NEWS HR

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – termination at initiative of employer – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant a regular and systematic casual employee – minimum employment period satisfied – applicant submitted he felt forced to resign as a result of the unacceptable working conditions he was subjected to – applicant claimed respondent’s practices included underpayments, pay back schemes, and threats that the applicant would be deported if he complained – Fair Work Ombudsman (FWO) was conducting an investigation into applicant’s allegations – Commission considered whether dismissal at initiative of employer – Commission found that evidence was complicated by family members opposing one another – found insufficient evidence to be satisfied about substance of allegations under investigation by FWO – found applicant tendered a letter of resignation which did not amount to dismissal at initiative of employer – application dismissed. Banda v Mrs Australia P/L t/a 7-Eleven

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – Small Business Fair Dismissal Code – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – reasons given for dismissal included unsatisfactory work performance and misconduct – applicant submitted respondent’s actual reason for dismissal was to avoid having to pay applicant his long service leave – jurisdictional objection raised by respondent on the basis that the dismissal complied with the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code – reasonable belief that applicant had engaged in serious misconduct due to the ‘unsafe and illegal way’ in which he had secured three vehicles on a car carrier – respondent had discussions with applicant about his failure to comply with the business safety policy and procedures – evidence of respondent witness preferred – employer complied with Code – application dismissed. Collins v Elfbill P/L t/a Alfies Towing

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – application to deal with a dispute in accordance with dispute resolution procedure in Wood Group PSN Australia P/L Electrical and Instrument Greenfields Agreement Lytton Refinery 2016-2019 (Agreement) – respondent proposed to introduce a new afternoon shift from 2:30pm- 10:47pm – whether respondent could implement afternoon shift on an ongoing basis with continual review for effectiveness – whether proposal aligned with definition of ‘shift work’ in Agreement – construction of relevant clauses in Agreement – meaning of ‘expected’, ‘duration’ and ‘job’ – Commission found ‘expected duration of the shift work’ not an ambiguous phrase and means for a period of time that does end – satisfied parties did not specifically consider limiting use of shift work during negotiation of Agreement – held respondent unable to implement proposal as put – shift work must have nominated final completion date to meet requirements of Agreement – dispute determined. Communications, Electrical, Electronic, Energy, Information, Postal, Plumbing and Allied Services Union of Australia v Wood Group PSN Australia P/L

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – dismissal based upon alleged misconduct arising from organisation of unlawful industrial action with consequential reputational damage to respondent – respondent further alleged applicant had not been truthful during the subsequent investigations, providing another reason for dismissal – applicant denied protest was not unlawful and caused reputational damage – alternatively, applicant submitted dismissal was harsh due to the applicant’s 27 years of service and previously unblemished record – Easy considered – Commission held that protest did not constitute unprotected industrial action as there was no limitation or restriction placed on the performance of work – Commission further found the protest action was tacitly authorised by the respondent – applicant’s alleged dishonesty during investigations could not be confirmed – dismissal found to be disproportionate response to applicant’s conduct – no valid reason for dismissal – reinstatement ordered – parties to agree on amount to restore lost pay. McLachlan v Illawarra Coal Holdings P/L t/a South32

25 unfair dismissal/labour dispute applications are listed for hearing by the Fair Work Commission today: North Coast Hotel Group (Fallon), Transgrid (Adsett), Cerebos (Australia) Limited (Ratcliffe), Front-Line Resources Management Pty Ltd (Lambropoulos), Svitzer Australia Pty Ltd (Asquith), Smartbuilt Perth Pty Ltd & D’Amico and Another (Gordon), MMG Australia Ltd (Harding), The Salvation Army (Tasmania) Property Trust as Trustee for The Salvation Army (TAS) Social Work (Webb), Mega Admin Services Pty Ltd (Glancy), ALDI Foods Pty Ltd (Joyner), Boom Logistics Limited (Kerr), Randstad Pty Ltd (Roberts), Woolworths Pty Ltd (AlChaher), Workforce Road Service Pty Limited (Metcalfe), Jeanswest Corporation Pty Ltd (Laidlaw), Airservices Australia (Balmer), Casabene Group (Claffey), Australian Government: Australian Financial Security Authority (Cummings), Seltec Pty Ltd (Pilic), Pacific HVAC Engineering Pty Ltd (Xu), H.W Greenham & Sons Pty Ltd (Boots), Flemings Nurseries Pty Ltd (Purnell).

The Fair Work Commission will hear twenty unfair dismissal/labour dispute applications today. The full list is: Canon Doors and Shower Screens Centre Pty Ltd (Major), Anglican Schools Commission (Khan), Newcastle Leagues Club (Devrell), The Trustee for Polite Enterprises International Unit Trust (Boticki), Broadspectrum (Australia) Pty Ltd (Petch), Sydney Trains (Perera), Mawland Quarantine Station Pty Ltd (Walters), Thompson Healthcare Pty Ltd (Adamopoulos), Glorious Health Australia Pty Ltd (Aneke), CDC Oakleigh Pty Ltd (Petraitis), Ulukile Pty Ltd ITF Wenckowski/Nanni Family Trust & Wenckowski (Drapac), CFC Employment Trust (Carberry), Dovaston Consulting Group Pty Ltd (Santosa), Hays Recruiting Experts in Resources and Mining (Gasser), ACCCO Pty Ltd (Duffy), Mamre Association Inc (Burke), Q Traff Pty Ltd (Apollini), 208 South Terrace Management (Boswell), G R Whittaker Nominees (Kerr), Walga Mining and Services Pty Ltd (Micheluzzi).

Thirty-seven unfair dismissal/labour dispute applications are due to be heard in the Fair Work Commission today. The full list is: TW Constructions Pty Ltd (Ellem), SBA Salmon Buckets & Attachments Pty Ltd (Jacobs), Westpac Banking Corporation (Grant), The Woodworkers Company (Ireland), Clough Projects Pty Ltd (Wardle), Belgravia Health & Leisure Group Pty Ltd (Dowling), Department of Health and Human Services (Ottrey), The Camberwell Grammar School (Dai), Kmart Australia Ltd (Cortes), Northern Territory Government (McAuley), 208 South Terrace Management (Boswell), G R Whittaker Nominees (Kerr), DBH Trust (Hibell), Walga Mining and Services Pty Ltd (Micheluzzi), Decon Technologies (SA) Pty Limited (Haines), Newcastle Leagues Club (Devrell), Anglican Schools Commission (Khan), Sydney Trains (Perera), Thompson Healthcare Pty Ltd (Adamopoulos), Mawland Quarantine Station Pty Ltd (Walters), The Trustee for Polite Enterprises International Unit Trust (Boticki), Broadspectrum (Australia) Pty Ltd (Petch), Glorious Health Australia Pty Ltd (Aneke), Canon Doors and Shower Screens Centre Pty Ltd (Major), Ulukile Pty Ltd ITF Wenckowski/Nanni Family Trust & Wenckowski (Drapac), CDC Oakleigh Pty Ltd (Petraitis), CFC Employment Trust (Carberry), Dovaston Consulting Group Pty Ltd (Santosa), Hays Recruiting Experts in Resources and Mining (Gasser), Q Traff. Pty Ltd (Apolloni), Mamre Association Inc (Burke), ACCCO Pty Ltd (Duffy), Liquorland (Qld) Pty Ltd (Schmidt), Bondall Pty Ltd (Hoger), Kormilda College Ltd (Illemann), SRSW Pty Ltd (Keighley), John Holland Pty Ltd (JHPL) (Norman).

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – incapacity – inherent requirements – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – respondent terminated applicant due to incapacity to perform his duties resulting from illness – a valid reason for dismissal has to be ‘sound, defensible or well-founded’ [Selvachandran] – Commission found it entirely defensible for respondent to rely on medical evidence from occupational physician – satisfied that respondent had valid reason for dismissal – applicant was notified in advance of dismissal and was given opportunity to respond – no unreasonable refusal for support person – regarding other matters, Commission found entitlement to salary continuance under the enterprise agreement has relevance – dismissal denied applicant benefits of salary continuance which were designed to cover long periods of absence by employees – Commission also considered differing opinion from applicant’s treating psychiatrist who had set an earlier return to work date than the physician – on balance, Commission determined that dismissal was harsh – remedy considered – Commission found reinstatement appropriate – puts applicant in same position before dismissal and allows access to salary continuance – no issue as to the applicant’s conduct – decision has no bearing on future conduct that respondent may take to dismiss applicant – respondent may revisit dismissal if applicant does not make the requisite recovery from his illness – reinstatement ordered and for continuation of service – Commission also ordered restoration of lost pay in accordance with the salary continuance clause. Papaioannou v CSL Limited