NEWS HR

Termination of employment – security for costs – ss.394, 404A Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – respondent made application for security for payment of costs – dispute whether applicant resigned employment – respondent submitted matter brought vexatiously by applicant without reasonable prospect of success – respondent further contended applicant failed to provide adequate written materials prior to hearing – Commission held exercise of discretion to order security for costs limited to exceptional circumstances provided in Zordana and Home Theatre Group – existence of possible resignation not sufficient to conclude whether dismissal occurred – unable to conclude matter brought vexatiously or that application has no reasonable prospect of success – contrary to s.381 of FW Act to draw conclusions from inadequacy of written materials provided by applicant – order for security of costs would discourage applicant from pursuing application for unfair dismissal – no other extraordinary circumstances present – application for security for costs dismissed. Cole v PQ Australia P/L t/a PQ Australia.

Enterprise agreements – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – respondent a manufacturer of bread and baked goods – respondent ceased paying a shift loading to employees on the rolls, crumpets and muffins lines (RCM lines) – applicant submitted respondent required to pay shift loading to employees on RCM lines – Goodman Fielder Baking (Western Australia) Enterprise Agreement 2014-2017 provides shift loading to those on a ”rotating shift’ – ‘rotating shift’ not defined by agreement – applicant submitted that a plain construction of the agreement, the employees on RCM lines were on rotating shifts as their start times varied from day to day – respondent submitted that employees were not on a rotating shift, as ‘rotating shift’ means there is a succession of shifts with sequential start times, such as dayshift, afternoon shift and nightshift – Commission satisfied employees on RCM lines not entitled to shift loading – application dismissed. United Voice v Quality Bakers Australia P/L t/a Goodman Fielder Fresh Baking.

Termination of employment – remedy – compensation – ss.392, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – previous decision found applicant dismissed unfairly – reinstatement not appropriate – Tabro Meat approach to calculation of compensation followed – applicant employed eight years – aside from one written warning, no performance issues – reasonable to assume applicant would have remained employed for one year – applicant unemployed 11 weeks following dismissal – earnings deducted from compensation amount – $12,982 ordered. Styles v TNT Express.

Termination of employment – remedy – compensation – ss.392, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – Commission found applicant forced to resign – reasons set out in November decision [[2015] FWC 6519] – Commission concluded that an amount of $9,915.15 gross was appropriate but provided an opportunity for the respondent to provide any submissions on the effect of the order on the viability of the respondent’s enterprise or to seek payment of the compensation by instalment – evidence provided by applicant indicated that his earnings from roofing work were significantly in excess of his previous estimate – found appropriate compensation was $5,966.28. Hocking v Tackle World Adelaide Metro.

Termination of employment – termination at initiative of employer – abandonment of employment – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant submitted an application for six weeks leave – respondent rejected the annual leave application because of lack of notice – applicant proceeded on annual leave – respondent wrote to applicant advising he had abandoned his employment – Commission found dismissal not harsh, unjust or unreasonable – applicant should have understood how this family company operated and that his role could not be backfilled whilst he was on leave. Chowdhury v LEDA Aluminium P/L.

Termination of employment – termination at initiative of employer – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief for unfair dismissal – following disagreement with principal, applicant decided to stand down from position and sent principal an email to that effect – applicant submitted that he was then offered an alternative position, which he accepted – applicant submitted that respondent subsequently withdrew offer of alternative position and advised him the alternative position would no longer be filled – applicant gave evidence that alternative position continued to be advertised – respondent submitted that they chose not to fill the alternative position and that it was never offed to the applicant – Commission satisfied that applicant was offered, and accepted, alternative position, and that it was from this alternative position that the applicant was dismissed – no valid reason for termination existed – Commission satisfied applicant unfairly dismissed – compensation of $11,360.37, plus $1,079.24 superannuation ordered. Turner v Peter Stevens Motorcycle Retail Group P/L.

Conditions of employment – redundancy – s.120 Fair Work Act 2009 – application to reduce redundancy pay – transport and distribution services industry – loss of contract – option of remaining employed by the employer or working for new employer – no resignation of employees – no transfer of entitlements – whether redundancy at the initiative of the employer – whether employer ‘obtained acceptable employment’ – meaning of ‘obtained acceptable employment’ – terms of enterprise agreement – interaction of enterprise agreement with National Employment Standards (NES) – no termination of employment – employees and their roles not made redundant – s.120 of FW Act cannot apply – no jurisdiction – application dismissed – alternatively, whether employer ‘obtained acceptable employment’ – same work, rate of pay, location and conditions – whether employer ‘strong and moving force’ – negotiations to achieve wage parity – representations to engage all employees – employer obtained acceptable employment – employees’ choice to accept new employment or remain employed – no pressure or coercion – all employees accepted new employment – redundancy pay would be reduced to nil. DRW Investments P/L t/a Wettenhalls v Richards and Ors.

Case procedures – costs – ss.400A, 611 Fair Work Act 2009 – Full Bench – application for costs by GM Holden against Mr Newbond in relation to appeal application and extension of time to lodge appeal – application to extend time dismissed – unreasonable to continue with extension of time application when aware that reasons for delay not compelling and could have been resolved via alternative settlement proposals from employer – jurisdiction established but whether costs order should be made – applications without sound basis consume time, resources and costs of parties – repeated and unreasonable failure to comply with directions – repeated failures should not be excused – continuation of application was unreasonable act – order to pay reasonable costs – parties to confer on the quantum of the costs incurred. Newbond v GM Holden Ltd.