TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – termination at initiative of employer – resignation – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – applicant employed as a modelmaker – respondent was a small architectural design company in Perth – operated in a very competitive market – applicant sought a performance review and salary increase in October 2014 – respondent offered two possible options – applicant replied ‘Please accept option 3. I tender my resignation effective immediately.’ – after discussions the applicant returned to work with no change to his employment contract – in September 2015 there was an incident in the model shop involving the applicant and another employee – heated verbal, almost physical, exchange – applicant given a written warning – meeting between parties – whether applicant resigned – applicant maintained he had tendered no resignation, verbally or in writing, implied or otherwise – respondent submitted applicant did resign – respondent accepted resignation and applicant’s employment was terminated at that point – Commission found applicant’s evidence repetitive, exaggerated, argumentative and self-serving – satisfied the applicant resigned, without notice, in the meeting with the respondent on 17 September 2015 – as the applicant was not dismissed at the initiative of the employer, he could not have been unfairly dismissed – Commission satisfied that if the applicant had not resigned his poor behaviour and inappropriate conduct would have justified dismissal – application dismissed for want of jurisdiction. Blythe v David Hartree Design Associates P/L t/a Hartree and Associates Architects
October 11, 2016
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – approval – notice of representational rights – s.185 Fair Work Act 2009 – application by Falcon Mining P/L for approval of the Falcon Mining P/L Enterprise Agreement 2016 – Commission held concerns about whether agreement could be approved – Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union Mining & Energy Division – Northern Mining and NSW Energy District (CFMEU) objected to approval – CFMEU was not a bargaining representative for agreement – filed a notice of representative commencing to act in respect of an employee of Falcon who would be covered by the agreement if approved – Commission decided to hear from the CFMEU pursuant to powers under s.590 of FW Act – series of errors and omissions on the part of Falcon in relation to the pre-approval process and application documents – effect of incorrect information in Notice of Employee Representational Rights (NERR) – effect of incorrect information in application documents including employer statutory declaration – requirement to take all reasonable steps to give NERR to employees – no requirement for NERR to be given to each individual employee – reasonable steps may include giving notice individually and collectively – NERR only required to be given to employees employed at the notification time – requirement to take all reasonable steps to give an explanation of the terms of the agreement and their effect to employees – other reasonable grounds for the Commission to believe that the agreement was not genuinely agreed – whether agreement contained unlawful terms – interaction between National Employment Standards (NES) and award in relation to personal/carer’s leave and public holidays – whether exclusion of NES term could be addressed by undertaking – whether agreement passed the better off overall test (BOOT) – whether undertakings required to meet Commission’s concerns about BOOT issues would result in substantial change to the agreement – approval refused. Falcon Mining P/L Enterprise Agreement 2016
October 11, 2016
ANTI-BULLYING – likely to continue – s.789FC Fair Work Act 2009 – application for order to stop bullying – applicant complained of bullying by CEO and General Manager of employer, a youth welfare organisation – applicant argued verbal harassment, unwarranted criticism by management and general discrimination – applicant was receiving worker’s compensation payments and had been on leave since anti-bullying application lodged – General Manager, one of alleged bullies, had left employer – Commission confirmed that where there is no risk that employee will continue to be bullied at work, matter should be dismissed for want of jurisdiction [Willis] – observed applicant had not been at work for 12 months and if he did return it would be to alternative supervision arrangements – applicant had not appeared at any Commission proceedings to prosecute his claim for a year – Commission found no risk that the applicant would continue to be bullied at work and matter had no reasonable prospects of success – application dismissed for want of jurisdiction. Mr Richardson
October 11, 2016
ENTERPRISE BARGAINING – protected action ballot – extension of notice period – s.437 Fair Work Act 2009 – protected action ballot orders (PABO) made in respect of applications made by AMWU and CEPU – reasons for decision – Broadspectrum (Australia) P/L opposed the making of a PABO and requested that if granted, the period of written notice be seven days, rather than three days pursuant to s.443(5) FW Act – respondent maintained that the Unions were not genuinely trying to reach an agreement – Commission not persuaded Unions were not genuinely trying to reach agreement with Broadspectrum – not satisfied exceptional circumstances existed which would warrant Broadspectrum receiving a further period of written notice. “Automotive, Food, Metals, Engineering, Printing and Kindred Industries Union” known as the Australian Manufacturing Workers’ Union (AMWU) v and Anor
October 11, 2016
ENTERPRISE AGREEMENTS – dispute about matter arising under agreement – s.739 Fair Work Act 2009 – dispute about matter arising under TW Power Services AGL Loy Yang Power Station Mechanical (AMWU & CFMEU) Enterprise Agreement 2016 – existing practice of many years where employees finishing work at 3.30pm would commence walking to exit around 3:25pm and pass through exit gate around 3.30pm – dispute arose about capacity of TW Power to bring end to existing practice and require employees to remain on site until 3.30pm – question whether existing practice was ‘over Agreement condition of employment’ – Clause 5.7 preserved existing over agreement payments and over agreement conditions of employment unless varied – Commission held existing practice not part of conditions of employment within meaning of expression in Clause 5.7 – question whether TW Power’s proposal constituted variation to usual finishing time – AMWU submitted ‘usual finishing time’ indicated common understanding as to custom and practice and Clause 13.2 operated to effect there be no change to common understanding unless agreed to by parties – Commission did not accept that ‘usual finishing time’ meant time employees were permitted to leave site – must be read and understood in context of hours of work provision – ordinary hours of work was 36 per week so ‘usual finishing time’ mandated finishing time at 3.30pm – question whether TW Power proposal constituted ‘extra claim’ – AMWU submitted that TW Power proposal amounted to extra claim for purposes of Clause 43 – Commission held that TW Power’s proposal not a claim but merely insistence that there be adherence to ordinary hours of work prescribed by Agreement – no orders made. “Automotive, Food, Metals, Engineering, Printing and Kindred Industries Union” known as the Australian Manufacturing Workers’ Union (AMWU) v TW Power Services
October 11, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – extension of time – date dismissal took effect – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – applicant and respondent alleged different dates of termination 18 days apart – if respondent’s date relied upon then application lodged 10 days outside statutory time limit – dispute as to date of termination – respondent submitted that applicant was terminated with immediate effect after meeting on 17 May 2016 – applicant paid four weeks’ pay in lieu of notice – applicant believed she had been placed on ‘garden leave’ and had to make herself available up to and including 20 June 2016 – Siagian v Sanel considered – Commission found applicant’s employment was terminated on 17 May 2016 with four weeks’ notice expiring on 14 June 2016 – held there was an agreement that applicant serve notice period as she was required to perform on-going duties in the form of a handover during this period – found respondent did not intend termination to take effect immediately – respondent tried to vary agreement but there was no mutual agreement – application filed within time and no extension of time necessary. Amanda Colledge v Bakersfield Holdings P/L atf Separovic Family Trust
October 11, 2016
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – minimum employment period – transfer of business – ss.311, 382, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – unfair dismissal application – whether minimum employment period served – three years’ service with previous employer – four months’ service with respondent – whether employment with previous employer counted as continuous service with respondent – whet her transfer of business in accordance with s.22(8)(b) of FW Act – whether a connection between old employer and respondent existed – meaning of ‘in accordance with an arrangement’ – Hillie and Zabrdac considered – Commission not satisfied of an arrangement between old employer and respondent – no evidence of connection pursuant to s.311 – no transfer of business – minimum employment period not served – application dismissed. Crossin v Tazzy Tyres Accessories P/L t/a Tazzy Tyres
October 11, 2016
MODERN AWARDS – 4 yearly review – common issues – s.156 Fair Work Act 2009 – decision finalises a number of outstanding matters in relation to the variation of annual leave terms in modern awards – should be read in conjunction with previous decisions issued on 11 June 2015 (the June 2015 decision) [[2015] FWCFB 3406], 15 September 2015 (the September 2015 decision) [[2016] FWCFB 5771], 23 May 2016 (the May 2016 decision) [[2016] FWCFB 3177] and 24 June 2016 (the June 2016 decision) [[2016] FWCFB 3953] – two categories of outstanding issues – whether the excessive model term should be included in certain modern awards and whether particular existing terms that provide for the taking of annual leave should be retained; and annual leave provisions in a number of awards in the Maritime industry – Timing of taking annual leave – June 2016 decision finalised the excessive leave model term – 20 modern awards contain existing provisions which require accrued annual leave to be taken within a certain period of time – relevant Unions confirmed they were seeking the insertion of the model excessive leave term – no objection received to insertion of the model term in 18 modern awards – Full Bench concluded the existing terms which require annual leave be taken within a specified period of time after accrual did not provide a fair and relevant minimum safety net of terms and conditions of employment and, accordingly, did not satisfy the modern awards objective – these18 modern awards set will be varied to insert the excessive leave model term – the two modern awards which were the subject of continuing objections were the Black Coal Mining Industry Award 2010 (the BCMI Award) and the Aquaculture Award 2010 (the Aquaculture Award) – FW Act does not require an employee to take their accrued paid annual leave within any particular timeframe – ‘a modern award or enterprise agreement may include terms requiring an employee, or allowing for an employee to be required, to take paid annual leave in particular circumstances, but only if the requirement is reasonable’ [s.93(3) of FW Act] – the assessment of whether a requirement to take paid annual leave is ‘reasonable’ within the meaning of s.93(3) is not viewed solely through the perspective of the employer – BCMIAward provides for 6 weeks’ annual leave per annum for continuous shiftworkers and 5 weeks for other employees – the Coal Mining Industry Employer Group (CMIEG) submitted data which showed that some 1,973 employees employed by 12 black coal mining industry employers (or about 9.5% of the employees) had an ‘excessive leave accrual’ within the meaning of the model term – further submitted that accrual of annual leave is not at a level that is problematic in the industry – Full Bench held that such a level of ‘excessive’ paid annual leave accruals was problematic and supported an inference that a significant proportion of these employees were not taking a reasonable portion of their paid annual leave – decided to insert the model excessive leave term into BCMI Award, subject to a modification to the definition of ‘excessive leave’ having regard to the level of annual leave entitlements under the award – Aquaculture Award provides that annual leave is to be taken within 18 months of accrual – also provides that employees may be directed to take annual leave where an employer ‘ intends temporarily to close (or reduce the nucleus) the place of employment or a section of it’ – NSW Farmers (Industrial) Association (NSW Farmers), which represents the interests of oyster producers in NSW, opposed insertion of the model excessive leave term – Full Bench concluded the excessive leave term in the Aquaculture Award did not provide a fair and relevant minimum safety net of terms and conditions of employment – satisfied that variation of the Aquaculture Award to insert the model excessive leave term is necessary to ensure award meets the modern awards objective – Maritime awards – whether the six modern awards in the Maritime industry (the Maritime Industry Awards) should be varied to include some or all of the model annual leave terms – no longer any opposition to the insertion of the excessive leave, leave in advance and cashing out model terms into the Dredging Industry Award 2010 and the Ports, Harbours and Enclosed Water Vessels Award 2010 – Full Bench proposed to vary these two awards to insert the three model terms – AMMA/MIAL joint submission asserted the existing terms in the Marine Towage Award 2010; the Maritime Offshore Oil and Gas Award 2010 ; and the Seagoing Industry Award 2010 gave employers ‘the necessary flexibility to manage rosters by working in sync with the ‘swing system’ eg four or five weeks on duty followed by four or five weeks off duty’ and that ‘annual leave cannot be accommodated for employees during the on duty period’ – Full Bench found operation of the swing system in these awards likely to minimise excessive paid annual leave accruals and on that basis did not propose to vary these awards to insert the excessive leave model term – whether these awards should be varied to insert the cashing out and leave in advance model terms – none of these awards presently provide for the cashing out of annual leave – cashing out model term is a facilitative provision – no obligation on the employer to enter into such an agreement – provisional view of Full Bench was that these three awards should be varied to insert the cashing out model term – standard leave in advance model term is a facilitative provision – provisional view of Full Bench was that these three awards should be varied to insert the leave in advance model term – Professional Diving (Industrial) Industry Award 2010 provides different entitlements for inshore and offshore during operations – AMMA/MIAL joint submission does not oppose the variation of the award to insert the annual leave model terms in respect of inshore divers, but does oppose the application of those model terms to offshore divers – Full Bench did not propose to deal now with whether the excessive leave model term should be inserted into this award – a number of drafting issues need to be addressed before this matter can be determined – provisional view of Full Bench was that the Professional Diving (Industrial) Industry Award 2010 should be varied to insert the cashing out and leave in advance model terms and they should not distinguish between inshore and offshore divers – interested parties will have until 5.00pm (AEST) Friday 7 October 2016 to notify the Commission (at [email protected]) if they wish to contest the Full Bench’s provisional views in respect of the other Maritime Industry Awards. 4 yearly review of modern awards – Annual Leave