TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – casual – contract for specific task – labour hire – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – unfair dismissal application – objection that applicant was a casual employee with no reasonable expectation of continuing employment – applicant employed for specified task which came to an end – Commission found applicant employed on a regular and systematic basis – had an expectation that employment would continue – contract for specified task must be clear and predictable as to when the task will be completed – no evidence applicant’s contract of employment was limited so it would come to an end on the completion of one or more tasks – satisfied applicant not under contract for a specified task – followed that contract of employment could not ‘simply come to an end’ once the specified task was completed – jurisdictional objection dismissed. Smith v Goldfields People Hire P/L atf Goldfields People Hire Trust t/a GPH Recruitment
January 9, 2018
As the Christmas break closes in on the Fair Work Commissioners, twenty unfair dismissal/employment dispute applications remain to be cleared from the lists. The cases are: Citywide Service Solutions Pty Ltd (Forlonge), Essential Energy (Campbell, Fitzgerald, Weekley), Carrington Aged Care (Duncan), Association of the Franciscan Order of Friars Minor (Frost), Kinderoos Group Pty Ltd (Witaarsari), Renovatex Pty Ltd (Connell), Campaspe Shire Council (Aldous), Northern Territory of Australia (Clarke), Sportsco Corporate Pty Ltd (Kazacos), G4S Custodial Services Pty Ltd (Lee), City of Kingston (Ayres), Caltex Refineries (Qld) Pty Ltd (Stanes), Regis Aged Care Pty Ltd (Bernasconi), The Uniting Church in Australia Property Trust (Q) (Kolobius), Casinos Austria International (Henry), TRG Administration Pty Ltd (Ward), WesTrac Pty Ltd (Mwango), Two Wells Community Children’s Centre (Martin).
January 9, 2018
Twenty-one unfair dismissal/labour dispute applications will be heard by the Fair Work Commission. The full list is: Games Workshop Oz Pty Ltd (Bennett), Westpac banking Corporation (Lecaude), S&L Lenz Pty Ltd (Rutland), Just Eat (Buttel), National Critical Care and Trauma Response Centre (Fawcett), Melbourne Water Corporation (Keshishian), CSL Behring (Australia) Pty Ltd (Zanon), Apricus Solar (Bugden), Ambulance Victoria (Petrasek), Lindsay Australia Limited (Menzies), Australian Taxation Officer (Nisha), Linfox Australia Pty Ltd (Howell), G A Quality Chickens (Kay), The Australian Capital Territory (Terlich), Digital Fox Pty Ltd (Gambling), Olympus Medical Centre (Brisbane City) Pty Ltd (Cantwell), SDA Schools (North NSW) Ltd (Carey), Toukay Enterprise Pty Ltd AFT (Portolesi), AAT Kings Coach Company Pty Ltd (MacKenzie), Spotless Services (Australia) Ltd (Swaine), Just Wrecking Toyota (Korosec).
December 20, 2017
A crowded house of forty-three unfair dismissal/employment dispute applications clutter the list of the Fair Work Commission this morning. The full complement includes: C.K. Jelsma & J Jelsma (Scaenes), Essential Energy (Campbell, Fitzgerald, Weekley), Alpine Designer Homes Pty Ltd (Olcayto), CPS Complete Plumbing Solutions Group Pty Limited (Savage), Construction Sciences (Dore), Nine West Australia Pty Ltd (Misoyannis), Arnott’s Biscuits Limited (Gielis), M & CK Engineering Services (WA) Pty Ltd (Rawlinson), Westpac Banking Corporation (Lecaude), Local Trade Specialist Group Pty Ltd (Bennett), Monash Health (Garnick), Tenix Solutions Pty Ltd (Stockman), Ramsay Health Care (Ho), G4S Custodial Services Pty Ltd (Lee), Transdev Melbourne Pty Ltd (Rivera), Foot & Thai Massage Pty Ltd (Durado, Isugan), Flight Centre Travel Group (Duperouzel), Southern Cross Care (Qld) Inc (Weekes), Department of Health (Blandford), Linx Stevedoring Pty Ltd (Hicks), Reece Pty Limited (Miles), Timberlink Australia Pty Ltd (Rembowski), Positive Group Australia Pty Ltd (Gordon), Atomix Design Pty Ltd (Stewart), Business Risks International Pty Limited (Baker), Cruise 1st Australia Pty Ltd (Seift), ResMed Limited (Tran), Sydney International Container Terminals Pty Limited (Colwell), Vogue Fashion Management Pty Ltd (O’Connell), Australian Pharmaceutical Industries Ltd (Chisari), P&G Growth Pty Ltd (Kabura), State of Victoria [Department of Education & Training] (Freeman), Parkinson’s Victoria Ltd (Speirs), Woolworths Limited (Lin), The Trustee for Dun & Bradstreet Unit Trust (Chatterton), Business Risks International Pty Limited (Baker), Mayfield Education Inc (An), Bee Cos We Care Pty Ltd (Phillpot), Australian Criminal Intelligence Commission (Suiter), Caltex Refineries (Qld) Pty Ltd (Stanes).
December 15, 2017
Twenty-four unfair dismissal/labour dispute applications will be heard by the Fair Work Commission today. The full list is: Cardboard King Assets Pty Ltd (Farrugia), Rail Industry Safety & Standards Board (Bonnar), Woodhams International Pty Ltd (Limmer), Wettenhalls (McCormack), Bondi’s Best Hall Street (Moffa), Mary Donald Nominees Pty Ltd (Awad), Big Small Biffo Pty Ltd (Tilston), MSS Security Pty Ltd (Sullivan), Compass Group (Australia) Pty Ltd (Kapeli), Bansley Pty Ltd (Bako), Bank of Queensland Limited (Chan), Gippsland Southern Rural Water Corporation (Johnson), The Nuance Group (Australia) Pty Ltd (Liang), Whitehorse City Council (Gardner), National Australia Bank Limited & McCroary and Others (Avey), Pelican Childcare (Tauafao-Ale), Cape Pty Ltd (Cooper), Laminex Australia Pty Ltd (O’Dwyer), Giorgio Group Holdings Pty Ltd (Leggenda), Whirwind Print Pty Ltd (Peckham), Act Government Payroll (Cao), Walpett Engineering Pty Ltd (Cabalt), Department of Human Services (Ford), Metricon Homes QLD Pty Ltd (Sachdeva).
December 15, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – contract for specified term – ss.386, 394, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – appeal – Full Bench – application for relief from unfair dismissal – appellant employed by respondent on series of time-limited contracts – at end of term of last contract on 30 June 2016, respondent did not offer appellant further contract – appellant contended this constituted dismissal within meaning of s.386(1)(a) FW Act and that employment was terminated at initiative of employer – respondent contended there was no dismissal and that the employment terminated through effluxion of time – at first instance, Commission considered itself bound by Lunn and held there was no dismissal at initiative of employer – Commission further found that anti-avoidance provision in s.386(3) of FW Act did not apply – appellant appealed on two grounds: that Commission erred in relying on Lunn and that Commission erred in finding anti-avoidance provision in s.386(3) not engaged – permission to appeal granted by Full Bench in decision [[2017] FWCFB 4092] on 12 July 2017 in relation to first ground only – Majority Decision: considered whether interpretation and application of s.386(1)(a) should continue to be guided by Lunn – majority ruled that Lunn did not correctly or completely state proper approach to interpretation of expression ‘termination of employment at the initiative of the employer’ in s.170CD(1) of Workplace Relations Act and its application to circumstances of person employed on time-limited contract(s) – majority held that because Commission in first instance considered itself bound to follow Lunn despite reservations about its correctness, its consideration of whether appellant was dismissed within meaning of s.386(1)(a) was ‘artificially constrained’, constituting appealable error – majority considered whether exclusion in s.386(2)(a) applied – as final contract of employment provided unqualified right for either party to terminate contract on four weeks’ written notice or four weeks’ pay in lieu of notice, majority held that contract was not for specified period and so s.386(2)(a) exclusion did not apply – appeal upheld – decision at first instance quashed – matter referred back to Commission for re-determination – Minority Decision: minority ruled that there was no termination of employment by respondent and rather, it decided not to enter into a new employment relationship – further held that the end of employment relationship came about as a result of the expiry of the contract by effluxion of time – minority also ruled that circumstances of the case fell within s.386(2)(a) exclusion and recommended the appeal be dismissed. Appeal by Khayam against decision of Hunt C of 22 May 2017 [[2017] FWC 1524] Re: Navitas English P/L t/a Navitas English
December 15, 2017
CASE PROCEDURES – appeals – ss.394, 400, 604, Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – appellant alleged errors of fact and law in first instance determination that the dismissal of Mr Lewis was harsh, unjust and unreasonable [[2017] FWC 4023] – appellant alleged the Commission erroneously applied established legal principles and made significant errors of fact – argued these matters were relevant to the public interest – Full Bench found no diversity of decisions at first instance requiring guidance from an appellate body – principles settled – appeal did not raise issues of importance or general application – did not manifest an injustice or counterintuitive result – found the legal principles applied by the Commission were not disharmonious with other decisions dealing with similar matters – public interest therefore not enlivened – permission to appeal refused. Appeal by Go To Court Franchising P/L t/a Go To Court Lawyers against order of Hunt C of 31 October 2017 [PR597245] Re: Lewis
December 15, 2017
REGISTERED ORGANISATIONS – records and accounts – inspection – s.483AA Fair Work Act 2009 – application by Maritime Union of Australia (MUA) to inspect non-member records at Manly Fast Ferry P/L (Manly) – long-running dispute over which modern award should be applied for the purposes of the better-off overall test (BOOT) in enterprise agreement negotiations – MUA submitted it was preparing prosecutions for a suspected breach by Manly of the Ports, Harbours and Enclosed Water Vessels Award 2010 (Vessels Award) for underpayment of wages – allegedly incorrect payslip issued to employee – Commission of the view that it must be satisfied access to records is necessary to investigate suspected contravention – Commission not satisfied access to non-member records was necessary, as MUA submitted it had member records which supported its suspicion of underpayment – Commission not prepared to grant access to non-member records – not satisfied that one allegedly incorrect payslip from over two years ago establishes many suspected breaches justifying granting of orders sought – not satisfied orders proposed were necessary to investigate suspected breach of Vessels Award – application dismissed. The Maritime Union of Australia