NEWS HR

Seven of today’s labour dispute applications emanate from a single employer (Superpartners Pty Ltd). The full list includes: Candor Stationary Manufacturers Pty Ltd (Nguyen), Town of Port Hedland (Pinzone), Cape Australia Onshore Pty Ltd (Bowell), Victoria University (Bleas), Superpartners Pty Ltd (Ayaz, Bronqueur, Harder, Kaur, Matthews, Ruff, Wilson), OSSA Services Pty Ltd (Mahoney), Lovisa Pty Ltd (Carthy), Vocus Communications Limited (Hogan), Sportscover Australia Pty Ltd (Lamb), 23 Digital (Sedaghatkish), BHP Billiton Iron Ore Pty Ltd (Babic), Hume City Council (Grenfell), Davidson Cameron Clydesdale Pty Ltd (Lloyd), Okee Dokee Coomera Rivers Early Learning Centre (Cupples), Cardinal Seafoods Pty Lt (Dyson), Australian Red Cross Inc (Slater), Seven Network (Operation) Limited (Dovico), Australia – China Commerce and Industry (Wang), Turramurra Supermarkets Pty Ltd (Hawke), Full Face Orthodontics Pty Ltd (Barragan Moral), Lovisa Pty Ltd (Carthy), Mercato Enterprises Pty Ltd (Joseph), Affordable Fitness Balmain (Raffel-Smithson), Rio Tinto Shipping Pty Ltd (Perry).

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – contract for specified term – costs – ss.394, 400A, 611 Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – at first instance appellant’s application for relief from unfair dismissal was dismissed for jurisdictional reasons – appellant sought permission to appeal – alleged improper actions by the respondent, that the Commission made errors of fact and that the Commission did not adequately consider the impact his ill health had on his ability to prepare for the first instance hearing – appellant refused to comply with Commission’s directions or provide an outline of submissions when seeking permission to appeal – permission to appeal was refused because nothing in the available information indicated an appeal would be in the public interest – respondent applied for appeal costs under ss.611(2) and 400A of FW Act – appellant did not comply with directions to provide submissions and evidence in reply for the costs application – did not attend the nominated hearing date – sought a lengthy adjournment supported by medical certificates – Bench decided to determine the costs application without submissions by the appellant on 14 June 2016 because appellant was only required to provide a written submission and had demonstrated he could do this in prior correspondence on 15 May 2016 – Bench first considered s.611(2) – respondent submitted the appeal was without merit – no arguable point of law – no matter of public interest or a substantial error of fact – no reasonable prospects of success due to the deficiencies in the grounds of appeal – held appellant had provided unsupported grounds of appeal that challenged the factual and legal basis of the first instance decision – held grounds could have been arguable if supported by proper submissions and the jurisdictional issues may have meant permission to appeal could have been granted – hence no costs ordered under s. 611(2) – Bench then considered s.400A – considered whether s.400A applies to unfair dismissal appeals – held an appeal against an unfair dismissal decision is a proceeding to enforce the Commission’s duty to decide an unfair dismissal remedy under Pt. 3-2 and hence s.400A does apply to appeals against a decision of a Pt.3-2 application – held history and legislative intent supports this interpretation – respondent submitted appellant engaged in numerous unreasonable acts and omissions that caused them all of their appeal costs – Bench held appellant acted unreasonably in not filing an appeal book and submissions – applying to adjourn hearing dates at late notice and not attending hearing dates when the material demonstrated he was not incapable of attending – held this caused the respondent to incur costs to attend a second hearing only because they had to prepare for one hearing anyway – costs of $2,500 ordered. Appeal by Gugiatti against decision of Williams C of 9 April 2015 [[2015] FWC 2447] Re: SolarisCare Foundation Ltd

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – ss.387, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant dismissed for failing to disclose second job as Uber driver – applicant submitted he was not an Uber driver but it was his wife’s franchise who he provided help to during busy periods – respondent argued express term of employment contract required employees to seek permission for second job – further argued that Uber driving interfered with fitness for work and applicant hindered investigation process – applicant provided with ample opportunity to negotiate with employer regarding Uber driving – applicant of the view that even if Uber driving constituted second job, not seeking permission was a genuine mistake – Commission of the view that ss.387(a) – (h) FW Act satisfied – applicant unreasonably refused to provide Uber driving records to respondent – there was a lack of transparency and cooperation from the applicant by denying the truth and misleading the employer – dismissal not harsh, unjust or unreasonable – application dismissed. Jacob v West Australian Newspapers Limited t/a The West Australian

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant suspended from duty without pay for seven days by respondent – applicant raised a dispute under Aurizon (Western Australia) Rail Operations Enterprise Agreement 2014 (the Agreement) – applicant sought a declaration that the disciplinary measure was unfair, unreasonable and harsh in the circumstances; an order that the he be reimbursed for losses arising from the disciplinary measure; and any other orders the Commission deemed appropriate – respondent objected to Commission arbitrating dispute on the ground that the relief sought was beyond the Commission’s jurisdiction, as the relief sought would involve trespassing on respondent’s right under the agreement to discipline its staff – applicant submitted application was within Commission’s jurisdiction as the Agreement permits the Commission to ‘make a determination that is binding on the parties’ and s.739(4) FW Act authorises the Commission to exercise this power and make any order is considers appropriate – s.739(5) FW Act states that the Commission ‘must not make a decision that is inconsistent with…a fair work instrument that applies to the parties’ – Commission satisfied that a decision to arbitrate the matter and uphold the applicant’s case would involve a reversal of the respondent’s suspension of the applicant, which would be inconsistent with the Agreement – Commission satisfied it had no power to arbitrate matter – application dismissed. Lloyd v Australian Western Railroad P/L t/a ARG an Aurizon Company

CASE PROCEDURES – evidence – production of documents – ss.394, 590(2) Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal remedy – order for AWH P/L to produce documents – application for production of documents concerned a list of staff turnover referred to in one of the respondent’s witness statements – submitted that production of documents necessary due to relevance, legitimate forensic purpose and because it was not oppressive or a ‘fishing expedition’ – respondent submitted that documents would need to be ‘created’ to comply, that the information was highly confidential and would breach its privacy policy and the Privacy Act (Cth) – also submitted that the application was an attempt to question the ‘character’ of their evidence that would result in a delay and disruption to the hearing – applicant submitted in reply that the purpose of obtaining the list was to test its veracity and to establish if the respondent followed correct procedure with each redundancy – Commission held that while other employees being made redundant may be evidence of context, it is only required to find whether the position of Business Development Executive was no longer required to be performed, as a discrete position, by the employer – further held that the issue of other employee’s circumstances would not be determinant of this – Commission not persuaded that the employment details of other employees whose employment ended on grounds of redundancy would assist it specifically in relation to the position of Business Development Executive – held that the applicant had the opportunity in cross examination to ‘test’ the veracity of the document as it was attached to the respondent’s witness statement – Commission exercised its discretion not to inform itself in the manner sought by the applicant pursuant to s.590(2) of the FW Act. Smith v AWH P/L

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – genuine redundancy – ss.389, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – respondent submitted applicant’s termination was a case of genuine redundancy – respondent reviewed organisational structure and subsequently terminated the applicant’s employment on the grounds of redundancy – meaning of ‘genuine redundancy’ under FW Act considered – undisputed that employer no longer required applicant’s position to be performed by a discrete person because of changes in operational requirements of business – Commission agreed with respondent that no modern award or enterprise agreement applied to applicant – Commission nevertheless satisfied that respondent consulted with applicant about redundancy – applicant submitted it would have been reasonable for her to be redeployed into role of Finance Manager – respondent submitted it did not consider the applicant appropriate for the role – redeployment to role of Finance Manager would constitute a promotion – Commission satisfied decision not to redeploy applicant was reasonable – Commission satisfied termination of applicant’s employment was a case of genuine redundancy – application dismissed. Bwalya v PM Financial Services P/L t/a McKinley Plowman & Associates

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – dispute related to same provision in two recently approved enterprise agreements: the Australian Paper (Enterprise) Agreement, 2016-2019 Maryvale Mill Mechanical Maintenance and Engineering Store (Maintenance Agreement) and the Maryvale Mill Electrical/Plumbing Maintenance Enterprise Agreement 2016-2019 (Electrical Agreement) – essence of dispute concerned finish times for dayworkers who work a 10 hour ordinary hour day in accordance with the roster set out in the table to clause 19.2 – clause 19.2 provides a clear start time for dayworkers but does not specify the finish time of either the eight hour days or the 10 hour days – employees contend that a dayworker working a 10 hour day is entitled to a 30 minute paid meal break which counts as time worked – employer contends a dayworker working a 10 hour day is entitled to a 30 minute unpaid meal break which does not count as time worked – Commission properly understood roster in table in clause 19.2 requires a dayworker to work the number of hours mentioned (either eight or 10) exclusive of any meal break – agreement does not specifically provide for an unpaid 30 minute meal break during a dayworker’s ordinary hours – the common understanding provides for an unpaid meal break of 30 minutes on those days in the roster where the dayworker is required to work eight ordinary hours – length of any meal break and the time of taking of a meal break by a dayworker working a 10 day is not set in concrete – appropriate that parties try and reach an agreement on these matters – in the absence of any agreement, Commission will determine the matter after hearing from the parties. “Automotive, Food, Metals, Engineering, Printing and Kindred Industries Union” known as the Australian Manufacturing Workers’ Union (AMWU) and Ors v Paper Australia P/L t/a Australian Paper

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 application for relief from unfair dismissal – respondent claimed applicant misused company fuel card and mobile phone, used company’s photo of item to sell personal item on Ebay, downloaded company information to external hard drive, operated private business in breach of employment contract and poor performance following stocktake by loss of stock – Commission found that private use of the fuel card was reasonable provided he did not exceed the $600 monthly limit – found no misuse of company mobile phone provided that the $200 limit on telephone calls was not exceeded – Commission found misconduct for use of photo – however, not serious misconduct to form valid reason for dismissal – Commission found applicant did not compromise the company’s interests by backing up company laptop to external hard drive – permission was given to applicant to purchase item through private business for a friend from the company – poor performance was not established as there was no wrongdoing by applicant – Commission found no valid reason for dismissal – unauthorised deductions were made from applicant’s annual leave payment and there was failure to pay notice to which he was entitled – Commission ordered reinstatement and remuneration. Abboud v Lencrow Group P/L