NEWS HR

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – termination at initiative of employer – constructive dismissal – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant employed as Business Manager at respondent’s Newstead dealership – respondent objected on basis applicant repudiated his contract of employment – applicant ceased to present for work or respond to any communications from respondent after 19 November 2015, following meeting with applicant regarding performance and conduct related processes – at the meeting respondent proposed a new contract of employment as a performance management tool that essentially sought to change the location of applicant’s employment and change of title from Business Manager to Relief Business Manager – applicant concerned new contract might result in his remuneration being reduced by an amount between 50% and up to 90% – applicant asserted that if he did not sign the new contract he would lose his job – contended that in offering new contract respondent had terminated his employment – Commission found applicant’s employment came to an end at the initiative of the respondent – no valid reason for dismissal – held dismissal was harsh, unjust and unreasonable – reinstatement not appropriate – ordered compensation of $50,119.80 gross, subject to applicable taxation. Dore v Motorcycle Holdings TCO P/L atf The Motorcycle Holdings Group Unit Trust t/a Morgan & Wacker Harley Davidson

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – on day prior to dismissal applicant left work without attending ‘huddle’ meeting – applicant claimed was feeling unwell and did not hear manager articulate direction as he left premises – applicant claimed had already clocked off at time of huddle – applicant dismissed following meeting held the next day between applicant, Manager and General Manager – employer claimed applicant’s conduct constituted gross misconduct for failing to follow lawful instrument from Manager – Commission found photographic material led by employer demonstrated applicant had not clocked off at time of huddle but had clocked off at time manager communicated intention to convene huddle – applicant conceded in cross examination aware of huddle and requirement to attend – one instance where applicant subject to written warning previously – no other warnings or disciplinary action – Commission found employer might reasonably have reservations about applicant’s conduct in this instance but conduct when considered in full circumstantial matrix not valid reason for dismissal – applicant not provided satisfactory notice that he faced dismissal for conduct – not extended opportunity to have support person present at meeting – Commission held dismissal harsh and unreasonable – employer ordered to pay $8,541.28 compensation. De Sola v ECB P/L t/a East Coast Bullbars

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – termination at initiative of employer – constructive dismissal – ss.386, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant employed as a salesman – resigned from his employment but said that he was forced to do so – respondent had concerns about the applicant’s sales figures and established a new remuneration structure for the applicant – applicant unhappy with new remuneration structure – believed that respondent had sabotaged him by reducing stock levels so that he could not meet his sales targets –Mohazab and AABB Engineering considered – Commission found applicant’s poor sales results were not attributable to any stock level issues – new remuneration structure designed to encourage applicant to achieve better sales – applicant would not have suffered any financial loss as long as he maintained his average sales for the previous two years – respondent’s conduct not intended to, nor would have had the probable result of, bringing the employment relationship to an end – found that the applicant resigned from his employment and was therefore not dismissed – application dismissed. Ampuero v H+Co Menswear t/a H’s Menswear

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant dismissed by text message following verbal altercation over telephone with respondent about unpaid overtime – no issue previously raised about applicant’s work performance – respondent failed to file response, participate in conciliation or file further materials – respondent failed to engage with Commission – respondent represented by employee not employed at time applicant dismissed – respondent business in voluntary administration – application not stayed by Corporations Act – applicant behaved in rude and disrespectful manner towards respondent – Commission found valid reason for dismissal – text message not appropriate mechanism for dismissal – no evidence applicant was substandard employee – applicant not given opportunity to respond – found dismissal procedurally unfair – ordered $828 compensation less tax. Hain v Ace Recycling P/L

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – dispute under Electrix Ply Ltd & ETU Powerline Enterprise Agreement 2013-2016 – dispute concerned interpretation of clause 45.1 of agreement which deals with wage rates – applicant contended respondent incorrectly paid employees back pay based on classification levels under predecessor agreement as opposed to their classification levels under agreement – respondent argued had it included the reclassification based wage increases in back pay calculation it would have been double paying employees who had undertaken leading hand and high-voltage operating duties – Commission considered plain meaning of relevant clauses – no ambiguity arose – no regard to subjective intention – Commission determined employees are entitled to back pay calculated with reference to the wages employees would have received under agreement inclusive of any increases flowing from the reclassification of employees. Communications, Electrical, Electronic, Energy, Information, Postal, Plumbing and Allied Services Union of Australia v Electrix P/L

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – applicant commenced casual employment with the respondent on 1 October 2014 – received third and final written warning on 8 July 2015 – all warnings based on customer complaints – after receiving the final warning applicant made a number of serious allegations against the respondent on 11 July 2015 and 12 July 2015 – respondent began to conduct an investigation – while investigations were ongoing applicant sent threatening emails to the respondent and ignored lawful instructions to cease sending these emails – applicant also uncooperative and confrontational during a meeting necessary to the investigations on 16 July 2015 – respondent submitted dismissal based on a failure to follow lawful instruction and allow the investigations to take their course – applicant submitted the three warnings he received were bogus and he was dismissed for making allegations against the respondent – Commission satisfied there was a valid reason for dismissal – held three warnings based on customer complaints – found that respondent’s instruction to cease sending threatening emails was reasonable – application dismissed. Whitham v Apple Marketing t/a Apple Marketing Group

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – amendment of application – unlawful termination – ss.365, 773 Fair Work Act 2009 – r.6, 8 Fair Work Commission Rules 2013 – application to deal with an unlawful termination dispute under s.773 FW Act – as respondent a constitutionally covered entity, applicant sought to amend application to one under s.365 of FW Act – applicant submitted did not initially file under s.365 because did not receive legal advice and thought was using correct form – general requirement under Rule 8(2) of FWC Rules to lodge application using correct approved form – Commission has broad discretion under Rule 6 to dispense with Rules – Commission held applicant attempted to promptly challenge dismissal and was within 21 day timeframe albeit lodging incorrect form – amendment sought at early stage – would not fundamentally alter nature of application – sufficient justification under Rule 6 to dispense with general requirement to comply with Rule 8(2) – Rule 6 invoked – Commission satisfied appropriate to amend application to application under s.365 of FW Act – order reflecting amendment issued. O’Keeffe v Sucasas P/L t/a Tapavino

ENTERPRISE BARGAINING – protected action ballot – extension of notice period – s.437 Fair Work Act 2009 – application by Maritime Union of Australia (MUA) for protected action ballot order concerning employees of MMA Offshore Vessel Operations P/L (MMA) – application opposed by MMA – MMA submitted application not validly made as there was no notification period under s.437(2A) FW Act – MMA submitted notification period related to bargaining for enterprise agreements different in scope to current application – Maersk considered – Commission satisfied scope of proposed MUA agreement a subset of MMA’s proposed scope – MMA submitted that MUA contravened interim orders of Cloghan C and was therefore unable to take protected industrial action in support of proposed agreement – Commission not satisfied matter has a bearing on validity of application – MMA submitted Commission could not be satisfied MUA had genuinely tried to reach agreement – Commission acknowledged negotiations long and tortuous but in all circumstances Commission satisfied MUA genuinely trying to reach agreement – MMA submitted that, if Commission were to grant application, notice period should be extended – witness evidence led – witness not cross-examined – Commission satisfied exceptional circumstances justify longer notice period – objections of MMA as to making of order rejected – notice period extended to seven calendar days – protected action ballot order made. Maritime Union of Australia, The v MMA Offshore Vessel Operations P/L