NEWS HR

Only sixteen unfair dismissal/labour dispute applications are listed for hearing today by the Fair Work Commission. The full list is: Serco Australia Pty Ltd (Hamoui, Sleiman, Thompson), Royal Rehabilitation Centre Sydney (Chung), Valcore Fit-Outs Pty Ltd (Zaccaria), Labour Express Australia Pty Ltd (Tanoko), Linfox Armaguard Pty Ltd (Jarmain), Qantas Airways Limited (Meintanis), Toll Transport Pty Ltd (Borg), Metropolitan Taxi Club Inc (Ninon), Madras Link Pty Ltd (Chang), Gravity Demolition (O’Connor), Qantas Airways Limited (Edwards & Waterhouse), Kone Elevators Pty Ltd (Mocanu), Aboriginal Sobriety group Inc (Hill), Wambo Coal Pty Ltd (Brooks).

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – better off overall test – ss.185, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – at first instance Commissioner approved KIS North West Onshore Operations Enterprise Agreement 2017-2021 (the Agreement) subject to various undertakings – appellant was not a bargaining representative for the Agreement but objected to approval – contended was a person aggrieved as it represented workers in construction industry – respondent accepted appellant had standing to bring appeal – appellant argued Commission erred in concluding Agreement passed better off overall test (BOOT) – Agreement provided for a higher base rate of pay but appellant argued various allowances and other provisions such as crib time, meal allowance and fares allowances were not reflected in the Agreement – Found Commissioner failed to factor into the financial analysis undertaken the application of the three allowances – material considerations in first limb of House v R not taken into account – Agreement did not pass BOOT and Commissioners conclusion was in error – considered appellants further grounds for appeal that might prevent future approval of the Agreement – appellant argued Commissioner erred in accepting undertakings that resulted in substantial changes – found Commissioner did not err in accepting undertakings – appellant argued employees had not genuinely agreed – found no merit in this ground of appeal – appellant argued requirements of s.180(5) of the Act not met – an incorrect answer in the statutory declaration might give pause to query whether the employer understood the full effect of the Agreement and whether it could then impart relevant information to employees – appellants contention that respondent did not meet requirements not substantiated – permission to appeal granted – appeal upheld – first instance decision quashed – application referred to Commission Harper-Greenwell for re-determination. Appeal by Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union against decision of Gregory C of 21 July 2017 [[2017] FWCA 3839] Re: KAEFER Integrated Services P/L

CASE PROCEDURES – representation – s.596 Fair Work Act 2009 – respondent sought permission to be represented by lawyers or paid agents at unfair dismissal hearing – applicant represented by union and raised objection to application – Found that matter was not beyond the normal level of complexity ordinarily found in routine unfair dismissal matters – Found respondent could effectively represent itself – Held that there would be no imbalance in the case if applicant were represented by union official and respondent by its specialised human resources staff – permission refused – in accordance with Fitzgerald v Woolworths Limited, refusal also applies to exclude lawyer or paid agent from providing assistance or advice to respondent in the role of a ‘McKenzie friend’. Taylor v Startrack Express t/a Startrack

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – respondent submitted the applicant committed serious misconduct – respondent alleged applicant engaged in serious misconduct by sending sexually explicit and pornographic images to his manager – respondent submitted this was a serious breach of the code of conduct – applicant submitted that this behaviour was normal within the team culture – he also submitted he did not receive any warning nor any counselling and was denied procedural fairness – Commission found the applicants misconduct was serious and constituted valid reason for dismissal – also found the respondent took adequate steps to notify applicant of allegations – Commission found applicant’s dismissal was not harsh, unjust or unreasonable – application dismissed.Higgins v Coles Supermarkets Australia P/L t/a Coles

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – minimum employment period – associated entities – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – s.50AAA Corporations Act 2001 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – jurisdictional objection – whether applicant met the minimum employment period to be a protected from unfair dismissal – applicant first employed by Games Laboratory (‘GL’) for 14 months and was employed by TGS for two months – unless period of service with GL was recognised, minimum employment period would not have been completed – applicant submitted period of service with GL counted as service with TGS – respondent argued no transfer of employment occurred as the companies were not associated entities – Commission found companies to be associated entities because TGS had capacity to determine the outcome of decisions of GL or vice versa – each entity had the same two directors – both directors had controlling interests and equal share holdings in both companies – director had practical control over the financial and operating policies of both companies – therefore there had been a transfer of applicant’s employment and applicant’s service with GL was recognised – jurisdictional objection dismissed. Charan v Meeples P/L atf The Games Shop Trust t/a The Games Shop

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – genuine redundancy – ss.389, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – jurisdictional objection – respondent claimed dismissal was a genuine redundancy – respondent restructured its operations which resulted in positions being redundant – whether dismissal was a genuine redundancy – whether respondent complied with obligation to consult under applicable modern award – whether redeployment was reasonable – Commission satisfied respondent made reasonable efforts to redeploy applicant within Foxtel – satisfied respondent complied with consultation obligations – accepted jurisdictional objection relating to ss.389(1), 389(2)(a) FW Act – insufficient evidence available on redeployment opportunities within respondent’s associated entities with respect to s.389(2)(b) FW Act – directions to be issued for the filing of material relevant to respondent’s associated entities and all available roles at the time of dismissal for which applicant could have been considered for redeployment. Webber v Foxtel Management P/L t/a Foxtel TV

GENERAL PROTECTIONS – extension of time – representative error – ss.365, 366 Fair Work Act 2017 – application to deal with contraventions involving dismissal lodged seven days out of time – applicant contended application late due to representative error – also exceptional circumstances existed as critical staff needed to lodge the application were absent due to illness and if applicant had not followed up delay might have been longer – representative took full responsibility for the error [Jones v Dunkel] – employer submitted representative error only one ‘element’ amongst others and the circumstances were not ‘out of the ordinary course’ [R v Kelly (Edward)] – Commission satisfied delay solely attributable to unexpected staff absences during final week of 21 day lodgement period – delay was due to representative error – applicant blameless for delay – satisfied applicant took steps to dispute dismissal – extension of time granted. Martin v Brisbane Plumbing and Sewer P/L t/a Brisbane Plumbing and Sewer

Fourteen of today’s forty-two unfair dismissal/employment dispute applications emanate from a single employer (Australasian Global Dairies Pty Ltd). The full list to be heard by the Fair Work Commission: Vennigie Pty Ltd & Wallm Pty Ltd (Farrell), D Cox & K Cox (Laine), Andersens Tweed Heads (Bond), DJ Ruskin Machining and Maintenance (Murphy), Western Downs Regional Council (Maloney), Kormilda College Ltd (Brown), Sam Technology Engineers Pty Ltd (Bernadou), Gunbalanya Sports and Social club Inc. (Wood), Audi Enterprises Pty Ltd (Caine, Zintchenko), Bacchus Marsh Coaches Pty Ltd (Nash), RS Components (Chand), Infosys Technologies Pty Ltd (Sriram), GTS Travel Management (Zhang), Australasian Global Dairies Pty Ltd (Chang, Chen, Chiang, Chin, Hou, Huang, Lee, Liu, Ou, Shih, Teng, Wang, Wu, Yang), The Trustee for Royal Blue Family Trust & Singh (Neha), Zodiac Group Australia Pty Ltd (Zaballero), DOMINELLI Group Pty Ltd (Zhang), Technical and Further Education Commission (Quai-Hoi), Daisii Designs Pty Ltd (Brown), Sydney International Container Terminals Pty Limited (Colwell), German Shepherd World (Lambert), Resource People Pty Ltd (McDonald), Travelex Ltd (Shahzad), City of Stirling (Nitschke), Ableridge Pty Limited & Monaghan and Another (Maharaj).