The full list of unfair dismissal and labour dispute cases to be heard by the Fair Work Commission today is: Commonwealth of Australia (Favas), Coffee Works Arabica Coffee Australia Pty Ltd Home to the Coffee Works (Ruffles), AGL Energy Limited (Green), Mercato Enterprises Pty Ltd (Joseph), DP World Sydney Limited & DP World Melbourne Limited (Irwin & Marvin and Otehrs), Lipa Pharmaceuticals Ltd (Lal), City Centre Newsagency P/L (Thompson), J Pilc & MA Pilc (Baxter), Martin-Brower Australia Pty Ltd (Newall), The Trustee for Dickson Trust (Murphy), Sales Pond Pty Ltd (Obagbemi), Job Centre Australia Pty Ltd (Skeen), Hawkesbury Community Outreach Services (Knott), Cootes Transport Group Pty Ltd (Cuplan), Linfox Australia Pty Ltd (Waters), Serco Group Pty Limited (Busuttil), Inner South-West Community Development Organisation (Samuel), Taitung Australia Pty Ltd (Wong), Golden Corridor Management Pty Ltd (Howley), NSW Bricks (Lauria), Fairbridge Village WA Inc (Hardie), Serco Group Pty Ltd (Karnicki), Yulella Aboriginal Corporation (Williams), LUCRF Pty Ltd (Lollio), Timothy James Hughes (Bryson), Visionstream Pty Limited (Evans), Monash Health (Gwozdziewski), The trustee for Claerwen Family Trust (Kerry), HHR Hotel Services Pty Ltd (Khan), Don Watson Pty Ltd (Smith), Central Queensland Services Pty Ltd (Engel), The University of Queensland (Frijters), RH Prosperine Pty Ltd (Lee), Tessa Group Pty Ltd (Kilbschon), NTI Limited (Post), Blackfairs Priory School (Gregg), Wakerley & Giddings (Hazeldine), Terrex Seismic Pty Ltd (Keat, Lewis).
September 6, 2016
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – dispute regarding shiftworkers who work additional hours being paid in accordance with provisions of clause 30.2(a) of the Joinery and Building Trades Award 2010 – award provided overtime rate of 200% for all work done by shiftworkers outside ordinary hours – respondent submitted shiftworkers are correctly paid in accordance with provisions of clause 12.5 of the Core Toughened P/L and CFMEU (FFTS Branch) Enterprise Agreement 2012 – 2015 which provides additional hours be paid at 150% for the first two hours and 200% for hours thereafter – CFMEU contended this clause did not specifically deal with overtime worked by shiftworkers – as such it submitted that clause 30.2(a), being incorporated into the agreement by clause 2.1, was not overridden by any inconsistent provision – respondent submitted that clause 12.5 was inconsistent with clause 30.2(a) and should prevail over it due to the operation of agreement clause 2.2 – also submitted that the provision contained in clause 12.5 ‘covered the field’ – Golden Cockerel applied – held there is no ambiguity or uncertainty as to the operation of the clauses 2.2 and 12.5 as they both deal with setting rates for additional hours – also held that the operation of clauses 2.4, 12.2 and 12.5 are not ambiguous or uncertain as they preserve the pre-existing above agreement conditions, including the entitlement of shiftworkers to a higher rate for additional hours worked – Commission concluded that shiftworkers who commenced employment after the commencement of the agreement are entitled to payment for additional hours at the rate specified by clause 12.5, while those who were employed prior are entitled to the rate specified by clause 30.2 of the award – additionally, Commission held that shiftworkers are entitled to the benefit of a minimum overtime period or payment as provided by clause 30.6(c) of the award. Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v Core Toughened P/L
September 6, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – performance – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant employed as finance manager dismissed for unsatisfactory conduct – respondent claimed actions of applicant in submitting BASS statements without Director’s approval caused significant harm to company – Commission found no valid reason for dismissal – applicant not put on notice that employment at risk concerning either conduct or performance – no written or verbal warnings made – absence of procedural fairness – held dismissal unfair – compensation of $16,816 ordered. Schneider v Eliana Construction and Developing Group P/L
September 6, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – Small Business Fair Dismissal Code – ss.388, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant’s employment terminated due to failure to attend apprenticeship training and failure to attend to work on time – respondent contended applicant terminated in accordance with the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code – Commission found applicant’s termination in accordance with Code – application dismissed. Hockley v Salon Inspired Hair & Beauty
September 6, 2016
CASE PROCEDURES – representation – ss.394, 596 Fair Work Act 2009 – unfair dismissal application lodged outside 21 day time limit – respondent sought permission to be represented at extension of time hearing – applicant opposed grant of permission – respondent submitted matter was complex and warranted permission being granted as it would enable matter to be dealt with more efficiently – Commission considered that application was the second made by applicant after first application discontinued in accordance with settlement agreement – satisfied that there was some complexity to matter and granting permission would enable matter to be dealt with more efficiently – noted FW Act operates on presumption that parties will represent themselves – unusual case – requirements of s.596(2)(a) of FW Act met – satisfied appropriate to grant permission to be represented in extension of time hearing – permission granted in extension of time hearing. Murray v Flamestop Corporate Services P/L t/a Flamestop
September 6, 2016
CASE PROCEDURES – discontinuance – ss.394, 586 Fair Work Act 2009 – settlement in unfair dismissal matter reached at conciliation on 29 June 2016 – applicant emailed Commission on 4 July 2016 advising he did not wish to go ahead with settlement and electing to proceed to arbitration – Notice of Discontinuance filed by applicant’s representative on 8 July 2016 – email from representative on 15 July 2016 suggesting they may have filed Notice of Discontinuance in error and confirming applicant’s intention to proceed to arbitration – applicant confirmed in writing of intention to proceed – Commission emailed applicant on 26 July 2016 directing him to file and serve any evidence and submissions in support of application to revoke discontinuance – applicant did not contact Commission nor provide submissions – AB v Tabcorp Holding Limited considered and held to be binding – Commission does not have power to set aside notice of discontinuance – application dismissed. Axelby v Woolworths Limited t/a Masters Home Improvements Upper Coomera
September 6, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – high income threshold – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant lodged an application for unfair dismissal – dispute over whether the applicant was an employee or an independent contractor, whether he earned in excess of the high income threshold and whether he was covered by a Modern Award – applicant submitted he was covered by the Professional Employees Award 2010 – Commission considered the scope of services in the consultancy arrangement between the parties – Commission not satisfied that the applicant was engaged in work that would fall within the classification criteria in the Award – applicant not covered by an Award or enterprise agreement – annual rate of earnings in excess of the high income threshold – Commission satisfied that the applicant was not a person protected from unfair dismissal when he or his company’s services were terminated – unnecessary for Commission to consider whether the applicant was an employee or independent contractor – application dismissed. Forkes v Amristar Solutions P/L
September 6, 2016
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – decision concerning form of orders to be issued in relation to matter of Metropolitan Fire and Emergency Services Board v Garth Duggan and the United Firefighters’ Union of Australia [[2016] FWC 5028] – that decision dealt with question of whether there was any impediment arising from enterprise agreement to applicant implementing decision to terminate employment of a recruit firefighter – decision of Commission extended probationary period of recruit, required disclosure of criminal history and arrests, and required written warning to be issued to recruit – applicant indicated intention to appeal decision, but requested Commission proceed to determine the matter of orders prior to Full Bench hearing application to appeal substantive decision – parties had been directed to confer on form and substance of orders and seek to arrive at a consent position – differences in orders sought were minimal – applicant sought order in permissive rather than mandatory terms, so that it wasn’t forced into action pending resolution of its application to appeal – respondent sought order in mandatory terms – respondent submitted applicant was seeking the effect of a stay order – Commission satisfied no impediment to permission orders exists – applicant submitted it was not possible for recruit to re-join training process, and that it was only possible for recruit to start training again from the beginning – respondent submitted the recruit was able to take up training where he left it – Commission satisfied length of probation should be the later of a specified date and the time he completes the training course – orders to be issued. Metropolitan Fire and Emergency Services Board v Garth Duggan and the United Firefighters’ Union of Australia