NEWS HR

ENTERPRISE BARGAINING – protected action ballot – s.437 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for protected action ballot order (PABO) – Coles Store Team Enterprise Agreement 2014-2017 (2014 Enterprise Agreement) approved in 2015 prior to being appealed and later quashed with effect from 5 July 2016 – respondent subsequently declined invitation from applicant to reconvene bargaining process, leading applicant to lodge PABO – respondent opposed PABO on basis there had not been a ‘notification time’ in relation to proposed enterprise agreement and on basis applicant had not been, and was not, genuinely trying to reach an agreement regarding the proposed agreement – Commission to determine whether the initial approval of the 2014 Enterprise Agreement extinguished the ‘notification time’ in relation to the proposed enterprise agreement and if not, whether the applicant was genuinely trying to reach agreement – applicant submitted PABO application made in relation to continued negotiations for the proposed enterprise agreement enlivened as a result of quashing of 2014 Enterprise Agreement – Commission determined that when bargaining process ceases (by the making of an agreement) the notification time under the FW Act must cease to have effect in relation to specific proposed agreement – applicant found not to have a notification time to rely on – absent notification time, a prerequisite for PABO application, means application must fail – in the alternative, Commission also not satisfied applicant’s conduct to date met the requirements of ‘genuinely trying to reach agreement’ – application dismissed. Australasian Meat Industry Employees Union, The v Coles Supermarkets Australia P/L

GENERAL PROTECTIONS – extension of time – date dismissal took effect – s.365 Fair Work Act 2009 – application to deal with contraventions involving dismissal – respondent objected to application on the basis that it was made one day late – respondent submitted dismissal took effect on 15 March 2016 – applicant submitted 30 March 2016 – respondent submitted that dismissal letter sent by registered post – respondent also engaged a courier to take a copy of the letter to the applicant’s address – applicant denied receiving the letter from the courier – applicant picked up the registered post letter from post office on 30 March 2016 and submitted this was the first notice of his termination – Commission not satisfied that the couriered letter was received – respondent’s argument that applicant had deliberately avoided communications from the respondent were rejected – dismissal was not communicated to the applicant until 30 March 2016 – application made in time. Mueller v Mun Australia P/L

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – costs – ss.400A, 401 and 611 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal dismissed by Commission [[2016] FWC 2985] – respondent sought costs against applicant and his agent – submitted applicant and his representative caused their costs to be incurred unreasonably by continuing to hearing where there was no reasonable prospect of success – respondent’s submissions and evidentiary material filed 13 April 2016 were comprehensive and compelling – should have been clear to applicant and his representative that the merits of his application were particularly poor and that therefore his application had no reasonable prospect of success – applicant’s representative should have advised the applicant to either discontinue the application or seek to settle the matter on mutually agreeable terms – unclear from the material before the Commission as to whether she did so – Commission not satisfied that the applicant’s representative encouraged applicant to continue his application after it became clear there was no reasonable prospect of success – satisfied that an order for the applicant to pay all costs should be made – Directions to be issued for respondent to provide an itemised schedule of costs. Abdulrahim v QBE Management Services P/L

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – approval – ss.185, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – appeal – Full Bench – appeal against decision which approved the JELD-WEN Australia QLD Enterprise Agreement on basis that it was not sufficiently clear s.180 and s.186 of FW Act had been satisfied – appeal concerned a typographical error in Appendix A of Agreement not identified by parties or Commission at first instance – dates of wage increases left as ‘[insert date]’ – employer gave an undertaking regarding relevant dates and that increases were agreed to by employees and would apply to all employees covered by Agreement – Full Bench granted permission to appeal on basis that appeal raised important questions concerning mandatory pre-approval requirements of FW Act in circumstances where an agreement contains unclear and objectively unidentifiable terms – Full Bench accepted that with relevant dates missing, Agreement did not pass mandatory requirements of FW Act – appeal upheld and decision quashed – Full Bench reheard application for approval – whether undertaking remedied the typographical error – Full Bench found Agreement, when read with undertaking, adequately reflected explanation respondent provided relevant employees, satisfying s.180(5) of FW Act – Agreement with undertaking gave effect to terms and dates genuinely agreed to and passed s.186(2)(a) of FW Act – employees better off overall under Agreement with undertaking – undertaking met concerns raised by CFMEU and sufficiently remedied error – no issues regarding s.190(3)-(5) requirements – satisfied appropriate to accept undertaking and approve Agreement – Agreement to be read in conjunction with undertaking pursuant to s.190(2) of FW Act – satisfied requirements of ss.186, 187 and 188 met subject to undertaking – Agreement approved with operative date of 27 July 2016. Appeal by Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union against decision of Lee C of 17 May 2016 [[2016] FWCA 3088] Re: Jeld-Wen Australia P/L t/a JELD-WEN Australia QLD

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – performance – ss.394, 400, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – appellant sought permission to appeal the dismissal of his application for relief from unfair dismissal – submitted that the Commission had failed to take into account information contained in certain documents – Commission satisfied that the decision made was reasonably open to the Commission on the facts – evident that all of the materials provided to the Commission had been considered – appellant had not taken the Commission to any specific errors said to have been made – Commission not satisfied that any error made – Commission not satisfied that it would be in the public interest to grant permission to appeal – permission to appeal refused. Appeal by Belachew against decision and order of Kovacic DP of 21 April 2016 [[2016] FWC 2532], [PR579337]] Re: Commonwealth of Australia as represented by the Australian Bureau of Statistics

Thirty labour disputes will be analysed, reviewed, determined or referred by the Fair Work Commission today. The full list is: Iplex Pipelines Australia Pty Limited (Bienias), Toll Personnel Pty Limited & Toll Jalco (Williams), Tabaro Pty Ltd (De Biasi), Amcal Max Shearwater (Wilson), Reece Australia Pty Ltd (Karahalios), TOD Investments (Presta), Oaky Creek Coal Pty Ltd (Watts), Water Dynamics Pty Ltd (Pope), UTECH Group Pty Ltd (Tablizo), Constantinos Fardoulis & Andrianna Athas (Wilkins), Stellar Asia Pacific Pty Ltd (Morgan), VST Enterprises (Duggan), BMD Constructions Pty Ltd (Brandy), Medway Plumbing Pty Ltd (Griffiths), Inner West Towing (Maynard), McDonald’s Australia Limited (Nadir), Collexion Pty Ltd (McIlroy), Ultimo Catering and Events (Guilfoyle), CSBP Limited (Rowe), Teys Australia Beenleigh Pty Ltd (Prange), Sandfort Pty Ltd ATF The Sandfort Trust (Miller), Granville Tavern (Reid), Careers Australia Group Limited (Chapman), MC Global Solutions Pty Ltd (Crawford), Sea Stradbroke Services Pty Ltd (Campbell), QLD News (Grant), Kennedy Property Services (Mulvihill) and Anglicare SA Incorporated (Lamb, Moore).

RIGHT OF ENTRY – application for permit – conditions – ss.512, 513, 515 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for a right of entry permit – Mr Graauwmans is employed by the CFMEU as an organiser – has continuously held entry permits from 31 May 2006 until the expiry of his most recent permit on 19 April 2016 – Director of the Fair Work Building Industry Inspectorate (Director) notified of the lodgement of the application – Director elected to exercise his right under s.72 of the Fair Work (Building Industry) Act 2012 to make submissions in relation to the matter – Director opposed the issue of an entry permit to Mr Graauwmans – declaration from CFMEU disclosed a number of court or Commission proceedings involving Mr Graauwmans – whether Mr Graauwmans a fit and proper person – decisions in White v CFMEU and ABCC v Graauwmans must be given considerable weight in the consideration of Mr Graauwmans’ fitness and propriety – White v CFMEU involved the organisation of and engagement in unlawful industrial action for coercive purposes – ABCC v Graauwmans involved the organisation of unlawful industrial action – both matters were indicative of an unwillingness on Mr Graauwmans’ part at the time to comply with industrial laws – held that the passage of time since these contraventions occurred (in White v CFMEU the conduct was in 2008, and in ABCC v Graauwmans it was in 2010) and the fact that they did not involve any breach of right of entry requirements meant that the two matters cannot by themselves be given decisive weight against the conclusion that Mr Graauwmans is a fit and proper person under s.512 of FW Act – however they remain matters of significant concern given that Mr Graauwmans has never expressed any contrition for his conduct or even demonstrated any real understanding that he contravened industrial laws – most alarming aspect of his evidence was that he did not recall, and perhaps has never actually known, that penalties were imposed upon him in both matters – findings made against Mr Graauwmans in DFWBII v CFMEU are relevant matters which must be assigned significant weight – at three Lend Lease worksites on 1 April 2014, Mr Graauwmans misused his entry rights – failed to comply with basic right of entry obligations such as the provision of notice, the production of his entry permit on request, and the refusal to leave the sites where right of entry had not properly been exercised – Commission concluded that Mr Graauwmans would be a fit and proper person to be issued with an entry permit that was subject to conditions that served to emphasise the need for him to comply with the relevant requirements of Part 3-4 of the FW Act, allowed his compliance to be monitored by the Director, and placed the continuance of his permit at risk if he failed to do so – parties provided with an opportunity to make submissions before Commission makes any final orders. Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union – Robert Graauwmans

MODERN AWARDS – 4 yearly review – plain language – s.156 Fair Work Act 2009 – Commission intends to undertake further plain language re-drafting of modern awards as part of the 4 yearly review of modern awards (the Review) – has undertaken a Plain language modern award pilot (the Pilot) to produce a plain language draft of the Pharmacy Industry Award 2010 – has adopted a plain language drafting approach to new provisions developed as part of the Review – during the Pilot the Commission has been mindful of the need to treat award-specific terms in a different way to general terms which have broader application across modern awards – initial guidelines for plain language re-drafting developed as part of the Pilot – guidelines will be a reference for further plain language re-drafting undertaken as part of the Review – will be published for comment from interested persons before the end of 2016 – interested persons invited to comment on proposed process and indicative timetable by 4.00 pm on Friday, 29 July 2016. 4 yearly review of modern awards – Plain language