TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – genuine redundancy – ss.389, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – applicant employed as a site supervisor – respondent objected on ground dismissal was genuine redundancy – applicant submitted he was not genuinely made redundant as majority of tasks he was required to perform still remain and are being performed by new site supervisor – applicant submitted he was covered by Road Transport and Distribution Award 2010 (the Award) and employer required to consult with employees about major change – respondent’s general manager submitted he was required to consider whether applicant’s position should be retained after the sale of one of the companies the site provided services to was sold – respondent submitted applicant’s redundancy resulted from a restructure and client’s request for greater operational assistance and a flexible driving resource – Commission found it was clear from the respondent’s evidence that a restructure of its operations resulted in a decision that the position was no longer required – respondent must also comply with any obligations under an applicable award or enterprise agreement to consult about the redundancy – no applicable enterprise agreement – Commission found the Award had no application to applicant – applicant argued it was reasonable he be deployed into another subcontractor position that undertook some of the duties of previous role – found position applicant referred to was not a position within the respondent’s enterprise or that of an associated entity – found there was no obligation on the respondent to consider terminating the applicant’s employment and offer him a subcontractor position – Commission found applicant’s termination was a result of a genuine redundancy – application dismissed. Corcoran v The Trustee for the Express Parts Trust t/a On Time Group of Companies P/L
May 29, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – genuine redundancy – modern award coverage – ss.382, 389, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – jurisdictional objections – not protected from unfair dismissal – not covered by modern award – redundancy was genuine – applicant employed in business now operated by respondent since 1989 – applicant’s rate of earnings in excess of high income threshold – not covered by enterprise agreement – applicant submitted Real Estate Industry Award 2010 (Award) provided coverage – not disputed that respondent was relevantly covered by Award – respondent submitted applicant’s senior management position was beyond classifications in Award – Commission considered respondent’s witness evidence in cross-examination against witness statement – considered respondent’s list of applicant’s duties against indicative tasks for Property Sales Representative classification in Award – applicant submitted his focus was property sales for respondent – submitted he was instructed not to provide guidance to staff – respondent submitted remuneration paid was indicative of different character of applicant’s position compared to position contemplated by Award – Commission held that high levels of remuneration are indicative only of an employer’s view that the employee is valuable and a reflection of their success – held that remuneration does not reflect award coverage – found that applicant had no managerial responsibilities, no direct reports and little role in strategy and management of respondent – found that principal purpose of applicant’s position was to sell real estate – found that at time of dismissal applicant’s duties fell squarely within definition of Property Sales Representative classification of Award – satisfied that applicant covered by Award and protected from unfair dismissal – jurisdictional objection dismissed – application to proceed – question of genuine redundancy to be determined in conjunction with merits of application. Kaufman v John Lang LaSalle (Vic) P/L t/a JLL
May 29, 2017
INDUSTRIAL ACTION – order against industrial action – ss.414, 418 Fair Work Act 2009 – application by Mangoola for order that planned industrial action stop and not be organised by CFMEU – employees who work at Mangoola open cut mine (Mine) are covered by Mangoola Coal Greenfields Enterprise Agreement 2010 – Agreement passed nominal expiry date – protected action ballot order made 22 March 2017 in relation to employees at Mine – ballot conducted 13 April 2017 and results declared – various forms of industrial action authorised by majority of relevant employees – on 15 May 2017 CFMEU gave Mangoola written notice of intention of members of CFMEU who are employed by Mangoola at Mine to take protected industrial action (Notice) – Notice stated industrial action would be taken in form of ‘four stoppages of work each of two hours in duration that may be consecutive’ for each of seven consecutive days – whether Notice satisfies requirements of s.414(6) FW Act – EnergyAustralia Yallourn P/L v CFMEU considered – Mine Operations Manager gave evidence of safety related risks that would arise at Mine if work stoppages were undertaken – Commission not satisfied Notice ‘specifies the nature of the action’ within meaning of s.414(6) – held Notice did not give Mangoola opportunity to take appropriate defensive action, particularly to deal with safety risks – in order to prepare for all eventualities contemplated by Notice, Mangoola would have to plan on the basis that stoppages of work would take place during each of the three shifts (or parts of shifts) on each day the subject of the Notice, for between two and eight hours on each occasion, by CFMEU members in each Department across the Mine – Alcoa considered – Commission held in the particular practical applied circumstances of workplace at Mine, Notice would satisfy requirements of s.414(6) if it specified commencement time(s) of proposed action on each day specified in Notice – satisfied in particular circumstances of this case that in specifying ‘nature of the action’, it is necessary in context of action proposed by Notice to specify commencement time(s) of proposed action – held Notice did not satisfy requirements of s.414(6) – as a result, proposed action the subject of the Notice does not meet common requirements for industrial action to be ‘protected industrial action’ – it follows that Commission must make an order pursuant to s.418 FW Act that industrial action stop and not be organised – order made. Mangoola Coal Operations P/L v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union
May 29, 2017
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – termination of agreement – ss.225, 226 Fair Work Act 2009 – application made by NQR P/L t/a NQR Grocery Clearance Stores (NQR) – initially opposed by National Union of Workers (NUW) however application subsequently withdrawn – agreement covers 14 warehouse workers – application for approval of new agreement made 21 December 2016 – Commission assessed the application but on 28 February 2017 the FWC Member Support Research Team wrote to NQR outlining a number of concerns and requesting a response – on 3 March 2017 NQR discontinued their application – NUW and NQR then engaged in further negotiations – agreement not reached and NQR made an application to terminate the Agreement – also indicated they would not seek to replace current collective agreement – Commission remained satisfied the Agreement provided terms and conditions that ensure each employee is better off overall than under the Award – the Commission received five written submissions from employees who strongly opposed termination of the Agreement – concerns related to job security and security of redundancy entitlements – no presumption agreements which have passed their nominal expiry date should be terminated – Commission not satisfied over award conditions contained in the Agreement are so onerous or significant that they could impact on employment or business viability – termination at this time and in these circumstances are likely to alter balance of power between the bargaining parties and not likely to promote productivity, employment or settle disputes – termination of the Agreement not appropriate in all circumstances – requirements of s.226 FW Act not met – application to terminate Agreement dismissed. NQR Pty Ltd and National Union of Workers Warehouse Enterprise Agreement 2015
May 29, 2017
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – dispute about matters arising under the Futuris Automotive Interiors (South Australia) Workplace Agreement 2013 (the Agreement) and the National Employment Standards (NES) – agreed power to arbitrate – notice and redundancy provisions – whether actual notice taken into account when applying the package of redundancy entitlements – approach to proper construction considered – Golden Cockerel considered – common objective intention to be ascertained – previous practice not relevant in this case – intention arises from the particular and contrasting approach in relevant provisions when read in context – apparent from the terms of clause 3.5 of the Agreement, when read in context, that the parties intended particular arrangements to apply where a redundancy of the nature present here was to apply – this involves particular notice and other provisions, and unlike the other provisions dealing with similar circumstances, the parties have chosen to refer expressly to the notice being paid as part of a package that is to be paid to the relevant employees – proper application of agreement determined. Illingworth v Futuris Automotive Interiors P/L t/a Futuris Automotive
May 25, 2017
A 789FC (Application for an order to stop bullying) lodged by Dr Michael McShane focused on his desire to be legally represented in his dispute with Deakin University. Commissioner Bissett, in Melbourne on 22 May 2017, said yes to the request.
May 25, 2017
The Fair Work Commission will hear 26 unfair dismissal/employment dispute cases today. The full list is: One Harvest (Chand), Rise (iiWorks), Churchill Management Pty Ltd (Athanates), Telstra Corporation Limited (Milonas), Compass Group (Australia) Pty Ltd & Compass Group Bl Hospitality Services Pty Ltd and Another (Wei), New Security Solutions (Bown), Farrugia Enterprises Australia Pty Ltd (Stefanovski), Stegbar Pty Ltd (Staniland), The Information Management Group Pty Ltd (Clarke), Mothers Pantry (Moyes), Tasmanian Water and Sewerage Corporation Pty Ltd (Ponting), Trustee for the Farmer Settlement Trust (Poke), McLoughlin Butchers (Rubin), Safe Places For Children Pty Limited (Charles), Queensland Marine Holdings Pty Ltd (Cullen), Nijjar and Sons Pty Ltd (Zver Mekis), Valspar Paint (Australia) Pty Ltd (Blackhurst, Jenkins, Milburn, Szczepny, Tantuccio, Taylor), Woolworths Limited (Morris), National Prescribing Service (McAllan), BGC Contracting Pty Ltd (Ninyette).
May 24, 2017
Twenty-seven unfair dismissal/employment contract dispute applicants are to be heard in the Fair Work Commission today. The full list is: Thirty Second Bean Company Pty Limited (Zaboj), Seovic Engineering Pty Ltd (Sheridan), CSR Limited (Cui), Michael Bailey Associates Pty Ltd (Hussey), Beecroft LDC Pty Ltd (Jones), Aurizon Operations Ltd (Jones), Rex Gorell Family Group Pty Ltd (Grozdanovski), Be Inspired (NSW) Pty Ltd (Stock), Visy Board Proprietary Limited (Kennedy), The Good Guys Discount Warehouse (Australia) Pty Ltd (French), Woolworths – Kingsway (Farah), Valspar Paint (Australia) Pty Ltd (Blackhurst, Jenkins, Milburn, Szczepny, Tantuccio, Taylor), Coles Supermarkets (Price), Youth Projects Ltd (Hosking), Fanissa Pty Ltd (Versace), Geelong & Surfcoast Laundry (Richardson), Workpac Pty Ltd (Fielder), Fawcett Plumbing Pty Ltd (Knight), Petro Industrial Pty Ltd (Malyon), Queensland Marine Holdings Pty Ltd (Cullen), Open Minds Australia Limited (Seggie), Beech Constructions Pty Ltd (Seabrook).