TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant employed as a mechanical trainer/assessor by a registered training organisation – applicant summarily terminated following alleged falsification of times on timesheets – applicant argued discrepancies were due to error in copying and pasting times from his Outlook calendar into his timesheet – Commission held conduct was valid reason for dismissal as there was no satisfactory explanation for the inaccurate recording of time found – timesheets were contrary to employer-supplied vehicle GPS records – Commission found that misconduct did in fact occur [Selvachandran] – dismissal not harsh – termination of employment not unfair – application dismissed. Whelan v Motor Trade Association of Western Australia Inc and Automotive Institute of Technology
December 8, 2017
ANTI-BULLYING – reasonable management action – ss.789FC, 789FF Fair Work Act 2009 – application for order to stop bullying – applicant employed as a security officer since January 2011 – initial application resulted in action against a direct supervisor but no finding of bullying – applicant transferred until supervisor’s retirement, taking into account applicant’s work restrictions following a workplace injury – applicant filed an amended application to reflect allegations against another respondent employee arising from four events in particular – in first event, Commission held that it was unable to conclude that a written warning was unreasonable management action as conduct did occur and was in breach of known policy which was required to be followed – in second event, respondent agreed to accommodate applicant’s request to withdraw warning – in third and fourth events, Commission found that action taken by respondent was reasonable management action carried out in a reasonable manner – found that applicant’s complaint not without some merit – held that applicant not able to demonstrate to Commission’s satisfaction that respondent repeatedly behaved unreasonably towards applicant – application dismissed. Mr Kotevski
December 8, 2017
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – application to deal with a dispute in accordance with dispute resolution procedure under WorkPac P/L Mining (Coal) Industry Enterprise Agreement 2012 (Agreement) – CFMEU contended applicants were shift workers working a roster which rotated from day shift to night shift and were entitled to be paid for all shifts worked – applicants’ rates of pay were changed – respondent submitted Commission did not have jurisdiction to arbitrate the settlement under the dispute settlement procedure – jurisdictional objection concurrently dealt with substantive issues – issue of whether dispute settlement term authorised Commission to arbitrate dispute in absence of agreement from all parties to dispute – Commission examined the construction of Agreement – construction of industrial instruments principles applied [Berri] – Commission rejected respondent’s submissions – jurisdictional objection dismissed – found Commission empowered to arbitrate dispute – held day shift workers not entitled to be paid afternoon and night shift rates for all shifts worked. Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v WorkPac P/L (No 2)
December 8, 2017
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – fairly chosen – ss.185, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – appeal – Full Bench – at first instance, Commission dismissed application by appellant for approval of Aerocare Collective Agreement 2017 (Agreement) on two bases: Commission not satisfied that group of employees covered by Agreement were fairly chosen and Commission not satisfied that Agreement passed BOOT – further, Commission held that any undertakings about BOOT concerns would amount to substantial changes to Agreement – appellant appealed on basis that Commission erred in making the above findings – permission to appeal granted in relation to ‘fairly chosen’ ground – Full Bench considered exclusion of casual employees from bargaining process and proposed agreement, where casual employees previously covered by pre-existing 2012 Agreement and Notices of Employee Representational Rights to initiate bargaining process were sent to casual employees – Full Bench held that ‘abrupt’ decision to exclude casuals would provide reasonable conclusion that group of employees covered was not fairly chosen – Full Bench rejected appeal ground that Commission erred in concluding ‘fairly chosen’ requirement was not satisfied – as ‘fairly chosen’ requirement not satisfied, remaining appeal grounds need not be considered as Agreement would not be approved – parties granted opportunity to make submissions about further disposition of appeal to be filed on or before 5.00pm Monday 4 December 2017. Appeal by Aerocare Flight Support P/L t/a Aerocare Flight Support against decision of Wilson C of 31 August 2017 [[2017] FWC 4311] Re: Transport Workers’ Union of Australia and Anor
December 8, 2017
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – application to deal with a dispute about appropriate classification of applicant under Boral Concrete Testers and Australian Workers Union Workplace Agreement 2007-2010 (2007 Agreement), the Boral Concrete Testers Enterprise Agreement 2011 (2011 Agreement), and the Boral Concrete Testers Enterprise Agreement 2013 (2013 Agreement) – applicant classified as Tester Grade 3 – Commission could not consider issue under 2007 Agreement as applicant did not engage dispute resolution procedure in that Agreement – Commission found applicant had not performed all duties of a supervisor and should not be classified as supervisor while covered by 2011 Agreement – found applicant was not able to perform requirements of a Grade 4 classification as defined in 2013 Agreement – determined that at all times whilst covered by the 2011 and 2013 Agreements, applicant not entitled to be classified as Tester Grade 4 or Supervisor – however, Commission noted respondent’s inconsistent treatment in classifying employees as two other employees were classified as Tester Grade 4 although they did no more than Tester Grade 3 work – Commission recommended respondent pay applicant an amount equal to half the difference between Tester Grade 3 and Tester Grade 4 – no obligation on respondent to adopt recommendation from Commission. The Australian Workers’ Union v Boral Resources (Vic) P/L
December 8, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – performance – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – applicant was employed as a Work Health and Safety Officer – role involved ensuring compliance with Work Health and Safety requirements on constructions sites – applicant received three written warnings from the respondent that safety requirements were not being met – the complaints included concerns arising from the amount of rubbish on site, inadequate drug and alcohol testing and insufficient fencing – the applicant maintained that his role was advisory and did not involve implementing safety initiatives and solutions – Commission was satisfied that respondent had a valid reason for termination – no evidence that applicant was refused a support person – applicant was given an opportunity to respond – Commission found that dismissal was not harsh, unjust or unreasonable – application dismissed. Nieberg v The Heran Building Group P/L t/a Heran Building Group
December 7, 2017
Only twenty applications are listed today. The full list for the Fair Work Commission is: Bushland Health Group Ltd (Mitchell), Helloworld (Scanes), Commonwealth Bank of Australia (Bozinoska), Sydney Aquarium Company Pty Ltd (Davis), Resilience Solutions Pty Ltd (Major), Travelex Ltd (Shahzad), Bechtel Construction (Australia) Pty Ltd (Kezich), Fresh Cheese Co (Aust) Pty Ltd (Condello), Boeing Aerostructures Australia Pty Limited (Cristobal), Alpha Flight Services (Pecoski), Aurora Energy (Philps), Foot & Thai Massage Pty Ltd (Durado, Isugan), Platinum 2224 Pty Ltd (Horgan), PJ Burns Builder Pty Ltd (Woodhead), The Brown and Hurley Group Pty Ltd (Stevens), Executive Security Group Pty Ltd (Cuff), Sydney Night Patrol & Inquiry Co Pty Ltd (Fang), Accolade Wines Australia Limited (Emery), Darwin Skills Development Scheme (Norton).
December 6, 2017
Twenty-five unfair dismissal/labour dispute assertions will be tested before Fair Work commissioner today. The full list is: Mission Australia Early Learning (Jobber), Shorefront Holdings Pty Ltd (Mohindra), Strata Community Association Ltd (Kumari), Startrack Express (Taylor), Fender Katsalidis (Aust) Pty Ltd (Bark), DJS Qualicoaters Pty Ltd (Zveglic), David Dye Pty Ltd (Dawson), G James Extrustion Co Pty Ltd (Mortimer), RACV Inverloch Resort (Chand), Ableridge Pty Limited & Monaghan and Another (Maharaj), Whirlwind Print Pty Ltd (Peckham), Sportsco Corporate Pty Ltd (Kazacos), The Nuance Group (Australia) Pty Ltd (Liang), Guru Amar Pty Ltd (Duiker), BMW Melbourne Pty Limited (Eagland), Vazza Pty Ltd (Li), Commonwealth Bank of Australia (Walker), Camp Australia Pty Ltd (O’Brien), Neilsens Concrete Pty Ltd (Law), Victory Church (Dailly), Kone Elevators Pty Ltd (Mocanu), G James Extrusion Co Pty Ltd (Mortimer), GHSR Pty Ltd (Rollason), Two Wells Community Children’s Centre (Martin).