TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – termination at initiative of employer – constructive dismissal – ss.385, 386, 394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for relief from unfair dismissal – applicant employed as a Family Worker – submitted she was subject to harassment and bullying by a co-worker and she had to resign to avoid further deterioration in her mental health and well-being – respondent received complaints by the co-worker about applicant, and had issued formal and informal warnings to applicant regarding her performance and conduct at work – conduct included limiting her hours without authorisation – applicant was requested to attend meeting to discuss limitation of hours – in response to request, applicant resigned – even if bullied by coworker, which Commission was not satisfied occurred, it was the relationship between the applicant and respondent which is crucial – whether applicant was left with no choice but to resign as a result of the respondent’s actions, or lack of action in respect of the alleged harassment of the applicant by her co-worker – Commission satisfied respondent acted appropriately to manage the situation by investigating complaints about applicant – respondent did not receive formal complaint from applicant about co-worker – respondent entitled to question limitation of hours without authorisation – Commission found applicant had alternative to resignation, with a number of choices open to the applicant – application dismissed. Taouk-Saade v Drug and Alcohol Multicultural Education Centre (DAMEC)
January 11, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – misconduct – s.394 Fair Work Act 2009 – application for unfair dismissal remedy – applicant employed as a cleaner at Glenunga High School – summary dismissal occurred on 2 September 2016 – respondent provided two reasons for dismissal – first was applicant not wearing his uniform after repeated instructions and warnings to do so – second was leaving work early on 1 September and not recording it on his timesheet – applicant submitted dismissal unfair as he was wrongly accused of fraudulently recording his work hours as he had never been required to sign in or fill out a timesheet – further submitted he always wore his uniform after being given a final written warning on 20 June 2016 – Commission satisfied applicant did not generally sign his timesheets nor was he required to do so – not satisfied applicant left the high school site early on 1 September 2016 but that he had packed up his cleaning gear and was undertaking work elsewhere on the school grounds such that he was not seen – however Commission satisfied applicant deliberately engaged in a campaign of disobedience by not wearing his uniform even after his warning on 20 June 2016 – found respondent’s entire basis for dismissal centred on applicant not wearing his uniform on 19 August 2016 – Selvachandran applied – Commission found valid reason for termination in that applicant failed to wear the required T-shirt on 19 August 2016 – not satisfied summary dismissal appropriate in circumstances as respondent had allowed applicant to continue working after 19 August 2016 – found dismissal was harsh as it was disproportionate to the nature of his misconduct and unreasonable because he was not afforded a reasonable opportunity to discuss that termination proposal before it was put into effect – dismissal unfair – reinstatement appropriate – order to maintain continuity of employment appropriate – order to restore lost pay not appropriate as it was the applicant’s deliberate disobedience that resulted in his dismissal. Parr v Southern Cross Cleaning
January 11, 2017
REGISTERED ORGANISATIONS – amalgamation – Transitionally Recognised Association – Sched.1, Cl.6(2) Fair Work (Registered Organisations) Act 2009 – transitionally recognised association, Local Government Engineers’ Association of New South Wales (LGEA), lodged application pursuant to clause 6(2) of Sched.1 of RO Act seeking extension of its transitional recognition – in absence of extension being granted the transitional recognition of LGEA would cease on 1 January 2017 – Commission may grant extension until 1 January 2018 in prescribed circumstances – Commission must be satisfied progress made towards becoming an organisation or rationalising its internal affairs with those of its federal counterpart – Commission found LGEA could not satisfy first condition because s.19(5) of RO Act prohibits Commission from registering association registered under State or Territory industrial law if association has federal counterpart – Association of Professional Engineers, Scientists and Managers, Australia (APESMA) prescribed federal counterpart of LGEA under Sched.1A of RO Regulations – statutory declaration provided by LGEA set out historical and financial arrangements between LGEA and APESMA – outlined measures that LGEA implemented towards rationalising affairs with those of APESMA – steps taken included that LGEA largely correlates with one of the divisions of APESMA and LGEA took steps to alter rules for complete and seamless correlation between LGEA and Division – internal administration of LGEA and Division regularised so systems applied appropriately to requirements of rules of both organisations including concurrently held committee meetings and annual general meetings – that staff jointly employed by both LGEA and APESMA – that internal affairs of LGEA reflected in its rules on practical level rationalised and consistent with rules of Division – Commission satisfied on basis of circumstances set out in statutory declaration progress made by LGEA to rationalise internal affairs with those of federal counterpart – considered appropriate to exercise discretion in favour of granting extension of LGEA’s transitional recognition until 1 January 2018 – Commission ordered extension of transitional recognition. The Local Government Engineers’ Association of New South Wales
January 11, 2017
MODERN AWARDS – 4 yearly review – s.156 Fair Work Act 2009 – Full Bench – application made by Veterinary Nurses Council of Australia for a new classification to be introduced for Diploma Veterinary Nurse in the Level 4 definition – Full Bench considered rate of pay should not be dependent on holding a qualification but rather based on the nature of duties required to be performed – no evidence provided by parties regarding nature of duties and no appearances made at relevant hearing – Full Bench not satisfied a new classification should be inserted into award at this time – declined to vary award. Animal Care and Veterinary Services Award 2010
January 11, 2017
TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT – termination at initiative of employer – ss.394, 400, 604 Fair Work Act 2009 – permission to appeal – Full Bench – appeal against decision which found that applicant had resigned from employment and dismissed unfair dismissal application – applicant’s grounds of appeal lengthy and confusing – Full Bench found many of the arguments raised were an attempt to reargue the case and seek a different outcome – not open to appeal bench to substitute its view of the matters for determination at first instance in the absence of an appealable error in the decision at first instance – Full Bench could not identify any arguable appealable error – not able to identify any matter in appeal that might have enlivened the public interest – not persuaded appeal raised any issues of importance or general application, nor that it identified any relevant diversity of decisions at first instance – not arguable that decision at first instance manifested an injustice or that the result was counterintuitive – legal principles applied not disharmonious when compared with other recent decisions dealing with similar matters – permission to appeal refused – appeal dismissed. Appeal by Blythe against decision of Sams DP of 15 September 2016 [[2016] FWC 6160] Re: David Hartree Design Associates P/L t/a Hartree and Associates Architects
January 11, 2017
CASE PROCEDURES – appeals – costs – ss.604, 611 Fair Work Act 2009 – Full Bench – application made by respondent for appellant to pay costs for permission to appeal hearing [[2016] FWCFB 5504] – aspects of appellant case for granting permission to appeal were reasonably arguable – no basis to conclude appellant instituted appeal proceedings in order to harass or embarrass respondent, or to gain collateral advantage – application seriously pursued – appellant represented by legal practitioner – properly considered submissions advanced on behalf of appellant – jurisdictional prerequisites for granting costs not satisfied – costs application dismissed. Appeal by Palm against decision of Kovacic DP of 30 June 2016 [[2016] FWC 4292] Re: Sydney Night Patrol & Inquiry Co P/L t/a SNP Security
January 11, 2017
MODERN AWARDS – 4 yearly review – s.156 Fair Work Act 2009 – Full Bench – Statement deals with the plain language re-drafting of the designated standard clauses and the review of the draft Guidelines for plain language drafting of modern awards following the conference held on 23 November 2016 – draft Guidelines were developed by Mr Eamonn Moran QC – draft Guidelines were published on 9 November 2016 – the draft Guidelines will not have the effect of an award but they are there to assist all of the parties including the Full Bench in determining what plain language clauses will look like – Full Bench will publish the Guidelines in final form early in 2017 – five clauses identified as ‘standard clauses’ to be re-drafted as part of the Plain language Full Bench matter – whether the re-drafting process may have changed the legal effect of the provision – during the conference parties worked through concerns with the re-drafted Award flexibility term and a number of agreed changes were noted – revised draft version of the Award flexibility standard clause, incorporating changes agreed to during the conference – further conference is proposed to be held in Sydney on Monday, 23 January 2017 commencing at 9:00am to deal with the remaining ‘standard clauses’ – Full Bench made it clear that the re-drafting process is not intended to change the legal effect of a provision. 4 yearly review of modern awards – Plain language re-drafting – Standard Clauses – Draft Guidelines
January 11, 2017
MODERN AWARDS – 4 yearly review – s.156 Fair Work Act 2009 – Full Bench – Statement addresses concerns raised in correspondence from the Australian Council of Trade Unions (ACTU) – ACTU outlined their concerns regarding the process of Plain language re-drafting of modern awards – Ai Group shared some of the concerns – Plain language re-drafting process comprises of several elements – the review of the standard and common clauses generally and the review of award-specific issues in the awards that have been selected for the plain language process [[2016] FWC 4756], [[2016] FWCFB 5621] – standard clauses will be dealt with by conferences before Hunt C, and if required, at a hearing before the Full Bench – common clauses will be dealt with in a similar process in 2017 – further consultation in March 2017 to identify the provisions which are to be regarded as ‘common clauses’ for this purpose. 4 yearly review of modern awards – Plain language re-drafting – General