NEWS HR

Thirty-two applicants seeking relief from unfair dismissal or employment contract breaches will make their case in the Fair Work Commission today. The full list is: Renrut Pty Ltd (Davis), Sunrise Health Service Aboriginal Corporation (Hopp), North West Supermarkets (Johnson), Wedding Dance Lessons Sydney (Karyo), Perfect Labour Solution (Darwash), Dr Dan White, Executive Director of Catholic Schools and legal representative of the Catholic Education Office, Sydney (Toohey), Colin Joss & Co Pty Limited (Bennett), Top Juice Pty Ltd (Li), Oscars Restaurant (Duddington), St John of Gold Health Care In (Fossey, Rupp), T.I.S Engineering (WA) Pty Ltd (Edwards), Department of Education and Training (Adams), Department of Health and Human Services (Matchett), Coles Supermarkets (Price), Defence Health Ltd (Douglas), Westpac Banking Corporation & Caccavo and Another (Gregg), Wavemount Holdings Pty Ltd (Santella), Gate Gourmet Services Pty Ltd (Bernardino), MSS Security Pty Ltd (Thomas), Lynette Margaret Harris (Fleming), Iseekplant Pty Ltd (Becker), Century Yuasa Battery Pty Ltd (Kee), Life Without Barriers (Troxell), Cleveland Bowls Club Incorporated (Craig), Corporate Protection Australia Group Pty Ltd (O’Brien, Schuh), Caltex Australia Petroleum Pty Ltd (Dennison), Queensland Marine Holdings Pty Ltd (Cullen, Oates), Life Without Barriers (Seck).

Authorities were warned a schizophrenic and intellectually disabled woman had been sexually assaulted at a psychiatric hospital months before she fell pregnant there. The woman’s partner yesterday said that before the pregnancy, she had complained of being groped, pinned against walls and stalked by fellow ­patients at The Park Centre for Mental Health at Wacol, in Brisbane’s west. He provided documents showing he had raised concerns about her safety in a mixed-gender ward. “In the last five months, she has been sexually assaulted once, assaulted by other patients four times,” he wrote to the West Moreton Hospital and Health Service four months before the pregnancy. “You keep young female ­patients in … locked wards with male patients and expose them to sexual assaults.”

A miniscule applications list is set for the Fair Work Commissioner roster today. The unfair dismissal/labour dispute list is only eleven long. The full list is: Officeworks (Gourvelos), Be Inspired (NSW) Pty Ltd (Stock), Department of Education and Training (Adams), SPC Ardmona Operations Limited (Bathman), The Rugby Union Players Association Inc (Yorke), V/Line Pty Ltd (Lothian), The Trustee for Delahey Superfresh Unit Trust (Siljanovski), Veolia Environmental Services Australia (Brown), Millennium Services Group Ltd (Hannemann), Trustee for the Farmer Settlement Trust (Poke), Lincoln Logistics Pty Ltd (Green).

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – incapacity – inherent requirements – ss.385, 387, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – respondent placed applicant on sick leave – respondent implemented return to work plan – applicant expressed concern about anticipated return to any work under direct supervision of supervisor – respondent reacted to applicant concerns by ceasing the return to work plan and instructing applicant to leave workplace – respondent decided applicant was to return to work and report to a new manager – applicant did not return to work and provided medical certificate – respondent wrote to applicant seeking advice about applicant’s medical condition and prognosis for return to work – applicant’s medical practitioner responded to letter advising applicant had no current capacity to work – respondent sent a letter to applicant advising that it intended to make a determination of the applicant’s ongoing employment following more than a three month absence on unpaid leave – respondent advised it was considering deeming the applicant medically unfit for a return to work resulting in termination of employment – advised applicant able to submit any further material regarding capacity to return to work by certain date – applicant’s solicitor requested a one week extension in order to submit further information – respondent granted extension – applicant’s solicitor requested further extension to submit material – respondent denied request – sent letter of dismissal by email advising that it had formed view that applicant had refused to work – applicant submitted unfair dismissal on basis of procedural unfairness – respondent submitted applicant unable to perform inherent requirements of the role – Commission found applicant’s medically certified absence did not represent any established refusal to perform work but confirmed incapacity to work – found that actual reason for dismissal may have involved frustration of employment due to extended absence – held there can be a valid reason for dismissal even if reason not properly or accurately articulated – Commission unable to establish valid reason for dismissal in absence of any evidence from decision maker – respondent provided no explanation as to why second request for an extension of time was refused and respondent proceeded to dismiss applicant when information about applicant’s medical prognosis was important – Commission held that applicant was not provided with a proper opportunity to respond – found denial of natural justice in dismissal without opportunity of a meeting – found method of communicating dismissal by email was harsh – applicant’s claim for unfair dismissal upheld – compensation appropriate remedy – ordered an amount equivalent to one week’s remuneration. Finnegan v Komatsu Forklift Australia P/L

CASE PROCEDURES – evidence – production of documents – ss.590, 789FC Fair Work Act 2009 – application sought orders to stop bullying at work – Dr McShane made application for orders for production of documents – two orders issued, one directed at Professor Gopalan at Deakin University (Deakin) and one directed at Ms Champness at University of Newcastle (UoN) – orders sought production of investigation report into allegations of misconduct by Professor Gopalan – Deakin and UoN objected to production – immediate question whether report had any relevance in determining whether Professor Gopalan’s behaviour towards Dr McShane at work was unreasonable and created risk to health and safety – report related to investigation of matters at UoN – Dr McShane did not say that he was subject to bullying behaviour because of any behaviour that occurred at UoN or behaviour engaged in by Professor Gopalan while at UoN – findings Commission must make in relation to substantive application relate to behaviour that occurred while Professor Gopalan was employed by Deakin – Commission found substantive task weighs against finding that report was relevant to matters to be ultimately determined by Commission – report does not need to have direct relevance to the finding that must be made but must have apparent relevance – further ground on which report might not be required would be if grant of order would be oppressive – terms of reference for report went beyond behaviour of Professor Gopalan and other persons named in report may have not yet had chance to respond – Commission held this alone would not provide basis to grant application to revoke order – Commission not satisfied test of relevance met – application by Deakin and UoN to set aside orders requiring production of report granted. Re: McShane

INDUSTRIAL ACTION – termination of protected industrial action – s.424 Fair Work Act 2009 – application made by the Minister for Industrial Relations for the State of Victoria (the Minister) that order be made terminating protected industrial action notified by Communications, Electrical, Electronic, Energy, Information, Postal, Plumbing and Allied Services Union of Australia (Electrical Trades Union of Victoria branch) (ETU) against AGL Loy Yang P/L (AGL) that was notified by AGL Loy Yang P/L in a Notice of Employer Response Action served on the ETU – industrial action notified by the ETU related to employees who would be covered by a proposed enterprise agreement to replace the terminated Loy Yang Power Enterprise Agreement 2012 – parties have been negotiating for over two years – intention to take industrial action in form of indefinite number of consecutive one hour stoppages on performance of all work commencing on 15 May 2017 – AGL notice served on ETU declared intention to lockout all employees who would be covered by proposed agreement if the industrial action foreshadowed by the ETU was engaged in by any AGL employee – application brought by the Minister on basis that industrial action notified in both ETU Notice and AGL Notice was protected action that was threatened, impending or probable and was threatening or would threaten; to endanger the life, personal safety or health, or the welfare of the population or of part of it; or to cause significant economic damage to the Australian economy or an important part of it – Commission satisfied, and not disputed by any party, that protected industrial action as described in the Notices was threatened, impending or probable – found industrial action would almost immediately impact power supply to Victoria and have implications for South Australia – satisfied industrial action would, if taken, threaten to endanger the life, personal safety or health, or the welfare of the population or part of it or cause significant damage to the Australian economy or an important part of it, being at least in the State of Victoria – considered factors outlined in Essential Energy and adopted approach taken in Esso – all parties submitted industrial action should be terminated rather than suspended – considered extensive bargaining over two years after which dispute appears to have remained intractable – termination of protected industrial action will see parties move on from current deadlock – termination will give rise to conciliation and arbitration pursuant to s.266 of the FW Act which will see the current bargaining round come to an end – Commission decided to terminate protected industrial action notified by ETU and AGL scheduled to commence on 15 May 2017. Minister for Industrial Relations for the State of Victoria v AGL Loy Yang P/L t/a AGL Loy Yang and Ors

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – genuine redundancy – ss.394, 400, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – application for permission to appeal against decision where Commission found appellant’s dismissal a case of genuine redundancy and dismissed the application – appellant’s submissions attempted to reargue the case and sought a different outcome – Full Bench applied Coal & Allied – whether in public interest to grant permission to appeal – established it was not open to an appeal bench to substitute its view of the matter that fell for determination at first instance – held it was not in public interest to grant permission to appeal – permission to appeal refused. Appeal by Williams against decision of Wilson C of 20 March 2017 [[2017] FWC 281] Re: Northern Land Council

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – ss.604, 739 Fair Work Act 2009 – appeal – Full Bench – permission to appeal was sought by Kentz P/L on a decision relating to the interpretation of clause 19(a) of the Kentz Pty Ltd Ichthys Onshore Construction Greenfields Agreement (Agreement) – Full Bench found that decision in the first instance failed to consider all of the relevant evidence – in the public interest to grant permission – permission to appeal granted – the Full Bench found that the clause in dispute was ambiguous and applied Golden Cockerel in admitting evidence of the surrounding circumstances when the agreement was negotiated – on considering the evidence the Full Bench found that the reference in the clause to an ‘approved insurer’ was a reference to an income protection insurance product of the named insurance bodies or to another insurance product which is agreed upon by both parties to the agreement – decision under appeal quashed to the extent that it dealt with clause 19(a). Appeal by Kentz P/L against decision of Bissett C of 2 February 2017 [[2017] FWC 376] Re: Communications, Electrical, Electronic, Energy, Information, Postal, Plumbing and Allied Services Union of Australia