NEWS HR

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – contract for specified term – termination at initiative of employer – ss.386, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – applicant’s employment ended on 1 April 2016 – jurisdictional objection raised by respondent – employment related to the running of a Family Reunification House in Cairns – respondent determined it would employ employees for a specified term of an initial 12 months – evidence from respondent that applicant informed during interview regarding the role being for this period – position description included in the documentation given to applicant stated employment status as ‘Full Time Fixed Term until 1 March 2016’ – due to employment not commencing until 30 March 2015, letter of engagement later amended the period nominated as 30 March 2015 to April 2016 – in early 2016 issues arose regarding the staffing structure that were discussed at a staff meeting in February 2016 – at further meeting in March 2016, applicant told her contract would not be renewed – applicant submitted she was shocked by this, as she had understood her employment beyond 1 April 2016 could be part-time or casual – necessary for Commission to determine whether terms provided a clear and unambiguous fixed period of time – advertisement for position made no mention of employment being for a fixed period ending on a certain date – position description held to be merely a reference document – letter of engagement also contained terms that were unsuitable for a fixed term contract, including termination and remuneration clauses – Commission held that clear words are necessary to satisfy the test that employment entered into by parties for a fixed term – due to ambiguity in such documents as the contract of employment, Commission adopted the decision in Carr v Blade Repairs Australia P/L (No 2) – held that the evidence demonstrated a reasonable person in the circumstances, having read the letter of engagement, would not have considered it to be a fixed term contract – jurisdictional objection dismissed. Fraser v Act for Kids

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – Small Business Fair Dismissal Code – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – applicant summarily dismissed for failing to carry out obligations with respect to maintenance of a work vehicle – vehicle broke down while on a highway – police issued infringement notice to driver for failing to provide other road users with appropriate notice of the hazard – fact that respondent a small business not contested – Small Business Fair Dismissal Code (the Code) requires employer be reasonably satisfied of serious misconduct to justify summary dismissal – no suggestion of theft, fraud or violence – Commission must be satisfied of serious breaches of occupational health and safety procedures – Commission satisfied applicant was neglectful in maintenance duties reasonably expected of him, but conduct did not constitute a serious breach of occupational health and safety procedures – not satisfied respondent believed on reasonable grounds that applicant’s conduct was sufficiently serious to justify summary dismissal – Code permits termination if employer has warned applicant of risk of termination if performance or conduct does not improve – applicant’s poor attitude to vehicle maintenance constituted valid reason for a warning – applicant was warned that improvements were required or disciplinary action would follow, but no suggestion of termination was made – Commission not satisfied dismissal in accordance with Code – while valid reason for termination existed relating to applicant’s conduct, termination was harsh, unjust and unreasonable – ordered compensation of $3,534.00, subject to taxation. Vieritz v YEO & CO. P/L

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – Small Business Fair Dismissal Code – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant a casual employee – employed in regular and systematic work – employer was a small business employer – applicant warned three times – respondent contended applicant was a casual employee and the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code (the Code) had been complied with – first warning for swearing at co-worker – second warning for disrespecting a co-worker – third warning for leaving work early with permission as unwell – respondent believed this was because applicant did not like the person she was working with – applicant contented third warning was not valid as she had permission to leave the workplace – applicant subsequently applicant ignored a direction by the respondent not to transport a co-worker to the workplace in private vehicle – respondent said this was the ‘straw that broke the camel’s back’ – respondent met with applicant – confirmed she had driven the co-worker to work – respondent then told applicant that based on work performance he had lost confidence in her and he would ‘let her go’ – Commission preferred applicant’s evidence – found third warning not substantiated – found other conduct did not amount to serious misconduct – no connection between private travel and the employment relationship – dismissal not consistent with the Code – found dismissal unfair – compensation of $2760 ordered. Bronakowski v Balanced Habitats

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – high income threshold – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant’s annual earnings exceeded the high income threshold – employed as Drill and Blast Engineer in open cut mining operations – respondent submitted applicant not covered by award – Kucks v CSR Ltd considered re construing an award – Black Coal Award 2010 the relevant award – Schedules A and B set out classes of work – relatively senior staff employees have traditionally been covered by awards in the black coal mining industry – history of professional occupations being covered by awards as early as 1945 – Black Coal Award was intended to ‘neither expand nor contract the reach of the key pre-reform awards (to) the extent to which the awards apply to such employers’ – consideration of applicants lack of formal engineering qualifications – Commission held principal purpose of applicant’s role supervisory – qualifications not required – consideration of Foreperson and Senior Foreperson classifications in the award – applicant in relatively senior role – satisfied applicant covered by Black Coal Award – not employed as Engineer or Open-Cut Overseer – jurisdictional objection dismissed. Todd v Whitehaven Coal Mining Limited t/a Tarrawonga Open Cut Coal Mine

ANTI-BULLYING – likely to continue – ss.587, 789FC Fair Work Act 2009 – application for order to stop bullying – alleged bullying behaviour resolved by respondent complying with recommendations – applicant initially accepted outcome then subsequently refused to accept matter resolved – applicant requested matter proceed to arbitration – respondent made application to have matter dismissed under s.587 due to applicant’s extended absence from work and respondent’s commitment which resolved alleged bullying behaviour – no basis to find any risk that applicant may bullied in future – meaning of ‘no reasonable prospect of success’ considered – the question of prospect may give rise to different answers depending on timing [Shaw v ANZ] – difficult to demonstrate future risk requirement [G.C] – held applicant’s case may have initially had some prospect of success but given respondent’s compliance with recommendation and commitment to restrict contact between applicant and individuals involved there was no further prospect of applicant being bullied or harassed – found no reasonable prospect of success – application dismissed. Lokteeva v Woolworths Limited and Ors

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – genuine redundancy – ss.389, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – respondent objected on grounds of genuine redundancy – Commission held employer failed to meet major change consultation requirement under Vehicle Manufacturing, Repair Services and Retail Award 2010 – did not discuss measure to mitigate adverse effect of change – found dismissal not genuine redundancy – held dismissal unfair – failure to consult at critical time when considering whether job was redundant made decision to dismiss unreasonable – reinstatement not appropriate – ordered compensation of $936.98 plus 9.5% compensation. Simpson v KAP Motors P/L t/a Kerry’s Automotive group

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – varying agreement – s.210 Fair Work Act 2009 – application by Veolia Environmental Services (Australia) P/L for variation of the Veolia Environmental Services (Australia) P/L Cooper Basin Enterprise Agreement 2014-2017 – variation agreed with employees – Australian Workers’ Union and Australian Manufacturing Workers’ Union covered by agreement and each indicated they opposed the application – whether agreement of employees genuine – whether proper process followed – whether copy of agreement with variations and any incorporated terms provided to employees – whether undertaking given in original proceedings retained – whether union marginalised – whether coercion or unreasonable pressure – whether outcome of the ballot unclear due to question posed – whether BOOT satisfied – whether serious public interest grounds to refuse approval – KCL considered – genuine agreement found – statutory requirements met – variation approved with undertakings. Veolia Environmental Services (Australia) P/L Cooper Basin Enterprise Agreement 2014-2017

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – employee organisation coverage – s.185 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for approval of MMAOL Pty Ltd Enterprise Agreement 2016 (MMAOL Agreement) pursuant to s.185 of FW Act on 4 May 2016 – Maritime Union of Australia requested to participate in proceedings, contending it had evidence to support that the group of employees to be covered by the MMAOL Agreement was not fairly chosen – Commission requested materials and oral evidence from MUA to support contention – hearing to admit materials and evidence from MUA held on 18 July 2016 – further decision on whether MUA should be heard in relation to Commission’s approval of MMAOL Agreement – MUA had standing to be heard in relation to approval of proposed MMAOL Agreement pursuant to s.590 which Commission adopted in view of the written submissions – applicant is subsidiary of MMA Offshore Limited – MUA currently engaged in bargaining on replacement enterprise agreement with another subsidiary, MMA Vessel Operations P/L (MMAVO) – concerned that proposed MMAOL Agreement will deny MMAVO employees opportunity to bargain, reduce MMAVO workforce in favour of employment through MMAOL and request/require employees to accept employment with MMAOL – contended the way in which applicant made agreement was for purpose of excluding MUA from negotiations and denying those to be covered by MMAOL Agreement of collective bargaining representation by union and protected action – questioned whether there were legitimate business reasons for making the MMAOL Agreement – Commission felt real issue is MUA did not want MMAOL to choose any employees for purpose of making any enterprise agreement in view of its current bargaining with MMAVO where it holds bargaining representative role – detected MUA were concerned with consequences for MMAVO employees should MMAOL Agreement be approved – Commission not inclined to presume what may or may not happen with respect to employees of another entity should MMAOL Agreement be approved – therefore, MUA’s further participation in proceedings not necessary – role of Commission is to approve proposed enterprise agreement if it meets legislative requirements, not to restrict ability of applicant to make enterprise agreement – no guaranteed right for MUA to be bargaining representative in all bargaining involving its members – Commission satisfied it can proceed to determination application for approval of MMAOL Agreement without further participation of MUA. MMA Offshore Logistics P/L t/a MMA Offshore Logistics