ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – genuinely agree – ss.174, 180, 185 Fair Work Act 2009 – application by CQ Field Mining Services (CQFMS) for approval of CQFMS Enterprise Agreement 2017 (Agreement) – CFMEU was a bargaining representative and opposed approval of agreement on following grounds: noncompliance with s.174(1A) FW Act for issuing valid Notice of Employee Representational Rights (NERR); all reasonable steps required by s.180(2) and s.180(5) of FW Act not taken; and better off overall test (BOOT) not passed with respect to some employees or prospective employees who were or would be covered by Black Coal Award – Agreement also contained objectionable term on ground that it was discriminatory – CFMEU objected to the NERR issued by CQFMS as it was set out on the company’s letterhead and not to be in form required by the Regulations – Commission did not accept that NERR given on the company’s letterhead was invalid as this was not a matter that went to the form or content of the notice – CFMEU contended that number of incorporated documents including various company policies and procedures referred to in proposed Agreement were not provided to employees, nor were they given access to this written material – CQFMS submitted that the relevant materials were made available to all employees at induction and were communicated to employees on an ongoing basis during employment – Commission determined that CQFMS did not provide copies of relevant materials referred to in proposed Agreement and did not inform where employees could obtain copies during access period – Commission did not accept that employees may have been informed about relevant materials in site inductions to meet requirements of s.180(2) FW Act and not satisfied that CQFMS complied – CFMEU asserted Agreement did not pass BOOT as employees were performing work in black coal mining industry and were governed by Black Coal Award – CFMEU pointed to a range of provisions where Black Coal Award provided more beneficial terms than the Agreement – Commission satisfied that CQFMS employed employees who were covered by Black Coal Award and on that basis, Agreement did not pass the BOOT – not satisfied that CQFMS took reasonable steps to provide explanation of Agreement given deficiencies identified in respect of the BOOT – Commission held Agreement not genuinely approved – Agreement did not pass the BOOT – application for approval refused. CQ Industries P/L t/a CQ Field Mining Services
November 16, 2017
MODERN AWARDS – 4 yearly review – s.156 Fair Work Act 2009 – Full Bench – conferences were held on 30 March 2015 to identify the issues to be raised by interested parties during the review of each of the Group 3 awards – Mentions were held on 6 and 7 June 2016 to deal with the technical and drafting issues – after the mentions, further conferences were conducted by individual members in respect of particular Group 3 awards – this decision should be read in conjunction with the decision issued on 6 July 2017 [[2017] FWCFB 3433] (the July 2017 decision) which dealt with 19 of the awards in Group 3 – this decision deals with the remaining awards in Group 3: Dredging Industry Award 2010; Educational Services (Post-Secondary Education) Award 2010; Educational Services (Schools) General Staff Award 2010; Horticulture Award 2010; Sugar Industry Award 2010; Clerks Private Sector Award 2010; Fitness Industry Award 2010; Gardening and Landscaping Services Award 2010; Legal Services Award 2010; Nursery Award 2010; Pastoral Award 2010; Silviculture Award 2010; Sporting Organisations Award 2010; and Wine Industry Award 2010 – submissions are to be emailed to [email protected] by the date specified in the section of the decision dealing with each award. 4 yearly review of modern awards – Award stage – Group 3
November 16, 2017
CASE PROCEDURES – apprehension of bias – ss.394, 589 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for recusal on ground of apprehended bias – applicant’s representative made a complaint regarding the handling of applications covering a variety of subjects and involving a number of members – advised that issue of apprehended bias be raised at the commencement of proceedings – telephone mention/directions scheduled – previous decision permitted respondent’s legal representation – Commission requested written authority that applicant representative was authorised to act on applicant’s behalf – applicant representative submitted Commission did not hold respondent to same test and was evidence of apprehension of bias – respondent representative suggested matter be dealt with on the papers – applicant representative contested not advised in advance of this submission and it was further evidence of an apprehension of bias – requested for an adjournment and matter be dealt with by another member – Commission referred to fair-minded lay observer principles and application in Johnson v Johnson; Ebner and Isbester – did not consider a reasonable apprehension of bias could possibly arise in the mind of fair-minded lay observer – stated to pass these applications on to another member of the Commission would be a failure to discharge duty to hear and determine matters in a fair and just manner – application to recuse dismissed. Deeney and Ors v Patrick Projects P/L
November 16, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – performance – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – Australia Personnel Global P/L (APG) is a labour provider – applicant assigned to work at premises of Baiada Poultry P/L – APG objected on basis that applicant did not have reasonable expectation of ongoing employment – had not met the minimum employment period – alternatively, dismissal was not harsh, unjust or unreasonable because applicant had attended work late, left work early, did not provide advice of absences – APG lost confidence and trust in applicant’s capacity to carry out tasks – Commission found that applicant was regularly engaged to work at Baiada for five days per week for average of 37.5 hours per week – had been employed on a regular and systematic basis for period exceeding six months – Commission determined that applicant’s work history, frequency of engagement and requirement to advise APG and/or Baiada if she was unable to attend work led to conclusion of a reasonable expectation of continuing employment – minimum employment period met – Commission found APG’s allegations of lateness, leaving work early and issuing of warnings against applicant not supported by evidence – complaints of leaving work early more accurately described as not working as much overtime as other employees – Commission found other incidents not to be a breach of employment obligations – Commission found APG did not investigate reason for termination – evidence did not indicate APG took reasonable steps to engage with Baiada or other employers about alternative assignments – Commission held dismissal was harsh, unjust and unreasonable – compensation of $8,597.31 ordered. Kumar v Australia Personnel Global P/L
November 16, 2017
CASE PROCEDURES – evidence – production of documents – ss.394, 590 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant made an application for orders to produce on respondent – respondent submitted documents sought were not relevant to the matter – also the request was vague, wide and appeared to be a ‘fishing expedition’ where some classes of documents sought were confidential or private material and relevantly unconnected to applicant’s case – documents sought must have some apparent relevance to the pleadings as they stand [McIlwain] – Commission considered documents before him had no apparent relevance to the primary matter – each class of documents sought by the applicant were a ‘fishing expedition’ or sought for collateral purpose other than support of his application for unfair dismissal remedy – Commission found disclosure of certain classes of the documents may have been prejudicial to the respondent by drawing into public matters not relevant to these proceedings, but with collateral possibility of consequential prejudice to the interests of the Northern Territory Government or persons employed by it – application refused. McAuley v Northern Territory Government t/a Department of Primary Industry and Resources
November 16, 2017
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – decision dealing with 34 separate applications – all applicants employed by Linfox at Regional Distribution Centre – dispute in relation to Clause 5 – ‘Custom and Practice’ of Linfox and Transport Workers’ Union Road Transport and Distribution Centres Agreement 2014 (2014 Agreement) and proposal by Linfox to have all employees in Distribution Centre to perform task of order picking, as required – applicants currently perform certain specific roles only – applicants maintain that custom and practice established over extended period whereby they are only required to perform those certain specific roles – Clause 5 of 2014 Agreement provided that it is not intended to alter an existing custom and practice – Full Bench in Transport Workers’ Union v Linfox Australia P/L considered – decision made clear that any such application of implying a custom and practice into applicants’ employment contracts must be determined having regard to propositions identified by High Court in Con-Stan – Commission not satisfied that in all the circumstances the existence of a custom and practice as claimed by applicants can be found to exist – evidence did not establish a custom and practice in Distribution Centre whereby all, or even majority of employees, only performed a single task or role as it appeared to be a situation that only applied to the 34 applicants – as custom and practice did not exist in terms of Clause 5 of 2014 Agreement, Commission no longer to give further consideration – applications dismissed. Paull and Ors v Linfox Australia P/L t/a Linfox
November 16, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – valid reason – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal – applicant employed for more than 11 years as an electrical technician – is the Lodge President for the Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (CFMEU) at the Dendrobium Mine of Illawarra Coal – dismissed after investigation following telephone calls involving tense and heated discussions about workplace issues, use of inappropriate language and making threats – not in dispute that applicant was under the influence of alcohol at the time of the discussions – also being treated for depression – ABCC v Upton considered – not the role of the Commission to determine appropriate standards of language in the community but to consider language used in the workplace context – Commission satisfied respondent had a valid reason for the dismissal – found applicant was unknowingly under the influence of a strong prescribed drug which, when mixed with alcohol, provided a cocktail which transformed a normally rational and considered human being into an entirely different human being who then acted in a manner which has been unchallenged as being ‘out of character’ – applicant’s conduct was in breach of the South32 bullying and harassment policy – applicant’s conduct was clearly inappropriate however taking into consideration mitigating factors Commission found applicant’s dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable – persuaded that reinstatement was appropriate – ordered applicant maintain his continuity of employment and restoration of lost pay minus a 25% penalty for applicant’s poor conduct. Gosek v Illawarra Coal Holdings P/L t/a South32
November 16, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – valid reason – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant employed at an independent boys’ school – dismissed for failing to attend meeting concerning previous complaint against respondent – applicant notified school she could not attend the meeting on the day because she was unwell – Commission considered if there was a valid reason for dismissal – a valid reason is sound, defensible or well-founded – not capricious, fanciful, spiteful or prejudiced [Selvachandran] – Commission ex tempore found dismissal harsh, unjustified and unreasonable – applicant had a clear reason for not attending the meeting – to characterise non-attendance as serious misconduct was egregious – imposed a completely unjust outcome on applicant – dismissal was unfair – consideration to be given to remedy. Dai v The Camberwell Grammar School t/a Camberwell Grammar School