NEWS HR

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – approval – ss.185, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – appeal – Full Bench – in decision at first instance the Commission approved the Sparta Mining Services P/L Enterprise Agreement 2016 with certain undertakings – First Appeal Decision [[2016] FWCFB 7057] concluded that question of whether respondent had complied with s.180(2) in relation to the industry codes of practice had not been dealt with – jurisdictional prerequisite in s.190(1)(b) of FW Act for the application were not fulfilled – additional factual matters emerged – three employees who voted upon Agreement were no longer employed by respondent – also employer now employed approximately 40 employees – gave ground that Agreement was not genuinely agreed to by employees – Full Bench ordered parties to adduce further evidence – respondent did not propose to lodge any further written submissions and did not wish to have the opportunity to make further oral submissions – appellant proposed that an enterprise agreement could only be approved of the requirements set out in the FW Act were satisfied – Full Bench found that the requirements of s.186(2)(a) had not been satisfied – rendered Agreement incapable of approval – Full Bench upheld appellant’s appeal – quashed the decisions of 5 July 2016 and 6 July 2016 – application for approval of Agreement dismissed. Appeal by Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union against decisions of Spencer C of 5 July 2016 [[2016] FWC 3100] and 6 July 2016 [[2016] FWCA 4528] Re: Sparta Mining Services P/L (No 2)

ANTI-BULLYING – likely to continue – applicant dismissed – s.789FC Fair Work Act 2009 – application for alleged breach of general protections with a conference held in April 2016 – conference unsuccessful in resolving the dispute – anti-bullying application also made – applicant delayed submitting relevant material due to medical reasons until February 2017 – on 12 January 2017 applicant informed Commission employment with respondent had been terminated – subsequent unfair dismissal application lodged on 25 January 2017 – Commission advised parties due to unfair dismissal claim, Commission unable to make an order to stop bullying – Commission received submissions from both parties related to the issue of hearing the anti-bullying application – as the employee is no longer at work the Commission no longer has power to make an order to stop bulling, therefore the application has no reasonable prospect of success [Shaw v ANZ] – power to dismiss application on the basis of no reasonable prospect of success discretionary [Application by P.K] – Commission considered that application for unfair dismissal leading to reinstatement at some point is speculative and uncertain – satisfied currently no risk of applicant being bullied at work – satisfied application has no reasonable prospect of success – applicant sought legal advice from Commission, advised that Commission cannot provide legal advice – application dismissed. Application by C.I

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant subject to disciplinary action for alleged misconduct – received final written warning and 4-day suspension – employee allegedly used company truck and forklift unauthorised for personal purposes, stored bricks on employer’s premises unauthorised and failed to adequately restrain load of bricks on company truck – employee covered by BlueScope Steel Port Kembla Steelworks Agreement 2015 (Agreement) – applicant submitted evidence proved employee had authorisation to use truck and load had been restrained adequately – sought warning be revoked and employee paid for 4-day suspension – respondent submitted Commission did not have jurisdiction to order removal of final written warning but accepted it had jurisdiction to deal with suspension – contended penalty was appropriate given employee had not sought permission to use truck and breached load restraint guidelines – Commission found employee did not engage in misconduct – held decision to stand employee down for 4 shifts invalid and therefore employee entitled to be paid for those 4 shifts – construction of Agreement – Golden Cockerel applied – Commission found Agreement quite specific in relation to Commission’s role in respect to matters arising under Agreement and NES – found Commission did not have jurisdiction to deal with employee’s final warning – orders made. The Australian Workers’ Union v BlueScope Steel Limited

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – termination at initiative of employer – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – on 13 September 2016 respondent requested applicant to sign Safe Work Method Statement – applicant refused – respondent queried why applicant refused to sign the Statement – applicant refused to provide explanation – applicant alleged to have repeatedly sworn at respondent – applicant stood down provisionally on pay – respondent ordered applicant to take personal possessions from office, return office key and have applicant’s access to company emails and digital profiles cut off during stand down period – applicant maintained he was sacked – invited to a meeting several days later – cancelled meeting – respondent made several attempts to contact applicant without success – applicant did not return to workplace following 13 September 2016 – Commission resolved no communications between applicant and respondent, whether in isolation or collectively, expressly terminated applicant’s employment – application dismissed. Lawson v Environet Australia P/L t/a ESP – Environmental & Safety Professionals

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – high income threshold – modern award coverage – ss.382, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant’s income exceeded high income threshold – whether applicant covered by the Manufacturing and Associated Industries and Occupations Award 2010 (manufacturing award) or the Mining Industry Award (mining award) and therefore protected from unfair dismissal under s.382(b)(i) of FW Act – Commission held that the respondent business did not operate in the manufacturing industry, but in the mining industry, and so the applicant was not covered by the manufacturing award – held that the applicant was a supervisor, but that supervisors are not covered by the mining award [Fry], [McMillan and Norman] – held that applicant was therefore not a person protected from unfair dismissal, as he was above the high income threshold and was not covered by and enterprise agreement or award – application dismissed. Scarborough v Sandfire Resources NL t/a Sandfire Resources NL

CASE PROCEDURES – representation – ss.400, 596, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – appeal – Full Bench – at first instance the Commission granted permission for the respondent to be represented – grounds for appeal included that the Commission failed to properly and duly consider and correctly apply the Federal Court decision in Warrell v Walton – effect of s.400(1) of FW Act is that permission to appeal is not available on discretionary grounds but may only be granted if the Full Bench considers the public interest test is met – whether or not s.400 applies – Full Bench applied public interest considerations [GlaxoSmithKline] – rarely appropriate to grant permission to appeal unless arguable case of appealable error demonstrated – not commonly the case that permission is granted to appeal interlocutory decisions – Full Bench not persuaded that it was in the public interest to grant permission to appeal – even if s.400 did not apply, no discretionary grounds justifying granting permission to appeal – permission to appeal refused. Appeal by Rayner against decision of Binet DP of 19 December 2016 Re: Little Moreton P/L t/a H-R Products

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – Small Business Fair Dismissal Code – ss.394, 400, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – Commission at first instance found that the employee’s dismissal was not in accordance with Small Business Fair Dismissal Code (the Code) – appellant challenged all identified aspects of the decision – 18 grounds for the appeal including failure to provide adequate reasons for findings and failure to determine the jurisdictional issue relating to the Code before considering the merits of the application – appellant also submitted permission to appeal based on public interest – GlaxoSmithKline Australia P/L v Makin considered – Full Bench accepted appellant’s submission that Commission erred in not discretely considering and determining whether dismissal was consistent with the Code before turning to issue of whether dismissal was unfair – however Full Bench found it does not follow from that conclusion that permission to appeal should be granted – Full Bench found decision procedure did not affect the obvious correctness of the conclusion that the dismissal was not consistent with the Code – found decision made sufficiently clear the basis upon which Commission decided the matter and has allowed the appellant a proper opportunity to exercise its appeal rights – Full Bench wholly satisfied that the text message and abusive phone call could only be understood as constituting a dismissal – not satisfied appeal raises any issue of general application or is counter-intuitive or manifests any injustice – permission to appeal refused. Appeal by Inner West Towing P/L against decision of Drake DP of 14 December 2016 [[2016] FWC 8582] Re: Maynard

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – ss.394, 400, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – application for relief from unfair dismissal dismissed at first instance – Commission found the applicant had deliberately headbutted a colleague for no apparent reason which led to a final warning – Commission found Mr Hughes behaviour at a subsequent Momentum social function was aggressive and had the potential to damage the reputation of Momentum – grounds for appeal included that Commission erred by applying the wrong legal test in determining whether there was a valid reason and findings made in relation to the altercation – Full Bench considered whether in public interest to grant permission to appeal – whether decision at first instance involved significant error of fact – Coal & Allied and GlaxoSmithKline applied – rarely appropriate to grant permission to appeal unless arguable case of appealable error is demonstrated [Wan] – Full Bench satisfied Commission at first instance duly considered all relevant evidence and no appealable error was identified – permission to appeal refused. Appeal by Hughes against decision of Williams C of 13 February 2017 [[2016] FWC 9072]] Re: Momentum Wealth P/L t/a Momentum Wealth