a person protected from unfair dismissal – genuine redundancy – Commission not satisfied applicant’s dismissal occurred because respondent no longer required applicant’s job to be done – three new employees were engaged the week before – found requisite consultation did not occur – respondent’s objection that dismissal was a genuine redundancy refused – jurisdictional objections dismissed – application referred for conciliation. Murray v Zinctech Cladding and Roofing.

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – extension of time – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy lodged 22 minutes late – applicant attempted to lodge application using incorrect email address – applicant re-submitted application shortly after receiving rejection email – Commission held reason for delay consistent with an exceptional circumstance [Nulty] – Commission of the view application would have been lodged within time had it not been sent to incorrect email address – exceptional circumstances established – extension of time granted – application to be referred for conciliation. Houston v ID Fabrication.

Jones Lang Lasalle (NSW) Pty Ltd is one of twenty-three entities to appear in the Fair Work Commission to defend their action (or inaction) in regard to various staff members. The full list includes: Jones Land LaSalle (NSW) Pty Limited (Whatling), Gunnedah Preschool Kindergarten Association Incorporated (Leys), Coles Supermarkets Australia Pty Ltd (Brumfield), Quality Bakers Australia Pty Ltd (Mutimer), Toll Energy Logistics Pty Ltd (O’Dea), Curtin University of Technology (Aoun), Claremont and South Port Aged Care Ltd (Badugodahewa), Dairy Country (Barkho), Coles Supermarkets Australia Pty Ltd and Bi-Lo Pty Limited (Hart), The Salvation Army Australia Southern Territory (Sager), Golridge Pty Ltd (Solman), The Ethnic Communities Council of Queensland (Sutehrland), Planet Plumbing (Qld) Pty Ltd (Zanda), KDR Gold Coast Pty Ltd (Lahey), Beaumont Care Pty Ltd (Robertson), AGA Assistance Australia Pty Ltd (McKenzie), Trans North Bus & Coach (Doyle), Southern Cross Group Services (Grobbelaar), Transdev Brisbane Ferries Pty Ltd (Metcalfe), Yeast2west Bakeries Pty Ltd (Skinn), Kwasi Studios (Demin), Calvary Health Care Adelaide Limited (Hansen), Robern Menz (MFG) Pty Ltd (Brittan).

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – performance – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant worked as Breakfast Chef for Morris Corporation at Karratha mining resources camp – applicant engaged under sub-class 457 visa – applicant acknowledged that number of performance issues were raised with him – issues generally related to manner of applicants relationship with other employees – these incidents were subject of disciplinary discussions with applicant – applicant disputed manner in which discussions occurred and contended discussions were unfair and breached policy position promoted by employer – applicant asserted that the final warning respondent contended was given, was never given to him – applicant contended no valid reason for termination of employment – applicant also contended termination process was unfair and applicants concerns about behaviour of other employees were not properly investigated – respondent asserted that applicants’ repeated intimidation and aggression directed at other employees constitute valid reason for termination and that process of termination was fair – Commission found valid reason for termination of employment – termination of employment unjust as Commission not satisfied that allegations against applicant were sufficiently specified so that applicant was able to properly respond to them – termination of applicant was unreasonable as extent of any other employee contribution to his behaviour was not properly established to Commission – applicant unfairly dismissed – reinstatement not appropriate – compensation ordered. Reposar v Morris Corporation Ltd

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – applicant was employed as a security guard at a detention facility – applicant was given duty of maintaining constant watch of a detainee who subsequently escaped – respondent argued applicant had engaged in serious misconduct because he had been negligent in the conduct of his duties – applicant commenced his shift without checking that his radio was working properly – respondent submitted applicant failed to maintain at least an arm’s length distance from detainee – applicant failed to ensure that the equipment he had been given was fully operational – Commission of the view applicant’s non-compliance with requirement to maintain at least an arm’s length distance from detainee was a significant matter – Commission concluded the dismissal was not harsh, unjust or unreasonable – application dismissed. Haidari v Serco Group P/L t/a Serco Immigration Services

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – application to dismiss by employer – ss.394, 399A Fair Work Act 2009 – member assisted conciliation took place but only applicant representative appeared and applicant was not contactable – applicant contacted Commission and sought 28 day extension to hearing date on the basis applicant representative unavailable – respondent strongly opposed application and Commission refused applicant request – respondent applied for s.399A application on basis applicant failed to attend conciliation and was put to unnecessary costs and time by needlessly preparing for conciliation – applicant contended application should not be dismissed as he would be denied natural justice – further contended he did not attend as he had looked at the wrong Commission form and made an honest mistake – Commission satisfied applicant unreasonably failed to comply with a direction of the Commission – found mitigating circumstances, including in particular, the substantial representative error that led to him not filing his required materials – Commission did not consider it appropriate to exercise discretion to dismiss the unfair dismissal application – application to be heard – directions to be issued. Johnston v Onesteel Manufacturing P/L t/a Arrium