ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – application to deal with a dispute under Thiess Curragh Mine Enterprise Agreement 2013 (2013 Agreement) – dispute related to selection for redundancy of a member of the applicant – respondent brought jurisdictional objection on account that dispute related to ex-employee; was not initiated while employee was employed; and because dispute had not been initiated in accordance with 2013 Agreement – Commission to determine whether employee initiated dispute in accordance with clause 7 of 2013 Agreement – following a meeting with the respondent regarding the redundancy, the employee’s employment ended on 5 November 2015, shortly before applicant filed a dispute with Commission on his behalf on 17 November 2015 – respondent asserted plain meaning of 2013 Agreement required any dispute about redundancy be referred immediately to the Commission and any dispute initiated must be made by a party to the 2013 Agreement – respondent outlined as applicant lodged application with the Commission 12 days after the employee’s employment had ceased, the Commission had no jurisdiction to deal with dispute – in the alternative, respondent claimed meeting between employee and respondent cannot be considered to have been initiation of dispute based on nature, tone and content of discussions – applicant submitted dispute was initiated by employee either questioning redundancy or once agreement could not be reached regarding the redundancy prior to cessation of employee’s employment – Commission did not accept clause 7.3 of 2013 Agreement should be read so that a dispute cannot be found to have been initiated by an employee before an application was made to Commission for resolution of that dispute – Commission further outlined a dispute under clause 7 could be initiated before an application was made to Commission and a former employee who put his or her selection for redundancy in issue before employment ceased had initiated a dispute and could make an application to the Commission after that time – determined employee did put issue of his selection for redundancy in dispute prior to end of employment – Commission found to have jurisdiction to deal with applicant’s application under s.739 FW Act – jurisdictional objection dismissed – matter to be listed so Directions can be issued in relation to it. Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v Thiess P/L
August 12, 2016
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – dispute whether applicant who has less than 12 months continuous service entitled to paid parental leave pursuant to clause 27.5, and specifically, clause 27.5.3, of the City of Wanneroo Salaried Officers Collective Enterprise Agreement 2012 (the Agreement) – applicant submitted he was entitled one week’s paid leave even though he had not completed a year’s continuous service – applicant submitted he was entitled to leave as supervisor initially approved application for one weeks’ leave and plain words of clause enable him to take one weeks’ paid parental leave – respondent asserts applicant was advised of reasons for rejection of application for leave and it has consistently applied the Agreement such that the qualifying service requirement of 12 months must be achieved before any employee is entitled to take paid parental leave – Golden Cockerel considered – Commission not satisfied the Agreement established an entitlement to one weeks’ leave pursuant to clause 27.5 .3 for applicant – not satisfied the approval process adopted by the City was such that, notwithstanding that the Agreement does not provide for access to one weeks’ paid leave in his circumstances, that leave should be granted in these circumstances – clause 27.5.3 provides for an entitlement to paid parental leave which is constrained by a requirement for a minimum period of 12 months continuous service. Truong v City of Wanneroo
August 12, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – performance – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant dismissed in February – respondent did not attend the hearing however contended that the applicant was negative and failed to follow implemented processes after being shown how to do the work – applicant and respondent had numerous meetings prior to her dismissal with the last meeting being held in December – Commission did not consider that the applicant’s performance and conduct in January and February was unsatisfactory to warrant the termination of her employment – at the time of the applicant’s dismissal there was no valid reason for the dismissal – Commission found that applicant’s dismissal was harsh, unjust and unreasonable – applicant sought reinstatement – appropriate to issue an order that the applicant be reinstated – order also that respondent pay the applicant the amount of remuneration lost as a result of her dismissal – order to maintain the continuity of the applicant’s employment also considered appropriate – separate order to be issued giving effect to the decision. McPartland v Degree Refrigeration P/L t/a Weston Family Trust
August 12, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – high income threshold – ss.382, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – jurisdictional objection – respondent submitted applicant earned in excess of the high income threshold – not protected by unfair dismissal legislation – applicant submitted he was performing the duties of a plant operator and as such he was covered by either the Guma ICRG JV P/L Base Enterprise Agreement 2013 (Agreement) or the Building and Construction General On-Site Award (Award), thus he was protected by unfair dismissal legislation – respondent submitted in response that the applicant was employed as a supervisor and therefore the Award or Agreement did not apply – further submitted he was not employed as a plant operator and any plant operator duties he performed were in breach of his position responsibilities – Commission first considered the ‘principal purpose’ test in McMenemy to determine what position the applicant was employed in at the time of dismissal – considered evidence from both parties – held at the time of dismissal applicant was engaged principally to perform the role of supervisor – Commission then considered whether the Agreement or Award would cover a supervisor – held Agreement classifications do not include the role of supervisor – applicant not covered by Agreement – held Award does not cover employees who are employed as supervisors or on a supervisory level – applicant not covered by Award – applicant not protected by unfair dismissal legislation – jurisdictional objection upheld – application dismissed. Matera v Guma ICRG JV P/L
August 12, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – national system employer – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant initially employed by Nestle Australia – signed a new contract of employment with Nestle (PNG) Ltd (Nestle PNG) – place of work located in Port Moresby PNG – applicant claimed unfair dismissal by Nestle Australia – respondent objected to the application and claimed applicant was employed by Nestle PNG – contended that applicant was not a national system employee – Commission found that applicant was employed by Nestle PNG which was a foreign corporation – Commission held that Nestle PNG was not a national system employer – application dismissed. Hatherall v Nestle Oceania t/a Nestle Australia Ltd
August 11, 2016
Six of today’s 29 labour dispute cases involve Patrick Projects Pty Ltd. The full Fair Work Commission hearing list today is: Bunnings Building Supplies Pty Ltd (Collins), Patrick Projects Pty Ltd (Deeney, Hughes, King, Park, Seiffert, Strauss), Citywide Service Solutions (Stone), Australian Broadcasting Corporation (Cafe & Himmelhoch-Mutton), CMIB Insurance Services P/L (Finemore), McDonalds – Balwyn (Mazzocca), Kitty Burns (Cooper), Straightline Excavators Pty Ltd (Narce, Jr), Tomizone Limited (Wu), APW Espresso Pty Ltd (Avery), Specialist Diagnostic Services Pty Ltd (Moore), The Jewellery Group Pty Ltd (Tsilivis), The Game Sports Bar (Sheridan), ACT Government as represented by the Health Directorate (Richardson), UPA Murray River Region (Watts), The University of Newcastle (Wilks), Broken Hill Operations Pty Ltd (Remmert), Pizzata Direct Pty Ltd (Imondi), The War Veterans’ Home Myrtle Bank Incorporated (Williamson), Serco Group Pty Ltd (Ruiterman), Southport Australian Rules Football Club Ltd (Maric), ISS Security Pty Ltd (Bennett), Ludowici Sealing Solutions Pty Ltd (Koulouris), Len Smith Carpet Court (McInnes).
August 11, 2016
An application for approval of the Proficient Fire Protection Pty Ltd Sprinkler Fitters Enterprise Agreement 2016-2019 (s.185 – Application for approval of a single-enterprise agreement) as well as an application for approval of the Specialist Electrical Engineering Group Pty Ltd (SEEG) Enterprise Agreement – 2016/2019 – Regional Queensland Minor Works (s.185 – Application for approval of a single-enterprise agreement) will both be heard by Fair Work Commissioner Cirkovic in his Hobart chambers.
August 10, 2016
Sixty unfair dismissal cases will absorb the Fair Work Commission today. One cluster involves 26 ex-employees of Skilled Offshore (Australia) Pty Ltd. The full list is: Metro Trains (Kaur), Ambulance Victoria (Davis), Skilled Offshore (Australia) Pty Ltd (Ainsworth, Byrne, Chisholm, Creely, Crumlin, Dennison, Gillis, Hicks, Kapperer, Keane, Latta, Leary, Macdonald, McCabe, McGregor, McKenzie, McPherson, Moreno, Olsson, Pitt, Raumati, Scott, Smith, Tate, Watson, Willis), Compass Group Australia Pty Ltd (Kapeli), Patrick Projects Pty Ltd (Deeney, Hughes, King, Park, Seiffert, Strauss), Hutt Street Centre (Sorrell), Commonwealth Department of Prime Minister and Cabinet & Stokes (Hall), G4S Custodial Services Pty Ltd (Doran), Amritsar Solutions Pty Ltd (Forkes), The University of Newcastle (Wilks), Marist Youth Care Limited (Magirazi), Limestone Coast Health Unit Trust (Paltridge), MMG Australia Ltd (Harvey), Salon Inspired Hair & Beauty (Hockley), Toyota Motor Corporation Australia Ltd (Abarra, Tainsh), Bendigo Health Care Group (Logan), NSW Trains (Ayub), Anglican Care (Charles), Sydney Night Patrol & Inquiry Co Pty Ltd (Palm), Sydney Water Corporation (Peterski), Toll Holdings Limited (White), Cardno Geotech Pty Ltd (Kek), Temples (WA) Pty Ltd (Bayley), Citic Pacific Mining Management Pty Limited (Kong), Hutt Street Centre (Sorrell), Brewarrina Business Coop Limited (Eastwood), Laverty Pathology (Pasion), Titan Plant Hire (Van Malsen), Electricity Networks Corporation (Townsley).