TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – ss.394, 400, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – appeal – Full Bench – at first instance, Commission not satisfied that dismissal harsh, unjust or unreasonable – during employment, respondent issued appellant with three warnings concerning drug use in the workplace – appellant engaged in drug rehabilitation program and was informed that repeat offences would result in dismissal – appellant was dismissed as a result of a car accident – after investigation, respondent concluded that appellant had consumed synthetic cannabis prior to or during journey home from work – appellant raised nine grounds of appeal – at the core of the dispute was whether an alleged admission made to police should have been regarded in evidence – at the time of the accident, appellant allegedly admitted to police that he had used ‘synthetic cannabis’ – appellant relied on Pfitzner principle and submitted that Watson VP erred by not taking such common law principle into consideration – appellant argued that at the time he allegedly made the admission he was incapable of exercising a sensible judgement about whether or not he should make a statement to the police – Pfitzner principle reflected in Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) and applies in criminal law proceedings – appellant argued should apply in unfair dismissal as it is a principle that guides a ‘fact finding exercise’ – Full Bench rejected such contention – Full Bench of the view that Pfitzner ‘founded on protection of rights of accused persons in criminal law proceedings’ – no application in unfair dismissal proceedings – appeal dismissed. Appeal by Wright against decision of Watson VP of 11 May 2016 [[2016] FWC 1941] Re: AGL Loy Yang P/L
August 12, 2016
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – ambiguity or uncertainty – ss.217, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – appeal – Full Bench – the appellant had brought court proceedings against the respondent in relation to the application of a clause in the MSS Security Enterprise Agreement (QLD) 2011-2014 and the MSS Security Aviation QLD Enterprise Agreement 2014-2017 – respondent made an application to vary the agreements to address the uncertainty – both terms varied – application for permission to appeal this decision made – appellant submitted that the respondent did not have grounds to make the application to vary and that the Commission did not have jurisdiction to determine it on the basis that the agreements had ceased to apply – permission to appeal granted on this issue – Commission considered that when the application was made there were still some employees covered by the agreements and as such the application was made validly – appeal dismissed on this ground – appellant also submitted that there was no uncertainty or ambiguity in the clauses – further submitted that if there was uncertainty in the clauses then the variation should have been to establish the appellant’s interpretation of the clauses – permission to appeal refused in relation to these grounds. Appeal by United Voice against decision of Sams DP of 23 May 2016 [[2016] FWCA 2774] Re: MSS Security P/L t/a MSS Security
August 12, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – termination at initiative of employer – ss.394, 400, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – at first instance Commission dismissed appellant’s application for relief from unfair dismissal – held that appellant not ‘dismissed’ within meaning of FW Act – appellant sought permission to appeal Commission’s decision – submitted that Commission mischaracterised events surrounding cessation of her employment – that there was agreement for respondent to treat termination as resignation in its consequences – that initial termination by respondent, although subsequently revoked, cannot be separated from the resignation as it was the initiating and operative factor leading to cessation of appellant’s employment – test under s. 400 is a ‘stringent one’ [Coal & Allied Mining Services] – whether permission to appeal is in public interest [GlaxoSmithKline] – whether arguable case of appealable error is demonstrated – Full Bench satisfied that Commission’s conclusion was available on the evidence – appellant had ample opportunity but failed to make submissions regarding alternative conclusion – public interest not enlivened – permission to appeal refused. Appeal by Cozaris against decision and order of Gooley DP of 28 April 2016 [[2016] FWC 2596] and [PR579431] Re: Emirates
August 12, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – termination at initiative of employer – ss.394, 400, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – at first instance the Commission found the appellant had resigned voluntarily from her employment with the respondent and dismissed her application – appellant’s representative submitted the decision manifested an injustice and the legal principles applied by the Commission were disharmonious when compared with other recent decisions of the Commission dealing with similar matters – asserted errors of jurisdiction, errors of law and significant errors of fact – submitted that the overwhelming weight of evidence supported a finding that the appellant’s resignation was forced upon her – Full Bench held the submissions from the appellant’s representative regarding the jurisdiction of the Commission were misconceived – a number of issues are dealt with by the Commission prior to a merits arbitration hearing – Full Bench unable to identify any error of the kind outlined in House v King – can identify no significant or other error of fact in the decision at first instance – appellant unhappy with the outcome of her application – satisfied the conclusions in relation to the alleged constructive dismissal of the appellant were available to the Commission on the evidence – not satisfied there is any public interest in granting permission to appeal – permission to appeal refused. Appeal by Reynolds against decision and order of Roberts C of 13 April 2016 [[2016] FWC 1187] and [PR577340] Re: Highfields Preparatory and Kindergarten School Ltd t/a Highfields
August 12, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – ss.394, 400, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – appellant contended Commission erred in finding there was a valid reason for dismissal – the applicant also contended that the finding in paragraph [86] was a significant error of fact as to the purpose and intent of the letter sent to the applicant on 6 March 2014 – the applicant contends that the Decision was appealable at law because it was not reasonable to conclude on the basis of the facts found that were was a valid reason for dismissal – the applicant also asserted the Commission erred in law because the respondent did not have a valid reason to dismiss the applicant and as the respondent failed to take any action against the applicant for the incident discussed therefore condoned the behaviour and/or waived its rights in relation to it – Commission did not consider that an arguable case of appealable error had been established – Commission does not accept there was any denial of procedural fairness – not satisfied that it is in the public interest to grant permission to appeal – permission to appeal refused. Appeal by Aitken against order of Clancy DP of 29 April 2016 [PR579733] Re: CUB P/L
August 12, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – performance – ss.394, 400, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – appellant sought to appeal unfair dismissal remedy compensation of $17,392.96 – appellant did not appear in original matter – Full Bench satisfied appellant was provided opportunity to file submissions and attend hearing – uncooperative and tardy in appeal application – consistent with original application – ground of appeal no merit – submission self-serving – no error of fact or law put – no failure to provide procedural fairness – not satisfied public interest in granting appeal – permission to appeal refused – employee lodged an Application for Costs and an Application for Security of Costs – pressed his application for costs at the permission to appeal hearing – Full Bench requested employee provide itemised list of costs – no list provided – costs order not granted. Appeal by WCH Services P/L t/a WCH Services against decision and order of Wilson C of 19 April 2016 [[2016] FWC 2454] and [PR579204] Re: Shortland
August 12, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – termination at initiative of employer – extension of time – ss.386, 394 of Fair Work Act 2009 – jurisdictional objection – whether applicant was terminated at the initiative of the employer – whether application lodged outside 21 days – applicant employed since 2004 – not disputed that applicant was able to work on respondent’s and others’ jobs at the same time – applicant requested assistance from FWO regarding alleged underpayments in late 2015 – applicant told respondent in November 2015 he would take a break from respondent pending resolution of entitlements dispute – respondent contended that applicant terminated subcontract at that time – told applicant that he had not been sacked – submitted that applicant withdrew this labour in November 2015 and application was out of time – Mohazab and Searle considered – Commission satisfied that applicant voluntarily ceased work in November 2015 and did not request more work from respondent until February 2016 – satisfied that respondent’s failure to respond to applicant’s request did not constitute termination at initiative of employer – applicant not dismissed as per s.386 of the Act and application does not meet requirements of s.394 of the Act – application dismissed. Zosel v The Grace Freeman Nelson Trust t/a Landsculpture Design & Construction P/L t/a Landsculpture
August 12, 2016
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – jurisdiction – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – application to deal with dispute under provisions of the ACT Public Service Education and Training Directorate (Teaching Staff) Enterprise Agreement 2011-2014 – applicant no longer employed by respondent – allegations regarding applicant’s conduct reported in September 2014 – delay in investigation – applicant’s registration with ACT Teacher Quality Institute lapsed on 31 March 2015 – registration a prerequisite to teach in the ACT – applicant submitted she was an employee at the time the misconduct procedures were commenced by respondent and she was entitled to the final stage of those procedures under the agreement – respondent submitted that applicant had no standing to bring her application in accordance with the agreement’s dispute settlement procedure as she was not an employee and had not been since February 2015 – two questions which the Commission needs to determine : whether applicant was an employee at the time she made her application and whether applicant had standing to bring her application – Commission held that as of 1 April 2015 applicant was no longer an employee of respondent – ING considered – found applicant not an employee of respondent at the time she lodged her application – Commission does not have jurisdiction to deal with application – application incompetent – application dismissed. Dayhew v ACT Government as represented by the Education and Training Directorate