23 unfair dismissal/employee disputes are listed for hearing today in the Fair Work Commission. The list is: Pentana Solutions Pty Ltd (Brown), The Salesian Society Inc (Kirkham), PALT Holdings Pty Ltd (Thorogood), Wilson Security Pty Ltd (Reilly), MMG Mining Pty Ltd (Shea), L.V. Dohnt and Company Pty Ltd (King), Apicius Catering (Kabir), Monivae College (Hayes), Victorian Equal Opportunity and Human Rights Commission (Kelley), Hunter Fleet Services Pty Ltd (King), Impact Supplies (Aust) Pty Ltd (Kross), Telstra Corporation Limited (Timpson), Woolworths Ltd (Tuysuz), Port Butchers (Dower), Royal Freemasons’ Benevolent Institution (Pentland), Smoque Pty Limited (Warnock), The Trustee for Parkross Family Trust (Sheppard), Ampelite (Brock), Amanda Maree English (Dunsdon), Inspireaust (Hunter), Victory College (Van Der Walt), Veolia Environmental Services (Sires), BGC Contracting Pty Ltd (Atkinson).
March 11, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – contractor or employee – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – respondent objected on basis that applicant was never employed by them – applicant sole director, company secretary and shareholder of company subcontracted to provide roadside mail delivery services in October 2008 – principal contractor assigned its contractual rights and obligations to company of applicant in December 2008 – Mail Contractor Agreement signed with respondent in June 2010 – Mail Contractor Agreement terminated by respondent in October 2015 – applicant believed he was an employee of respondent because he says he was engaged to undertake a particular job, was directed to use a certain vehicle and accessories, was required to wear an Australia Post uniform, was required to have a company to contract with respondent, was required to have ‘all items available for inspection at all times, all for the exclusive use of Australia Post’ – no evidence of an express written or oral contract of employment between applicant and respondent – Commission satisfied that contractual arrangements made between respondent and applicant’s company were not a sham or a pretence – satisfied that applicant not employed by respondent at the time he ceased providing services – applicant not dismissed – application dismissed. Turner v Australian Postal Corporation
March 11, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant employed as lead educator for early childhood centre – applicant exposed child to food containing egg resulting in an anaphylactic reaction – respondent alleged applicant failed to recognise symptoms or provide adequate first aid – further alleged applicant failed to report incident and misrepresented it to supervisor – Commission found valid reason for dismissal – applicant failed to follow procedure and check status of food – failed to identify anaphylactic symptoms and provide adequate first aid – failed to maintain emergency medical bag – failed to event to immediate manager – provided misleading or inconsistent details about incident – combination of matters meant reason for dismissal sound, defensible or well-founded [Selvachandran] – Commission considered the fact that another employee was not dismissed who also failed to recognise anaphylactic symptoms in child – insufficient evidence for Commission to determine whether unfair differential treatment applied with respect to other employee – applicant not unfairly dismissed – application dismissed. Nicolaou v Minifie Park Early Childhood Centre
March 11, 2016
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – application to deal with dispute arising under the Metropolitan Fire and Emergency Services Board Corporate & Technical Employees Agreement 2013 – dispute about employees working a New Alternative Rostered Day off (RDO) arrangement of an eighteenth day month – Commission satisfied it had jurisdiction to deal with dispute – interpretation of enterprise agreement requires construction of the words of the instrument [Golden Cockerel] – question for determination is the circumstances which respondent should accede to request to work a new alternative RDO arrangement – respondent prepared a Guidance Note after agreement was approved that indicated how decisions would be made on requests for new alternative RDO arrangements – both Guidance Note and Rostered Days Off Application Form were consistent with the decision tests referred to within the clause itself – Commission found the disputed New Alternative RDO Arrangement provision had a plain meaning – held mechanism of sub-clauses of a New Alternative Rostered Day off arrangement of an eighteenth day month could be worked – concluded that the proposed arrangement to maintain or improve productivity or service levels – Commission satisfied respondent currently implementing obligations of the clause – application dismissed. United Firefighters’ Union of Australia v Metropolitan Fire and Emergency Services Board t/a Metropolitan Fire Brigade
March 11, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant dismissed one week after a meeting including a robust conversation with employer concerning allocation of work – following the meeting the applicant confirmed by email that she would accept the employer’s direction – applicant dismissed for misconduct – employer admitted applicant not given opportunity to respond – absence of natural justice heightens the harshness of the dismissal – Commission found that the applicant not dismissed for a valid reason – respondent’s reasons for termination not sound or defensible – termination of employment harsh and unreasonable – reinstatement is the primary remedy – Perkins considered in relation to breakdown in trust – parties invited to make submissions in relation to reinstatement. Luckman v HP Bowral P/L t/a Highlands Property
March 11, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – Small Business Fair Dismissal Code – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – Applicant worked as a book keeper until dismissed for allegedly transferring money out of company without authorisation of respondent – applicant submitted she was operating under instruction of second manager – respondent dismissed applicant whilst he was overseas by email – email did not provide reasons for termination – applicant was not provided opportunity to respond to accusation – no evidence of any appropriate procedure being followed during applicant’s termination – Commission found applicant transferred money without requisite authority – applicant was not presented with the reason for her termination, nor was she given opportunity to respond – Commission of the view lack of procedural fairness was of such a magnitude to render the termination unjust – Commission held applicant’s dismissal was unjust and harsh only in relation to the questions of process – reinstatement not appropriate as level of trust and confidence cannot be re-established in the circumstances – compensation to the amount of $7,988.40 ordered. Liu v Hit and Bounce P/L t/a FX Zone
March 11, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – identity of employer – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – two applications for relief from unfair dismissal – first application against Queensland Property Investments P/L t/a Woolworths Ltd (Woolworths) – second application against Manpower made outside statutory time limit – applicant alleged Woolworths terminated employment – Woolworths alleged applicant not an employee of Woolworths – Woolworths argued employee was labour hire employee on assignment through Manpower – this decision considers who was the applicant’s employer – nothing in enterprise agreement to suggest agreement covers labour hire employees – Commission satisfied no employment contract between applicant and Woolworths – nothing to suggest Woolworths has capacity to determine outcome of financial and operating policy decisions – Manpower not an associated entity nor agent of Woolworths – found applicant not an employee of Woolworths – jurisdictional objection upheld – application against Woolworths dismissed – extension of time objection to be determined. Chidiac v Queensland Property Investments P/L t/a Woolworths Ltd and Anor
March 11, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – applicant stood down with pay due to concerns for his welfare following incidents at workplace – applicant suffered from depression and alleged bullying from colleagues – respondent advised applicant he could not return to work until he had attended a medical examination by doctor nominated by them – applicant failed to attend appointment – stood down without pay – given notice that failure to confirm willingness to attend assessment could lead to dismissal – applicant refused and was dismissed – two reasons for dismissal given – failure to comply with direction to attend medical assessment and failure to comply with direction to only communicate with Vice President of Human Resources regarding issue – applicant later advised if provided resignation with no restrictions respondent would pay accumulated leave (including sick leave) to which applicant was entitled upon resignation, and three weeks’ pay in lieu of notice – applicant resigned – submitted actions of employer left no choice but to resign – employer submitted not forced to resign but dismissed due to failure to follow instructions – Commission found applicant dismissed at initiative of employer – considered whether first reason for dismissal was valid – found no prolonged or frequent absences – fact that applicant disclosed he was suffering from depression, and the claim of being victimised and unfairly treated because of that, did not provide a reasonable basis to assume incapable of performing inherent requirements of job – not satisfied failure to agree to attend medical examination constituted valid reason for dismissal – considered second reason – direction to communicate only with Vice President of Human Resources reasonable – applicant communicated with other managers – found limited breaches of direction were not valid reason for termination – found none of the other factors outweighed the harshness and injustice of termination without valid reason – audio recordings made by applicant and post dismissal communications made reinstatement inappropriate – compensation appropriate – 5% deducted for inadequacy of efforts to mitigate loss – compensation amount of $45,907.82 – exceeded six month cap – six month cap applied – order that compensation of $43,906.72 be paid, less appropriate taxation, within 14 days. Cole v PQ Australia P/L t/a PQ Australia