NEWS HR

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – application to dismiss by employer – deed of settlement – ss.394, 400, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – at first instance Commission satisfied binding settlement agreement reached and appellant acted unreasonably in failing to discontinue application – respondent’s application to dismiss upheld – appellant sought permission to appeal identifying 23 errors of fact or finding or failures on the part of the Commission including failure to acknowledge evidence of particular file note – whether in public interest, where test is ‘a discretionary one involved a broad value judgment’ [Coal & Allied] – public interest not satisfied simply by identification of error or preference for different result – rarely appropriate to grant permission to appeal unless an arguable case of appealable error demonstrated, as appeal cannot succeed in absence of appealable error [Wan] – even if Commission made an error, not necessarily sufficient basis to grant permission to appeal [GlaxoSmithKline] – Full Bench not satisfied appellant established denial of procedural fairness – not satisfied appellant demonstrated arguable case of error by Commission – no basis to grant permission to appeal – not in public interest – permission to appeal refused. Appeal by Kong against decision of O’Callaghan SDP of 4 July 2016 [[2016] FWC 4290] Re: Citic Pacific Mining Management P/L t/a Citic Pacific Mining

CASE PROCEDURES – stay order – ss.237, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – appeal – at first instance Commission granted Union’s application under s.236 of FW Act and issued majority support determination (Determination) – employer appealed and sought stay of Determination – to grant stay, Commission must be satisfied that there is an arguable case, with some reasonable prospects of success, regarding leave to appeal and substantive merits of appeal; and that balance of convenience favours stay [Kellow-Falkiner Motors P/L v Edghill] – Commission held that grounds of appeal concerning s.237(d) of FW Act, if successfully made out, could provide basis for allowing appeal – found arguable case with some reasonable prospects of success regarding leave to appeal and merits of appeal – balance of convenience favoured granting stay as Commission unable to conclude employer would not suffer disadvantage if decision not stayed – stay order appropriate – first instance decision and Determination stayed pending hearing of appeal. Appeal by Blue Lake Milling P/L against decision of Ryan C of 18 August 2016 [[2016] FWC 5857] Re: National Union of Workers

Thirty-six unfair dismissal/labour dispute claims will be heard before the Fair Work Commission today. The hearing list includes: Spotless Group Limited (Cross), Epic Industry Training Board & Frazer (De Jong), BUPA Australia (Kalsi), ATF Sri Balaji Supermarkets Unit Trust Pty Ltd (Walton), Queensland Rail Limited (Nest), Sunco Motors Pty Ltd (Dunham), HSE Mining Pty Ltd (Ball, Bounden, Smith), The Australian Capital Territory as represented by the Chief Minister, Treasury and Economic Development Directorate (Cargill), Australian Nursing a& Midwifery Accreditation Council (Fogarty), Airservices Australia (Roneberg), Terrex Seismic Pty Ltd (Keat, Lewis), Wilson Security Pty Ltd (Davis), Monadelphous Engineering Associates Pty Ltd (Bailey), Liddell Colleries Pty Limited (McKenzie), Bendigo Health Care Group (Logan), Anglican Retirement Village (Fu), Sargents Pty Ltd (Mulcahy), Cement Australia Pty Limited (Perceval), Toll Holdings (Pirko), The Trustee for the Roman Catholic Church for the Diocese of Parramatta (Ramsey), Ignite Vision for Health and Vitality Pty Ltd ATF M and J Charlton Family Trust (Cox), Fisherman’s Wharf Narooma Pty Ltd (Brice), Cootes Transport Group Pty Ltd (Culpan), Project Air Conditioning Pty Ltd (Harry), University of New England & Duncan (MacKenzie), Uniting Church in Australia New South Wales Synod (Davidson), Toll Holdings (Bintoro), Qantas Airways Limited (Dawson), Truck Centre WA Pty Ltd (Powell), Momentum Wealth Pty Ltd (Hughes), Lawton McIvor Pty Ltd (Sullivan), Project Air Conditioning Pty Ltd (Harry), National Investigation Services of Australia Pty Ltd (Hobson).

An application for approval of the Firesafe Systems Pty Ltd and CEPU – Plumbing Division (WA Branch) Fire Sprinkler Services Enterprise Agreement Western Australia Contracts 2016-2019 (s.185 – Application for approval of a single-enterprise agreement) will be heard by Commissioner Lee in his Melbourne chambers.

Twenty-five of the fifty unfair dismissal/labour dispute cases to be heard by the Fair Work Commission today emanate from Skilled Offshore (Australia) Pty Ltd. The full list is: Skilled Offshore (Australia) Pty Ltd (Ainsworth, Byrne, Chisholm, Creely, Crumlin, Dennison, Hicks, Kapperer, Keane, Latta, Leary, Macdonald, McCabe, Mcgregor, McKenzie, Mcpherson, Moreno, Olsson, Pitt, Raumati, Scott, Smith, Tate, Watson, Willis), Electricity Networks Corporation (Healy), James Cook University (Smith), Defence Health Ltd (Nally), Yarrawonga Lake Resort Villas Pty Ltd (Ratcliffe), Cardwell Enterprises Pty Ltd (Simmons), Zone Security Pty Ltd (Karkun), Matthew Thomas Kennedy trading as Matt’s Bakery Cafe (McDonald), Mt Arthur Coal Pty Ltd (Goodall), Sydney Water Corporation (Peterski), Quality Bakers Australia Pty Ltd (Quispe), Wideform Pty Ltd (Trajkov), Anytime Australia Pty Ltd (Anthony), Royal Automotive Club Queensland (RACQ) (Massimissa), IBM Australia Ltd (Springmeyer), Warring Plastics Pty Ltd (Wigglesworth), City of Casey (Banks-Smith), Lawson Worldwide Forwarding Pty Ltd (Ilves), USG Boral Building Products Pty Ltd (Palmer), ZNX Pty Ltd (Bruce), Broadspectrum (SA) (Sadler), Moonta Health & Aged Care Inc (Maggi), Tessa Group Pty Ltd (Klibschon), BHP Billiton Mitsui Coal Pty Ltd (Peters), Rand Transport 1986 Pty Ltd (Triggell), Ardent Leisure Limited (Ranch).

Twenty-seven unfair dismissal claims will be picked apart by Fair Work Commissioners today. The list of applicants includes: Asplundah Tree Experts (Australia) Pty Ltd (Corbett), Liddell Colleries Pty Limited (McKenzie), James Cook University (Smith), Australian Native Landscapes Pty Limited (Hicks), Telum Precast (NSW) Pty Limited & Myles and Others (Howarth), National Film & Sound Archive (Constable), Capital Landscape Contractors Pty Ltd (Elford), United Management Services Pty Ltd (Court), Cement Australia Pty Limited (Perceval), Byron Group Holdings Pty Ltd (Lekov), Eve O & G (Cox), Tresmine Pty Ltd (Ha), Sydney Water Corporation (Petreski), DP World (Fremantle) Ltd (Moylan), Asciano Services Pty Ltd (Ellery), Victoria Police (Verma), National Retail Association Limited (Campitelli, Nimmo), CPB Contractors Pty Ltd (Flavell), Orora Limited & Orora Limited (Cajdin), Ecolab Pty Ltd (Smith), Anatole G Kowaliw & Associates Pty Ltd (Bernie), Australian International Academy of Education Inc (Badawi), Cairns Coach Care Pty Ltd (Johns), J Mathews Pty Ltd (Lambert), Broadspectrum (SA) (Sadler), Peter Balnaves (Galil).

Thirty-three labour dispute applications are listed for hearing today in the Fair Work Commission. The full case load is as follows: James Cook University (Smith), Seven Network (Operation) Limited (Dovico), Queensland University of Technology (Delaat), Community Services #1 Incorporated (Robertson), Zrtexact Pty Ltd (Power), Australian Comfort Group Pty Ltd (Sampson), Western Sydney University (Byrne), Staples Australia Pty Ltd (Rogers, Williams, Wu), Big Fat Smile Pty Ltd (Curry), Nelson (Aust) J A Pty Ltd (Lau), Endeavour Energy (McWhirter), Pilbara Iron Company (Service) Pty Ltd (Fountain), Award Signs (Heller), VGW Investments Pty Ltd (Morton), SMR Learning Services Pty Ltd (Hayes), GO Marine Group Pty Ltd (Verignon), Ceva Logistics (Broukoumis), Toll Liquids (Greig), Elbarki Nominees Pty Limited (Jackson), Sensis Pty Ltd (Manticas), Turi Foods Pty Ltd (Nipoe), Toyota Motor Corporation Australia Limited (Wessley), Cabrini Health Limited (Kent), Trade & Investment Queensland (Lim), Jain Pty Ltd (Michael), ASP Ship Management Pty Ltd (Evans), Vertest Pty Ltd (Green), Walls Bros Furniture & Upholstery Pty Ltd (Fahy), Unity Group Ned’P Pty Ltd (Howard), Penrice Soda Products Pty Ltd (Klemm), Department of Planning, Transport and Infrastructure (Williams).

An application for approval of the Melbourne Construct Solutions Pty Ltd and the CFMEU (Victorian Construction and General Division) Enterprise Agreement 2016-2018 (s.185 – Application for approval of a single-enterprise agreement) will be determined by Commissioner Gregory in his Melbourne chambers at 13.45