NEWS HR

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – dispute in accordance with grievance procedure in the Woolworths National Supermarket Agreement 2012 – two conferences held and the parties agreed to participate in further direct discussions – applicant later contacted the Commission seeking to have the application set down for arbitration – respondent submitted that the applicant had not followed the grievance procedure in the agreement – further submitted that the grievance procedure required both parties to agree to arbitration – Commission found that grievance procedure required agreement from the employer to arbitrate – Commission did not have any power in the circumstances to arbitrate the dispute – Commission suggested applicant continued to escalate her grievance through the grievance procedure – suggested the respondent provide the applicant with information of who to raise her grievance with and how to pursue it. Bonham v Woolworths Ltd t/a Woolworths

INDUSTRIAL ACTION – suspension of protected industrial action – endangering life – s.424 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for an order to suspend protected industrial action that was threatened for 90 days – threatened industrial action took the form of ‘an indefinite stoppage of work’ over a span of four hours on a specified day – applicant submitted the threatened industrial action would endanger or threaten to endanger the life, personal safety, health and/or welfare of school children left stranded by the cancellation of bus routes – TWU submitted there was no evidence to suggest a four hour stop work meeting met the ‘high threshold’ required to suspend the action – Commission objected to TWU’s frequent use of the term ‘high threshold’ as the duty of the Commission is to apply the words of the FW Act, and that to apply a synonym or otherwise reformulate the statutory language would likely cause the Commission to fall into error – Commission not satisfied evidence of applicant more than a generalised prediction – TWU submitted Commission entitled to have regard to measures applicant could have put in place to mitigate effect of industrial action, and that applicant had not made efforts to mitigate effect of industrial action – time still available to applicant to make such efforts – Commission not satisfied proposed stoppage will endanger life, personal safety or health, or the welfare, of the population or a part of it – application dismissed. Busways Blacktown P/L & Busways Blacktown North P/L and Ors v Transport Workers Union of NSW

ENTERPRISE BARGAINING – protected action ballot – ss.437, 443 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for protected action ballot order (PABO) – valid application made – respondent objected to application on the basis applicant had not genuinely tried to reach agreement – respondent further submitted that if PABO made, written notice be longer than three working days – respondent submitted preconditions in s.443(1)(b) of FW Act not met as applicant refused to provide reasons for rejecting multiple proposals advanced by respondent and consistently delayed bargaining – Commission considered failure or refusal to accept respondent’s claims does not mean applicant had not been trying to reach agreement – not an unusual phenomena of bargaining – totality of circumstances to be considered – no evidence put forward to demonstrate that the applicant had been dragging its heels – Commission of the view that applicant was genuinely trying to reach an agreement – respondent failed to discharge onus of establishing exceptional circumstances to extend period of written notice – protection ballot order to be issued – order made. Australian Workers’ Union, The v Winchester Australia Ltd

REGISTERED ORGANISATIONS – alteration of eligibility rules – s.158(1) Fair Work (Registered Organisations) Act 2009 – application to amend eligibility ‘membership’ rule – notice published in Government Gazette and Commission website in accordance with RO Regulations – no objection to application received within prescribed timeframe – material filed in support and responses provided at hearing considered – Commission held requirements under the RO Act and RO Regulations satisfied – consent to the changes to the eligibility rules sought – change to take effect from 2 September 2016. The Association of Independent Schools of South Australia

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – performance – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant employed as groundsman – respondent claimed applicant’s termination followed series of poor behaviours and failure to follow basic instructions – failed to comply with reasonable instructions regarding attendance and leave arrangements – applicant advised of dismissal in text message – dismissal occurred on a summary basis – Commission found respondent had a valid reason for dismissal, however found dismissal unfair as gravity of applicant’s misconduct was disproportionate to summary dismissal – applicant not adequately warned about performance or behavioural issues – no opportunity to improve, respond or request support person – Commission found reinstatement inappropriate – compensation reduced by one third due to misconduct – ordered compensation of two week’s pay, less tax. Hayes v Mechanical Vegetation Solutions P/L

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant employed for 17 years as a foreman – made threat to harm another employee – incident occurred four days after performance discussion at which applicant was told violence or threats of violence were not tolerated or consistent with supervisory position – applicant received previous warning in 2014 that further violence would result in dismissal – Commission noted that duration of effectiveness of warning is affected by seriousness of behaviour and nature of warning given – to be valid, reason for dismissal must be sound, defensible and well-founded [Selvachandran] – threatening physical harm against another employee was valid reason – applicant’s behaviour was inconsistent with obligations as employee and as supervisor – Commission took into account warnings of 2014 and fact that performance discussion made it clear threats of violence were as inappropriate as violence itself – although ‘robust’ language was commonplace in work environment, dismissal was not due to use of foul language and workplace did not accept violence or threats of violence – found dismissal not harsh, unjust or unreasonable – dismissal based on appropriate assessment of circumstances, not inferences – dismissal not unfair – application dismissed. Maile v Inception WA P/L atf the Araminta Trust t/a Jackson Asphalt

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – genuine redundancy – ss.389, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant employed in an administration role and performed duties out of employer’s Gladstone office – respondent objected on basis of genuine redundancy – after a review of the employer’s business in Gladstone, and due to declining market, the number of office administrators required by the respondent at the Gladstone office decreased – some of the duties performed by the administration staff were able to be transferred to alternative positions and therefore it was then possible to combine the two roles into one – new position not identical to prior positions – applicant had to re-apply for position – applicant indicated she did not understand why she had to apply for her former position – applicant informed respondent she would not be applying for the position – Commission found it was not reasonable for the respondent to redeploy applicant directly to the new position as there was another employee who was also qualified to perform the new role – held respondent reasonably applied a selection process to the available position and invited each employee whose position had been made redundant to apply – found no error on the part of the respondent in requiring applicant to apply for new position – respondent discharged its obligations under s.389 of FW Act – application dismissed. Mossman v Veolia Environmental Services

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – ss.394, 400, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – at first instance the Commission dismissed applicant’s unfair dismissal application – found appellant had engaged in serious misconduct – notice of appeal alleged a number of significant errors relating to findings of fact including issues relating to evidence – appellant’s representative submitted that the finding of theft and subsequent finding of serious misconduct by the Commission were not available as the surrendered item had been abandoned and was destined for disposal – Full Bench held Commission took an orthodox approach to the matters in s.387 of FW Act – findings made concerning the key facts were supported by evidence – no case that the Commission erred in concluding that there was a valid reason for dismissal – not satisfied the grant of permission to appeal in the public interest – permission to appeal refused. Appeal by Palm against decision of Kovacic DP of 30 June 2016 [[2016] FWC 4292] Re: Sydney Night Patrol & Inquiry Co P/L t/a SNP Security