TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – costs – ss.394, 400A, 611 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant made application for unfair dismissal remedy – at first instance the Commission found applicant had engaged in serious misconduct and his dismissal was not harsh, unjust or unreasonable – the application was dismissed on 9 July 2015 [[2015] FWC 3911] – respondent filed an application for an order for costs on 23 July 2015 – applicant lodged appeal – Full Bench dismissed appeal finding there was no significant error in the findings made by the Commission at first instance and that there was no other public interest ground for granting permission to appeal on 16 October 2015 [[2015] FWCFB 6785] – subsequently applicant commenced proceedings in Federal Court of Australia for judicial review seeking to set aside the order of the Full Bench – applicant discontinued this application on 2 February 2016 – respondent’s application for an order for costs limited to consideration of costs incurred by the respondent in responding to the substantive unfair dismissal remedy application not subsequent applications – basis of costs application was that respondent incurred costs because of a number of unreasonable acts or omissions of the applicant in connection with the conduct or continuation of the proceeding – respondent seeks costs on indemnity basis – Commission satisfied that application made without reasonable cause – held that it should have been reasonably apparent to the applicant that his application was hopeless and was so lacking in merit as to not be reasonably arguable – Commission satisfied the unfair dismissal remedy application had no reasonable prospect of success – satisfied that grounds for a costs order have been made out by the respondent under each of sub-section 611(2)(a) and (b) of FW Act – respondent also submitted that on each occasion the applicant rejected one of the respondent’s offers of settlement, this rejection was an unreasonable act in connection with the continuation of the matter which caused the respondent to incur costs – Commission found applicant was unwilling to or unable to objectively assess the merits of his application – rejecting the various offers was an unreasonable act – satisfied that under s.400A of FW Act the applicant should be ordered to pay the costs the respondent incurred from 5 December 2014 – applicant not required to pay any element of the respondent’s costs twice – order that applicant pay the respondent’s costs on an indemnity basis – directions will be issued requiring the respondent to submit a Bill of Costs. Post v NTI Limited t/a NTI
March 11, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – high income threshold – ss.332, 382, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – Commission considered whether annual death cover insurance premium should be included in calculation of applicant’s earnings – applicant’s salary was $133,475 at date of dismissal – insurance premium of $7447.45 was also to be paid by respondent for the period from 11 September 2015 to 10 September 2016 – respondent submitted that applicant’s total salary package included insurance premium and that this resulted in applicant’s earnings being above high income threshold – respondent submitted that 11 September 2015 was last day on which premium could be paid and that 2014/2015 premium still placed applicant above high income threshold – respondent submitted that insurance premium fell within s.332(1)(b) of FW Act as it was amount applied or dealt with in any way on applicant’s behalf – further submitted that test to be applied was not that applicant was ultimate beneficiary but that this was amount being applied or dealt with on applicant’s behalf – applicant submitted that insurance premium should not be included in earnings – submitted that premium was payable after date he was dismissed and that he never discussed or made any request for the death cover insurance – applicant also submitted that legislative intention is that there needs to be ability for payments made to be amounts which can be determined in advance – submitted that death cover only payable in the event of death and was not cashable – Commission considered whether insurance premium was amount applied or dealt with on applicant’s behalf – Commission found that death cover insurance premium was not amount applied or dealt with on applicant’s behalf as plan was taken out in the respondent’s name – found that applicant was named beneficiary but respondent was owner of plan – further found that insurance did not form part of wages/work bargain between respondent and applicant but was provided as part of company policy – distinguished from [Tipene] – Commission found applicant earned less than high income threshold – jurisdictional objection dismissed. Crowley v Savannah Nickel Mines P/L
March 11, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – termination at initiative of employer – constructive dismissal – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant claimed unfair dismissal due to circumstances of his termination by respondent – constructive dismissal – in April 2014 applicant was involved in a motor vehicle accident and did not return to work until February 2015 – on return to work applicant and respondent had discussions regarding a possible exit package and was told to work in an alternate office – applicant objected – a number of conversations and email exchanges took place concerning CPD points, AR status, client issues and exit negotiations – applicant resigned and provided reasons – Commission considered Mohazab and Barkla in making decision – found the actions of the respondent resulted in the termination of the applicant’s employment and had it not occurred the applicant would have remained in an employment relationship – compensation ordered. Foster v FM Financial Group P/L t/a FM Financial
March 11, 2016
ENTERPRISE BARGAINING – protected action ballot – ss.414, 437 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for protected action ballot order (PABO) by TWU in respect of ‘road crew’ employees of respondent – respondent objected to application on the basis that the group of employees to be ballot was not properly specified as the group was not clearly limited to those who would be covered by the proposed agreement – TWU submitted it did not oppose the description of employees being amended to incorporate reference to agreement – Commission satisfied amending description of employees would satisfy requirements of FW Act for making PABO – respondent also submitted that if PABO were made, exceptional circumstances existed which justified notice period under s.414 FW Act being extended to five days – respondent submitted it would need to put in place contingency arrangements to maintain availability of cash to clients and minimise cash holdings on clients’ premises – ‘exceptional circumstances’ are ‘out of the ordinary course, or unusual, or special or uncommon but need not be unique, or unprecedented, or very rare’ but must also provide justification for a longer notice period [Australia Post] – Commission satisfied ‘exceptional circumstances’ exist – Commission satisfied these circumstances justify an extension of the notice period to five days – PABO made. Transport Workers’ Union of Australia v Linfox Armaguard P/L
March 11, 2016
ANTI-BULLYING – likely to continue – s.789FC Fair Work Act 2009 – application for an order to stop bullying – applicant employed as a group leader for an education early learning centre – named individuals were the centre manager and a member of management – applicant complained of continuous bullying which commenced in 2013 and further alleged the conduct had a significant effect on her health and welfare – Commission held a conference in October 2014 – it was agreed an independent mediation would take place before applicant went on maternity leave in December 2014 – mediators report was provided to the Commission in February 2015 – issues had not been resolved – applicant on maternity leave until December 2015 – in May 2015 respondent advised Commission that applicant had been transferred to another centre and believed the matter had been resolved – in August 2015 applicant insisted matter proceed to hearing – applicant did not appear at hearing – Commission gave applicant opportunity to make a written submission – applicant responded and did not agree to withdraw matter – named individuals resigned from employment with respondent – respondent applied to dismiss matter – Commission satisfied that because of the resignations there was no risk applicant would continue to be bullied – new manager provided evidence of measures taken to ensure respondent was better situated to deal with such matters – found no risk applicant would continue to be bullied – no reasonable prospects of success – application dismissed. Ms Fsadni
March 11, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – extension of time – ss.394, 586 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant filed a Form F1 on 3 November 2015 – contacted by phone the same day and was advised she had not filed a valid application – correct form filed on 30 November – whether applicant lodged her application within time, albeit using the wrong form – considered the prejudice suffered by the respondent in the applicant’s failure to file the correct form – also considered that applicant was immediately notified she had lodged incorrect form and did not lodge correct application until 30 November – applicant was self-represented and filed an application within time – had she not used the wrong form claim would have proceeded – Commission waived the irregularity of using the wrong form to lodge application – application referred to conciliation. Reilly v Blairlogie Living & Learning Inc.
March 11, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – minimum employment period – transfer of business – ss.384, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – respondent objected on grounds applicant did not serve the minimum employment period – applicant was a transferring employee and there was a transfer of business – applicant was provided a letter of offer and contract of employment which referred to a six month probation period – applicant provided evidence respondent did not explain her service would not count – statement must specifically address the requirements of s.384(2)(b)(iii) of FW Act, namely that service with the old employer would not be recognised – Commission did not accept including a probation period in letter of offer or contract satisfied this requirement – not satisfied respondent’s explanation would have made it clear applicant was not able to make an unfair dismissal application in the first six month of employment – requirement of FW Act is that advice must be in writing – oral explanation did not suffice – objection dismissed – minimum employment period met. Gregory v Shaver Shop P/L
March 11, 2016
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – dispute concerned the interpretation of a number of provisions of the DBRL Enterprise Agreement 2009 in the context of the union alleging that shift employees were not receiving the night shift allowance – union submitted that clause included payment in lieu of all loadings – clause 76 of the agreement did not adequately compensate employees which is why the Commission required undertakings at time of approval – employer submitted there was no ambiguity and employees were paid rates which include shift loadings – further submitted union was seeking to double-dip with the payment of a loading already included in the rates paid – Commission found rates adequately compensate employees – no ambiguity or uncertainty – words given their plain, ordinary meaning [Golden Cockerel] – annualised salary included night shift allowance – matter concluded. Australian Workers’ Union v Dalby Bio-Refinery Limited