NEWS HR

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – performance – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant employed full-time as account manager – meeting which led to dismissal arose from email sent by applicant to client which respondent considered inappropriate – termination letter prepared and signed prior to meeting – applicant dismissed ‘due to unsatisfactory work performance’ – performance issues raised included failure to meet monthly targets, failure to arrange sufficient appointments to seek new business, and poor handling of one client – Commission satisfied that inappropriate email combined with poor performance in respect to sales budget and appointments constituted valid reason for termination – procedure utilised particularly unjust and unreasonable and dismissal was a harsh or disproportionate response to performance and conduct matters involved – dismissal harsh, unjust and unreasonable – reinstatement inappropriate – ordered compensation of $8,400, taxed accordingly. Makai v Victorian Radio Network P/L

GENERAL PROTECTIONS – extension of time – ss.365, 366 Fair Work Act 2009 – application to deal with contraventions involving dismissal – respondent raised jurisdiction objection that application nine days out of time – date of dismissal in dispute – respondent submitted applicant resigned on 19 January 2015 – applicant submitted dismissed on 10 February 2015 – Commission considered that while text messages sent by applicant on 19 January 2015 suggested resignation on that day, respondent’s actions after 19 January 2015 appeared to implicitly acknowledge that resignation not definite – found applicant dismissed on 10 February 2015 – application lodged within time – jurisdictional objection dismissed – application to be listed for conference. Ludgate v West Australian Rifle Association Inc.

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – minimum employment period – ss.383, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – respondent objected on basis that applicant did not meet minimum employment period – applicant employed from 26 February 2015 to 19 October 2015 – casual employment – respondent’s main contention that work prior to 25 April 2015 was not on regular and systematic basis – after considering the evidence the Commission concluded that applicant did have a reasonable expectation of continuing employment on a regular and systematic basis prior to 25 April 2015 – found period of employment was greater than six months – minimum employment period completed – matter referred for further allocation. Findley v Diamond Protection P/L t/a Diamond Protection.

Thirty-one ex-employees will parade before various Fair Work Commissioners pleading an ‘industrial foul’. The brutal reality is that 26 will cock up and waste their day. The full list today is: CUB Pty Ltd (Sayers/Aitken); Builders Choice Insulation (Woodhall); Arthur J Gallagher Australia & Co (Hazledine); St Vincent’s Hospital Melbourne (Steele); Peter MacCallum Cancer Centre (Sutton); Leighton Contracting (Tiernan); Roads Corporation (Forbes); Decon Communication and Power Solutions (Soso); Redline Plumbing Pty Ltd (Lamb); S & R Wyndham Pty Ltd (Houlshan); Mater Misericordiae Health Services Brisbane Limited (Kuether); Supercheap Auto (Williams); Prouds Jewellers Pty Ltd (King); Legrand Australia (Sheehan); RACQ Operations Pty Ltd & Buric and Another (James-Guy); MMA Vessel Operations Pty Ltd (Milovale Masoe); Pactum Australia Pty Ltd (Tamati); Medalist [Test-Rite] (Kazmar); Byng Street Pty Ltd (Aniscenko); Arthur J Gallagher Australia & Co (Hazledine); Tony and Guy Leichhardt (Farshadi); Golden Swan Investments [Australia] Pty Limited (Angius); BHP Coal Pty Ltd (Schmidt); Parmalat Food Products Pty Ltd (Tran); Quality Bakers Australia Pty Limited (Rozyn); South Coast Equipment Pty Limited (Harding/Boulding); Aminjarrinja Enterprises Pty Ltd (Paterson); Geelong Harley-Davidson (Wall); PJ & P Eldred (Peters); and Compass Group (Wright).

Woolworths’ relationship with a trio of staff members is ‘not so fresh’. The ramifications of stripping off three lettuce layers will be tested today in the Fair Work Commission. The full attendance list includes: St George Aged Care Centre (Taungakava, Perera and others), Hymix Australia Pty Ltd (Canny), Solibrooke Pty Ltd (Vosper), The Herald and Weekly Times Pty Ltd (Dar), Tyco Fire & Security (Byrne), BHP Billiton Iron Ore Pty Ltd (McGinnis), Murdoch University Child Care Centre (Abdul Rahim), Pino Nominees Pty Ltd (Barton), Prestige Paving Pty Ltd (Basse), Calvary Health Care Tasmania Limited (Beamish), Kids Choice ELS WA Pty Ltd (Rolfe), Foster Pharmacy Pty Ltd (Wakeling), Epworth Foundation (Selcuk), Marist Brothers St Joseph’s College (Burke), Hollingsworth & Australian Sports Commission (Hanson), Clyde & Co (King), ISG Technology Pty Limited (Duryea), Dingo Australia (Gooderham), Pacific National Queensland Coal Pty Ltd (Feodoroff), Western Auger Drilling Pty Ltd (Kimber), Quality Bakers Australia Pty Limited (Signall), Woolworths Limited (Taito/Young/Bonham), Immersive Technologies (Farmer), Fast Cut Qld Pty Ltd (Smith), McLean Farms Staff Pty Ltd (Boyce), SAI Global Limited (Moushall), Mary MacKillop Care SA Ltd (Handley), Target Australia Pty Ltd (Sneddon) and Locale Revegetation Services (Farrell).

AB Contract Packing Pty Ltd is being challenged by four ex-staff members (Del Balso, Deville, Khroud and Migale) who have all mounted s.365 (unfair claims) in the Fair Work Commission this morning. The full list includes: Good Start Early Learning (Dann), Lost Dogs Home (Jessup), Retic Water Pty Ltd (Peterson), Manpower (Chidiac), Woolworths (Chidiac), Menzies Aviation (Ground Services) Pty Ltd (Blake), Mechanical Plumbing Services (Salman), Karingal Inc (Carroll), Traffic Diversions Group (Jaeger), ADSE Pty Ltd (Karaklic), Metal Manufactures Limited (Cicciari), SES Labour Solutions Pty Ltd & Anglo Coal (Dawson Services) Pty Ltd (Martin), Queensland Engineering Services (Murphy), Thiess Pty Limited (Garratt), Stramit Corporation Pty Limited (Hanley), The Pool Maintenance Man (Munro), Eve O & G (Cox), Members Equity Bank Limited (Meehan), Department of Education & Training, North-Eastern Victoria Region (Somasundaram), Compass Group Australia Pty Ltd (Newman), Grandviews Bowling & Recreation Club (Robinson), TNT Australia Pty Ltd (Campbell), PPG Industries Australia Pty Ltd (Dang), Bar’s Leaks (Australia) Pty Ltd (Lay), Sibelco Australia Limited (Medlicott), Redimed Pty Ltd (Chan), Retic Water Pty Ltd (Peterson), AB Contract Packing Pty Ltd (Del Balso/Deville/Khroud/Migale), Volgren Australia Pty Ltd (Khroud) and Melbourne Pathology (Matthiesson).

Two entities face multiple unfair dismissal claims including Victoria Police. A full list of today’s Fair Work Commission cases includes the following applicants and respondents: Eve O & G (Cox), The University of Newcastle (Wilks), Stramit Corporation Pty Limited (Hanley), Visy Packaging Pty Ltd (Higgins), Mogo Zoo Pty Ltd (Ryman), Tritton Resources Limited (Yeomans), Australian Islamic College of Sydney (Gleeson), Commonwealth of Australia as represented by the Australian Federal Police (Read), Mid-West Mining Pty Ltd (Simpson), AGL Loy Yang Pty Ltd (Wright), O’Toole Electrical (Morris), Skyways Hotel/ALH Group (Ranjit), Shearform Pty Ltd (Sutton), Farstad Shipping (Indian Pacific) Pty Ltd (Fry), Catholic Education Office Melbourne (Fisher), Konute Enterprises (Lama), Victoria Police (Matthews/Raso), The GEO Group Pty Ltd (Flaws), UnitingCare Community (Collins), Barbera Fresh Pty Ltd (Hannay/Sheppard), Auto and General Holdings Pty Ltd (Savva), Pacific National Queensland Coal Pty Ltd (Feodoroff), Stramit Corporation Pty Limited (Hanley), Gilbarco Aus Pty Ltd (Singh), Errol Matschoss Motors Pty Ltd (Conroy), Kellyvale No 87 Trust & The Lamb Spit Trading (Millar) and Telstra Corporation Limited (Smale).

Enterprise bargaining – protected action ballot – s.437 Fair Work Act 2009 – application made by union on behalf of employees – parties met approximately 10 times in effort to negotiate – employer does not consent to application and did not wish to make submissions – application determined on papers – satisfied statutory requirements been met and parties genuinely tried to reach agreement – concerned with a number of questions in ballot – whether action falls within meaning and scope of industrial action – Ambulance Victoria applied – action may or may not fall within scope of industrial action – matter for later consideration – order issued. Automotive, Food, Metals, Engineering, Printing and Kindred Industries Union known as the Australian Manufacturing Workers’ Union (AMWU) v Hydro-Electric Corporation t/a Entura.