ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – approval – notice of representational rights – ss.173, 174, 181, 185, 186 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for approval of enterprise agreement – concerns regarding pre-approval process in particular notice of employee representational rights and information provided on notice – notice referred to Fair Work Australia website instead of Fair Work Ombudsman as required by sch.2.1 of Fair Work Regulations 2009 – Parliament was clear that Fair Work Ombudsman website was to be referred to in notice – notice must be in form prescribed by the Regulations [Peabody] – Commission found valid notice not given and was not satisfied that agreement was genuinely agreed – application dismissed. Seymour College Inc Enterprise Agreement 2015
February 12, 2016
Lend Lease Services Pty Ltd is in the naughty corner today with seven accusations of unfair dismissal lined up for challenge. The full list in the Fair Work Commission includes: Hickey Food Service (Brown); Werrigar Pty Ltd (Crisp); David Moss Corporation Limited (Lee Anthony); Bam Clough Contracting Pty Ltd (Taylor); Gliderol Garge Doors (Simatovic); Work Placement Pty Ltd (Gadan); Durri Aboriginal Corporation Medical Service (Blanch); ASG Group Limited (Stevens); Tocojepa Pty Ltd (Hardwick); Sunny Sign Company Pty Ltd (Court); Australia Western Railroad Pty Ltd (Lloyd); Melbourne Pathology (Matthiesson); Sundance Racking Pty Ltd (Knop); The Hutchins School (Anders); Transpacific Industries Pty Ltd (Maguire); Dairy Country (Barkho); Milgate Primary School (Heading); Filipino Community Council of Victoria Incorporated (Serrano); KDR Victoria Pty Ltd (Smith); Donlyn Courier Services Pty Ltd (Thurston); RBH Building Group Pty Ltd (Medforth); The Hutchins School (Anders); Presbyterian Care Tasmania Inc (Esam); Miwatj Employment and Participation Ltd (Manns); ACT Government as represented by the Health Directorate (Burdack); Suncorp Group (Donman); Active Hearing Pty Ltd (Birch); Arrium Pty Ltd (Johnston); and Lend Lease Services Pty Limited (Arnold/Dale/Hoyle/Hutchins/Potts/Vaughan/Watt)
February 11, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – minimum employment period – ss.394, 400, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – at first instance Commission found appellant had not served minimum employment period – appellant sought permission to appeal – whether grounds of appeal attract the public interest, where the test is a ‘stringent one’ [Coal and Allied] – GlaxoSmithKline applied – Full Bench held period of employment is calculated from the commencement of employment to the time when notice of dismissal is given or immediately before the dismissal, whichever is the earlier – appellant employed 2 February 2015 – appellant notified of dismissal 31 July 2015 – Acts Interpretation Act 1901 considered – Full Bench held ‘6 months’ in s.383(a) of FW Act means 6 calendar months – held period commencing at the beginning of 2 February 2015 and ending immediately before the beginning of the corresponding day of the following sixth month, being midnight 1 August 2015 – grounds of appeal did not identify any error of law or mistake in fact at first instance – permission to appeal refused. Senaratne v King & Wood Mallesons
February 11, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – contractor or employee – ss.394, 400, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – appeal – Full Bench – appeal against decision at first instance that respondent was an employee – Full Bench found Commissioner properly considered the nature of the relationship at the relevant time and made findings which led to conclusion there was jurisdiction to deal with the matter – not satisfied decision involved any error of principle – not persuaded appeal gave rise to public interest considerations – permission to appeal refused. Appeal by JG King Homes against decision and order of Wilson C of 18 September 2015 [[2015] FWC 6352] Re: Tyler
February 11, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – ss.394, 400, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – appeal against decision at first instance that appellant’s dismissal was not unfair – appellant sought permission to appeal – contended that Commissioner failed to properly consider s.387(h) of the FW Act and failed to consider number of relevant factors in relation to whether dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable – test whether in ‘public interest’ to grant permission is ‘a stringent one’ and ‘involves a broad value judgment’ [Coal & Allied] – rarely appropriate to grant permission to appeal unless an arguable case of appealable error is demonstrated, an appeal cannot succeed in the absence of appealable error [Wan] – Full Bench found appellant had not demonstrated any error in the decision or any basis of public interest – Commissioner’s conclusion was not unreasonable or plainly unjust – found no error in approach of Commissioner – Full Bench held that the findings were made on the evidence and that no other factors considered suggested that the appellant’s dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable – factors raised by appellant did not require additional consideration – permission to appeal refused. Appeal by Walpola against decision and order of Roe C of 2 November 2015 [[2015] FWC 7554] and [PR573563] Re: Transdev Melbourne P/L t/a Transdev Melbourne
February 11, 2016
RIGHT OF ENTRY – application for permit – s.512 Fair Work Act 2009 – application by CFMEU for right of entry permit for Mr Merkx – application opposed by Director of Fair Work Building Industry Inspectorate – dispute whether Mr Merks received appropriate training regarding right of entry requirements – Mr Merkx previously engaged in unlawful industrial action in DFWBII v Merkx – Mr Merkx currently one named respondent in application filed in Federal Court regarding breaches of ss.348 and 355 of FW Act – whether Mr Merkx a fit and proper person to hold entry permit – Commission satisfied ACTU online training course to be an appropriate training provided to Mr Merkx [CEPU] – Mr Merkx did not fully comprehend he was contravening FW Act when he participated in unlawful industrial action – unable to conclude Mr Merkx not fit and proper person due to low penalty imposed in DFWBII v Merkx – application in Federal Court cannot be given any weight in consideration of CFMEU’s application – application contains allegations only – Commission satisfied Mr Merx a fit and proper person to hold an entry permit – application granted. Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union
February 11, 2016
CASE PROCEDURES – stay order – s.604 Fair Work Act 2009 – s.235 Fair Work (Registered Organisations) Act 2009 – appeal -CFMEU lodged appeal against decision of General Manager for Fair Work Building Construction to inspect membership records – under s.235(1) of Registered Organisations Act the General Manager can grant access to records – CFMEU applied for decision to be stayed pending the appeal – Commission satisfied CFMEU’s case was arguable with reasonable prospects of success – balance of convenience favoured grant of stay – Commission granted stay application subject to there being an expedited hearing of the appeal. Appeal by Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union against decision of General Manager of 15 January 2016
February 11, 2016
INDUSTRIAL ACTION – suspension of protected industrial action – cooling off – ss.413, 425 Fair Work Act 2009 – application by Patrick Stevedores to suspend protected industrial action by employee members of MUA – MUA submitted only current industrial action relevant in considering appropriateness of suspension and planned 24 hour stoppages not relevant – Commission accepted that operation of s.425 of FW Act premised on industrial action that is being engaged in, as distinct from threatened, impending or probable – whether being engaged in a question of fact – industrial action in the form of bans had occurred and further bans occurring – stoppages imminent at date of hearing – Commission satisfied bans in place provided the jurisdictional trigger for exercise of Commission’s powers – held s.425 needed to be construed in context of FW Act, in particular the effect of s.413(7) that no protected industrial action can occur if suspension order in operation – appropriateness of suspension under s.425 should be considered in light of the full consequences of suspension – interpreting clause more narrowly an artificial approach ignoring practical realities – appropriate to have regard to industrial action happening and impending when assessing appropriateness of suspension – concept of an order being limited to specific action and impliedly permitting other future protected action inconsistent with scheme of FW Act – Commission noted Booth DP’s involvement in facilitating discussions regarded as useful by parties – noted industrial action appeared to have escalated rapidly while Booth DP on leave – considered compromise on some issues likely – involvement of Commission likely to be of assistance – Commission had regard to the nature of the industry and the importance of Patrick to important aspect of economy – disruption of services to third parties, combined with other circumstances a relevant contextual consideration to the question of benefit to the parties in resolving matters in dispute – satisfied suspension of protection industrial action would assist bargaining representatives in resolving matters in dispute – considered suspension positively consistent with public interest and object of FW Act – Commission satisfied suspension appropriate – suspension for 35 days would enable detailed consideration before Booth DP and not deprive parties of their options for the future. Patrick Stevedores Holdings P/L v The Maritime Union of Australia