NEWS HR

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – genuine redundancy – ss.389, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – two applications for unfair dismissal remedy – parties agreed to join the applications for the purposes of the conciliation and hearing – respondent raised jurisdictional objections to applications on basis of genuine redundancy – respondent provided BlueScope Steel with load and haul services at Port Kembla – BlueScope Steel sought price reductions from respondent as well as embarking on number of trails with modified manning structures across variety of shifts – in November 2015 BlueScope Steel advised respondent to immediately implement 12 hour day shift structure – respondent met with employees 3 December 2015 and then issued communication that it had made a decision to make 12 positions redundant – communication indicated that selection criteria would be developed and employees would be assessed by a number of supervisors – evidence led indicated that management embarked on the selection process between 30 November 2015 and 7 December 2016 – redundancy requirements of the South Coast Equipment P/L Plant Operator CFMEU Enterprise Agreement 2013 (clause 27.3(c)) considered – respondent acknowledged that did not consult the Union regarding selection criteria to be utilised – respondent argued requirement in agreement was for respondent to consult regarding ‘process of redundancy’ rather than the selection criteria specifically – [Golden Cockerel] considered – Commission found that on ordinary meaning of words in clause 27.3(c) the respondent had an obligation to consult with Union before applying selection criteria – found that even if Commission accepted respondent’s submissions regarding meaning of clause they had obligation to consult – found selection criteria was integral part of redundancy process – on 3 December 2015 respondent said selection criteria would be developed however management implemented selection criteria on 30 November 2015 – s.389 FW Act required respondent to comply with requirements of agreement – respondent failed to do so – found dismissals not cases of genuine redundancy – jurisdictional objection dismissed – Directions for substantive hearing to be issued. Harding and Anor v South Coast Equipment P/L t/a SCE Industrial Services

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – application to deal with a dispute under BlueScope Steel Port Kembla Steelworks Agreement 2012 – respondent proposed to remove entitlement of additional penalty pay previously agreed to by parties in accordance with ‘Slab Yard Agreement’ – proposed change due to decrease in demand for product and thus less labour required – employees accepted a fixed RDO on weekend to compensate for loss but opposed reduced penalty pay – applicant argued proposal unfair and consultation by respondent deficient – respondent submitted in order to maintain operations savings were essential – respondent further submitted that it would be unfair to limit the ability of the company to implement change to improve viability – Commission found that proposal safe and shift roster not changed by fixing RDO – held that proposal efficient, fair and legal – application dismissed. The Australian Workers’ Union v BlueScope Steel (AIS) P/L

TRANSFER OF BUSINESS – enterprise agreement – s.318 Fair Work Act 2009 – application by Territory Transit P/L for an order relating to instruments covering transferring employees – applicant sought order to the effect that the Northern Territory Public Sector Enterprise Agreement 2013-2017 would not cover the applicant and transferring employees – requirements in s.318 of FW Act considered – Commission determined such an outcome is in public interest – Commission satisfied order should be made. Northern Territory Public Sector Enterprise Agreement 2013-2017

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – costs – ss.394, 400A, 611 Fair Work Act 2009 – application by respondent for costs against applicant on indemnity basis under ss.400A and 611 of FW Act – Commission held failure of applicant to discontinue application following conciliation not unreasonable act – reasonable for applicant to reject settlement offer – respondent did not incur costs for applicant’s failure to comply with orders and/or directions – application for costs under s.400A must fail – applicant’s case never ‘so obviously untenable that it cannot possibly succeed’ [Church] – fact that applicant lost case did not itself mean applicant made application without reasonable cause or that it should have been reasonably apparent had no reasonable prospects of success – application for costs under s.611 must also fail – application dismissed. Barkho v Dairy Country P/L

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – high income threshold – ss.332, 382, 394, Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant operations supervisor – written offer of employment provided gross salary of $120,000 per year plus $15,600 vehicle allowance – also entitled to single health cover under company scheme – applicant submitted dismissal unfair – applicant submitted respondent restructured department he managed to financially support the relocation and redeployment of employee based in South Africa – respondent submitted dismissal case of genuine redundancy – further submitted applicant’s earnings exceeded high income threshold as car allowance and health insurance premiums constituted ‘earnings’ – premiums in offer of employment were applied or dealt with on behalf of applicant – applicant submitted that premiums paid for under company scheme – further submitted policy in his name and issued membership card – applicant submitted health insurance premiums not part of his earnings as did not obtain benefit of policy and entitlement was not sought – Commission considered whether health insurance premiums ‘earnings’ under s.332 of FW Act – found that s.332 does not impose requirement that amounts applied on employee’s behalf or direction deliver some benefit to employee – found health insurance premiums to be ‘earnings’ for the purposes of s.332 applying Tipene v Norton Goldfields – Commission considered whether vehicle allowance ‘earnings’ – found that car allowance formed part of applicant’s wages as travel was incidental to role – distinguished from Davidson – Commission found that company policy provided for applicant to separately seek reimbursement for private use of car and paid separately to vehicle allowance – found vehicle allowance included in ‘earnings’ – earnings exceeded high income threshold – applicant not protected from unfair dismissal – application dismissed. Pasznicki v Expro Group Australia P/L

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – jurisdiction – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – dispute arising under Qube Ports P/L and Maritime Union of Australia Enterprise Agreement 2011 (the Port of Bunbury) – MUA submitted dispute settlement procedure had not been followed and Commission did not have jurisdiction to hear and determine dispute – night shift employees were required to commence wash-down of loading area after loading Trans Friendship 1 – Commission satisfied had jurisdiction to hear and determine the substantive dispute and dismissed MUA’s objection – Golden Cockerel considered in relation to interpretation of subclauses 1.7(b) and (c) of agreement – Commission interpreted employees can conduct wash-down on night-shift on three conditions: imminent berthing of a vessel, berth at which vessel has to be cleaned, and that there has been no prior opportunity to complete the task of cleaning before the berthing of the vessel – found that in event of dispute application should be dealt with pursuant to clause 45 of agreement. Qube Ports P/L t/a Qube Port, Qube Bulk, Qube Ports and Bulk v Maritime Union of Australia

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – dismissed due to number of concerns including interactions with staff and swearing – respondent evidence preferred – summary dismissal followed swearing and related commentary – circumstances surrounding dismissal reflective of an almost immediate response in small workplace to what unfolded following swearing incident – not satisfied applicant established case of unfair dismissal – application dismissed. Koleski v Renito P/L t/a Hair Health and Beauty Professional

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – applicant was employed as a Detention Services Officer – applicant allegedly terminated because he did not maintain positive control of a detainee and the detainee escaped – applicant submitted his termination was unfair because the circumstances of the escape were dynamic and fluid and required rapid decisions which were consistent with applicable policies – further submitted Escort Operational Order for this detainee was not satisfactory, any misbehaviour on his part was not wilful or deliberate, the incident investigation process was deficient and lacked procedural fairness and his termination was disproportionate to the incident itself – respondent argued applicant did not comply with mandatory escort procedures, did not comply with clear instructions relating to the escorting of the detainee and failed to seek guidance over how the escort should be escorted – Selvachandran applied – Commission satisfied that the reason for employment termination primarily related to failure to comply with the required procedure – held dismissal was not unfair – application dismissed. Nadeem v Serco Australia P/L