Twenty-seven unfair dismissal claims will be evaluated by the Fair Work Commissioners today. The full list is: NRG Concepts Pty Ltd (Lauris), Victorian Building Authority (Stefanidis), Spotless Group Limited (Cross), Toll Ipec Pty Ltd (David), Cielo Publishing Pty Ltd (Paroz), Endless Solar Operations (Cole), DAMEC Counselling Service (Taouk-Saade), Batchelor Institute of Indigenous Tertiary Education (Lal), Raytheon Company Inc (Langcake), NAB (Bernacki), STA Travel Pty Ltd (Baron), Enfield Furniture (Wood), Wires and Pliers Electrical and Data (Angelowitsch), Bretcod Pty Ltd (Snowden), Cubbyhouse Childcare Australia (Diaz), Maitland St Dental (Hobby), McDonald’s Australia Limited (Nadir), Hylton Catering Management Pty Ltd (Esperal), Fortescue Metals Group (Summerfield), Comphire Pty Ltd (Sierra), Water Corproation (Bradford), Thiess Pty Limited (Garratt), Agri Labour Australia Pty Ltd (Fan), Grindle Services Pty Ltd (Seidenkranz), LJ Hooker Property Management Pty Ltd (Lessing), Limestone Coast Health Unit Trust (Paltridge), Flinders Port Holdings Pty Ltd (Iancu).
July 29, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – performance – ss.394, 400, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – appeal – Full Bench – at first instance, Commission satisfied that dismissal harsh, unjust or unreasonable and order made to for reinstatement and to maintain continuity of service – permission to appeal granted [[2016] FWCFB 2661] – appellant raised seventeen grounds of appeal which respondent disputed – at the core of the dispute was whether there were errors in accordance with House v The King – respondent submitted that Commission correctly interpreted ‘valid reason’ in accordance with Selvachandran by requiring the reason for dismissal to be well founded, sound and defensible or just – meaning of ‘valid’ in Macquarie Dictionary distinguished from meaning in industrial relations context – Full Bench agreed with Northrop J – ‘just’ excluded as consideration in determining valid reason for dismissal – Commission erred in considering justness of reason for dismissal to guide him as to whether there was a valid reason – appellant posited that Commission failed to take into account a relevant consideration, that being, the existence of an industrial dispute raised by the CPSU concerning duties of the respondent – Commission found that the industrial dispute was relevant to considering whether the dismissal was unfair – based on such finding, obligations under the Australian Taxation Office Enterprise Agreement 2011 (ATO EA) were ignited – ATO EA prescribed that while dispute on foot, status quo to remain – as Commission found that dispute was a relevant consideration, Full Bench of the view that failure to cogitate ATO EA obligations was an error in accordance with House – Full Bench not required to consider every appealable error – based on aforementioned findings appeal upheld and original decision quashed – respondent position at ATO made redundant and transferred to new role – respondent submitted he was not qualified for new role – dispute arose as to respondent’s competency to perform role – respondent refused to perform new duties, thus dismissed for non-performance – respondent submitted that he did not have required skills or knowledge to undertake duties assigned to him – evidence before Full Bench established respondent did have requisite knowledge – failure to perform duties sound, defensible and well founded reason for dismissal – Full Bench further of the view that respondent adequately notified of reasons for dismissal – ss.387(d)-(f) of FW Act not relevant – respondent argued that appellant failed to consider medical condition when determining dismissal – Full Bench not persuaded a relevant matter – dismissal not harsh, unjust or unreasonable – application for unfair dismissal remedy dismissed – appeal upheld. Appeal by Commonwealth of Australia (Australian Taxation Office) t/a Australian Taxation Office against decision of Ryan C of 23 March 2016 [[2016] FWC 1844] Re: Shamir
July 29, 2016
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – termination of agreement – ss.225, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – appeal – Full Bench – at first instance the Commission concluded that the Griffin Coal (Maintenance) Collective Agreement 2012 should be terminated with effect from 10 July 2016 – agreement achieved its nominal expiry date on 26 April 2016 – a stay of the Commission’s decision was granted by consent, pending the determination of the appeal – grounds for appeal included the application of the public interest test, the application of the ‘appropriateness test’, asserted errors in the exercise of discretion, and natural justice considerations – Full Bench satisfied that permission to appeal should be granted – appeal raises a number of important issues including the manner in which this matter proceeded at first instance and whether this gave rise to natural justice considerations – appeal proceeded by way of a rehearing – application of public interest test – CEPU v Aurizon considered – Full Bench satisfied the Commission’s approach to public interest considerations was consistent with the requirements established by s.226(a) of FW Act – not satisfied the appellant demonstrated appealable error with respect to the Commission’s finding – application of ‘appropriateness test’ – decision at first instance must be taken as demonstrating consideration of the competing interests of Griffin Coal, the employees covered by the agreement and the interests of the appellant – not satisfied the Commission’s decision demonstrates error relative to the application of s.226(b) – errors in the exercise of discretion – not satisfied that the Commission failed to take into account relevant considerations – fair reading of the Commission’s decision confirms all of the material was taken into account in the context of the considerations required pursuant to s.226 – natural justice considerations – held appellant not denied the opportunity for a fair hearing – Full Bench satisfied the Commission examined all of the relevant factors required pursuant to s.226 of FW Act and this was undertaken in an equitable and fair manner – not satisfied the appellant identified appealable error in the exercise of the Commission’s discretion – permission to appeal granted – appeal itself dismissed. Appeal by ‘Automotive, Food, Metals, Engineering, Printing and Kindred Industries Union’ known as the Australian Manufacturing Workers’ Union (AMWU) against decision of Cloghan C of 9 June 2016 [[2016] FWCA 2312] Re: Griffin Coal Mining Company P/L
July 29, 2016
RIGHT OF ENTRY – application for permit – conditions – ss.512, 513 Fair Work Act 2009 – application by CFMEU for a right of entry permit for Mr Hall – Mr Hall has held entry permits as a CFMEU organiser concurrently from 25 March 2009 until the expiry of his most recent permit on 10 April 2016 – Commission considered declarations disclosed in application to determine if Mr Hall was a fit and proper person to hold permit – declaration disclosed findings of contravention against Mr Hall related to a 2010 Federal Magistrates court matter where consent order terms were imposed rather than a monetary penalty – this matter arose for consideration regarding an application for Mr Hall to be re-issued with an entry permit in 2013 – in this application it was held that a single contravention of the Act for which a penalty was not imposed did not outweigh the purposes of the relevant sections in determining Mr Hall a fit and proper person – Commission provided with a Statement of Agreed Facts, Admissions and Proposed Orders Between the Applicant and Respondents (Statement) relating to 2010 matter upon request for further information – held that although Mr Hall found to have hindered and obstructed a person and used abusive language, he acted out of genuine concern about safety and admitted the contraventions – particular weight given to the fact that no monetary penalty was imposed in relation to the 2010 matter – also considered relevant that Mr Hall has not been found to have committed any further contravention of industrial law in the six years since – Commission satisfied on overall balance that Mr Hall a fit and proper person to hold an entry permit – permit to be issued. Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union – Adam Hall
July 29, 2016
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – two applications to deal with disputes under the dispute settlement procedure in the Coles Smeaton Grange (NUW) Regional Distribution Centre Enterprise Agreement 2014 – applicants employed on night shift (7:00pm-5:00am) at Coles Warehouse Distribution Centre (the Centre) at Smeaton Grange in New South Wales – in late 2014 Coles was decided to remove the permanent night shift – 35 employees rostered permanently on night shift – majority of night shift employees expressed a preference to work only on afternoon shift (3:00pm-1:00am) – only 26 positions available on afternoon shift – Coles developed selection criteria to determine the most suitable candidates for afternoon shift – seven employees allocated to the mid shift (10:00am-8:00pm) – five of the affected employees, who had not been allocated to afternoon shifts, filed dispute notifications – three of these applications were subsequently resolved – whether Coles properly complied with its consultation obligations in abolishing night shift – major rostering change – Bundaberg Sugar adopted – Commission held Coles had no other reasonable alternative, except to adopt a selection procedure based on objectively determined criteria – not dissimilar to a ‘spill and fill’ exercise – however in this case no team member actually lost their job, just their preferred working hours – satisfied Coles complied with its obligations under the notification and consultation provisions of the agreement – further satisfied the merit selection process to determine which night shift employee should be able to transfer to afternoon shift was transparent, fair and reasonable in all the circumstances – applications dismissed. Roberts and Anor v Coles Group Supply Chain P/L t/a Coles
July 29, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – minimum employment period – small business employer – ss.23, 383, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – applicant employed as sales representative – commenced employment on 14 September 2015 – wage reduced in March 2016 due to performance issues – applicant resigned as a result, giving notice on 15 March – employment ceased on 16 March 2016 – respondent raised jurisdictional objections – small business employer – only employed seven employees – Commission found Think Commercial Construction P/L was not an associated entity of respondent – minimum employment period for an employee employed by a small business employer is one year – applicant employed for period of just over six months – minimum employment period not met – applicant not protected from unfair dismissal – application dismissed. Hemingway v Think Commercial Projects P/L atf Think Commercial Projects Trust t/a Think Commercial Projects
July 29, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – costs – s.400A Fair Work Act 2009 – employee made unfair dismissal application on 10 November 2015 – matter listed for hearing on 22 January 2016 – late on 21 January 2016, the employee’s solicitors sought adjournment – granted and matter relisted for hearing on 19 February 2016 – part-heard by Commission on 19 February and adjourned to 8 March 2016 – on 7 March 2016, employee’s solicitors sought adjournment – employer agreed with request – adjournment refused and parties directed that matter would proceed – neither employee nor employee’s solicitors appeared – at hearing, employer made application for dismissal of substantive unfair dismissal application pursuant to s.399A of FW Act – Commission granted application to dismiss – employer made application for costs on 16 May 2016 pursuant to s.400A based on three grounds – first, because employee failed to attend hearing on 8 March 2016 – second, because employee failed to discontinue application after 8 January 2016 despite nature and force of employer’s jurisdictional objections, being that employee was not covered by modern award or enterprise agreement and his earnings exceeded high income threshold – third, because employee continued application after part-heard hearing on 19 February 2016 – Commission satisfied that employee’s failure to attend hearing on 8 March 2016 was unreasonable act or omission by him and that costs were incurred by employer as a result – not satisfied with second and third grounds that employee ought to have reasonably known his case had no reasonable prospect of success – Commission refused to exercise discretion to make costs order as employer joined in on employee’s application for adjournment of proceedings listed for 8 March 2016 – held that by joining adjournment request, employer was prepared to continue matter – application dismissed. Retic Water P/L v Petersen
July 29, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – national system employer – casual – ss.14, 384, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – two jurisdictional objections raised – whether respondent national system employer – employment arrangement was private and domestic in nature – respondent had ABN and the entity type was individual/sole trader – respondent submitted not covered by the extended meaning of national system employer and s.30 FW Act did not apply – Commission found the Victorian Fair Work (Commonwealth Powers) Act 2009 referral of termination of employment to Commonwealth did not exclude private arrangements – Commission satisfied that matter not claim for enforcement of contract but application for unfair dismissal remedy – held extended meaning of national system employer applies – first jurisdictional objection dismissed – whether applicant was casual employee – respondent contended not ongoing systematic employment nor reasonable expectation of continuity – respondent accepted rosters indicated consistent pattern of employment – did not accept it was also systematic employment – argued applicant’s availability and willingness to respond to ad hoc changes to roster did not constitute a pattern – applicant argued rostered hours established sequence of engagements through series of contiguous periods of service – argued engagement by respondent almost every week over 14 month period – Ponce and Yaraka Holding P/L considered – Commission found employment regular and systematic – work regularly offered by respondent – respondent argued ongoing employment not possible as funding from individual support package outside respondent’s control and circumstances could change at any time – applicant submitted respondent required 24-hour care by a team of carers – applicant a carer every week for 14 months – no indication arrangements would change – applicant had expectation employment would continue – Commission satisfied applicant had reasonable expectation of continuing employment with respondent on regular and systematic basis – found applicant met minimum employment period – second jurisdictional objection dismissed – matter referred for conciliation. Lewis-Driver v McLean