CASE PROCEDURES – referral to Full Bench – ss.225, 615A Fair Work Act 2009 – Ms Vickers made application for termination of Coles Supermarkets Australia P/L and Bi-Lo P/L Retail Agreement 2011 (Agreement) – Ms Vickers sought termination of Agreement to take effect retrospectively, from 31 May 2014 – Ms Vickers applied for termination application to be referred to Full Bench for determination pursuant to ss.582, 615 and 615A of FW Act – Coles, SDA and AWU opposed application – Ms Vickers submitted referral of termination application would be in public interest – Collinsville Coal Operations considered – Commission found number of employees to which Agreement applied is so large as to make question of termination of Agreement a matter of public significance because of its potentially broad economic and commercial effects – found effect of backdated termination of enterprise agreement raised complex legal and practical issues particularly in relation to employees who have been paid aboveaward rates and other benefits – found cases of particular significance are from time to time heard by Full Benches even where they involve receipt of extensive evidence and there is no reason why allocation to Full Bench should result in delay in conduct of hearing – Commission directed termination application (AG2016/3797) be referred to Full Bench for hearing and determination. Re: Vickers
May 22, 2017
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – application to deal with a dispute in accordance with the Victoria University Enterprise Agreement 2013 (the Agreement) – applicant sought an interim order restraining respondent, until further order, from determining any expression of interest in voluntary separation, change of employment arrangements, or application for a role in the First Year College – applicant at liberty to re-apply for an interim order at any stage in proceedings – in determining whether to make an interim order, Commission must consider whether there was a serious question to be tried, and whether the balance of convenience favoured granting the interim order – Commission held there was no serious issue to be tried – held that individual academics may have legitimate issues which warrant them not being held to elections that they might make, or which raise issues of research requirements in Schedule 9, or some other issue which is of a more general nature involving many academics such as forced redundancies, or other issues – respondent at liberty to make applications in relation to such issues, or others, including interim relief, to some degree this application may be premature – in relation to the balance of convenience, applicant refers to the difficulty of reversing acceptance of voluntary separation or acceptance of jobs, and that academics should not be held to their election, and other matters – respondent refers to the substantial cost impacts of a delay to implementation of the First Year College, and the overall ‘precarious position of the University’ – Commission satisfied that respondent is in some financial difficulty, and that a delay in the introduction of the new First Year College would increase costs – Commission held the balance of convenience favours the respondent. National Tertiary Education Industry Union v Victoria University
May 22, 2017
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – dispute whether employee had been correctly paid for redundancy and long service leave (LSL) under the Air Liquide Australia Limited/Botany Plant Enterprise Agreement 2012 (the Agreement) – at issue were calculations on basis of annualised salary versus ‘ordinary hours’ as contained in the National Employment Standards (NES) and the Manufacturing and Associated Industries and Occupations Award 2010 (the Award) – applicant submitted clause 29 of the Agreement was clear that redundancy was calculated on the basis of the Agreement annualised salary rate – respondent submitted their calculations were based on 38 ordinary hours per week as the annualised salary incorporated an overtime component – the long service component calculated as ‘ordinary remuneration’ as defined in the Long Service Leave Act 1955 (NSW) – where a term is ambiguous the general approach should consider the objective framework of facts within which the contract came into existence, and parties’ presumed intention in this setting [Golden Cockerel] – Commission found meaning of redundancy clause clearly identified the annualised rate as basis for calculation despite tension between the NES and the Award – the applicants calculation method was appropriate – the LSL calculation was more difficult – on balance the proper Agreement interpretation was the application of the same calculation based on the context of the Agreement, the operation of the annualised salary and consistency of approach – applicant’s claim granted. Moffat v Air Liquide Australia Ltd
May 22, 2017
CASE PROCEDURES – evidence – production of documents – s.229 Fair Work Act 2009 – on 8 May 2017 an order was issued for the production of documents with respect to an application by The Maritime Union of Australia (MUA) for a bargaining order – the bargaining order related to negotiations for the proposed enterprise agreement between GrainCorp and the Australian Workers’ Union (AWU) – MUA asserted it was entitled to make the bargaining order to represent employees of GrainCorp who are members of the MUA – MUA sought a bargaining order that GrainCorp recognised and bargained with the MUA – application for bargaining order was opposed by GrainCorp and AWU – on application by the MUA, the Commission ordered the AWU to produce documents identifying financial members of the AWU in their Queensland branch currently employed by GrainCorp at port grain terminals in Queensland – AWU objected on grounds of relevance and confidentiality – GrainCorp supported AWU objection – AWU further objected on grounds that disclosing membership would disclose industrial strength to GrainCorp and adversely impact on AWU negotiations – Commission rescinded first order to address some concerns advanced by the AWU – criterion for production of documents from BHP Coal considered – Commission considered respective membership numbers of the AWU and MUA as relevant to whether a bargaining order should be exercised – order made to produce documents subject to a non-requirement to disclosure private or commercially sensitive or confidential information, excluding workplace and financial status of members within the AWU or AWUQ – documents to be made available for viewing by Counsel for the MUA – Counsel for the MUA to provide undertaking he will not disclose actual number of AWU or AWUQ members to the MUA only disclose if AWUQ has more or less members than MUA – whether information to be disclosed to GrainCorp will be dealt with at hearing of substantive application. Maritime Union of Australia, The v GrainCorp Operations Limited t/a GrainCorp
May 22, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief for unfair dismissal – applicant employed as a Federal Agent at the respondent’s ‘Crime Operations A’ office – applicant dismissed on 9 November 2016 for serious misconduct – breaches arose from applicant’s private life whereby stalking and imitation, falsification of time records, misleading an investigation and providing incorrect information to a court proceeding occurred – respondent submitted applicant’s breaches contravened its values – applicant denied some and conceded to some of the breaches – purported the dismissal was disproportionate to any error which may have occurred – submitted the investigation process was unfair and dismissal was not justified – respondent conducted a comprehensive two year investigation before dismissal – applicant concerned with the duration of the investigation – Commission found the duration did not depart from the respondent’s standard procedures and investigation process was appropriately robust but fair – found assessment of applicant’s conduct to be against high standards of a police officer – Commission considered all material and was satisfied each allegation was substantiated – satisfied applicant’s deliberate conduct was inconsistent with respondent’s professional standards and core values required of police officers – found valid reason for dismissal – applicant’s conduct had the potential to damage the reputation of the respondent – held dismissal was not harsh, unjust or unreasonable – application dismissed. Hackett v Australian Federal Police
May 22, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – Small Business Fair Dismissal Code – ss.388, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – matter previously subject of jurisdictional hearing – on 3 October 2016 Commission found applicant protected from unfair dismissal as minimum employment period had been completed – appeal of that decision dismissed by Full Bench – when employment contract initially engaged in respondent and applicant negotiated and agreed applicant had individual sales target of $1.3 million of solar products – applicant disputed the target was individual and argued the target was for entire staff base – Commission determined it was more likely the sales target was that of the applicant’s rather than the entire staff base – six months into employment contract applicant was well below end of year sales target – numerous meetings held between January 2016 and end of April 2016 to resolve issues of underperformance – issues also related to applicant’s unexplained absences and aggression towards other staff members – applicant provided with letter of termination on 29 April 2016 with four weeks’ notice and expected to work until 27 May 2016 – respondent largely relied on underperformance for reasons of dismissal – due to events on 26 May 2016, the day before the end of the employment contract, the respondent also relied on summary dismissal reasons for serious misconduct – respondent asserted applicant was involved in pushing a staff member while attempting to leave the office – this occurred after the staff member had asked if applicant had taken any company property home with him and requested he sign forms to formalise he had not taken any company property – applicant refused to sign forms and became increasingly frustrated and agitated – Commission considered whether the respondent genuinely held the belief the employee’s conduct was sufficiently serious to justify immediate dismissal, whether that belief was based on reasonable grounds and whether a reasonable investigation into the matter had been carried out [Ryman v Thrash] – regulation 1.07 of the Fair Work Regulations 2009 considered – Commission found conduct of applicant on 26 May 2016 could be categorised as sufficiently serious to justify immediate dismissal – found no question that respondent presented its concerns to applicant, indicated consequences for lack of remediation and gave opportunities for applicant to provide response – Commission determined applicant’s underperformance in relation to sales consistent with other dismissal part of the Code – application dismissed. Cole v Endless Solar Operations
May 22, 2017
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – ss.604, 739 Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – dispute arising under Victoria Police (Police Officers (Excluding Commanders), Protective Services Officers, Police Reservists and Police Recruits) Enterprise Agreement 2015 (Agreement) – dispute concerned proposed termination of variable roster agreement for police officers employed in Water Police Squad – determination of dispute in first instance turned on proper construction of the Agreement – respondent in first instance sought to terminate variable rostered agreement pursuant to clause 34.8(b) which allowed it to be terminated where service delivery requirements were not being met as result of variable shift roster – Golden Cockerel considered – appellant submitted Commission erred by misconstruing expression ‘service delivery requirements’ in clause 34.8(b) of Agreement – Full Bench found Commission’s reasoning process did not disclose error and interpretation adopted was correct – found in context of Water Police Squad, evidence supported finding that regulatory and operational demands have changed over past decade – found it was open to Commission to make finding required by clause 34.8(b) that service delivery requirements were not being met as a result of variable shift roster – not persuaded it was in the public interest to grant permission to appeal – held appellant did not establish arguable case of error or that there were other considerations that warranted granting of permission to appeal – held Commission’s interpretation of clause 34.8(b) of Agreement was correct and findings of fact made were reasonably open – permission to appeal refused. Appeal by The Police Federation of Australia (Victoria Police Branch) against decision of Wilson C of 19 January 2017 [[2017] FWC 340] Re: Victoria Police/Chief Commissioner of Police
May 22, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant alleged his dismissal was unfair – dismissal reasons in respondent’s letter, in addition to the safety incident resulting in an injury as result of failure to follow procedure, included pre-existing written warning for failure to report safety breach, failing to provide satisfactory responses to serious issues and to show the required level of accountability – applicant said he had a record of regularly reporting potential health and safety risks – issue of prior warning – applicant believed he followed procedure for reporting a breach – reported incident in database entry rather than direct to a supervisor which led to the first and final warning – appeared from evidence was not made explicit to employees safety entries in the database not regarded as reporting an incident – Commission concluded warning did not warrant it’s significant weight in respondent’s later decision to dismiss the applicant – final safety incident resulted in injury whilst loading a truck – applicant followed respondent’s Loading and Unloading Standard Work Instructions (SWI) – applicant used forklift to load empty cage onto the truck – driver should not have been on truck giving guidance – respondent investigated the incident but applicant was not interviewed – at meeting applicant given show cause letter and advised he had breached the SWI, Code of Conduct and Our Charter Values – stood down – applicant’s support person requested but not provided with information relied upon to determine the allegations proven – not told how he was alleged to have breached the Code of Conduct or Charter Values – dismissed at meeting with respondent week later – applicant not given opportunity to respond to findings or allegations – applicant said his actions were a ‘momentary lapse of judgement’ – applicant’s evidence common practice prior to August 2016 for drivers to assist as ‘spotter’ with loading/unloading – driver assistance not a breach of previous procedure – not sure this clearly communicated to employees – SWI did not expressly say loading must cease when a driver is on the truck deck – Commission satisfied this created a degree of ambiguity about how the forklift operator and truck driver undertake loading – incomplete hazard form not entirely explained – investigation report found deficiency in SWI – SWI later amended – Commission found the safety incident a valid reason for dismissal but issues with the respondent’s processes tell in favour of a finding of unfair – Commission satisfied dismissal was harsh as inadequate account taken of applicant’s safety record – unjust due to improper characterisation of true circumstances of the incident and procedural ambiguities – unreasonable in concluding applicant acted deliberately – Commission ordered applicant reinstated by 29 May 2017 and payment of $10,578.60 for lost remuneration, taking into account earnings since dismissal and deduction of two months’ salary for lapse of judgement. Tomlinson v BHP Coal P/L t/a BHP Billiton