ENTERPRISE BARGAINING – bargaining order – ss.228, 230, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – at first instance the Commission dismissed application made by TWU for bargaining orders seeking that respondent restrain from conducting vote until subsequent bargaining meetings held and respondent gave genuine consideration to TWU’s claims – at first instance TWU submitted that respondent had breached good faith bargaining requirements as issued misleading notice and letter to employees signed by manager and TWU delegate that TWU and Consultative Committee endorsed proposed agreement – TWU also submitted that conduct of further ballot held by respondent was objectionable in context of misleading communications and that ballot held during school holidays caused difficulties for TWU to communicate with members as many drivers not at work – TWU submitted that Commission’s decision made in error in that respondent’s communications had to be ‘seriously misleading’ not just misleading and that it was not open to Commission to find that respondent’s conduct as a whole was not unfair conduct which undermined collective bargaining – Full Bench considered whether the particular procedure adopted by employer in respect to conduct of a vote upon proposed enterprise agreement was matter which was relevant to compliance with good faith bargaining requirements – Full Bench found that FW Act not prescriptive about procedures for conduct of ballot to vote upon proposed non-greenfields agreement but that agreement must be ‘genuinely agreed to by employees’ – Full Bench found that if vote was conducted in a way which deprived substantial number of employees opportunity to vote then it would be a matter relevant to assessing whether agreement had been genuinely agreed to – found that issue of timing of conduct of vote may impinge upon bargaining process [CEPU v Contact Electrical] however TWU’s concern about timing of ballot was not tangibly connected to bargaining process – Full Bench found that Commission did not err in finding that conduct of further ballot did not amount to failure to meet good faith requirements – Commission’s finding that no employee could reasonably have held belief that TWU supported agreement was not in error given TWU’s capacity to robustly communicate position – no appealable error found – appeal dismissed. Appeal by Transport Workers’ Union of Australia against ex tempore decision of Hamberger SDP of 18 December 2015 Re: Transit (NSW) Services P/L t/a Transit Systems
March 11, 2016
MODERN AWARDS – 4 yearly review – ss.134, 138, 156 Fair Work Act 2009 – application to insert electrical licence allowance in the Manufacturing and Associated Industries and Occupations Award 2010 and Electrical Power Industry Award 2010 – awards sought to be varied by CEPU in May 2014 to insert an electrical licence allowance – proposed allowance of approximately $34.80 per week based upon current rates – CEPU identified other modern awards that include an electrical licence allowance and submitted this was a common feature of pre-modern awards applying to electricians who became part of these modern awards – also submitted that allowance generally paid in recognition of level of training and skill possessed and practiced, and for responsibilities associated with holding the licence, including supervising electrical work by non-licence holders – CEPU submitted it was not the industry of the employer that should determine whether or not a licence holder is entitled to allowance, but rather that it should be paid in recognition of responsibilities or skills not taken into account in rates of pay – evidence provided by CEPU relating to ‘value adds’ accruing from holding an electrical licence – submitted that licence requirement an additional requirement to that contemplated by the competency standards and classification requirements – Full Bench satisfied that the possession of an electrical licence issued by the appropriate regulator is taken into account by the minimum training requirement and other requirements of the classification definitions – as such the allowance claimed not for ‘responsibilities or skills that are not taken into account in rates of pay’ – no basis for inclusion of allowance in the Manufacturing Award or Electrical Power Award – not satisfied CEPU established a cogent reason for changing the award position – application refused. Manufacturing and Associated Industries and Occupations Award 2010 and Electrical Power Industry Award 2010
March 11, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – genuine redundancy – ss.389, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – respondent objected on basis that dismissal was a genuine redundancy – respondent lost significant business in 2015 and restructured its fire department operations so as to require substantially fewer staff – changes in operational requirements meant it no longer required the job being done by applicant to be undertaken – Commission found no evidence of any alternative positions which may have suited applicant’s skills – consultation obligations in agreement complicated by poor drafting – satisfied respondent met model consultation obligations – not satisfied consultative committee obligations in agreement complied with – applicant’s dismissal cannot be considered a genuine redundancy – application will be referred for conciliation – circumstances may be regarded as analogous with those considered in Harvey v UES Int’l – copy of decision provided to parties. Byrne v Tyco Fire & Security t/a Wormald
March 10, 2016
Twenty-two s.394 (unfair dismissal) applications will be heard in the Fair Work Commission today. The full list is: 1234 Star (Carter), Santosheema Pty Ltd (Alexander), BigAir Group (Anand), Platypus Pty Limited (Jimizez), Gunnedah Preschool Kindergarten Association Incorporated (Leys), Westpac Banking Corporation & Westpac Banking Corporation (Mistry), Morris Corporation Ltd (Reposar), Croker Constructions (Jarvis), STA Traffic Management Solutions Pty Ltd (Beaton), Qantas Airways Ltd (Smith), Tooradin garden Supplies/Metro Quarry Group (Cicciari), Citylink Towing & Transport Aust P/L (Young), KAP Motors Pty Ltd (Costello), ACT Government as represented by the Education and Training Directorate (Dayhew), Transdev Brisbane Ferries Pty Ltd (Mercalfe), TNT Australia Pty Ltd (Martin), Department of Agriculture (Allan), QT Hotels & Resorts Pty Ltd (Csontos), The Cootharinga Society of North Queensland (Mancuso), Adelaide Integrated Precast Pty Ltd (Dornin), Macedonian Community of Adelaide & South Australia Inc. (Gligorovski), Exact Cleaning & Maintenance Services Pty Ltd (Zoran).
March 9, 2016
Only 15 unfair dismissal applications are listed for hearing before Fair Work Commissioners today. They include: Atwood Oceanics Australia Pty Ltd (Munro), Ecocentric Energy Pty Ltd (Darcy), Active Individualised Family Services (Clarke), National Australia Bank (McKibbin), Platypus Pty Limited (Jimizez), Caddy Can Storage Systems (Vic) Pty Ltd (Sivaram), CFC Consolidated Pty Ltd atf CFC Employment Trust (Turner), Morris Corporation Ltd (Reposar), Active Individualised Family Services (Clarke), Department of Education and Training Victoria (Regional Services Group) (Nolen), Murdoch Childrens Research Institute (Lewis), Coates Hire Operations Pty Limited (Chisholm), McDonalds Flooring Accessories (Harrison), Adelaide Community Healthcare Alliance (Targett), Peter W Beck Pty Ltd (Dragani).
March 9, 2016
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – approval – ss.172, 185, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – appeal – Full Bench – appeal against decision to approve ALDI Regency Park Agreement 2015 – scope of agreement covered employees in ALDI’s Regency Park Region and any new stores which opened in that region – at the time agreement was voted on no stores in the region had commenced trading – employees who voted on agreement were employed by ALDI at other locations but had accepted a written offer of employment to work in the region when stores commenced operations – appellants advanced various grounds of appeal – first ground: agreement should have been made as a greenfields agreement because ALDI was establishing a new enterprise and had not employed any of the persons who would be necessary for the normal conduct of the enterprise – respondent submitted that conducting its traditional operations in a new geographical area is not a genuine new business, and employees had been employed in the enterprise covered by the agreement – Full Bench had to consider if employees were employed at the time the agreement was made and were covered by the agreement – both elements involved questions of fact – found employees who accepted on-going employment in the region were employed by ALDI at the time the agreement was made – further, as their employment comprehended work within the scope of the agreement they were covered by the agreement – second ground: employees who were selected to approve the agreement were not fairly chosen because a group of 17 employees were selected to make an agreement for a much larger group of employees – appellants also submitted employees were not appropriately representative because seven of the 17 selected employees who voted on the agreement were managers – Full Bench held the test to determine whether the group of employees was fairly chosen requires consideration of the employees covered by the agreement, not the employees who vote for the agreement at the time it is made – third ground: the better off overall test (BOOT) was not properly applied – Full Bench found BOOT had been properly considered in the first instance – permission to appeal granted given the important interpretation issues – no appealable error found – each ground of appeal dismissed – appeal dismissed. Appeal by Transport Workers’ Union of Australia & Anor against decision of Bull DP of 22 September 2015 [[2015] FWCA 6373] Re: ALDI Foods P/L as General Partner of ALDI Stores (A Limited Partnership)
March 9, 2016
CASE PROCEDURES – representation – ss.400, 596, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – applicant in unfair dismissal matter sought permission to appeal against Commission decision – grounds of appeal were that Commission erred in exercising discretion to permit representation and made a significant error of fact in finding that representation would aid efficiency – Full Bench considered test for determining the public interest under ss.400 and 604 of FW Act described in [GlaxoSmithKline] – not open to appeal bench to substitute its view on matters for determination in absence of error of appealable nature in first instance decision [House v The King] – procedural decisions will not normally be disturbed on appeal unless demonstrable error – Full Bench found Commissioner did no more than apply FW Act’s provisions and the proper approach to s.596 in deciding to permit representation – unexceptional decision of a routine procedural nature – no arguable case of error of kind required by House v The King – not in the public interest to grant permission to appeal – Full Bench declined to grant permission to appeal – application for permission to appeal dismissed. Appeal by Findley against decision of Ryan C of 14 December 2015 [[2015] FWC 8645] Re: Diamond Protection P/L t/a Diamond Protection
March 9, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – consideration of unreasonable – overall circumstances [J Boag and Son] – particular circumstances – applicant on workers compensation undertook activities inconsistent with advice – had long employment history and unblemished record in terms of disciplinary matters – Commission found applicant defrauded employer, mislead doctors, placed himself at risk of aggravating injuries, applicant abused workers compensation system – Commission rejected applicant’s argument that actions could be characterised as some form of self-regulated work hardening initiative – loss of trust fundamental to the maintenance of the employment relationship – application dismissed. Harvey v GM Holden Ltd t/a Holden