NEWS HR

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – dispute about selection and consultation in relation to redundancy of AMWU shop steward – AMWU filed application for Commission to deal with dispute in accordance with Disputes Resolution Procedure of The Longford Gas Conditioning Plant Project Construction Agreement 2013 between CBI Constructors P/L and the AMWU, AWU, CEPU and CFMEU – dispute concerned downsizing of CBI workforce and dismissal of shop steward by way of redundancy – contended by CBI that Commission lacked jurisdiction to deal with dispute – CBI submitted the subject matter was not one that could be dealt with under clause 15, mandatory procedural steps for attempting to resolve the dispute had not been followed, and the filing of the application after dismissal meant the Commission lacked jurisdiction – held that AWMU followed procedure under clause 15 by raising the dispute at the appropriate workplace level – also held that once it was informed that CBI did not consider the subject matter of the dispute one to which clause 15 applied, it was reasonable and proper for AMWU to refer the unresolved matter to the Commission – Commission satisfied the matter one which arose under the agreement, due to AMWU informing CBI of a dispute regarding the pending termination of the shop steward while they were still employed – authorities are clear that where a dispute arises before an employee is terminated the Commission can deal with it even when the application is filed after dismissal takes effect – held that application is within the jurisdiction of the Commission and the Commission should exercise its jurisdiction to deal with the dispute. ‘Automotive, Food, Metals, Engineering, Printing and Kindred Industries Union’ known as the Australian Manufacturing Workers’ Union (AMWU) v CBI Constructors P/L t/a CB&I

CASE PROCEDURES – evidence – production of documents – ss.394, 590 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant dismissed for serious misconduct based on allegations of sexual harassment toward a number of crew members – applicant sought production of documents on 10 and 11 May 2016 – respondent objected to order being made with respect to documents in 1, 3 and 4 based on legal privilege – further submitted that order for documents was nothing more than a ‘fishing expedition’ – both parties agreed that principles set out in [Commissioner of Taxation v Pratt Holdings P/L] applied – ‘if the dominant purpose for which a document comes into existence is to get legal advice, the document is privileged, and the time at which ‘dominant purpose is determined is the time the document came into existence’ – in exercising its discretionary power in s.590(1) FW Act, the Commission must do so in a manner which is fair, just and quick, informal and avoids unnecessary technicalities’ – Commission found from material provided by parties, applicant terminated due to his conduct – found applicant terminated following investigation into various allegations – applicant confined order only to the investigation which led to his dismissal – Commission found request for documents not a ‘fishing expedition’ but appropriately narrow and relevant to dismissal – considered whether documents attracted legal advice privilege as per [Pratt] – found that documents created had to be created regardless of any intention to seek advice – also found that may have been some parts of those documents that were only created for purpose of receiving legal advice – Commission found in first instance, documents in 1, 3 and 4 to be provided to Commission unredacted – Commission will subsequently determine whether part or all attract legal professional privilege. Applicant v Respondent

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant’s employment terminated due to serious misconduct – respondent raised four allegations against applicant – allegation one and two related to sale and discounting of shoes – allegation three related to breach of layby policy – allegation four related to falsification of time keeping records – applicant asserted dismissal was unreasonable because he was given insufficient notification of the allegations and lured into a meeting by deliberate deceit on the part of his managers – further asserted dismissal was unjust because evidence did not support finding that the applicant had engaged in deliberate criminality, but rather he had failed to process funds in a manner which represented an aberration – respondent asserted applicant was given details of allegations and was provided with full opportunity to respond both at the meeting of 21 September, and a further meeting held on 9 October 2015 – respondent further asserted applicant’s conduct constituted serious misconduct – Commission found only one of respondent’s allegations of serious misconduct could be sustained – employer’s finding of serious misconduct in respect to the allegation regarding applicant failing to properly record and receipt the cash provided in respect to the purchase of the New Balance shoes established valid reason for the dismissal of the applicant – however the manifestly erroneous approach adopted by the employer when dealing with what has subsequently been established to be both serious misconduct and significantly less serious misdemeanours meant that there was no proper basis on which to summarily dismiss the applicant – dismissal found to be unreasonable and unjust – compensation issued. Jimenez v Accent Group t/a Platypus Shoes (Australia) P/L

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – notice of representational rights – ss.174(1A), 185 Fair Work Act 2009 – Sched 2.1 Fair Work Regulations 2009 – application for approval of Melbourne Polytechnic Professional Administrative Clerical Computing and Technical Staff Agreement 2016 made by Melbourne Polytechnic – whether a valid Notice of Employee Representational Rights (Notice) was given to relevant employees – Notice issued to employees proposed to be covered by agreement replaced of the words ‘please speak to either your employer….’ under the heading ‘Questions?’ to ‘please speak to Joy Drever Ext. 1261….’ – parties conceded the Notice differed from the version in Schedule 2.1 of the Regulations – argued that the Commission had a discretion to find a Notice that deviated from Schedule 2.1 valid in circumstances where the deviation was ‘minor, insignificant and immaterial’ [AMOU] and [DP World Melbourne] – contended that the mere inclusion of Ms Drever’s name and contact number did not change the intent or effect of the language in the version of the Notice prescribed by the Regulations and indeed was more helpful than simply using the word ’employer’ – Peabody considered – Commission found the Notice did not conform with s.174(1A)(a) of FW Act – consistent with Peabody, Commission found the Notice was invalid and therefore no Notice as required by the FW Act was given – failure to issue a complying Notice meant the application for approval of the agreement must fail – application dismissed. Melbourne Polytechnic Professional Administrative Clerical Computing and Technical Staff Agreement 2016

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – contract for specified term – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant filed an application – respondent asserted that the Commission had no jurisdiction to deal with it – applicant was not dismissed – respondent claimed contract of employment ended at the end of the specified term – applicant’s first engagement commenced with a fixed term contract for the period 22 February 2010 to 14 April 2010 – comprised of sixteen discrete periods up until 5 March 2016 – fixed terms contracts, interspersed with periods of casual and ongoing employment – applicant only worked consecutive periods covered by fixed term contracts once, from 15 January 2012 to 21 April 2012 – respondent submitted applicant did not perform work after 5 March 2016 – respondent wrote to applicant – asserted applicant’s fixed term contract commencing 10 January 2016 expired on 5 March 2016 – he was no longer employed by it – contract from 10 January 2016 to 5 March 2016 was confirmed via email on 23 March 2016 – rosters are prepared six weeks in advance – respondent denied making verbal offers of extending fixed term contract – but paid additional 80 hour payment addition to the payment of accrued entitlements on 19 March 2016 due to an administrative error as his name appeared on the roster – respondent submitted that it was common practice for fixed term contracts to be offered and extended on a ‘verbal basis’ – also if fixed term contracts were not extended, they fall into a casual pool – on or around the 16 February 2016, he was informed that he was suspended with pay, pending the outcome of an investigation of alleged misconduct said to have occurred the day before – Commission satisfied that there was an oral contract between the parties in existence which commenced on 10 January 2016 – had a termination date of 5 March 2016, which was not confirmed in writing until after 5 March 2016 – Full Bench makes clear in Lunn, regardless of applicant’s expectations at the termination of the contract in terms of automatic ongoing employment – does not permit conclusion that there was a common intention that the contract he and the respondent entered into was not to terminate on 5 March 2016 – contract of employment between the parties was for a specified period of time, once it reached its end date of 5 March 2016, the contract of employment terminated through the effluxion of time – there was no termination on the respondent’s initiative – Commission found applicant has not been dismissed, so application was dismissed. Margetts v Department of Justice and Regulation t/a Corrections Victoria

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – extension of time – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – unfair dismissal application lodged 28 days late – whether ‘exceptional circumstances’ [Nulty] – applicant’s grandmother, with whom applicant had a special bond, died day after dismissal – applicant was also dealing with a stressful custody battle, financial hardship and house sale – no medical evidence confirming degree of incapacity or duration – applicant mistakenly believed time limit was 28 days – well established that ignorance of timeframe is not exceptional circumstance – Commission not satisfied applicant had provided reasonable explanation for delay – applicant’s circumstances, while undoubtedly distressing and significant for him, were not out of the ordinary course, unusual, special or uncommon and he has not provided a reasonable explanation for the whole of the delay – not satisfied there were exceptional circumstances – extension of time refused – application dismissed. Corunna v BHP Billiton Iron Ore P/L t/a BHP Iron Ore

TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – Small Business Fair Dismissal Code – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – respondent a small business – respondent objected on basis dismissal consistent with Small Business Fair Dismissal Code (Code) – summary dismissal aspect of Code considered in Ryman – inconsistencies in key aspects of applicant’s evidence – employer dismissed employee for lying – employer genuinely held belief applicant’s conduct warranted immediate dismissal – respondent carried out reasonable investigation of matter – found dismissal consistent with Code – application dismissed. Chimlum v Phoenix Combat Sports P/L t/a Phoenix Gym

ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – ss.604, 739 Fair Work Act 2009 – appeal – Full Bench – at first instance the Commission found appellant had employed 35 teachers on a fixed-term basis in contravention of clause 9.6 of the Monash College Proprietary College Ltd (Monash University Foundation Year Teaching Staff) Agreement 2012 (Agreement) – NTEIU v University of Melbourne followed – found that had the appellant not employed the teachers on fixed-term contracts they would have been employed on on-going contracts – found parties should consult to give effect to this determination – appellant sought to appeal the decision – submitted the Commission erred in finding the teachers were not permitted to be appointed on fixed-term contracts and erred in finding the college would have employed the teachers on an ongoing basis had fixed-term contracts not been available – submitted the determination was without precedent and beyond power and alternatively the discretion to make the order was miscarried – respondent submitted the Commission had not acted beyond power and the determination was the application of the agreement and standard dispute resolution process – parties only obligation was to consult to give effect to her determination – further submitted the Commission correctly assumed the College required the 35 teachers to perform work and would have employed them on ongoing contracts if fixed term contracts were not available – Full Bench granted permission to appeal – held appeal raises important questions concerning the interpretation of enterprise agreements in circumstances where the Commission’s discretion to alter existing employment contracts is an issue in the dispute – Commission’s approach to enterprise agreements in the public interest – Full Bench then considered the appeal – House v The King cited – held the weight of evidence from the appellant did not support the Commission’s contention that the appellant would have employed the 35 teachers on an on-going basis had fixed-term contracts not been available – error made in accordance with House v King – further held the determination at first instance retrospectively altered the contracts of the 35 teachers – NTEIU v University of Melbourne does not support the determination and there is no power in the FW Act or Agreement to have made it – held no jurisdiction to make initial determination which was another House v King error – Commission did not properly exercise the discretion vested in the Commission – appeal upheld – decision quashed. Appeal by Monash College P/L against decision of Bissett C of 6 June 2016 [[2016] FWC 3538] Re: Independent Education Union of Australia