NEWS HR

GENERAL PROTECTIONS – extension of time – ss.365, 366 Fair Work Act 2009 – application to deal with contraventions involving dismissal lodged one day late – applicant notified respondent of pregnancy on 21 or 22 June 2016 – dismissed 4 July 2016 – solicitor error in calculating when 21 day time period expired – whether exceptional circumstances – Nulty considered – Commission satisfied applicant took appropriate actions to ensure application lodged on time – applicant blameless – substantive application not without merit – satisfied exceptional circumstances – satisfied reason for delay was out of ordinary course, unusual, special and uncommon – application granted – order issued. Veale v Aspire Group Enterprises atf Real Estate Prosperity Trust t/a Premium Property Management Specialists

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – extension of time – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal lodged one day outside of statutory timeframe – Commission may allow a further period for the application to be made if satisfied there are exceptional circumstances – Nulty considered – applicant submitted that he misconceived the date his dismissal took effect due to representative error – Commission considered M N Robinson v Interstate Transport P/L – found applicant was solely responsible for the error in his interpretation of the advice he received and his error in calculating the final date for filing his application – found no exceptional circumstances – application for an extension of time dismissed. Hay v Renesola Australia P/L

GENERAL PROTECTIONS – extension of time – date dismissal took effect – ss.365, 366, 386 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for general protections application involving dismissal – application made 30 days late if applicant’s argument as to effective date of dismissal accepted – Toll Personnel P/L t/a Toll People (first respondent), a labour hire company, placed applicant on temporary assignment with Toll Jalco t/a Toll People (second respondent) – applicant argued dismissal due to absenteeism – applicant met with first respondent after shifts at second respondent were reduced – first respondent contacted applicant at least 20 times after meeting to offer alternative work matching applicant’s skill set and with commensurate hourly rate – applicant did not respond – applicant later requested employment separation certificate to access unemployment benefits – Commission observed that if there was no dismissal there could be no basis upon which to grant extension of time – concept of dismissal as being action at initiative of employer remains central to concept of dismissal for purposes of s.365 – there must be action by employer which either intends to end employment relationship or has that probable result [O’Meara] – Commission accepted applicant was not employed by second respondent, since parties did not dispute that first respondent engaged applicant to perform work for second respondent – not satisfied applicant’s employment was terminated at initiative of employer – applicant had not established any action by respondent which intended to end employment relationship or which had that probable result – Commission did not accept that applicant did not respond to first respondent’s offers of employment because applicant shared mobile phone with partner and often checked messages too late – since applicant’s employment was not terminated at initiative of employer, Commission did not consider it had capacity to determine an extension of time application – applicant was not dismissed – s.368 certificate to be issued advising application had no reasonable prospect of success in that applicant was not dismissed and application could not properly be made. Williams v Toll Jalco t/a Toll People; Toll Personnel P/L t/a Toll People

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – applicant part of the Field Maintenance team – an employee (X) of the respondent had been bullied in a serious and unacceptable way by people with whom he worked – primary question was whether the applicant was involved in the bullying of X – alleged that the applicant, with two other employees, left the workplace and deliberately drove their cars in a way to block X from being able to make a right hand turn off the Golden Highway – respondent conducted an investigation and concluded the alleged conduct had occurred – the applicant and one other employee were dismissed – whether respondent had a valid reason for the dismissal of applicant – Briginshaw considered – after consideration of the evidence the Commission concluded the applicant acted intentionally, together with two other employees, to prevent X from being able to turn right off the Golden Highway – risk of a serious motor vehicle accident – only in exceptional circumstances that an employer has a right to extend any supervision over the private activities of employees [Appellant v Respondent] – out of hours conduct must have a relevant connection to the employment relationship in order to be a valid reason for dismissal [Rose v Telstra] – no question that applicant’s conduct in making a plan or agreement with the two other employees was conduct that took place at the workplace and is therefore not ‘out of hours conduct’ – Commission satisfied that the conduct engaged on the Golden Highway in relation to X had a relevant connection to the employment relationship – satisfied respondent had a valid reason for applicant’s dismissal related to his conduct, including its effect on the safety and welfare of other employees – satisfied dismissal not harsh, unjust or unreasonable – application dismissed. Kedwell v Coal & Allied Mining Services P/L t/a Mount Thorley Operations/Warkworth Mining

ENTERPRISE BARGAINING – majority support determination – s.236 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for a majority support determination – applicant relied on a petition signed by employees in May 2016 to establish a prima facie case – once respondent became aware of application it conducted a ballot of employees in June 2016 which provided three options – the result of the ballot was 30 votes against bargaining, 31 votes abstaining and 38 votes in favour of bargaining – respondent submitted the applicant posed the wrong question on the petition and that some employees may have signed the petition without it having been explained – respondent submitted that its ballot should be preferred over the applicant’s petition, as it was more recently conducted – respondent submitted that those who chose the option on the ballot of abstaining from voting should be taken to have elected against bargaining – employees not informed that a vote to abstain would be counted as a vote against bargaining – Commission of the view that it would be equally wrong to attribute a ‘no’ vote to all those who abstained as it would be to attribute a ‘yes’ vote to those who abstained – Commission also of the view that toolbox meetings conducted by the respondent were one-sided and did not fully inform employees of the facts – respondent submitted some employees who had signed the applicant’s petition had subsequently changed their minds – any ballot or petition only represents employee views at a particular point in time – Commission satisfied that time petition was taken by applicant represented the most appropriate time for determination of whether majority support for bargaining existed – Commission satisfied majority of employees support bargaining for an enterprise agreement – majority support determination made. Australian Workers’ Union, The v Kantfield P/L t/a Martogg & Company

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – dispute about classification and applicable allowance for employees appointed as electrical work team leader pursuant to Kentz P/L – CEPU Gorgon Project – Barrow Island Enterprise Agreement 2015 – union submitted the allowance properly classified as an all-purpose allowance – employer submitted it was to be paid as a flat rate – relevant clause used the words ‘weekly rate’ – leading hand clause within the agreement referred specifically to ‘all-purpose allowance’ – union submitted the team leader clause had the some property as the leading hand clause despite different text – employer submitted the textual differences were intended to be different and thus have different application – City of Wanneroo considered in relation to construction – Commission considered that the agreement distinguished electrical work team leaders from leading hands – there was no reason to import text into the agreement as it the plain, ordinary meaning could be understood – bargaining history of parties considered – the issue of characterisation of the allowance was in dispute during bargaining – does not alter the final text of the agreement – the ‘weekly rate’ was determined to be a flat rate. Communications, Electrical, Electronic, Energy, Information, Postal, Plumbing and Allied Services Union of Australia v Kentz P/L

A miniscule list of fifteen labour disputes are listed for hearing today by the Fair Work Commission. The assembled will include: Downer EDI Works (Rezaei), Community Services #1 Incorporated (Robertson), Keep Australia Beautiful Council Northern Territory (Williams), New South Wales Basketball Association Limited & Elphinston (Martinez), Toll Transport Pty Ltd (Pena), Bomaderry High School P & C Association (Walker), CHEP Pallecon Solutions Pty Ltd (Muscat), Trade Port International Pty Ltd (Cairns), Lane Cove Retirement Units Association Ltd (Allan), Momentum Media Pty Ltd (Garcia), Serco Group Pty Ltd (Karnicki), Toll Energy Logistics Pty Ltd (Zang), Rio Tinto Limited (Hocking), SJJ Group Pty Ltd (Abra), GDS Holdings (Kooyman).

An application for approval of the Unified Fire Protection Pty Ltd & CEPU NSW/NFIA Sprinkler Fitting Fire Protection Union Enterprise Agreement NSW & ACT 2015-2019 (s.185 – Application for approval of a single-enterprise agreement) will be determined by Commissioner Gregory in his Melbourne chambers.