CASE PROCEDURES – appeals – extension of time – s.400 Fair Work Act 2009 – Full Bench – application for extension of time to lodge appeal – notice of appeal lodged almost two years out of time – at first instance appellant found unjustly dismissed and 38 hours’ pay ordered as compensation – matters relevant to whether extension of time should be granted are reason for and length of delay; nature of appeal grounds and likelihood of grounds being upheld; and prejudice to respondent – reasons given for delay were appellant took time to complain about, then seek to resolve, issues regarding the matter at first instance without appealing – Full Bench found reasons for delay unsatisfactory and length of delay ‘very substantial’ – Commission must not grant permission to appeal unless in public interest – appeals on question of fact may only be made if decision involved significant error of fact – statutory test is stringent [Coal & Allied] – public interest test is discretionary and involves broad value judgment [O’Sullivan] – considerations that may attract public interest identified in GlaxoSmithKline – rarely appropriate to grant permission to appeal unless arguable case of appealable error [Wan] – fact that Member at first instance made error not necessarily sufficient basis for granting permission to appeal [GlaxoSmithKline] – appeal grounds included appellant had not received all correspondence between Commission and parties – employer had not provided legal name of relevant persons – Full Bench found these insufficient for granting permission to appeal – other grounds were material filed by respondent was illegal, incorrect and could be damaging to appellant’s current employment – Full Bench found member at first instance had not erred in admitting evidence used and although appellant might not be happy with the evidence, this was insufficient to allow permission to appeal – appellant unhappy with compensation amount but did not submit grounds showing appealable error – Commissioner had correctly applied legislation and there was no arguable case of any error of principle or significant error of fact – even if extension of time were granted, Full Bench not satisfied permission to appeal would have been granted – no prejudice to respondent – Full Bench concluded appellant had not provided satisfactory explanation for delay – lack of prejudice to respondent was not sufficient to extend time for appeal – not satisfied appeal raised public interest considerations – application for extension of time to lodge appeal dismissed – permission to appeal refused. Appeal by Iurato against decision of Ryan C of 12 May 2015 [[2015] FWC 3248] Re: Crossmark Australia P/L
May 29, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – applicant employed in Mobile Maintenance Department at Coppabella Mine – applicant dismissed as result of applicant losing control of a light vehicle in a ‘no go zone’ – breach of Cardinal Rule 3 (Rule 3) – applicant conceded he was in alleged ‘no go zone’ but refuted allegation area was a ‘no go zone’ according to respondent’s policy – claimed no valid reason for termination – respondent did not articulate what policy was breached – restricted area was not signed and work in the area lead reasonable person to believe the area was no longer restricted – respondent did not substantiate how the applicant failed to drive to conditions – submitted prior warnings taken into account by respondent in deciding to terminate his employment should not have carried any weight – respondent submitted termination not harsh, unjust or unreasonable as there was valid reason for termination being the serious breach of safety procedures – safety breach constituted valid reason for termination – claimed applicant had poor record of compliance with safety procedures, evidenced by three final written warnings – claimed applicant was notified mine pit a restricted area which was signed accordingly but applicant entered without authorisation and lost control of vehicle, causing serious damage – claimed it had discharged its onus to establish the misconduct occurred as alleged – whether dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable – Commission satisfied applicant was notified of reasons for dismissal and given opportunity to appropriately respond – respondent conceded allegation initially put to applicant was that he breached Rule 3 by entering a ‘no go zone’ but reconciled allegation to a ‘restricted access area’ and therefore applicant was not in breach of Rule 3 – Commission found this a procedural flaw – found issues arising from applicant’s ability to properly respond and consider reasons provided for termination did not constitute fatal procedural flaws – found conduct of applicant substantiated as valid reason for dismissal – dismissal not harsh, unjust or unreasonable – application dismissed. Hill v Peabody Energy Australia PCI Mine Management P/L
May 29, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – applicant travelled to Bali in September 2014, February 2015 and February 2016 to have dental procedures carried out – applicant provided medical certificate for February 2015 visit which stated that she had been treated at Clinic – applicant submitted she provided a second certificate, which included the words ‘so was unable attended work’ – respondent considered applicant had fabricated second certificate so as to have annual leave converted to sick leave – applicant suspended then later terminated for fabrication of medical certificate – applicant absolutely denied that she had falsified certificate in order to claim personal leave entitlement – admitted to modifying medical certificate in 2015 but explained that this was with intention of emailing it to Clinic with a request to have medical certificate reissued with additional phrase ‘so was unable attended work’ – Commission found applicant altered medical certificate – found, on balance, valid reason for applicant’s dismissal – dismissal not harsh, unjust or unreasonable – application dismissed. Bluzer v Monash University
May 29, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – genuine redundancy – ss.389, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – four applications for unfair dismissal remedy heard together – respondent raised jurisdictional objection that applicants were dismissed on grounds of genuine redundancy – applicants employed as emergency services officers – enterprise agreement applied to employment relationship – applicants submitted redundancies not genuine as only alteration was 13 per cent salary reduction not to job tasks or responsibilities – further submitted their roles continued to be performed by other newly appointed employees on the same terms and conditions but on lower salaries – respondent submitted reductions in its contract prices resulted in need to reduce costs – to reduce costs respondent undertook operational restructure – respondent argued Commission should adopt wide 11 view of the words ‘the employer no longer requires the person’s job to be performed’ to include remuneration – applicant argued a narrow interpretation be adopted which does not include remuneration – Commission found remuneration not a reason for redundancy as provided in explanatory memorandum or in FW Act – Commission found no reduction in responsibilities or tasks in applicants positions and no redistribution of tasks or responsibilities of applicants positions to other positions – not satisfied wide interpretation of FW Act supported by authority – Commission found words ‘person’s job to be performed’ in the FW Act refer to the functions, duties and responsibilities associated with the job only – genuine redundancy not made out – matter listed for future direction. Mallard and Ors v Parabellum International P/L t/a Parabellum International
May 29, 2017
CASE PROCEDURES – referring question of law – ss.156, 608 Fair Work Act 2009 – claim by the Australian Council of Trade Unions for paid family and domestic violence leave clause to be inserted into modern awards – background to immediate issue in matter, the ‘constitution issue’, was set out in the Statement of 28 April 2017 [[2017] FWC 2347] (April Statement) – written and/or oral submissions regarding constitution issue made by various employer/employee organisations and peak bodies – Commission expressed provisional view in April Statement that it should seek certainty in final disposition of matter AM2015/1 by referring questions of law to the Federal Court pursuant to s.608(1) of the FW Act – parties and any other interested persons were requested to provide submissions on provisional view and various matters outlined in the Attachment to April Statement – various parties lodged submissions – Commission decided to refer questions set out in the Attachment to the April Statement to Federal Court, with one deletion from statement of facts. 4 yearly review of modern awards–Family & Domestic Violence Leave Clause
May 29, 2017
GENERAL PROTECTIONS – extension of time – ss.365, 366 Fair Work Act 2009 – application lodged one day late on 4 April 2017 – applicant represented by Shine Lawyers – applicant’s representative provided written submission that due to Force Majeur, an Act of God and representative error application was delayed – representative unable to access office computers during flooding in Brisbane from Cycle Debbie – question of exceptional circumstances and timeliness of application [Nulty] – dispute in relation to actual termination date – Commission determined applicant has provided credible explanation for entire period of delay – satisfied applicant’s circumstances can be regarded as exceptional to support an extension of time – request for extension of time granted – orders issued. Hanson v Blueprint Global P/L
May 29, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – applicant was courier driver with respondent – respondent alerted to presence of competitor referred to as ‘Today’s Express’ from customers – respondent received an electronic message via WeChat group from customer expressing satisfaction for service provided by Today’s Express and respondent, whom she believed were operating in a joint arrangement – respondent requested copy of messages involving Today’s Express, which implicated applicant – respondent accused applicant of operating own company in competition to respondent – applicant denied allegation and requested proof – respondent forwarded copy of relevant WeChat messages to applicant – at subsequent meeting with respondent the applicant said he was entitled to do whatever he wanted outside work time – respondent summarily dismissed applicant – applicant challenged reason for dismissal and denied any of his activities with Today’s Express were inimical to the respondent – applicant submitted Today’s Express was not a company but a WeChat group operating in conjunction with another company as an agent for the respondent – applicant submitted real reason for his dismissal related to claims of alleged underpayment of wages, superannuation and taxation – respondent submitted there was a valid reason for dismissal as applicant was operating a rival company using respondent’s commercial and intellectual property without authorisation – Commission found evidence problematic as applicant had limited English skills and both applicant and respondent introduced statements from individuals who did not appear for crossexamination – Commission satisfied applicant involved in activities in direct conflict to respondent’s business interest which represented valid reason for summary dismissal – lack of proper documentation of the termination and allegations of underpayment and taxation breaches could not justify or mitigate the serious misconduct of applicant – allegations of underpayment should be pursued through alternative government agencies – found even if applicant had established dismissal was unfair, there was little prospect of remedy as applicant did not make efforts to find alternative employment and did not provide evidence to support assertion that mental and physical health problems impeded this pursuit – application dismissed. Jiang v C J Express Sydney P/L
May 29, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – application to dismiss by employer – premature application – ss.394, 586, 587 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant made unfair dismissal application – respondent objected on basis that application made during notice period and prior to effective date of dismissal – applicant provided with one month’s notice of termination – respondent submitted that application was invalid as it was made prior to the effective date of dismissal – applicant submitted that termination date was the last day he physically attended the office – Commission raised Mihajlovic as authority that it has discretion to amend an application – applicant submitted that Commission should exercise discretion to waive the irregularity in form or matter in which application was made – respondent submitted that Commission should not exercise discretion – respondent submitted that Mihajlovic was authority that the Commission’s power to waive irregularities not ‘automatic’ and required consideration of all circumstances – respondent referred to Gee – Commission considered Mihajlovic – Commission found that arrangements were put in place when applicant notified of termination that may have led applicant to believe that his termination was with immediate effect – applicant was requested not to return to office and computer and phone were confiscated – Commission noted filing of application early had not prejudiced respondent – Commission exercised discretion in applicant’s favour. Cooper v Statseeker P/L t/a Statseeker