MODERN AWARDS – 4 yearly review – common issues – s.156 Fair Work Act 2009 – Full Bench – consideration of the insertion of the TOIL model term into 10 modern awards – Full Bench first considered insertion into Mobile Crane Hiring Award 2010 and Amusement, Events and Recreation Award 2010 – provisional view expressed 11 July 2016 model term should be inserted – no objections received – held model term to be inserted into these awards – Full Bench then considered insertion into Hydrocarbons Industry (Upstream) Award 2010, Mining Industry Award 2010, Oil Refining and Manufacturing Award 2010 and Salt Industry Award 2010 (Resources Sector Awards) – Resources Sector Awards already contain a TOIL provision – AMMA submitted current provisions should not be altered – submitted current provisions were simple to understand and have met the modern awards objective – model term provides increased prescription and regulatory burden on employers – no industry evidence supports insertion of the model term – Commission should consider its previous decisions in the award modernisation process relevant to this contested issue – AWU and AMWU support the insertion because there are no industry specific reasons against it – Full Bench reiterated points from previous Full Bench decisions dealing with TOIL provisions – held no previous decisions related to this issue in award modernisation process – model term not burdensome – no relevant industry evidence against the insertion – current TOIL provisions in the Resources Sector Awards are deficient and do not provide a fair and relevant safety net because they do not provide the additional employee safeguards in the model term – model term to be inserted into the Resources Sector Awards – Full Bench then considered insertion into Marine Towage Award 2010, Ports Harbours and Enclosed Water Vessels Award 2010 (Ports Award), Professional Diving Industry (Industrial) Award 2010 (Diving Award) and Dredging Industry Award 2010 – all of these awards contained overtime provisions and the Ports Award also had a TOIL provision – MIAL, AMMA submitted similar submissions to those advanced against the insertion of the model term in Resources Sector Awards – submitted model term should not be incorporated into these awards – MUA agreed the Awards should not incorporate the model term – AWU agreed except they supported the inclusion of the model term in the Ports Award because the current TOIL term was deficient and not consistent with the modern awards objective – Full Bench held Ports Award’s current TOIL provision is deficient and does not provide a fair and relevant safety net because they do not provide the additional employee safeguards in the model term – model term to be inserted into the Ports Award – Full Bench cited April 2016 Award flexibility decision when considering the insertion of the model term into the other three Awards – held model term not to be inserted into the Dredging Industry Award 2010 or the Marine Towage Award 2010 because all interested parties opposed the variation and the awards already contained sufficient aggregate salary provisions commonly used in practice – held model term to be inserted into the Diving Award but limited to apply only to inshore divers because the Diving Award currently only provides overtime for inshore divers and not offshore divers – draft determinations to be published. 4 yearly review of modern awards – Award flexibility
September 13, 2016
CASE PROCEDURES – procedural and interim decisions – s.589 Fair Work Act 2009 – application brought on second day of hearings regarding competing scope orders – scope orders for three agreements sought by Unitywater and AWU, with application for one agreement for enterprise sought by ASU and CFMEU and supported by other unions – CFMEU sought further scope orders for either one agreement or alternatively two agreements – interim order sought to allow CFMEU to advance its position – HSU v Victorian Hospitals Industrial Association & Ors applied – Commission can make interim orders if there is a serious question to be tried and if balance of convenience favours making the order – CFMEU argued that if scope order for three agreements granted and accepted by employees, this would preclude its alternative two-agreement position – sought order that Unitywater ‘ceases and refrains from making any requests for employees to approve an enterprise agreement until FWC makes a decision on the substantive application’ – opposed by Unitywater who argued the question to be tried was weak – submitted arguments against three agreements apply equally in two and these led nowhere in advancing bargaining – issue of defective concerns notices raised – Unitywater contended interim order could also result in prejudicial delay – Commission held that the effect of the order as sought would be to re-open matter with fresh grounds – foundation for scope application considered weak due to notice of concerns not raising two agreement alternative – concerns notice likely defective – due to likelihood of causing delay and late nature of filing, Commission held that the balance of convenience weighed against interim order – application dismissed. Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v Northern SEQ Distributor – Retailer Authority t/a Unitywater
September 13, 2016
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – approval – s.185 Fair Work Act 2009 – application by Downer EDI Engineering Electrical P/L t/a Downer EDI Engineering for approval of the Downer EDI Engineering Electrical P/L Southern Region Electrical Services Enterprise Agreement 2016 – ETU opposed the approval of the agreement, on the basis that the agreement, when filed, was not signed in accordance with the requirements under FW Act and FW Regulations – Commission considered whether the agreement with signatures completed, filed after the 14 day period for an application under s.185(3)(a), be accepted (with an extension of time) under s.586 of FW Act – employee who signed agreement, only agreed to do so if his identity remained confidential, as he was concerned about victimisation for signing agreement – Commission followed decisions of Sustaining Works, McDermott and Brockman determining discretion to remedy signatory page of agreement exercised pursuant to s.586(a) – respondent argued delay in making valid application was attributable to applicant – Commission satisfied applicant endeavoured to file signed agreement and discretion to extend time for application was granted – Commission also satisfied it was appropriate in circumstances to issue separate Order supressing from publication and disclosure the employee’s signature, name, address and title contained in the signature page of the agreement and to supress the affidavit filed – approval decision to be issued with agreement. Downer EDI Engineering Electrical P/L Southern Region Electrical Services Enterprise Agreement 2016
September 13, 2016
ANTI-BULLYING – likely to continue – s.789FC Fair Work Act 2009 – application for order to stop bullying – applicant complained of intimidatory language and behaviour and unwarranted criticism by supervisors – the employer, TNT Australia P/L, submitted it carried out investigation and found allegations unsubstantiated – applicant absent from work on sick leave – employer’s representatives sought to raise performance and attendance issues without success due to applicant’s non-attendance – applicant did not attend a conference at work – applicant dismissed following day – also did not attend Commission hearing – employer filed application to dismiss on basis Commission does not have jurisdiction to make orders sought because applicant was dismissed – applicant had not taken steps to prosecute claim – Willis v Capital Radiology considered – Commission held where applicant was dismissed there was no risk applicant will continue to be bullied at work and matter has no reasonable prospects of success – application dismissed. Mr Belmar
September 13, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – remedy – compensation – ss.390, 392, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – previous decision of Commission determined no valid reason given for dismissal of applicant and found dismissal unfair [[2016] FWC 4595] – remedy to be dealt with separately – Commission found reinstatement not appropriate – McCulloch v Calvary Health Care considered – WorkCover payments and contingencies discounted – no other adjustments – ordered compensation of $34,551 plus 9.5% superannuation. Mahoney v OSSA Services P/L t/a OSSA Services
September 13, 2016
ENTERPRISE BARGAINING – scope order – s.238 Fair Work Act 2009 – three applications for competing scope orders – Unitywater and AWU sought three separate agreements covering different groups of employers – ASU and remaining unions sought a single agreement – ASU provided unchallenged evidence it met good faith bargaining requirements – ASU and CFMEU contended Unitywater breached good faith by engaging in capricious or unfair conduct, failing to provide information in a timely manner and not recognising or bargaining with representatives – concluded Unitywater did not satisfy the requirements of s.238(4)(a) of FW Act and its scope application cannot succeed – ASU and CFMEU also submitted AWU had not met its obligation to disclose reasons for pursuing a change of scope – held to have satisfied this requirement – whether scope orders proposed promote fair and efficient conduct of bargaining – AWU argued ‘three scope’ agreement more efficient due to the fact it is ready to be put to a ballot – held that fairness and efficiency favoured this proposal – whether groups operationally or organisationally distinct – ASU submitted a ‘whole of enterprise group’ is fairly chosen – Cimeco applied – ASU submitted classification overlaps and a lack of organisational distinction – AWU provided breakdown of groups – held to be clear and rational organisational distinctness – employee survey results slightly favoured AWU proposal – Kwinana considered – held three scope order best fulfils the criteria of s.238(4) – Commission satisfied it was reasonable in all the circumstances to make the order sought by AWU. Australian Municipal, Administrative, Clerical and Services Union v Northern SEQ Distributor – Retailer Authority t/a Unitywater; The Australian Workers’ Union v Northern SEQ Distributor – Retailer Authority t/a Unitywater; Northern SEQ Distributor – Retailer Authority t/a Unitywater v Australian Municipal Administrative Clerical and Services Union and Ors
September 13, 2016
RIGHT OF ENTRY – dispute over right of entry – s.505 Fair Work Act 2009 – dispute about frequency that permit holders of respondent enter applicant’s premises under s.484 of FW Act – applicant sought orders to restrict frequency and times at which entry is exercised by permit holders – further submitted that visits were a drain on their resources – respondent submitted that restrictions would impede permit holders visiting the Site and employees would be prevented from discussing or obtaining advice about enterprise bargaining process and workplace issues – Commission not persuaded that visits are particularly onerous, unreasonable or causes significant drain on applicant’s resources – requirement to escort permit holders was self-imposed one borne out of poor relations between applicant and respondent – the requirement to escort is not particularly time consuming – not satisfied that frequency with which permit holders enter applicant’s premises for discussion purposes would require unreasonable diversion of applicant’s critical resources – application dismissed. Zerella Holdings P/L v National Union of Workers
September 13, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – genuine redundancy – ss.389, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – six applications for unfair dismissal – respondent advised applicants as part of a larger group of employees that they were to be made redundant – disputes were lodged with the Commission – respondent business practice was to employ full-time workers on core work and contractors on project work – dispute resolved by offering eligible full-time employees identified as redundant project work for four months – each signed a document accepting the fixed term extension – effectively deferring the redundancy – project work continued beyond this date – respondent said documents employees signed were clear that they were employed for fixed period and not for the duration of the project – unfair dismissal applications made – jurisdiction issue of genuine redundancy – redeployment to core activity not available – employees agreement with respondent shows employees accepted redundancies – Commission found redundancies genuine – applications dismissed. Johnston and Ors v Helensburgh Coal P/L