TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – performance – casual employee – ss.383, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant employed as heavy duty fitter in Darwin – first engaged as a casual employee on 11 August 2015 and became a full-time permanent employee of the company on 9 November 2015 – advised of need for him to be available for periodic work at the Old Pirate Mine, 1600km from Darwin – respondent submitted applicant failed to follow fatigue management requirements by driving long distances without breaks or sufficient breaks – submitted applicant drove entire distance to Darwin in single day – no evidence of disciplinary action or warning – respondent further submitted that applicant agreed to be available at mine, refused and failed to live up to his side of agreement – further submitted that applicant put respondent in difficult position by failing to go as did not have another person to go to site – both parties agreed that on 2 March 2016 applicant was approached with a firm request to go to the Old Pirate Mine site and applicant refused – also agreed that applicant then handed letter of dismissal – Commission considered whether applicant served minimum employment period – whether employed on regular and systemic basis and whether had reasonable expectation of continuing employment – in assessing whether employment on regular and systemic basis, Commission looks for employment to have been on regular and systemic basis, not hours worked – clear pattern or roster of hours may be strong evidence – while term ‘regular’ implies repetitive pattern, does not mean frequent, often, uniform, or constant’ [Yaraka Holdings] – Commission found applicant employed on casual basis but letter of offer anticipated that after successful trial period would be offered permanent position – found at no stage continuous service broken and applicant completed minimum employment period – Commission unable to find that refusal to attend site amounted to valid reason for dismissal – found applicant was dismissed and dismissal was unfair – ordered compensation of $15,162, less taxation, and $1,440 to be paid to his superannuation. Malsen v Titan Plant Hire P/L
July 28, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – termination at initiative of employer – resignation – ss.386, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – applicant claimed he was unfairly dismissed following a heated conversation with his supervisor his absences from work, after which he left the workplace and remained away from work for the balance of the day – respondent alleged applicant voluntarily resigned from his employment – considered resignation given in ‘special circumstances’ [Ngo] – Commission satisfied there were ‘special circumstances’ in existence at the time – respondent waited until after the close of business before sending its letter to applicant at 5:11pm, accepting his resignation – applicant did not contact, or attempt to contact, supervisor or any other person from respondent between his departure from the workplace at about 10:00am and his voicemail message for supervisor at 6:42pm – held respondent allowed a reasonable period of time to lapse before informing applicant it had accepted his resignation – attempt by applicant to withdraw his resignation the next morning was too late – Commission satisfied applicant resigned at his own initiative – applicant not dismissed within the meaning of s.386 of FW Act – application dismissed. Mallinson v Algon Steel P/L
July 28, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – minimum employment period – Small Business Fair Dismissal Code – ss.388, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – applicant employed as hairdresser on 1 June 2011 by Queen Street Palladeum Trust (Palladeum) – business sold to respondent on 30 June 2015 – applicant commenced working with respondent on 1 July 2015 – dismissed for misconduct regarding ‘rent-a-chair’ arrangements and not paying for use of salon products – respondent raised two jurisdictional objections – it was a small business and dismissal consistent with Small Business Fair Dismissal Code (Code) – minimum employment period not met as applicant a transferring employee notified for purpose of s.384(2)(b) of FW Act in sale agreement – applicant submitted her prior service with Palladeum formed part of service with respondent as notification that the period of service with Palladeum would not be recognised not provided under s.384(2)(b) of FW Act – dismissal inconsistent with Code – Commission found applicant a transferring employee – found business sale agreement did not inform applicant that prior service would not be recognised so applicant had met minimum employment period – termination letter indicated dismissal with immediate effect as a result of respondent’s belief applicant engaged in serious misconduct – two step test [Pinawin] – no evidence of serious misconduct – belief not on reasonable grounds – no valid reason for dismissal – found dismissal harsh, unjust and unreasonable – reinstatement not appropriate – ordered compensation of $4007.70, taxed accordingly. Wheare v Houndstooth P/L t/a The Palladeum Hair
July 28, 2016
RIGHT OF ENTRY – dispute over right of entry – s.505 Fair Work Act 2009 – alleged dispute concerning Right of Entry (ROE) at Ichthys Onshore Construction Project – applicant sought orders to deal with what it said was the respective willingness and propensity of three officials to engage in inappropriate conduct when exercising ROE – respondents opposed jurisdiction – Commission has jurisdiction to deal with dispute – conduct of Union Officials taken to be conduct of Unions – conduct of Officials inappropriate and unacceptable – no repetition of conduct for extended period – role of Commission is not to sanction any of the respondents for past conduct, but to find a practical resolution for the matters going forward – findings themselves and prospect of future orders sufficient to resolve the dispute – respondents should be aware that any further findings of such conduct against them would provide the applicant a very strong basis for the kind of orders sought in this matter. JKC Australia LNG P/L v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (CFMEU) and Ors
July 28, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant terminated for engaging in conduct designed to seriously undermine respondent, senior management and staff – respondent claimed that while applicant was on WorkCover he made derogatory comments to respondent’s employees, clients and service providers – Commission of belief much of the evidence relied on in relation to applicant’s alleged behaviour was hearsay – in absence of any direct evidence, Commission could not find applicant made any disparaging comments about respondent, its senior management to clients and or contractors of respondent – Commission determined no valid reason given for dismissal of applicant – applicant’s termination found to be unjust and unreasonable in circumstances – Commission not satisfied enough evidence or submissions provided to determine remedy – separate directions to be issued regarding remedy. Mahoney v OSSA Services P/L t/a OSSA Services
July 28, 2016
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – application to deal with a dispute concerning meaning of part of clause 27 of the Tenix Australia P/L and ETU Power, Construction, Maintenance Enterprise Agreement 2013 – 2016 – clause 27 provides for payment to employees removed from availability roster – group of employees who were on availability roster and in receipt of availability allowance dismissed due to redundancy – applicant contended that as employees were removed from availability roster at initiative of respondent and had not received 12 months’ notice of removal from the roster they were entitled to payment of availability allowance in lieu of notice – found availability allowances are not payable as part of weekly wage for the purpose of redundancy payments – where termination of employment occurs due to redundancy, the initiative of respondent is not on removing an employee from the availability roster but rather on reducing the size of the workforce through redundancy – it would be a step too far to read the clause as including any action of employer which had the effect of ending employee’s participation in availability roster – termination of employment will always end possibility of employees being included on availability roster – termination not done for purpose of removing employees from the availability roster – clause 27.1.1 is about performance of work outside normal hours and payment to employee of allowance for being available to perform that work – clause 27 is linked with performance of work within a continuing employment relationship – found Clause 27.2.1 does not create entitlement for payment in lieu of notice for employee who is removed from availability roster as consequence of employee’s employment being terminated at the initiative of respondent. Communications, Electrical, Electronic, Energy, Information, Postal, Plumbing and Allied Services Union of Australia v Downer Utilities Australia P/L
July 28, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – costs – ss.400A and 611 Fair Work Act 2009 – Sch. 3.1 Fair Work Regulations 2009 – previous decision of the Commission determined that applicant would be required to pay respondent’s costs on an indemnity basis [[2016] FWC 1059] – bill of costs submitted by respondent – applicant provided with opportunity to object to bill of costs – Commission considered that a number of items in the bill were instances of duplication and these were deducted – also deducted amounts claimed for business class travel rather than economy, research and for preparation of the bill – the total amount claimed by the respondent was $128,421.31 – $15,134.62 deducted from bill – total costs awarded were $113,286.69 – order to be issued. Post v NTI Limited t/a NTI
July 28, 2016
RIGHT OF ENTRY – dispute over right of entry – jurisdiction – ss.490, 505 Fair Work Act 2009 – application CFMEU to resolve a dispute regarding CFMEU permit holders exercise of right of entry at premises occupied by BHP – BHP submitted that Commission lacked jurisdiction to hear the matter as there was no relevant dispute between the parties – ‘dispute’ the subject of application had come to an end, and employees to which it related were no longer permitted to access premises – BHP further submitted that hearing the dispute and making any orders would be an exercise of judicial power and not arbitral power – CFMEU sought right of entry for permit holders before and after shifts – BHP submitted this did not fall within the scope of ‘other breaks’ as referred to in s.490(2) of FW Act – determination of this issue would involve statutory interpretation, requiring an exercise of judicial power – Commission satisfied that CFMEU sought a bare declaration of existing rights rather than resolution of an existing dispute, and that application sought the enforcement of an existing right, rather than the creation of a new right, which involved an exercise of judicial power – Commission also not satisfied ‘other breaks’ includes periods before or after shifts – application dismissed. Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v BHP Billiton Nickel West P/L