NEWS HR

Today’s Fair Work Commission line-up of claimants is drawn from 10 work sectors. The full list includes: Janison Solutions Pty Ltd (Rothacker), Durri Aboriginal Corporation Medical Services (Jarrett), Peppers Ruffles Lodge and Spa (McInnes), JBS Australia Pty Limited – Cobram (Kells), Toll Holdings Limited (Oruc), Vinidex Pty Limited (Paikea), Ceres Agricultural Company Pty Ltd (Batchelor), Mine Concepts Pty Ltd (Breed), Gas Motors Pty Ltd (Howarth), Nigel Frank International Pty Limited (Brand), Ricoh Australia Pty Ltd (Smaill), Sawtell Hotel (Meys), International Grammar School Sydney Limited (Tsomis), South Coast Equipment Pty Limited (Boulding), South Coast Equipment Pty Limited (Harding), Grow (Sherback), VUE DC Pty Ltd (Kiss), Water Corporation (Batchem), Murrin Murrin Operations Pty Ltd (Gupta), Elements Speciality Cleaning (Bray), Aquanas Foods (Mankarious), LED Autolamps (Thorneycroft), Roo & Oz Sheetmetal Pty Ltd (Ngo), ONCALL Personnel & Management Services Pty Ltd (Trika), St Francis of Assisi Aged Care (Kalpana), Betta Grower Fertilizers (Gregory), Winslow Constructions P/L (Grey), Goulburn Valley Diaries Pty Ltd (Fenton), NPA Family and Community Services Aboriginal & Torres Strait Islander Corporation (Backo), ECB Pty Ltd (De Sola), ESRI-Australia Pty Ltd (Jarnet), RACQ Insurance (Goodingham), Foresto & Emmerson Smash Repairs (Braddy), MODEC Management Services Pte Ltd (Pettifer).

Thirty three alleged miscreants are endeavouring to fight their way out of the naughty corner. The full list includes: Gunnedah Preschool Kindergarten Association Incorporated (Leys), Passion Hair and Beauty (Berni), Camp Australia Services Pty Ltd (Stubis), Retail Food Group Pty Ltd (Bens), The Trustee for the Anrymar Trust (Angove), Richmond Fellowship ACT Inc.(Maloney), Geocon Constructors (ACT) Pty Ltd (Blyton), Carter Hold Harvey Woodproducts Australia Pty Ltd (Dunn), The Australian National University (Bladen), Cheeki Holdings P/L (Devitt), Robson Environmental Pty Ltd (Keane), Capital Property Corporation Pty Ltd ATF the Carrington Trust (Pattulo), Eaton Services Group (Downs), Quality Bakers Australia Pty Ltd (Mutimer), BHP Billiton WAIO Pty Ltd (Mazgaltsidis/Massaro), BHP Billiton Minerals Pty Ltd (Coleman), Atwood Australian Waters Drilling Pty Ltd (Ashby), Sun Connect Pty Ltd (McGregor), Belmont Sport & Recreation Club (Forde), Coles Supermarkets Australia Pty Ltd and Bi-Lo Pty Limited (Hart), Spotless Facility Services Pty Ltd (Kinsella), Jackson & Jackson Refrigeration Pty Ltd (Farrell), Twin Towns Services Club (Dank), BKE Pty Ltd (Gebadi), Atwood Australian Waters Drilling Pty Ltd (Ashby), The Trustee for SWC Unit Trust (Webb), Blackbocks Pty Ltd (Jones), Qantas Domestic Pty Ltd (Christian), Adelaide Hospitality and Tourism School (Corbo), Cheeki Holdings P/L (Devitt), Office Furniture Direct (Gehlken), Petbarn Pty Ltd (Forbes).

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – costs – ss.394, 604, 611 Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – at first instance Commission dismissed application for remedy from unfair dismissal – decision was appealed and Commission granted permission to appeal [ex tempore decision issued 25 August 2015] – Full Bench received written submissions and upheld appeal, quashed first instance decision, re-determined employees application and dismissed application [[2015] FWCFB 5264] – employer then made application to Full Bench for the applicant to pay its costs for the hearing at first instance and on appeal – employer submitted that both limbs of s.611(2) of FW Act were applicable to both proceedings and that the discretion to order costs should be exercised – submitted employee fabricated version of events to support application that was designed to harass employer and that application was vexatious – argued that employees argument that summary dismissal provisions of Small Business Fair Dismissal Code (the Code) was without merit – argued employer was put to significant inconvenience, stress and expense by proceedings – Full Bench considered the interpretation and application of s.611(2)(a) [Church & Eastern Health] and s.611(2)(b) [Salva Resources] – Full Bench not prepared to accept, having not heard the evidence that employee deliberately fabricated his evidence – Full Bench found employee was ultimately successful on appeal that the summary dismissal provisions of the Code did not apply to his dismissal – found that whilst application was ultimately unsuccessful, it could not be said that his case was unarguable on the merits – Full Bench held that employee did not institute or maintain proceedings vexatiously and employee did not institute proceedings without reasonable cause or without reasonable prospect of success – application for costs dismissed. Appeal by Ryman against decision of Cambridge C of 12 June 2015 [[2015] FWC 3942] Re: Thrash P/L t/a Wisharts Automotive Services

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – dispute under Appendix C and clause 25.5 of Part B of the Siemens Building Technologies/”US” Utility Services and ET Enterprise Agreement 2010-2014 – employees covered by agreement are provided with use of a motor vehicle by respondent known as tool of trade (TOT) vehicle – issue in dispute was whether respondent was precluded by reason of agreement from implementing provision of e-TAGs and reimbursement for toll incurred by TOT vehicles – clause 25.5 of Part B of agreement deals with fair, travel and toll allowances – applicant argued words ‘fair and reasonable use’ contemplates respondent taking financial responsibility for operational cost of the vehicles – respondent submitted they may be required to meet petrol costs associated with ‘fair and reasonable use’ – principles of interpretation applied from Golden Cockerel – Commission did not consider there was anything in Appendix C which would prevent respondent from implementing e-TAG procedure – Commission found phrase ‘fair and reasonable use’ does not include a requirement that respondent be responsible for toll expenditure incurred while using TOT vehicle – dispute is resolved accordingly and no order is necessary. Communications, Electrical, Electronic, Energy, Information, Postal, Plumbing and Allied Services Union of Australia v Siemens Ltd

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – casual – ss.384, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant employed from 10 June 2011 to 31 August 2015 – applicant part-time from 18 November 2013 to 28 April 2015 and casual at all other times – applicant performed no work from 6 March 2015 to 28 April 2015 because she had troubles with her health and her student visa – applicant terminated by text message on 31 August 2015 which said in part ‘I have taken you off the roster as you have become too unreliable. All the best.’ – Commission considered various jurisdictional objections – respondent alleged text message was not a dismissal merely removed applicant from the roster – Commission held text message was dismissal – respondent alleged applicant repudiated her contract between 6 March 2015 to 28 April 2015 and commenced a new casual contract on 28 April 2015, thus new casual contract would not meet minimum employment period – Commission held there was no repudiation of applicant’s contract because the applicant kept in regular contact with the respondent and there was a clear implication of on going work – respondent alleged applicant’s last period of service as casual was not regular or systematic and she had no reasonable expectation of continuing employment – Commission dismissed this objection based on the applicant’s rosters and her communication with the respondent – jurisdictional objections dismissed – matter listed for further proceedings to determine whether applicant’s dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable. Rahim v Murdoch University Child Care Association t/a Murdoch University Child Care Centre

RIGHT OF ENTRY – application for permit – s.512 Fair Work Act 2009 – application by the CFMEU for right of entry permit to be issued to Mr Davis – application disclosed Mr Davis had been penalised for contraventions in respect of s.44(1) of the Building and Construction Industry Improvement Act 2005 related to coercive conduct to make an enterprise agreement – matter Commission required under s.513 of FW Act to take into account in determining whether Mr Davis a fit and proper person to be granted permit – Commission found prior conduct exhibited a willingness to act over some time in a manner that had no regard for lawful responsibilities with respect to an activity central to the industrial system – Commission noted Mr Davis had not taken opportunity to present to Commission or provide any supportive statement in defence of conduct or otherwise – no evidence of remorse or contrition – no evidence before Commission that Mr Davis a changed man regarding prior actions and attitudes – Commission not satisfied prior conduct and attitudes would not be further exhibited – not satisfied Mr Davis a fit and proper person to hold a right of entry permit under FW Act – application dismissed. Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union-Construction and General Division, Queensland Northern Territory Divisional Branch

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – termination at initiative of employer – constructive dismissal – ss.386, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant lodged unfair dismissal application – advised that he was notified by respondent on 22 June 2015 that he could either take redundancy package or become independent contractor – respondent later retracted offer – applicant put on notice on 4 and 13 August – submitted resignation on 28 August 2015 – applicant alleged his manager made his work situation intolerable leading to his resignation – applicant submitted the respondent’s action were taken because he refused to become independent contractor – his duties were changed and his workload was substantially increased – submitted that he was offered an inferior contract in July – respondent went into voluntary administration and did not appear at the hearing, nor did they lodge submissions or witness statements despite requests from Commission – applicant was protected from unfair dismissal – where applicant claims they were forced to resign they must show they had no real choice [Mohazab] – Commission satisfied that applicant’s resignation was constructive dismissal – no valid reason for dismissal – reinstatement inappropriate in the circumstances – order for compensation to be made. Foster v Sushi Tribe P/L t/a Pacific Retail Management

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – costs – ss.394, 611 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant’s unfair dismissal application dismissed because she had not served the minimum employment period – respondent applied for costs – submitted it should have been reasonably apparent to applicant that application had no reasonable prospects of success – further submitted application was lodged out of time and applicant not employed for minimum employment period – applicant submitted that respondent could have saved costs if they had responded to claim promptly and that her term of employment was six months – Commonwealth of Australia v Wilson considered – Commission not satisfied application had no reasonable prospects of success given the respondent sent the email dismissing the applicant at 11.41pm on 28 October 2015 when to have been employed for six months she needed to have still been employed at midnight on that day – Commission found it was not reasonably apparent to applicant that lodging application out of time meant that it had no prospects of success – also found not reasonably apparent to applicant that respondent was small business until respondent filed evidence proving such – Commission power to award costs discretionary – Commission considered this an occasion where costs should not be ordered – applicant unrepresented and inconsistent information put forward by respondent – application for costs dismissed. Whitton v Trustee for Rahul Family Trust t/a United Partners Transport and Logistics P/L