NEWS HR

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – respondent engaged services of owner drivers carrying out deliveries from Melbourne Airport – previously engaged under terms and conditions contained in ‘Independent Contractor Agreement’ – respondent terminated agreement previous year and offered different arrangements called ‘New Operation Model’ – respondent explained to owner drivers about cost model which underpinned new arrangements – union subsequently took issue with whether new arrangements complied with employer obligations under Toll Group – TWU Enterprise Agreement 2013-2017 (Agreement), particularly subclause 17(f) – parties unable to resolve dispute in workplace and notified Commission – union claimed new arrangements put in place by respondent with owner drivers did not comply with terms of Agreement because cost model on which they were based did not ensure owner drivers received labour component as part of those arrangements, which was equal to applicable wage rate in Agreement – new arrangement was based on an hourly rate, which when all other costs were taken out, left an amount that was less than what an employee driving the same vehicle under the relevant Local Agreement would receive – Agreement must be interpreted in context of its obvious purpose and intent; to protect wages and job security of employees by ensuring that rates provided to owner drivers did not undercut those entitlements – submitted this the plain and ordinary meaning – respondent submitted that only obligation subclause 17(f) created was to pay same labour rate to an owner driver as it was required to pay to an employee driving the same capacity vehicle – submitted this meant ‘the base rate of pay’ an employee covered by Agreement would receive – submitted that Commission was also required to consider whether dispute actually existed under s.739 of FW Act, and whether it had jurisdiction to deal with dispute in manner proposed by union – Schefenacker considered – Commission satisfied union, on behalf of its employee members, entitled to lodge dispute in regard to whether subclause 17(f) was being complied with, and Commission was empowered to deal with that dispute because it pertained to employer-employee relationship, given the potential impact of changes upon employees’ job security – satisfied conclusion consistent with decision of Full Bench in Schefenacker – Commission also satisfied subclause 17(f) had plain and unambiguous meaning and should be interpreted in that way – respondent’s approach rejected – subclause 17(f) contained within series of provisions that dealt with employer’s commitment to job security, and recognition by parties that job security was important issue for employees – against that background clause was essentially concerned to ensure that owner drivers engaged by respondent received a labour rate equal to wage rate that would be payable to an employee who was driving same vehicle driven or ‘utilised’ by owner driver – obvious intent was to prevent respondent from engaging owner drivers on a lower cost basis to cost of employing employee drivers, because of obvious implications for job security of those employees – if obligation in subclause 17(f) discharged in way that respondent now contended would ignore plain meaning of what was intended when words in subclause 17(f) considered on basis of what reasonable person would understand them to mean in terms of how such arrangements apply to owner drivers – Commission not satisfied that owner drivers now receiving a labour rate equal to applicable wage rate payable for relevant vehicle utilised by owner driver at the site at which they are engaged, as required by subclause 17(f) – Commission prepared to offer further assistance to parties in any matter arising as consequent of decision. Transport Workers’ Union of Australia v Toll Ipec P/L t/a Toll Ipec

ANTI-BULLYING – reasonable management action – s.789FC Fair Work Act 2009 – application for an order to stop bullying – applicant an employee of Alice Springs Town Council (ASTC) and alleged bullying by several employees of ASTC, namely Georgina Davison (Manager Library Services), Clare Fisher (Library Operations Team Leader) and Skye Price (Director Corporate and Community Services) – applicant employed by ASTC in Alice Springs Public Library since 2005 and currently a Children’s and Youth Services Officer – six broad matters requiring determination as to whether any, some or all were bullying – Commission found that decision by ASTC to commence performance counselling of applicant not unreasonable conduct and instead, reasonable management action carried out in reasonable manner – found that disciplinary letter dated 23 June 2016, which initiated disciplinary meeting in relation to applicant’s response to ‘respect’ email was unreasonable conduct – found that ASTC’s decision after a review of applicant’s grievances did not amount to unreasonable conduct – found that First Allegations Letter dated 12 October 2016 alleging that applicant contravened Code of Conduct was unreasonable conduct – found that Second Allegations Letter dated 20 October 2016 initiating disciplinary meeting for range of matters not previously raised with applicant was unreasonable conduct – found ASTC’s revocation of applicant’s February 2017 annual leave was unreasonable conduct – Commission held that applicant had been bullied at work within meaning of s.789FD of the FW Act – found there was risk of further conduct that may be regarded as bullying – ordered that requirement for applicant to apologise to Ms Fisher be set aside; that requirement for applicant to respond and answer to matters set out in First and Second Allegations letters be set aside; that ASTC approve any future application by applicant for annual leave, provided she has complied with its leave applications processes and policies and has sufficient leave accrued; that applicant participate in performance counselling in relation to matters set out in performance appraisal; that ASTC’s assessment of applicant’s performance be no earlier than four months from the date she returns to work; that applicant complies with ASTC’s Code of Conduct, policies and procedures; ASTC to arrange for conduct of anti-bullying and positive communication training, and; ASTC to review its procedures for commencing disciplinary action, handling interpersonal or workplace bullying grievances and for investigating complaints of workplace bullying. Burbeck v Alice Springs Town Council and Ors

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant had been employed with respondent for over 18 years – at the time of dismissal applicant was a Paintline Operator – applicant claimed his dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable – respondent dismissed applicant for serious and wilful misconduct – respondent alleged applicant had engaged in ‘horse-play’ on 11 May 2017 contrary to company policy and safety obligations – respondent concluded that applicant intentionally sprayed an unsuspecting employee with paint, hitting that employee on the back of his neck and back – applicant was summarily dismissed on 7 June 2017 – Commission found applicant’s conduct was serious and wilful misconduct – found the serious misconduct was contrary to company policy concerning the safe use of spray guns by Paintline Operators – found it was conduct that constituted a valid reason for summary dismissal – Commission did not accept applicant’s claim his conduct was a mere accident – found conduct was intentional or reckless and dismissal for conduct contrary to policy was not a disproportionate response – Commission satisfied applicant was notified of a valid reason for dismissal and given a full opportunity to respond – applicant pointed to the fact that had he continued in employment until the factory closure on 6 October 2017, he would have been eligible for a significant redundancy payment – Commission found the dismissal must stand or fall on the basis of the conduct complained of and its surrounding circumstances, not on basis of a future exigency – Commission found applicant’s dismissal was not harsh, unjust or unreasonable – Commission not required to consider the question of remedy as there was no unfair dismissal – application dismissed. Graham v Walker Australia P/L t/a Tenneco

RIGHT OF ENTRY – application for permit – s.512 Fair Work Act 2009 – application by Victorian Branch of AMWU for a right of entry permit (permit) for an official – permit issued on 18 September 2014 and initially returned on 11 August 2017 – AMWU wrote inquiring if the permit could be returned to him as it did not expire until 19 September 2017 – permit made available for collection – through annual leave and administrative oversight there was a lack of communication that permit was available for collection – Commission noted relevant statutory provisions and application – considered MUA decision of Full Court of Federal Court of Australia re ‘fit and proper person’ – also CEPU decision of Hatcher VP – declarations filed by AMWU – Commission accepted disclosed information in the declarations as accurate and correct – found to be a fit and proper person to hold permit – no relevant matters nor cogent evidence of any relevant matter which account should be taken – application granted – permit will be issued. “Automotive, Food, Metals, Engineering, Printing and Kindred Industries Union” known as the Australian Manufacturing Workers’ Union (AMWU) – Victorian Branch

GENERAL PROTECTIONS – extension of time – date dismissal took effect – ss.365, 366 Fair Work Act 2009 – general protections application involving dismissal lodged 43 days after the date the dismissal took effect – considered whether exceptional circumstances existed to justify granting an extension of time – applicant took action to make an application within the permitted period, albeit on the wrong form – in finding the error in the application, applicant took steps to file the correct application – no prejudice to respondent caused by the delay as applicant had made a substantial response to the initial application which was similar to the late application – merits of the application a neutral factor – fairness not a relevant consideration as there were no employees in the same situation as the application – found exceptional circumstances existed – extension of time granted. Smith v A&J Container Services

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant employed from 21 March 2016 until termination on 17 May 2017 – applicant employed by respondent and chair of the board for Nyangatjatjara Aboriginal Corporation (NAC) – respondent wholly owned subsidiary of NAC – applicant commenced absence from work due to stress in November 2016 and made a claim for workers’ compensation, which has been denied – report handed down to the NAC board in January 2017 provided a list of persons who may have a conflict of interest including the applicant – in February 2017 the respondent adopted a policy that no employee could be a board member of the NAC – this document was provided to the applicant – applicant was provided with decline of 1 March 2017 to respond – no response in relation to applicant’s board membership was received – respondent wrote to applicant on 5 May 2017 providing applicant till 8 May 2017 to provide a response, when a decision was to be made in relation to his employment – on 17 May 2017 respondent wrote to applicant terminating his employment – Commission determined applicant’s employment was terminated due to failure to follow lawful and reasonable direction in relation to his employment – Commission satisfied applicant did disregard lawful and reasonable direction given – satisfied reason for dismissal was valid – applicant argued dismissal in breach of obligation of respondent under Return To Work Act (NT) – Commission satisfied respondent was not in breach – Commission satisfied dismissal was not harsh, unjust or unreasonable – application dismissed. Thomas v Wana Ungkunytja P/L t/a Anangu Jobs

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – minimum employment period – ss.382, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for an unfair dismissal remedy – respondent submitted that applicant’s employment did not meet the minimum employment period of 6 months and therefore applicant was not protected from unfair dismissal – applicant performed unpaid practical legal training (PLT) with respondent between 5 August 2016 and 14 October 2016 – applicant accepted offer of formal employment from respondent on 20 October 2016 – applicant dismissed 23 weeks and 5 days after commencement of formal employment, two weeks and two days shy of minimum employment period – applicant submitted that period between 28 September 2016 and 14 October 2016 counted towards minimum employment period as the nature of the work he performed could not be characterised as work experience – Commission considered whether the PLT arrangement between the applicant and respondent involved the creation of an employment contract – considered the reasons for the arrangement, the length of time of the PLT, the work completed by the applicant and who was getting the benefit of that work – Commission not satisfied that any part of PLT counted as an employment relationship between applicant and respondent – found applicant not protected from unfair dismissal – application dismissed. Klievens v Cappello Rowe Lawyers

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – termination at initiative of employer – ss.386, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – applicant did not attend work after a period of annual leave – respondent expressed dissatisfaction about applicant failing to return on time among other issues – applicant submitted that respondent terminated his employment – respondent denies this and submitted that he advised applicant to attend work site – applicant attended work site but subsequently ceased working – applicant submitted that he was unfairly dismissed and sought reinstatement or compensation – respondent submitted that applicant was not dismissed and there was an expectation that he would continue to work – Commission found irreconcilable differences in version of conversation – found that although there may have been mention of redundancy or that employment relationship may end at some time in the future, it was clear from text message exchanges that applicant was employed and expected to continue to work – found nothing in the conduct of respondent could be described as action by the employer that either intended to bring the employment relationship to an end or had that probable result – satisfied that applicant was not terminated on the respondent’s initiative – not satisfied that applicant was dismissed – application dismissed. De Maria v BiltBeta Constructions