TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – application to dismiss by employer – failure to prosecute application – ss.394, 587 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – filed in July 2014 – respondent in liquidation – in-principle settlement – application not formally discontinued – deed not executed – no application to relist or otherwise deal with matter – application made to list application for arbitration 15 months later after approach to statutory fund unsuccessful – application by respondent to dismiss under s.587 – Carter and Chand considered – Commission found failure to prosecute and abuse of process – appropriate and within powers to dismiss application – unfair dismissal application dismissed. Klemm v Penrice Soda Products P/L (In Liquidation)
October 11, 2016
CASE PROCEDURES – apprehension of bias – ss.394, 589 Fair Work Act 2009 – applicant’s unfair dismissal application made on 23 February 2016 – hearing dates on application’s merits rescheduled on multiple occasions – on 18 August 2016 respondent applied to have current hearing dates vacated and relisted on dates determined by the Commission in consultation with the parties due to witness availability – on 26 August 2016 Commission gave parties two options for hearing dates – Commission had ex-parte conversations with both parties on the setting of hearing dates – parties could not agree – applicant’s representative unavailable on one set of dates – respondents’ senior counsel unavailable on the other set of dates – Commission determined the hearing would be held when the respondent’s senior counsel was unavailable as all 7 witnesses could attend those dates and only 6 witnesses could attend the other set of dates – subsequently respondent applied for the Commissioner to recuse himself from the matter – submitted Commissioner has made decisions and contacted and discussed the matter with parties on an ex-parte basis which demonstrated apprehended bias – applicant submitted they had no concerns about bias, apprehended or otherwise – Commissioner used the reasonable lay observer test from Johnson v Johnson – held that given the circumstances, a reasonable lay observer would not apprehend that the Commissioner was biased – decision made was procedural and administrative to break the impasse between parties and decide when matter would be heard – no basis to conclude decision made in interlocutory proceedings against the respondent’s preferred hearing dates would repeat itself when determining the merits of the case – Commissioner to proceed and hear and determine the applicant’s application. Applicant v Respondent
October 11, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – Small Business Fair Dismissal Code – ss.388, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – respondent was small security company and objected to application on basis that dismissal consistent with Small Business Fair Dismissal Code (the Code) – applicant dismissed for serious misconduct but also given one week’s notice of termination of employment, during which he continued to work for respondent – Ryman considered – question whether dismissal can be said to have been made on basis of serious misconduct – Commission felt it difficult to accept reliance on serious misconduct in circumstances where applicant allowed to continue working with respondent for one week period after being notified of dismissal – Commission held that applicant’s alleged conduct cannot be categorised as serious misconduct within meaning of FW Act – applicant and respondent submitted different accounts of events leading up to dismissal – Commission preferred and accepted evidence of respondent – satisfied dismissal was compliant with the Code – application dismissed. Karkun v Zone Security P/L
October 11, 2016
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – dispute concerned additional work employees directed to perform by respondent – dispute arose in relation to application of various clauses of recently approved Aurizon Train Crew and Transport Operations Enterprise Agreement 2015 (the Agreement) – applicant claimed employees entitled to higher grade allowance for the time undertaking new duties – applicant claimed the use of the provisions to have additional duties undertaken for no additional payment was not agreed during negotiations – respondent argued the combination of a number of clauses provided basis for the duties to be undertaken – probative evidence in terms of requirements in Golden Cockerel required – matter unable to be conclusively determined given the significant ambiguity and uncertainty that existed in relation to dispute that potentially had broader implications for further application of the provisions in the same way – improper to determine issue without providing additional opportunity to address comparison between how employees’ duties were previously undertaken compared to the current directions, and how this issue was considered in negotiations or associated matters relevant to the intention of the use of the clauses in this manner – Commission to set further directions to deal with issue of ambiguity and ordered a listing for conference be issued. Australian Rail, Tram and Bus Industry Union v Aurizon Operations Limited
October 11, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – costs – ss.394, 400A, 401 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – original decision found that dismissal was fair and application dismissed [[2016] FWC 5282] – respondent sought costs against applicant – submitted applicant caused their costs to be incurred unreasonably by continuing to hearing where there was no reasonable prospect of success – further submitted that applicant acted unreasonably by not accepting settlement proposals – Wright considered – matters of fact to be determined in this case – Commission rejected applicant’s contention – Commission not satisfied applicant unreasonably pursued and protracted application – Commission further noted that legislation not designed to prevent applicant from defending application – application for costs dismissed. Chimlum v Phoenix Sports P/L t/a Phoenix Gym
October 11, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – minimum employment period – transfer of business – ss.384, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant employed full-time for prior employer from January 2011 to February 2016 – submitted they became a transferring employee for respondent under s.311(3) of FW Act from March 2016 – after first shift, applicant signed casual employment contract – was informed no hours available but would receive more if available in future – no further communication about work or shifts provided – applicant submitted respondent repudiated contract by no longer communicating or offering work, which he accepted by lodging application – submitted casual employment contract should be set aside due to inverse power relationship between parties and that original full-time position with prior employer had been maintained – Commission found period of service included period served with prior employer – constructive dismissal took effect day application lodged – beyond Commission’s jurisdiction to reach finding regarding redundancy and notice entitlements for period to March 2016 – applicant continued from March 2016 under casual employment contract – facts did not show applicant subject to coercion or duress or had been unaware of his interests – brief employment as a casual employee concluded for an operational reason, being unavailability of work – no valid reason based on conduct or capacity for purpose of s.387(a) of FW Act – s.387(a) not relevant consideration when employee terminated for operational reason – operational reason relevant under s.387(h) – sound and defensible reason for employer to bring employment relationship to an end [UES (Int’l) P/L] – dismissal not harsh, unjust or unreasonable – application dismissed. Nicholls v The Trustee for MJ Hooper Trust
October 11, 2016
CASE PROCEDURES – referral to Full Bench – ss.394, 615A Fair Work Act 2009 – unfair dismissal application lodged on 21 September 2015 – on 28 August 2015 applicant was notified that his employment was terminated effective from 24 September 2015 – relevance of first instance decision in Pettifer v MODEC Management Services P/L (Pettifer) – Pettifer subject to Full Bench appeal – application for unfair dismissal application to be referred to Full Bench – respondent opposed – whether in public interest to refer matter – applicant submitted likely impact of Pettifer warranted referral and Pettifer Full Bench decision ‘arguably wrong’ – Commission not satisfied referral in the public interest – s.615A of FW Act not a mechanism for reviewing decisions – applicant’s rights not adversely affected if referral application rejected– application to refer to Full Bench dismissed. Gee v Tasmanian Ports Corporation P/L t/a Tasports
October 11, 2016
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – jurisdiction – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – jurisdictional objection to application to deal with dispute under BlueScope Steel Port Kembla Steelworks Agreement 2015 – dispute concerned employee who was stood down and given final written warning – respondent objected to application as warning issued was beyond the scope of the dispute resolution procedure in cl.35.1 – AWU argued Commission authorised to deal with dispute given changes to manner in which permission to be sought for personal use of company truck constituted a workplace change under the Agreement and consultation procedures/criteria for implementation of change not complied with – in the alternative it is sufficient for part of dispute to be characterised as being about matters arising under Agreement for Commission to deal with entirety of the dispute [Hay Point Services v CFMEU] – Commission dismissed AWU’s first argument as the change described is one of normal day to day operations and therefore excluded from the workplace change clause under the Agreement – Commission considered AWU’s second argument and held issues in dispute not so disparate or disconnected dispute essentially about whether employee’s misconduct justified disciplinary action – stand down and final warning letter cannot be dissected into separate components because both arise from single substratum of facts – Agreement specifies circumstances in which respondent may stand down employee including for misconduct – respondent’s conclusion that employee misconducted himself was pre-requisite for exercise of power to stand employee down – therefore dispute about whether respondent had proper basis to conclude employee engaged in misconduct necessarily one about a matter which arises under Agreement – artificial to treat final warning letter as severable from dispute to which cl.35.1 applies as it is a manifestation of that dispute – jurisdictional objection dismissed. The Australian Workers’ Union v BlueScope Steel (AIS) P/L