CASE PROCEDURES – apprehension of bias – s.604 Fair Work Act 2009 – appeal – Full Bench – appeal against Decision of single Member of Commission – Commission held that general dissatisfaction expressed by appellant with Member and Commission did not form basis upon which Member should recuse herself on grounds of apprehended bias – Commission found application made under s.365 FW Act was resolved and therefore refused to issue certificate – decision [[2017] FWC 4300] issued to that effect – at appeal, appellant argued that Commission erred in applying ss.365 and 368 FW Act and that Member should have recused herself – any hearing of an application for apprehended bias should be heard at earliest opportunity and before hearing of substantive matter [Parramatta Design] – Full Bench found Commission erred by determining application for recusal and substantive merits of case concurrently – test of apprehended bias requires decision-maker recuse self if a fair-minded lay observer might reasonably apprehend that the decision-maker might not bring an impartial mind to the resolution of the question [Ebner] – Full Bench found Commission consistently misstated test for apprehended bias and therefore fell into appealable error – Full Bench also found that by holding a conference and subsequently issuing a decision in relation to the substantive matter, Commission erred on jurisdictional grounds as s.368 FW Act does not empower Commission to make findings on substantive matter [Hewitt relevant] – permission to appeal granted – appeal upheld – decision of Member quashed – matter referred to Kovacic DP to determine matter. Appeal by Hunter against Decision of Hunt C of 14 September 2017 [[2017] FWC 4300] Re: Anthony Costello Automotive
November 22, 2017
MODERN AWARDS – variation – ss.160, 163 Fair Work Act 2009 – Full Bench – application by Australian Southern Bluefin Tuna (SBT) Industry Association Ltd (ASBTIAL) for variations to Ports, Harbours and Enclosed Water Vessels Award 2010 (Ports Award) – variations sought included inserting new definition of ‘Wild Catch Fishing Industry’ (WCFI), inserting new clause 4.7 to exclude coverage of employees in WCFI, and to renumber existing clauses following insertion of new clause – ASBTIAL submitted that WCFI traditionally award-free and that stages 2 and 4 of award modernisation process confirmed that award-free status of WCFI should be retained – Full Bench considered whether Ports Award covered WCFI – Full Bench determined that on its face, the coverage clause in Ports Award could encompass employers and employees in WCFI as employers in the industry operated vessels both within Australian coastline and at sea – however, Full Bench considered analysis of award history and determined that, to extent the Ports Award did purport to cover WCFI, it reflected an error that was amenable to correction under s.160 FW Act – Full Bench held that s.163 FW Act did not prevent it from varying an award to stop employees from being covered by it in circumstances where they became covered in error – Full Bench inclined to make variations sought by ASBTIAL – granted interested parties four weeks from date of decision to make any submissions in relation to this course of action. Australian Southern Bluefin Tuna (SBT) Industry Association Ltd
November 22, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.604 Fair Work Act 2009 – appeal – Full Bench – at first instance the Commission found valid reason for dismissal but due to range of ‘other matters’, found dismissal was harsh and unreasonable – ordered reinstatement without any backpay – appellant appealed on four grounds – contended that Commission incorrectly considered and applied concept of harshness; that Commission acted outside of jurisdiction; that insufficient weight to evidence given; and, that order for reinstatement was not supported – Full Bench considered Coal & Allied Mining Services and GlaxoSmithKline Australia – Full Bench satisfied in public interest to grant permission to appeal based Grounds 1.1 and 2 of Notice of Appeal, where respondent contended that Commission incorrectly considered and incorrectly applied concept of harshness – however, Full Bench found test posited by appellant for harshness was contrary to established authority – Full Bench otherwise found that other grounds of appeal did not disclose arguable case of error, and that decision at first instance did not manifest injustice nor were applied legal principles disharmonious – permission to appeal in respect of remaining grounds refused – appeal in relation to Grounds 1.1 and 2 dismissed. Appeal by Reliable Petroleum P/L against decision of Hampton C of 20 July [2017] FWC 3552 Re: Mr. Fraser Murray
November 22, 2017
REGISTERED ORGANISATIONS – cancellation of registration – s.30(1)(a) Fair Work (Registered Organisations) Act 2009 – application by Association to cancel its own registration – application signed by executive director and president – notice of application was gazetted – no objections received within time prescribed – no challenges to application – application complied with regulations 33 and 34 – cancellation to take effect from 13 November 2017. The Timber Merchants’ Association (Victoria)
November 22, 2017
CASE PROCEDURES – failure to prosecute application – ss.394, 587 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – applicant failed to attend initial conciliation – application listed for phone conference which applicant again failed to attend – application relisted, applicant advised in writing that failure to attend may result in dismissal of application – when contacted for phone conference applicant advised he could not stay on the phone – applicant reminded of content of email to which he responded ‘fair enough’ – Peter Viavattene v Health Care Australia considered – Commission dismissed application for want of prosecution under s.587 of FW Act. Hooper v ITKM Transport
November 22, 2017
RIGHT OF ENTRY – application for permit – s.512 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for Right of Entry (RoE) permit – ABCC objected to application – whether union official ‘fit and proper person’ – consideration of meaning of ‘fit and proper person’ by reference of suitability to hold an entry permit [MUA v FWC] – Commission to take into account permit qualifications matters in s.513 – official previously ordered to pay a penalty under FW Act on three occasions – CFMEU submitted that these were isolated incidents that do not indicate pattern of improper behaviour and not suggestive of future misconduct – official had RoE permit made subject to conditions on two occasions – ABCC submitted evidence of CFMEU engaging in contraventions – Commission considered that past contraventions by organisation can be relevant to consideration of permit holder’s fitness even where contraventions did not involve permit holder – ABCC submitted evidence of official being susceptible to complying with directions from employer – Commission satisfied evidence suggested some susceptibility to comply with directions of employer with history of repeated breaches – Commission found contraventions so close in time to proceedings suggested lack of genuine contrition and propensity to continue to engage in unlawful conduct – highly relevant to whether ‘fit and proper’ person – Commission not satisfied ‘fit and proper’ person’ to hold entry permit – application dismissed. Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union-Construction and General Division, WA Divisional Branch
November 22, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – amendment of application – ss.394, 586 Fair Work Act 2009 – application to amend unfair dismissal application to a general protections application – unfair dismissal application lodged on 19 September 2017 – applicant requested Commission to exercise discretion under s.586 FW Act to amend application to general protections application involving dismissal on 27 September 2017 – submitted he could only receive legal advice about submitting the wrong application after the prescribed time limit expired – respondent submitted Commission did not have the power to accede to applicant’s application and that legal advice had been obtained – Ioannou and Hambridge considered – satisfied applicant intended to make an application in relation to his allegation employment was terminated because he inquired about his pay – satisfied unfair dismissal application was a general protections application made using the wrong form – Commission granted application and amended irregularity in the form filed – application given general protections matter number. Hui v Evanita P/L t/a Paylink Business Services
November 22, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – termination at initiative of employer – resignation – ss.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – applicant claimed respondent forced her to resign – respondent raised jurisdiction objection, claiming there was no dismissal as applicant voluntarily resigned – Mohazab and Elgammal considered – respondent’s conduct, viewed objectively, did not show an intention to no longer be bound by the contract – respondent held applicant in regard as an employee and never intended for applicant to resign – applicant not dismissed – applicant voluntarily resigned – application dismissed. Hill v Pathways Australia P/L t/a Pathways Australia