An application for approval of the Traineeship Mining Services Enterprise Agreement 2016 (s.185 – Application for approval of a single-enterprise agreement) will be determined by Fair Work Deputy President Asbury in Hearing Room 4 in Brisbane.
May 3, 2016
What a lazy day for the quasi-judiciary with only 22 applicants wanting their attention. The full Fair Work Commission list for hearing today includes: Durri Aboriginal Corporation Medical Service (Jarrett), Countrywide Pet Foods Pty Ltd (Flasza), Mt Pleasant Stud Farm Pty Limited (McCormick), NSW Users and Aids Association Inc (Nielsen), Northern Inland Credit Union Ltd (Sayner), South Coast Equipment Pty Limited (Boulding/Harding), Australian Red Cross Blood Service (Cugini), Serco Australia Pty Limited (Nadeem), Kimberley Quarry Pty Ltd (Hampson), ABM Resources NL (Bamford, Lowe, McInnes, Sanford, Sawley), Colorpak Limited (Byrant & Easdon and Others), Just Fine Food (Drew), Qantas Airways Limited (Gregory), St Vincent’s Hospital Melbourne (Steele), City of Greater Geelong (Stratton), Malouf Group Enterprise (Disher), AUS Water & Gas Pty Ltd (Drummond).
May 3, 2016
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – application to deal with dispute in accordance with dispute settlement procedure in Teys Bros (Beenleigh) P/L AMIEU Production Departments Enterprise Agreement 2010 (2010 agreement) – issue regarding incentive based payment system (the Remuneration Document in the 2010 agreement) and whether employees entitled to back pay – 2010 agreement expired on 31 December 2012 – respondent applied and had a new agreement approved in 2013 [[2013] FWC 7804] but this was later quashed by Full Bench [[2014] FWCFB 1313] – respondent appealed quashing order to Federal Court – Federal Court dismissed appeal – 2010 agreement never ceased to cover employees – respondent discontinued incentive payments from 4 October 2013 to 30 August 2015 due to ongoing uncertainty regarding status of 2010 agreement and other applications – Commission to determine amount of back pay owed to employees under Remuneration Document – complex dispute – Commission of the view that quantifying amounts employees owed virtually impossible due to highly variable conditions – recreating incentive scheme under 2010 agreement like ‘unscrambling an egg’ – time and effort required by parties to undertake task would result in delay of payment to employees – Commission found delay and uncertainty detrimental to all parties – litigation and disputation must end – Commission ordered respondent pay employees back pay determined according to their classification – limited to employees who have not previously accepted settlement offers – employees whose employment has terminated and were not employed for the entire disputed period are to receive a pro-rata payment – order made. Australasian Meat Industry Employees Union, The v Teys Australia P/L
May 3, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant dismissed for misconduct – respondent alleged applicant misrepresented himself as a supervisor to a client of the respondent and became privy to information that the client would normally only share with decision makers or supervisors – when confronted with this accusation the applicant responded that he had safety obligations – respondent decided the applicant’s conduct was unacceptable and his employment terminated – Commission satisfied that the applicant represented himself to the client as a supervisor when he was not one – however not satisfied that his conduct warranted a dismissal – no valid reason for the termination of the applicant’s employment – termination was harsh because he was terminated summarily and even if his conduct had been sufficient to justify dismissal it was not of such a character as to warrant summary dismissal – Commission satisfied that applicant’s misconduct contributed to decision to dismiss him and so reduced the amount of compensation payable by 20% – ordered compensation of $9,120.00 and an additional $866.40 to his superannuation fund. Jarvis v Croker Constructions
May 3, 2016
ANTI-BULLYING – likely to continue – s.789FC Fair Work Act 2009 – application for an order to stop bullying – preliminary jurisdictional issue of whether future risk of workplace bullying present – application regards alleged bullying conduct by Managing Director of a business in the online healthcare sector – applicant has not been present in workplace since mid-July 2012 when during an absence from work she was apparently denied access to her work emails – due to this and other factors the applicant considered at the time that she had been dismissed – since this time there has been various forms of litigation including an unfair dismissal application and complaints made by the applicant to the AHRC alleging dismissal from employment – litigation has also included defamation and contempt proceedings taken by the respondent – the applicant also made a workers compensation claim arising from the events in 2012 and this claim has been accepted by the relevant insurer and remains on foot – the applicant sought to rely upon conduct of the employer and its representatives in support of its application under s.789FC – respondent sought that the application be dismissed on grounds of no reasonable prospects of success, contending the applicant was no longer an employee and there was no reasonable basis upon which it was anticipated the employee would return to the workplace – applicant contended she was not dismissed and sought to return to the workplace without the risk of future unreasonable conduct – employer contended that because the applications claiming dismissal initiated by the applicant did not ultimately proceed and reinstatement was not granted, parties have, in effect, conducted themselves in a manner consistent with the absence of any employment (or contractual) relationship – G.C. and Atkinson considered – Commission satisfied that applicant no longer employed by respondent employer – return to work arrangements linked to ongoing employment – no reasonable prospect that applicant returning to workplace as a worker – no reasonable prospects that orders can be made – discretion to be exercised – outstanding matters may be taken up in other forums – application dismissed. Ms KM
May 3, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – contractor or employee – termination at initiative of employer – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – respondent raised two jurisdictional objections – applicant not an employee but an independent contractor, and there was no dismissal of applicant by respondent – applicant submitted that the employment relationship started as one of client/independent contractor however that changed and became a relationship of employer/employee – approach to distinguishing between employees and independent contractors considered [Do Rozario] – Commission found applicant was an employee of the respondent at the date of dismissal – found respondent intended to significantly alter the nature of the relationship that had existed – intended change was to convert applicant from a permanent ongoing relationship to an irregular casual relationship – change in relationship unilaterally initiated and implemented by respondent – effect of the unilateral change was to end the ongoing permanent relationship – found applicant was dismissed – Commission satisfied the dismissal of applicant was harsh – reinstatement totally inappropriate – ordered compensation of $7,000 taxed at the appropriate rate. Rohde v Bedlam Enterprise P/L t/a Cola Solar
May 3, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – genuine redundancy – ss.389, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – respondent submitted applicant’s dismissal was a genuine redundancy due to no longer requiring security services on Quill Way site – applicant conceded the requirements in s.389(1)(a) and (b) of FW Act had been satisfied – only issue in dispute was whether respondent had fully explored redeployment opportunities for applicant – respondent submitted it had no obligation to displace contractors to create a vacancy for applicant and it was not reasonable for respondent to explore redeployment outside of Western Australia – submission consistent with decision in Huang – Commission satisfied it was not reasonable in the circumstances for applicant to be redeployed to various casual positions and applicant refused the positions when offered – applicant did not express an interest in interstate or overseas redeployment prior to Determinative Conference and therefore the Commission found it was not unreasonable that respondent did not contemplate interstate or overseas redeployment – at the Determinative Conference the applicant first indicated that he would be prepared to consider interstate or overseas redeployment and that he believed that the respondent’s failure to consider such opportunities made his otherwise genuine redundancy not genuine – as a result of applicant’s failure to comply with the Directions of the Commission there was no evidence before the Commission on which it could find on the balance of probabilities that there was a job, position or other work within the respondent or an associated entity in Western Australia or elsewhere to which it would have been reasonable in all the circumstances to redeploy the applicant – found the dismissal was a case of genuine redundancy – application dismissed. Watson v G4S Secure Solutions P/L t/a G4S Security
May 3, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – incapacity – ss.394, 400, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – at first instance the Commission dismissed the appellant’s application for unfair dismissal remedy – appellant was employed as a Credit Assessment Officer for respondent – respondent became aware that appellant had been banned from engaging in credit activities for a period of five years and having had the Australian credit licence of her company cancelled – at first instance Commission found valid reason for dismissal because it was likely the appellant could no longer perform the inherent requirements of her role and the respondent could no longer have trust and confidence in the appellant – appellant sought permission to appeal – appellant argued public interest enlivened because first instance decision manifested substantial injustice, had a result which was counterintuitive, applied legal principles which were disharmonious with previous decisions of Commission and decision was attended with sufficient doubt to warrant reconsideration – test under s.400 of FW Act is a ‘stringent one’ [Coal & Allied Mining Services] – Full Bench found first instance decision was of a discretionary nature – House v King considered – found first instance decision detailed and well-reasoned – first instance decision addressed relevant statutory factors and made findings available on the evidence – Full Bench found no significant errors of fact – not satisfied grounds of appeal attract public interest – permission to appeal refused. Callychurn v Australia and New Zealand Banking Group t/a ANZ