NEWS HR

CASE PROCEDURES – review of external decision – r.58 Fair Work Commission Rules 2013 – sch.3 Offshore Petroleum and Greenhouse Gas Storage Act 2006 – application for review of decision of Inspector of NOPSEMA to issue prohibition notice (PN 614) – Technip operates the Wellservicer facility (a diving support vessel) – carries out saturation diving activities – in the event of an emergency on the Wellservicer that requires hyperbaric evacuation, once divers are safely secured in the Self Propelled Hyperbaric Life Boat (SPHL) stored on board the Wellservicer, the SPHL is launched and joined by a Hyperbaric Support Rescue Vessel (HSRV) that is located within two hours of diving operations at all times – NOPSEMA Inspector satisfied on reasonable grounds that an activity may occur at the facility that, if it occurred, would involve an immediate threat to the health or safety of a person – saturation diving without hyperbaric boat rescue capability at location for a period of 48 hours – application to Commission made on grounds of legal error and whether reasonable grounds for satisfaction – whether prohibition notice reasonably necessary – requirement that satisfaction be based on reasonable grounds requires an objective assessment of all relevant circumstances – Commission found that PN 614 was not based on satisfaction on reasonable grounds, that the separation of the Wellservicer and HSRV for 48 hours would involve an immediate threat to the health or safety of a person – issue of prohibition notice not based on satisfaction on reasonable grounds that it was reasonably necessary to issue the notice in order to remove the threat – appeal allowed – prohibition notice revoked. Technip Oceania P/L v National Offshore Petroleum Safety and Environmental Management Authority t/a NOPSEMA

CASE PROCEDURES – evidence – production of documents – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – on 17 April 2015 applicant filed a notice of appeal against a decision issued by Commissioner Bissett [[2015] FWC 2563] – appeal concerned the decision to deny the applicant access to a report prepared by DGHR Services and several associated documents (together referred to as the Documents) on the basis that the Documents were not relevant to his unfair dismissal application – respondent objected to the release of the Documents claiming legal professional privilege (privilege) – appeal heard by a Full Bench on 17 June 2015 – Full Bench granted applicant permission to appeal insofar as his appeal concerned the Documents, upheld his appeal regarding the Documents, quashed the relevant aspects of the Commissioner’s decision and remitted the respondent’s claim of privilege in relation to the Documents to the Commission for determination [[2015] FWCFB 3995] – Commission determined that the Documents, other than the copy of the Federal Court of Australia’s ‘Practice Note CM7 – Expert Witnesses in Proceedings in the Federal Court of Australia’ attached to the email of 5 June 2014 and the documents dated 27 and 28 February 2015 both of which were considered to fall outside the scope of the Order to produce issued by the Commission on 11 March 2015, were protected by privilege and that privilege has not been waived in respect of the remaining documents – Practice Note CM7 can be inspected by the applicant or his representative upon application. Kirkman v DP World Melbourne Limited

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – extension of time – ss.394, 400, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – appeal against decision at first instance dismissing application for extension of time – the application was filed two days out of time – applicant was aware her application required to be lodged within 21 days – applicant informed United Voice 17 days after dismissal – union did not act until two days beyond time limit – case was transferred from one union official to another – public interest test discretionary involving broad value judgement [GlaxoSmithKline] – error not a sufficient basis to grant permission – Full Bench found there was a 17 day period where applicant did nothing to pursue her unfair dismissal application – the circumstances from the time of the dismissal must be considered in order to determine whether there is a reason for the delay beyond the 21 day period [Shaw] – representative error did not provide an inviolable reason amounting to exceptional circumstances – Full Bench concluded an arguable case of appealable error had not been made out – permission to appeal refused. Appeal by Diotti against decision and order of O’Callaghan SDP of 10 November 2015 [[2015] FWC 7659] and [PR573703] Re: Lenswood Cold Stores Co-op Society t/a Lenswood Organic

INDUSTRIAL ACTION – order against industrial action – s.418 Fair Work Act 2009 – application to stop industrial action – question whether proposed industrial action is protected action – definition of term ‘relief lessons’ clear in enterprise agreement and accords with ordinary meaning – notice requirements of s.414 of FW Act met – proposal to stop work for 30 minutes not in excess of industrial action proposed by protected ballot – unable to find action is unprotected – application dismissed. Catholic Church Endowment Society Inc t/a Catholic Education Office v Independent Education Union (South Australia) Incorporated

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – genuine redundancy – ss.389, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – applicant employed for 23 years – respondent restructured its Academic division in 2014 – no longer required applicant’s job to be performed by anyone because of changes in the operational requirements – applicant declared a ‘detached’ employee – whether it would have been reasonable in all the circumstances for applicant to be redeployed – Ulan Coal considered – Commission satisfied that respondent considered redeployment for the applicant, wherever possible, to avert or minimise potential redundancy – satisfied that applicant did not have the skills and experience necessary to perform alternative roles either immediately or within a reasonable period of retraining – satisfied that it would not have been reasonable in all the circumstances for applicant to be redeployed within the respondent’s enterprise – found dismissal was a case of genuine redundancy – applicant was not unfairly dismissed – application dismissed. Kitanovski v University of Newcastle

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – extension of time – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal lodged five days late – applicant made redundant – applicant attempted to lodge her application with the Fair Work Ombudsman (FWO) within the 21 day period – FWO referred applicant to Commission – applicant incorrectly addressed envelope to Commission which required the person in receipt of the letter to readdress the letter – applicant used the mail service as she does not have a computer – Commission considered meaning of exceptional circumstances [Nulty] – circumstances must be out of the ordinary course or unusual – Johnson v Joy Manufacturing considered – Commission found bona fide attempt to make real time application – acceptable reason for delay – applicant took action to dispute her dismissal within days of her dismissal with the FWO – extension of time granted. McAllister v Smartcaller P/L t/a Smart Caller

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief of unfair dismissal – applicant employed as a full-time pick-up delivery driver – dismissed after an investigation determined that he engaged in theft of a box containing a laptop at Townsville depot – a complaint was made by email regarding some missing freight – complaint reported other freight that had gone missing over time – respondent conducted investigation – viewed CCTV footage – footage unable to identify who box was stolen by – applicant not shown CCTV footage despite asking – respondent organised meeting to discuss alleged misconduct – applicant did not attend meeting, provided medical certificate that morning – respondent terminated the applicant – for reason to be a valid reason within meaning of s.387(a) of the FW Act it must be sound and defensible or well founded [Selvachandran] – respondent not able to discharge the onus upon it to satisfy the Commission on the balance of probability that the applicant engaged in the alleged conduct – Commission found it would have been appropriate for the applicant to see and respond to the CCTV footage – satisfied the dismissal was unjust and unreasonable – applicant did not seek reinstatement – order for payment of compensation – applicant took reasonable steps to mitigate his loss including applying for jobs and achieving new causal employment – Commission ordered compensation of $25,468.13. Mulhall v Direct Freight (Qld) P/L t/a Direct Freight Express

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – performance – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant dismissed for poor performance – following a restructure of the respondent’s enterprise, the applicant’s position as Senior Property Officer was made redundant – applicant was offered the position of Property Specialist, at the sane rate of pay and on the same terms and conditions – applicant accepted position and did not suggest any alternative positions – new role substantially the same as the previous role – following the hiring of a new team leader, Property Specialist position description amended to include ‘commercial and financial analysis’ – following this amendment applicant’s performance suffered – applicant subsequently terminated for poor performance – Commission found valid reason for dismissal – while respondent entitled to restructure business and to amend position descriptions, respondent obliged to ensure adequate training or existing staff members affected by amendment – training provided by respondent insufficient to equip applicant for new requirements of position – Commission satisfied applicant unfairly dismissed – matter to be relisted on issue of remedy. Vernon v Electricity Networks Corporation t/a Western Power.