NEWS HR

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – conversion – s.739 Fair Work Act – dispute concerns application cl.59.5 Murdoch University Enterprise Agreement 2014 – jurisdiction not in contention – cl.109 dispute settlement procedure provides for Commission to arbitrate – applicant employed over four years on four fixed term contracts, with two extensions – agreement allows for conversion to continuing employment after three years – employer submitted conversion process a two-step process – depends on which provision of agreement the fixed term contract is made – Commission considered purpose of conversion clause was to minimise use of fixed term contract – found employee employed under cl.59.5(a) for specific task or project – contract extension extended the contract, it did not vary or replace it – given purpose of cl.59.5 if conversion was not intended to apply to people employed under subclause (a) this would have been clearly stated – no prohibition in subclause – Commission held employee eligible to make application for conversion to continuing employment – application should be considered at time application made and contract employee was on at that time – employee should not be disadvantaged by delay in having application properly considered by employer. Hayes v Murdoch University

RIGHT OF ENTRY – revocation of permit – s.510 Fair Work Act 2009 – pecuniary penalty imposed by Federal Circuit Court against permit holder for admitted breach of s.500 FW Act – Director of Fair Work Building Industry Inspectorate (Director) indicated a wish to lodge submissions in relation to s.510 FW Act – the Commission, upon becoming aware of imposition of pecuniary penalty being applied to respondent, obliged to suspend or revoke respondent’s right of entry (ROE) permits and to determine ban period – Director submitted Commission should revoke ROE permits for two years – Director submitted that Commission should have regard to fact that permit holder’s conduct attracted a penalty representing 88% of maximum penalty Federal Circuit Court was empowered to impose, and that in an analogous case Commission had revoked permit holder’s ROE permit for 19 months [Perkovic] – Director also pointed to newspaper article in which permit holder quoted, which Director submitted showed complete lack of contrition – Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (CFMEU), on behalf of permit holder, submitted actions of permit holder were unique, had not previously occurred in seven years in which he had held permit, and were not likely to be repeated – CFEMU submitted permit holder’s anxiety and depression, for which he was receiving treatment, should be taken into consideration – Commission aware permit holder had been previously ordered to pay court imposed penalty for breach of industrial law, albeit unrelated to ROE matters – Commission mindful that no evidence suggested any remorse expressed by permit holder – permit holder’s behaviour of serious kind – while Commission accepted evidence of anxiety and depression, no evidence led by CFMEU that permit holder’s stressors would be alleviated – Commission satisfied ROE permits should be revoked for two years, after which permit holder may seek to persuade Commission that he is a fit an proper person to hold ROE permit. Director, Fair Work Building Industry Inspectorate v Vink

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – small business employer – ss.23, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – s.50AAA Corporations Act 2001 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – respondent objected on the bases that applicant had made another claim relative to his employment, and that that it had only one employee at the time of the dismissal – applicant made an application to the Fair Work Ombudsman for underpayment – Commission held underpayment application did not represent an impediment to the pursuit of his unfair dismissal application – no dispute that at the time of dismissal the applicant was the only employee engaged by the respondent – dispute whether another entity which operates in South Africa should be regarded as an associated entity – South African corporation employed 21 people at the time of the applicant’s dismissal – Corporations Act requires that Commission take into account the employees of the related, but overseas operated, corporation – Commission found respondent did not meet the definition of a small business – satisfied applicant has exceeded the requisite minimum employment period – application to be referred for conciliation. Pretorius v Gardens of Italy P/L

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – genuinely agree – ss.181, 182, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – appeal against decision at first instance to refuse approval of McDermott Australia P/L Ichthys Project Offshore Construction Agreement 2016 on basis casual employees who voted in favour of approving agreement not engaged in work or being paid at time of voting and were therefore not employed, and that application not accompanied by properly signed copy of agreement as signatory was not properly appointed employee representative – appellant appealed on basis Commission had erred by concluding casual employees were not employed at time – appellant submitted employees to be balloted should include those who were usually employed or likely to be engaged [Swinburne] – Full Bench satisfied because contingent of casual employees had been hired and trained for project and none had been terminated or indicated they were unwilling to work on project, they should be included in ballot – Full Bench also satisfied signature requirements met, as agreement was signed by an employee to be covered by agreement – public interest enlivened – permission to appeal granted – appeal upheld – agreement approved. Appeal by McDermott Australia P/L against decision of Lee C of 25 February 2016 [[2016] FWC 1113] Re: The Australian Workers’ Union and Anor

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – genuine redundancy – ss.389, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant a trainer in civil construction field – respondent submitted dismissal a genuine redundancy – significant decline in students commencing civil construction courses in latter half of 2015 – applicant told position redundant at meeting – evidence there were no vacant positions in business – Commission satisfied respondent had operational reason to reduce number of trainers – found obligation to consult arose when respondent decided to reduce the number of trainers by one – should have advised all civil construction trainers of decision as they were affected employees who should have been given opportunity to discuss decision – by only notifying applicant after decision taken to select him for redundancy no such discussion able to occur – found respondent did not comply with obligations to consult under modern award – not reasonable to redeploy applicant – dismissal not genuine redundancy – decision in UES relevant in determining harshness – while failure to consult does not make dismissal harsh, unjust or unreasonable, in circumstances failure to consult was unreasonable – had respondent advised all trainers of decision, employees may have been able to propose measures to avert or mitigate adverse effects – termination unreasonable – satisfied applicant unfairly dismissed – reinstatement not appropriate – Commission considered applicant likely to have remained in employment for another week to allow consultation to occur, but applicant still would have been selected for redundancy – compensation of one week’s pay ordered. Coll v Foresite Training P/L t/a Foresite Training

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – termination at initiative of employer – resignation – ss.386, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant was employed as Sales Manager in transport and removal company – dismissal took effect on 5 November 2015 – respondent submitted that applicant was not dismissed but rather resigned of his own volition – further submitted that on a phone call the applicant said ‘I quit’ – Commission not satisfied that applicant dismissed by respondent – likely that the applicant did not clearly resign but inferred that he was ‘finished’ – that there was no further action or attempt to clarify situation until five days later confirmed the applicant had resigned – Commission found that applicant not dismissed – application dismissed. Tomlinson v Ballina Furniture Overnighters t/a Ballina Removals & Storage

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – performance – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – employer raised a number of performance issues with applicant over the course of several months – independent assessor engaged to assess applicant’s work – during the assessment period, weekly meetings were held with applicant and notes provided to him – final report following assessment concluded that the applicant was not preforming at level – applicant given opportunity to respond to report – applicant submitted that the assessment process was flawed – Commission satisfied that the underperformance constituted a valid reason for termination of employment – applicant notified of the reasons for dismissal and given the opportunity to respond – applicant also given numerous opportunities to respond to the performance issues raised – dismissal not harsh, unjust or unreasonable – application dismissed. Belachew v Australian Bureau of Statistics

GENERAL PROTECTIONS – amendment of application – ss.365, 586 Fair Work Act 2009 – request by applicant to amend general protections application by adding several respondents – applicant sought to add one company (Sphere 38 Group P/L) and two individuals – applicant submitted that his application to amend was made because of uncertainty as to the actual respondent – applicant argued that his application would be prejudiced if the application was not amended as there was a possibility Korr Electrical P/L may be deregistered by ASIC – Commission has broad discretion to correct or amend application on any terms that it considers appropriate – found employment contract indicated Sphere was applicant’s employer – complicated by fact that Sphere was not registered with ASIC until after applicant was employed – found while individuals were directors of Korr and Sphere respectively there was no material before the Commission which pointed to either of them being the applicant’s employer – Commission found appropriate to amend application to add Sphere 38 Group P/L as respondent – Commission found it appropriate for Korr to continue as a respondent given uncertainty about employer – found inappropriate to add individuals as respondents – order issued – Commission satisfied that all reasonable attempts to resolve dispute have been or are likely to be unsuccessful – certificate under s.368(3) of FW Act to issue. Doohan v Korr Electrical P/L