NEWS HR

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – termination at initiative of employer – ss.386, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant commenced work as part of one year contract with respondent on 26 January 2005 – contract tacitly renewed each year until dismissal on 30 June 2015 – applicant submitted where employment for fixed term continues after expiry, employment continues for indefinite period subject to termination – submitted that in alternative, if employed on series of one year fixed term contracts, dismissal took effect midway through current contract – respondent submitted that applicant effectively resigned by taking one month absence on sick leave as notice – Commission found that there was no sustainable basis for respondent’s contention that employment contract expired on 30 June 2015 – found nothing to support respondent’s contention that applicant resigned – held that termination was at initiative of respondent and that there was no valid reason for termination – applicant submitted that dismissal was harsh having regard to her age, difficulty in obtaining alternative employment and length of service – Commission held dismissal was harsh, unjust and unreasonable – reinstatement not appropriate in the circumstances – ordered maximum statutory compensation of 26 weeks ($15,506.46) taxed according to law. Kim v Embassy of the People’s Democratic Republic of Algeria

RIGHT OF ENTRY – application for permit – ss.512, 513, 515 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for a right of entry permit – Mr Benstead has been employed by the CFMEU as an organiser since December 2004 – was first issued with an entry permit on 21 June 2004 – most recent entry permit issued to him expired on 20 April 2015 – it was not returned to the Commission upon expiry because Mr Benstead had lost it – Director of the Fair Work Building Industry Inspectorate (Director) notified of the lodgement of the application – Director elected to exercise his right under s.72 of the Fair Work (Building Industry) Act 2012 to make submissions in relation to the matter – Director opposed the issue of an entry permit to Mr Benstead – declaration from CFMEU disclosed a number of court proceedings involving Mr Benstead – whether Mr Benstead a fit and proper person – White v Benstead raised serious concerns about Mr Benstead’s fitness and propriety to hold an entry permit – involved a serious breach of s.500 of the FW Act in that Mr Benstead (together with another CFMEU official) entered a worksite without having given any notice of his proposed entry and having no legal basis to do so, pushed past security guards who sought to prevent his entry, failed to identify the purpose of his entry, interrupted employees who were at work for the purpose of holding discussions, disobeyed directions to leave, and eventually had to be escorted out of the site by police – the conduct exhibited was of a person who had no regard whatsoever to the legal obligations and responsibilities in the FW Act attaching to entry to employers’ premises – Commission particularly disturbed by Mr Benstead’s evidence about this matter – evidence was inconsistent with the agreed statement of facts and also internally inconsistent – was simply not credible and not accepted by Commission – demonstrated a refusal to accept responsibility, almost seven years after the event, for a contravention described by the Court as ‘flagrant’, and evinces no recognition of the need to comply with the right of entry provisions in the FW Act – other contraventions were all serious and demonstrated a readiness to engage in unlawful conduct – not persuaded Mr Benstead had learnt anything from the findings made against him in these matters – considered the contraventions found and penalties imposed in Draffin v CFMEU, White v Benstead and FWBII v CFMEU, John Holland v Benstead and Alfred v CFMEU weighed heavily against a conclusion that Mr Benstead was a fit and proper person to hold an entry permit – no evidence that Mr Benstead has in recent years ever actually exercised right of entry under the FW Act in a lawful manner – not satisfied Mr Benstead was a fit and proper person to hold an unconditional entry permit – no confidence that he recognises and takes seriously the need to comply with the right of entry obligations contained in Part 3-4 of the FW Act – no conditions that could be attached to an entry permit which would address the concerns, and allow the Commission to conclude that Mr Benstead was a fit and proper person to be issued with a conditional entry permit – CFMEU given opportunity to propose conditions which might deal with concerns – Director will have an opportunity to respond. Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union – Gerard Benstead

CASE PROCEDURES – stay order – s.604 Fair Work Act 2009 – application to appeal decision not to issue right of entry permit to Mr Tadic, CFMEU official – entry permit expired – permit returned to Commission – applicant sought stay of decision – Edghill applied – Commission satisfied arguable case to grant permission to appeal and appeal itself – not persuaded balance of convenience favours stay in circumstances – decision now under appeal incapable of being stayed – matter must simply be determined on appeal – stay cannot be taken to re-establish entry rights where rights do not now exist or resurrect any rights which formally existed – stay application refused. Appeal by Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union against decision of Watson VP of 31 May 2016 [[2016] FWC 3322] Re: Director of the Fair Work Building Industry Inspectorate

GENERAL PROTECTIONS – extension of time – s.365 Fair Work Act 2009 – application to deal with contraventions involving dismissal made outside 21 day statutory timeframe – applicant complained bullying at work caused medical condition – medical report supported finding medical condition impacted ability to lodge application in time – Commission satisfied severe medical condition explained delay – lack of prejudice to respondent weighed in favour of a finding of exceptional circumstances – satisfied there were exceptional circumstances – extension of time granted. McDonald v D&A Mitrevski P/L t/a Stockdale Leggo Bayswater

ANTI-BULLYING – bullied at work – unreasonable behaviour – s.789FC Fair Work Act 2009 – application for an order to stop bullying – applicant is a teacher and is also OH&S representative – alleged she has been bullied at work by the Principal of the College – Principal appointed in 2013 with a mandate from the Board of Mercy Education to effect change and arrest declining enrolment – some staff were resistant to change and preferred the status quo – applicant gave evidence that she became increasingly concerned about Mercy Education’s bullying policy and in May 2013 raised the issue of bullying and the need to update the policy – Business Manager agreed to review the bullying policy by the end of the year – this did not eventuate – issue raised again in April 2014 – no Deputy Principal at the College – Deputy Principal had resigned after Principal had been appointed – Deputy Principal continued to be listed in the outdated bullying policy as the complaints officer – bullying policy revised and re-issued in 2015 after applicant filed complaints in December 2014 – applicant identified a number of incidents occurring from late 2013 and continuing after her return from LSL in mid-2015 which she maintained were together repeated unreasonable behaviour by the Principal – Amie Mac adopted – Commission concluded that four of the incidents about which the applicant complained, taken together, amounted to repeated unreasonable behaviour – found conduct was likely to have caused applicant distress – behaviour created a risk to the health and safety of applicant – found applicant was bullied at work – what orders (if any) should be made – held relationship between applicant and Principal is an obviously tense one involving some mutual animus – interpersonal relationship disputes are best resolved through the efforts of the parties and perhaps assisted by some form of facilitation or mediation – any orders made would likely favour one side over the other – some form of reconciliation is much more likely to produce a lasting positive improvement in the working relationship between the parties than any order – proposal that the parties engage with each other in a series of mediated or facilitated meetings with the aim of repairing their relationship and engaging in a dialogue that will accommodate an ongoing professional working relationship and a safe working environment – if parties unwilling to engage with each other then they can request the expeditious hearing and determination of the question whether orders should be made. Purcell v Ms Mary Farah and Mercy Education Ltd t/a St Aloysius College

MODERN AWARDS – 4 yearly review – common issues – s.156 Fair Work Act 2009 – Full Bench – July 2015 Award Flexibility decision dealt with a number of claims to vary certain modern awards in respect of make up time and time off instead of payment for overtime [[2015] FWCFB 4466] – make up time claim rejected – interested parties provided with opportunity to file written submissions in relation to the content of the provisional model term and the proposition that the model term be inserted in 113 modern awards – October 2015 decision dealt with submissions concerning the content of the model term [[2015] FWCFB 6847] – April 2016 decision proposed further changes to the form and content of the model TOIL term [[2016] FWCFB 2602] – interested parties given opportunity to comment on the plain language redraft of the model term – 8 July 2016 decision dealt with submissions received in relation to the proposed plain language model term and finalised the model term and associated template agreement [[2016] FWCFB 4258] – this decision deals with the 49 modern awards which contain existing ‘time off in lieu of overtime’ (TOIL) provisions, but which are not the subject of an award specific submission – Full Bench propose to vary the 44 modern awards set out at Attachment D to insert the model term and the associated schedule containing the template agreement – existing TOIL terms in these 44 modern awards should be deleted – satisfied the variation of these 44 modern awards to incorporate the model term is necessary to ensure that each of these modern awards provides a fair and relevant minimum safety net, taking into account the s.134 considerations – April 2016 decision provided for the variation of 26 modern awards – 70 of the 122 modern awards will now contain the model term and associated schedule – regarding the other five modern awards – the Mobile Crane Hiring Award 2010 and the Amusement, Events and Recreation Award 2010 – provisional view of Full Bench that the two existing provisions do not achieve the modern awards objective – these awards will be listed for further hearing at 9.30 am on 24 August 2016 – the Book Industry Award 2010 – our provisional view that the TOIL term in this award does not provide a fair and relevant safety net and on that basis does not achieve the modern awards objective – Full Bench will publish a draft variation determination in respect of this award and list the matter for further hearing on 24 August 2016 – the Supported Employment Services Award 2010 and the Children’s Services Award 2010 – provide a limitation on the amount of overtime that can be the subject of a TOIL agreement – provisional view that if the existing provisions were replaced by the model term then such a limitation may be unnecessary – Full Bench propose to adopt the provisional view that these two modern awards should be varied to delete the existing TOIL provisions and insert the model term and the associated schedule – interested parties will have 14 days to comment on the draft variation determinations – directions for the further hearing of this matter to be listed in due course. 4 yearly review of modern awards – Award flexibility

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – ss.394, 400, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – at first instance Commission held that the appellant had been unfairly dismissed – found valid reason for the appellant’s termination but considered the dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable due to a procedurally flawed and unfair termination process – held applicant 75% responsible for his termination and awarded reduced compensation based on this finding – appellant expressed general dissatisfaction with the Commission’s decision and sought permission to appeal – submitted he worked for the company honestly, he had been treated badly and did not engage in the conduct found to have occurred – Coal & Allied considered – held appellant’s appeal was a statement of dissatisfaction with the Commission’s conclusions and he had failed to demonstrate any error on the part of the Commission – appeal not in the public interest – permission to appeal refused. Appeal by Weldemichael against decision of Roberts C of 10 March 2016 [[2016] FWC 164] Re: Carbridge P/L t/a Easycart Australia

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394, 400, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – appeal of unfair dismissal application in respect of the decision and amount of compensation awarded – at first instance Deputy President held that the applicant was unfairly dismissed and ordered an amount of compensation in lieu of reinstatement – Croker submitted permission to appeal should be granted as it raised important issues of general application and because the decision is not in the public’s best interests – several grounds were relied on by the appellant, including that the Deputy President did not exercise ‘proper discretion’ – onus was on Croker to establish a valid reason for the dismissal related to Mr Jarvis’ capacity or conduct – at first instance it was submitted by Croker that Mr Jarvis misrepresented himself in attempts to obtain sensitive information in a ‘corrupt and deceptive manner’ – Full Bench held that the Deputy President’s findings made it clear that Croker did not make out its case in relation to this alleged motivation for conduct – while the Deputy President found that Mr Jarvis misrepresented himself as a supervisor, on the evidence before them they were not satisfied this was done with any malicious or corrupt intent – Croker did not direct the Full Bench to any specific errors made by the Deputy President – Full Bench not satisfied of any error and considered the findings of the Deputy President to be open to her on the evidence – not satisfied it was in the public interest to grant permission to appeal – permission to appeal refused. Appeal by Croker Constructions against decision of Gooley DP of 19 April 2016 [[2016] FWC 2377] Re: Jarvis